Volcanic Vs Industrial Air Pollution: Which Is More Harmful?

Volcanic eruptions can have a significant impact on air quality and human health. The release of volcanic gases, ash, and particles into the atmosphere can cause air pollution and lead to respiratory issues, especially for those with asthma. On the other hand, industrial activities contribute to air pollution through the emission of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases from the burning of fossil fuels. While volcanoes can have a substantial impact on a local scale, human-induced industrial pollution has a more widespread and long-term effect on a global scale. The question arises: which of these two sources of pollution poses a greater threat to our environment and health? Let's delve into the evidence and explore the impacts of both volcanic and industrial air pollution to determine which one poses a greater challenge.

Industrial activities cause more CO2 emissions than volcanic eruptions

Volcanic eruptions can have a significant impact on air quality and climate. Volcanoes emit various gases, including carbon dioxide (CO2), a greenhouse gas, as well as sulphur dioxide (SO2), hydrogen fluoride, and hydrogen chloride, which contribute to air pollution and can have detrimental effects on human health and the environment. While volcanic eruptions can lead to the release of substantial amounts of CO2, human activities, particularly industrial activities, are responsible for significantly higher emissions.

Industrial activities cause significantly more CO2 emissions than volcanic eruptions. According to the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), all the volcanoes on land and under the sea worldwide generate approximately 200 million tons of CO2 annually. In comparison, automotive and industrial activities contribute to around 24 billion tons of CO2 emissions globally each year. This disparity highlights the substantial impact of human activities, especially in the industrial sector, on the environment.

The argument that human-induced carbon emissions are negligible compared to volcanic emissions has been a topic of discussion for years. However, scientific evidence refutes this claim. While volcanic eruptions can release large amounts of CO2, present-day volcanic activity releases far less than 1% of the carbon dioxide emitted by human activities. The projected anthropogenic CO2 emission for 2010, for example, was approximately 35 billion metric tons, significantly higher than the estimated global volcanic CO2 emissions.

Industrial activities, including the burning of fossil fuels, have led to a rapid escalation of CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere. This increase has sparked concern among international organizations such as the United Nations. The massive output of anthropogenic CO2 is an international pollution issue that cannot be overlooked. While volcanism contributes to CO2 emissions, the scale of human-induced emissions, particularly from industrial processes, far surpasses that of volcanic activity.

In summary, while volcanic eruptions can have significant local and regional impacts on air quality and climate, industrial activities are the primary drivers of CO2 emissions on a global scale. The high volume of CO2 emissions from industrial processes contributes to the escalating atmospheric concentrations of this greenhouse gas, with far-reaching consequences for the planet. Addressing and mitigating human-induced emissions, especially from the industrial sector, is crucial in combating climate change and minimizing its impacts on the environment and human health.

Volcanic gases and ash can worsen asthma symptoms

Volcanic eruptions can have a significant impact on air quality and, consequently, respiratory health. When a volcano erupts, it releases lava, small rocks, steam, and gases into the atmosphere. These gases, including sulphur dioxide, carbon dioxide, and fine sulphate aerosols, can have detrimental effects on human health, particularly for those with pre-existing respiratory conditions like asthma.

Secondly, the gases themselves can be directly harmful when inhaled at high concentrations. Volcanic gases can cause a range of respiratory symptoms, from mild eye irritation to more severe difficulties in breathing. In some cases, exposure to certain volcanic gases can even lead to unconsciousness and death. The odourless and invisible nature of many volcanic gases makes avoiding exposure challenging, and people with asthma may find their symptoms worsening without obvious warning signs.

The impact of volcanic emissions on asthma symptoms can be long-lasting. Particle pollution from volcanic events can persist in the environment for several days and can become airborne again during cleanup operations. This means that even after the initial eruption, individuals with asthma may continue to experience symptoms if they are in an affected area or involved in cleanup efforts.

To manage asthma during periods of high volcanic air pollution, individuals are advised to follow their asthma action plan, carry their medication, and limit exposure to volcanic gases and ash by staying indoors, closing doors and windows, and using air purifiers. When outdoors, wearing a well-fitted N95 mask or respirator, along with goggles, can help reduce the inhalation of harmful particles.

Volcanic eruptions can cause acid rain

The Kilauea volcano in Hawaii, which has been erupting since 1983, is a notable example of the impacts of volcanic acid rain. The emissions from Kilauea have caused air pollution in the form of volcanic smog, or "vog". This vog is a recognised health hazard, causing issues such as difficulty breathing, headaches, and increased susceptibility to respiratory ailments. The acid rain that accompanies volcanic eruptions can also contaminate drinking water sources, causing further health concerns for residents in affected areas.

In addition to the immediate health risks, acid rain from volcanic eruptions can have long-term environmental consequences. Acid rain can cause rusting in metal objects, including cars, industrial and farm equipment, and building components. It can also damage plants and crops, impacting agricultural industries. Furthermore, when acid rain is washed into lakes and streams, it can turn the water acidic, harming aquatic life such as insects and fish.

While volcanic eruptions are a natural source of acid rain, it is important to note that human activities, such as the burning of fossil fuels, are the primary contributors to acid rain on a global scale. The conversion of sulfur dioxide to sulfuric acid, released during volcanic eruptions, can lead to regional cooling of the Earth's lower atmosphere. However, the carbon dioxide (CO2) released from contemporary volcanic eruptions has not been shown to cause detectable global warming.

Volcanic gases can cause shortness of breath and unconsciousness

Volcanic eruptions can result in serious health hazards. When a volcano erupts, it can release harmful particles, including volcanic gases and ash, into the air. Volcanic gases are hazardous to people, animals, agriculture, and property. Volcanic gases can cause shortness of breath and unconsciousness.

Volcanic gases, including carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and hydrogen halides, can be released during volcanic eruptions. These gases can pose serious risks to people and animals, especially when they reach high concentrations in the atmosphere. Breathing air with more than 3% carbon dioxide can lead to dizziness, increased heart rate, and difficulty breathing. At even higher concentrations (over 15%), carbon dioxide can cause rapid unconsciousness and death.

Sulfur dioxide (SO2) is a colorless gas with a pungent odor that irritates the skin, eyes, nose, and throat. High concentrations of SO2 can cause rapid unconsciousness, pulmonary edema, and death. Exposure to lower concentrations of SO2 over long periods can also have negative health effects, and the long-term impacts of persistent exposure are still being evaluated.

Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is a colorless, flammable gas with a strong, offensive odor. At high concentrations, H2S can irritate the upper respiratory tract and cause pulmonary edema. Exposure to very high concentrations of H2S can lead to unconsciousness and death within an hour or less.

Other gases, such as hydrogen chloride (HCl) and hydrogen fluoride (HF), are typically minor components of a volcanic plume. However, they can cause acute irritation of the skin, eyes, nose, throat, and lungs. High concentrations of HCl can cause swelling of the breathing passage and pulmonary edema, while brief exposures to high concentrations of HF can be dangerous.

In summary, volcanic gases can cause shortness of breath and unconsciousness, among other serious health issues. It is important to follow local guidance and take precautions to protect oneself from the harmful effects of volcanic air pollution during a volcanic eruption.

Volcanic smog, or vog, is a recognised health hazard

Vog is associated with Hawaiian volcanoes in particular. The Kilauea volcano on the Island of Hawai'i has been erupting continuously since 1983, causing air pollution. The Pu'u 'Ō'ō eruption of Kilauea Volcano is its longest rift-zone eruption in over 500 years. The emissions from the volcano are unpredictable and non-linear. The sulfur dioxide resulting from the emissions can be predicted using ARIMA models.

Vog can negatively affect human health and agriculture, and acid rain can contaminate household water supplies by leaching metals from building and plumbing materials on rooftops. People with asthma or other pre-existing respiratory conditions are the primary group at risk of experiencing health effects from vog exposure. However, healthy people may also experience symptoms. If you have existing heart and/or respiratory ailments, or other conditions that compromise your physical health, or if you are pregnant, consult your doctor for advice before travelling to any location with poor air quality.

The health effects of volcanic air pollution are well-documented. Volcanic eruptions can release harmful particles, including volcanic gases and ash, into the air. Many volcanic gases are odourless and invisible, so there is often little to no warning to help people avoid dangerous exposure. If you have asthma, exposure to volcanic gases and ash can exacerbate your symptoms. During a volcanic eruption, follow local guidance on how to respond and take additional steps to protect your health from air pollution.

Frequently asked questions