How Snow Salt Pollutes Water Sources

Snow salt, also known as rock salt or road salt, is widely used to melt ice and snow by lowering the freezing point of water. While it helps to create safer walking and driving conditions during winter storms, its environmental impact cannot be ignored. This article will explore the topic of whether snow salt pollutes water and discuss the potential consequences of its use.

Rock salt is the most widely used de-icer

Rock salt is a natural, untreated form of table salt, chemically known as sodium chloride (NaCl). It is composed of small and large sodium chloride crystals treated with an anti-caking agent to ensure efficient and effective ice melting. It is effective at temperatures as low as 5°F, making it a reliable and economical choice for winter maintenance.

The use of rock salt as a de-icer has several advantages, including its affordability and effectiveness in melting ice and snow. It is readily available in convenient bag sizes, making it practical for winter maintenance. Additionally, rock salt is easy to apply and can be stored for future use, making it a popular choice for emergency preparedness kits.

However, despite its benefits, rock salt has come under increasing scrutiny due to its environmental and health impacts. As the amount of salt used for de-icing has increased, concerns have been raised about its potential to contaminate drinking water sources, harm wildlife, increase soil erosion, and damage infrastructure. The sodium and chlorine from rock salt can leach into the ground and water, leading to increased chloride levels that are toxic to aquatic life and pose risks to human health.

In response to these concerns, alternative de-icing methods and more environmentally friendly products are being explored. These include mechanical snow removal methods such as shovelling, plowing, or using snow blowers, as well as innovative solutions like porous pavement that reduce the need for salt. While these alternatives may be more expensive or require additional adjustments, they offer potential solutions to mitigate the environmental and health impacts associated with rock salt.

Salt contaminates drinking water

While road salt is an effective method of clearing ice and snow from roads, it can also contaminate drinking water. This is because, as snow and ice melt on roads, the salt washes into the soil and can eventually infiltrate lakes, rivers, and streams. This can lead to increased chloride levels in the water, which is harmful to aquatic life and can also corrode infrastructure.

A study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found that salt ions increased in rivers and streams across 37% of the contiguous United States, impacting the chemistry of freshwater sources. This has toxic effects on aquatic life, with high chloride levels endangering fish, bugs, and amphibians. The Environmental Protection Agency has reported that freshwater ecosystems are being contaminated by road salt beyond safe concentrations for both freshwater organisms and human consumption.

The use of road salt can also have indirect effects on drinking water sources. For example, the sand used to provide traction on icy roads can be washed into nearby water bodies, clouding the water and hindering aquatic plant photosynthesis.

In recognition of these issues, some states have implemented initiatives to reduce road salt usage. Rhode Island, for instance, has adopted the practice of applying a brine solution (a mixture of salt and water) to roads before snowfall, which prevents the formation of ice and reduces the amount of salt required. New Hampshire has also successfully reduced road salt use through improved management practices and policies, such as upgrading equipment to allow for more precise salt application and lowering speed limits during winter weather events.

Alternative de-icing methods are also being explored to mitigate the environmental and health impacts of road salt. These include the use of other chemicals such as magnesium chloride, calcium chloride, and calcium magnesium acetate, as well as mechanical snow removal methods like shoveling, plowing, or using snow blowers.

Salt endangers wildlife

Salt used for deicing roads and highways, also known as rock salt or road salt, can contaminate water sources and harm wildlife. While it is very effective at melting snow and ice, creating safer walking and driving conditions during winter storms, its use has several drawbacks.

The amount of salt used for deicing roads and highways has increased over the years. Nearly half a million tons is used annually in Massachusetts alone for winter road maintenance. This salt accumulates in water bodies and increases their chloride levels, which can be harmful to aquatic life. Freshwater ecosystems are particularly vulnerable to rising salinity, which can alter nutrient cycling, water quality and clarity, and cause population declines in economically important fish species. For example, salty water kills the eggs and larvae of mussels and other wildlife.

In addition to the direct harm caused to aquatic life, increased salinity can also impact the food sources of wildlife. Zooplankton, a critical food resource for many young fish, may be affected by changes in salinity. This could have cascading effects on fish populations and the wider ecosystem.

The contamination of water sources with salt also poses risks to human health. In some places, salt concentrations in tap water can reach levels where the water tastes salty. This indicates that the water has been contaminated with salt, which can have potential health risks.

There are alternative methods to deicing roads that can help reduce the environmental and ecological impact of salt. These include using brine solutions or a mixture of salt and sand, upgrading equipment to allow for more accurate monitoring and release of salt, and using mechanical snow removal methods such as shoveling or plowing.

Alternative methods to de-icing

While snow salt is effective at melting ice and creating safer driving conditions, it has several damaging consequences for the environment and infrastructure. Its runoff can contaminate water sources, harm wildlife, increase soil erosion, and damage public and private property.

Anti-icing

Anti-icing is a method that involves applying a brine solution (a mixture of salt and water) or other anti-icing chemicals to roads, pavements, or surfaces before a snowstorm to prevent the formation of ice and snow. This practice can significantly reduce the amount of salt or de-icer required after the snowstorm.

Porous Pavement

Porous or permeable pavement is a type of road surface that allows standing water to seep through, reducing the amount of water available for ice formation. This technology helps prevent ice from forming on roads, reducing the need for de-icing.

Sand or Gravel

Sand or gravel can be used to add traction to icy surfaces, making them less slippery and ideal for areas with high foot traffic. While sand does not melt the ice, it can be an effective and inexpensive alternative to salt, especially when paired with mechanical snow removal methods such as shovelling or plowing.

Eco-Friendly De-icers

There are eco-friendly de-icing products available that are derived from natural substances like limestone and acetic acid. These products are biodegradable, plant-friendly, and minimize corrosion on paved surfaces. Some examples include CMA (calcium magnesium acetate) and beet juice, which can be mixed with rock salt to reduce its chemical content.

DIY De-icers

You can create your own de-icing solutions at home with simple ingredients like vinegar, water, baking soda, and rubbing alcohol. Vinegar, for example, lowers the freezing point of water and helps dissolve ice. Baking soda acts as a mild ice-melting agent and is safe for plants and pets.

Reducing salt usage

While snow salt is essential for creating safer walking and driving conditions during winter storms, its environmental impact cannot be ignored. The runoff from melting snow salt can contaminate water sources, increasing the chloride levels that are toxic to aquatic life and harming the environment and human health. Therefore, it is important to reduce salt usage to minimize its negative impact. Here are some ways to achieve that:

Pretreating with Brine Solution

Before a snowstorm, pretreat the roads with a brine solution (a mixture of salt and water) to prevent the formation of ice. This method, known as anti-icing, has been effectively used in Rhode Island since 2012, reducing the amount of salt required to de-ice roads.

Using Better Plow Blades

Upgrading to better plow blades can significantly lower salt consumption. Aggressive blades, designed to cut through snow and ice, maximize snow and ice removal, reducing the need for salt. Road-friendly blades, on the other hand, increase the blade's surface area in contact with the road, creating the right surface for salt to react and enhancing its efficiency.

Porous Pavement

Innovative solutions like porous pavement can reduce snow and ice cover, decreasing the need for salt. This type of pavement allows standing water to seep through, preventing water from freezing and reducing ice formation. A study found that porous pavement reduced snow/ice cover and led to a significant decrease in annual salt usage.

Alternative De-icers

In extremely cold temperatures, when salt is ineffective, use alternatives like sand. While sand doesn't melt ice or snow, it provides traction and increases friction, reducing the need for salt. However, ensure proper removal of sand after the snow melts to prevent it from washing into water bodies and causing sedimentation issues.

Improved Management Practices

Implementing improved management practices and policies can help reduce salt usage. This includes using upgraded equipment with closed-loop systems for accurate salt application, lowering speed limits during snowstorms, and mandating the use of snow tires in winter. These measures can collectively contribute to reduced salt usage.

Frequently asked questions