China's Water Pollution: Government Complicity And Inaction

Water pollution is a significant issue in China, with approximately 70% of the country's rivers and lakes unsafe for human use. The Chinese government has implemented various measures to reduce water pollution, such as the Water Pollution Prevention and Control Action Plan, which was launched in 2015 to improve water quality by 2030. However, local governments often fail to implement water quality standards, and there are challenges with enforcing remediation targets. Climate change, urbanization, and socioeconomic development have also contributed to the complexity of China's water environment situation, and the country faces severe water stress due to shortages and quality issues. While some improvements have been made, groundwater pollution remains a long-term challenge.

Lack of coordination between environmental and public health objectives

China's sustainable development faces significant challenges, including a fragile natural ecological environment and resource constraints. The country's per capita fresh water accounts for 28% of the global average, with a total volume of freshwater resources of 2.8 trillion cubic meters, ranking fourth in the world. This limited water supply is threatened by water pollution, which has become one of the most important public health issues in China.

The Chinese government has recognized the importance of addressing water pollution and has taken several critical actions. In 2015, the State Council promulgated and implemented the Action Plan for Water Pollution Prevention and Control, which clarified that local governments are primarily responsible for improving water pollution. The Ministry of Ecological Environment, along with other ministries, guided local governments in implementing this plan. As a result, by 2017, prefectural cities, provincial capitals, and municipalities under central government control had achieved specific goals, such as ensuring no large floating objects appeared on river surfaces and no garbage appeared on riverbanks.

However, there is still a lack of coordination between environmental and public health objectives. While the Ministry of Ecological Environment and the Ministry of Water Resources are responsible for monitoring water quantity and quality, including surface water, groundwater, and production of domestic water, the National Health Commission is separately responsible for monitoring drinking water quality. This separation of responsibilities can create a disconnect between environmental and public health goals, potentially leading to conflicting priorities and a lack of comprehensive planning.

To address this lack of coordination, China should focus on strengthening the integration of environmental and public health policies. This could involve establishing cross-sectoral committees or task forces that bring together experts from both fields to develop holistic strategies that consider the interconnectedness of environmental and public health. Additionally, China should continue to invest in data monitoring and health risk assessment systems, as recommended by the Outline of the "Healthy China 2030" Initiative. By bridging the gap between environmental and public health objectives, China can more effectively tackle water pollution and safeguard the health and well-being of its citizens.

Inadequate investment in basic water supply and treatment infrastructure

China's rapid economic growth, industrialization, and urbanization have resulted in widespread water pollution, exacerbated by inadequate investment in basic water supply and treatment infrastructure. This has led to critical deficits in water supply and sewage treatment systems, increasing the risk of exposure to harmful substances and infectious diseases.

The Chinese government has made efforts to address water pollution and increase local water supplies through projects like the $60 billion South-to-North Water Diversion Project and relocation of heavy industries from water-stressed regions. However, the country still faces significant water challenges, with a water supply gap that could reach 25% by 2030.

The issue of inadequate investment in water infrastructure is multi-faceted. Firstly, there is a lack of coordination between environmental and public health objectives, resulting in a fragmented system for managing water resources. This fragmentation contributes to the complex governance of water resources, making it challenging to implement effective solutions. Secondly, the treatment of water as a common property resource has hindered the development of targeted solutions to address water quality and quantity issues.

Moreover, the financing of water infrastructure projects is a significant challenge. Currently, 70-80% of water infrastructure and 50-60% of wastewater infrastructure are financed through debt or private equity, putting upward pressure on tariffs. While BOT contracts, where private entities invest in infrastructure and recover costs through fees, have been popular, they have also contributed to the financial burden on local governments and utilities.

The impact of inadequate investment in water supply and treatment infrastructure is evident in the health risks faced by the Chinese population. Contamination of drinking water with animal and human excreta is a critical issue, with over half of the population consuming water that exceeds maximum permissible levels of contamination. This has led to an increased risk of waterborne illnesses such as diarrhea and viral hepatitis.

Lack of regular monitoring of remediation efforts by central and provincial authorities

Water pollution is a persistent problem in China, and one of the reasons for this is the lack of regular monitoring of remediation efforts by central and provincial authorities. This has resulted in local governments failing to implement water quality standards set by national and provincial authorities. The central and provincial inspections of remediation efforts are infrequent and haphazard, especially for small waterways. As a result, higher authorities often lack regular information about the immediate and long-term achievements of remediation targets.

The Chinese government has recognized the importance of addressing water pollution and has taken some steps to tackle the issue. For instance, the State Council promulgated and implemented the Action Plan for Water Pollution Prevention and Control in 2015, which clarified that local governments are primarily responsible for improving water pollution. The Ministry of Ecological Environment and the Ministry of Water Resources are tasked with monitoring the quantity and quality of water, including surface water, groundwater, and seawater. However, the implementation of these plans and the effectiveness of monitoring efforts vary across the country.

The complex interactions between central, provincial, and local governments in China pose challenges to consistent and effective monitoring. In some cases, local governments may have conflicting interests, acting as both environmental regulators and sources of poor environmental conditions. For example, factories and enterprises owned by local governments may be significant polluters in certain areas. Additionally, local officials may prioritize achieving targets observable by higher authorities, leading to oversight problems when monitoring is incomplete.

To address these challenges, central authorities have encouraged non-governmental organizations (NGOs) to monitor local governments' remediation efforts. These NGOs provide information about the progress of remediation efforts to local and provincial governments, which has been shown to improve water quality. However, the causal evidence of the effects of regular, systematic monitoring by NGOs is still lacking, and there is a need for more comprehensive data to evaluate the impact of these efforts fully.

The Chinese government has also taken steps to improve accountability for the protection of water resources. The local and national environmental protection authorities have been consolidated under a new ministry-level agency to enhance coordination and oversight. Additionally, China has included safeguarding water resources as a key feature in its 11th Five-Year Plan, emphasizing further emission reductions and ambitious source protection measures. These measures demonstrate the government's commitment to tackling water pollution and improving environmental health.

Insufficient implementation of existing pollution standards

While China has implemented various measures and policies to address water pollution, insufficient implementation of existing pollution standards remains a challenge. China's rapid socioeconomic development and urbanization have made its water environment situation increasingly complex, with water safety becoming a critical public health issue.

One example of insufficient implementation is the continued discharge of pollutants into water sources. Despite regulations prohibiting the discharge of pollutants into drinking water source reserves, there have been instances where construction projects or industrial activities have contaminated water supplies. Insufficient monitoring and enforcement of these regulations have allowed for the degradation of water quality.

Another issue is the lack of coordination between different levels of government. In China, water protection is managed by various ministries and levels of government, from the central government to local municipalities. However, a lack of cohesive implementation and inconsistent enforcement of standards across different regions can create gaps and loopholes that are exploited by polluters.

Furthermore, there is a discrepancy between the standards set by the central government and the actual practices of enterprises. While China has established vehicle emissions standards and fuel consumption limits, the implementation of these standards by businesses has been inadequate. Some enterprises engage in rent-seeking behaviours, such as paying bribes to discharge pollutants without adhering to the stipulated emission standards.

The Chinese government has recognized the importance of addressing water pollution and has taken steps to improve implementation. The Ministry of Ecological Environment, in conjunction with other ministries, guides local governments in implementing measures to improve water quality. However, more stringent enforcement and oversight are necessary to ensure that existing pollution standards are effectively implemented across the country.

Climate change and drinking water safety challenges

Climate change has had a profound impact on the global natural ecosystem and human society. It has brought about human health risks due to water shortages and pollution. China, one of the world's fastest-growing economies, is facing significant challenges in ensuring safe and healthy drinking water for its population.

China's water environment situation has become increasingly complex due to rapid socioeconomic development and urbanization over the past few decades. The health impact of water safety has become one of the important public health issues. The total volume of freshwater resources in China is 2.8 trillion cubic meters, accounting for only 6% of global water resources. This limited supply of freshwater resources supports a population of over 1.4 billion people and booming industries, making China vulnerable to water insecurity.

Climate change is exacerbating this problem by accelerating Himalayan glacial retreat and bringing abnormal weather patterns. Southern China, in particular, is at risk, with a severe drought in southwest China in 2011 impacting the drinking and irrigation water of more than 60 million people. Additionally, the reduction in river discharge from the Yangtze River due to water diversion projects may lead to a decline in groundwater levels, resulting in seawater intrusion during dry seasons and further contaminating freshwater aquifers in the Yangtze Delta.

To address these challenges, the Chinese government has taken several critical actions. In 2015, the State Council promulgated and implemented the Action Plan for Water Pollution Prevention and Control, clarifying that local governments are primarily responsible for improving water pollution. The Ministry of Ecological Environment and the Ministry of Water Resources monitor water quality and quantity, including surface water, groundwater, and drinking water production. By 2017, major cities and municipalities had achieved goals such as eliminating large floating objects and garbage from river surfaces and banks and preventing illegal sewage discharge.

However, despite these efforts, water scarcity, regional disparity, urbanization, and climate change remain significant challenges for safe and healthy drinking water in China. A variety of emerging contaminants, including disinfection byproducts, pharmaceuticals, personal care products, and endocrine-disrupting compounds, have been detected in drinking water sources. China needs to focus on reducing global warming, fighting water pollution, improving environmental health surveillance, and establishing health risk assessment systems to address these pressing issues.

Frequently asked questions