Ethanol's Air Pollution Hazard: What You Need To Know

Hazardous air pollutants, also known as air toxics or HAPs, are known to cause cancer and other serious health issues. The Clean Air Act requires the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to regulate these pollutants, which come from a variety of sources, including motor vehicles and their fuels, and have a wide range of health and environmental impacts. While the harmful effects of HAPs are of particular concern in areas closest to where they are emitted, they can also be transported and affect populations in other geographic areas. Ethanol, a common fuel, has been identified as a contributor to hazardous air pollutants, specifically in the form of motor vehicle emissions. This raises the question: is ethanol a hazardous air pollutant?

Ethanol's classification as a hazardous air pollutant

Ethanol is a hazardous air pollutant (HAP) or air toxic. These are compounds known or suspected to cause cancer or other serious health issues, as well as environmental damage. The Clean Air Act (CAA), amended in 1990, requires the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to regulate HAPs from industrial facilities in two phases. The EPA must also characterise, prioritise, and control emissions as appropriate.

The EPA's National Emissions Standards for HAPs (NESHAP) addresses the results of residual risk and technology reviews (RTRs) and includes provisions for revising emission limits, testing and monitoring requirements, and updating reporting and record-keeping requirements. The CAA establishes a two-stage regulatory process to address HAP emissions from stationary sources. In the first stage, after the EPA has identified categories of sources emitting one or more HAP, it must promulgate technology-based NESHAP for those sources. "Major sources" are those emitting or with the potential to emit 10 tons per year (tpy) or more of a single HAP or 25 tpy or more of any combination of HAPs.

The EPA strives to provide maximum feasible protection against health risks from HAPs by protecting as many people as possible from an individual lifetime risk level no higher than approximately 1-in-1 million. It also limits the estimated risk that a person living near a plant would face if exposed to the maximum pollutant concentrations for 70 years to no higher than approximately 1-in-10 thousand (or 100-in-1 million). The EPA considers the incidence of cancer or other serious health effects in the exposed population to be an important measure of the overall health risk.

Motor vehicles are significant contributors to national HAP emissions, including ethanol. The EPA's Integrated Urban Air Toxics Strategy aims to reduce urban air toxic emissions by evaluating emissions and potential strategies relating to HAPs from both on-highway and non-road engines and vehicles.

Health and environmental impacts of ethanol

Ethanol is a renewable biofuel that can be made from corn, poplar, or other cellulosic feedstocks. It has been touted as a way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and address energy security concerns. However, there are concerns about the health and environmental impacts of ethanol.

One of the main benefits of ethanol is its ability to reduce harmful tailpipe emissions. Testing has shown that using gasoline blended with higher amounts of ethanol can reduce emissions of carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, air toxics, and fine particulate matter, which can have negative effects on human health. For example, carbon monoxide reduces oxygen delivery to the body's organs, hydrocarbons irritate the eyes and damage the lungs, air toxics like benzene can cause cancer and reproductive effects, and fine particulate matter can enter the lungs and cause serious health issues.

However, critics argue that the environmental impacts of producing ethanol, particularly from corn, are often overlooked. Growing corn for fuel can lead to higher prices for this staple food crop and contribute to deforestation. Additionally, higher-ethanol blends can reduce fuel efficiency and have been known to damage engines. There are also concerns about the increase in toxic pollutants in drinking water and the occurrence of toxic algae blooms due to ethanol production.

While ethanol has the potential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline, the overall impacts on the climate are still uncertain. Studies have shown that grain-based ethanol can cut greenhouse gas emissions by 44-52% compared to gasoline, and corn ethanol offers an average reduction of 46%. However, other studies have ranked cellulosic and corn-based ethanol last out of nine energy sources in terms of their impact on the climate. It is important to note that the environmental sustainability of ethanol varies depending on the feedstock and production method used.

In conclusion, while ethanol has the potential to reduce harmful tailpipe emissions and provide a renewable alternative to fossil fuels, there are still concerns about its health and environmental impacts. It is important to carefully consider the feedstock and production method used to minimize any negative consequences.

Regulations and standards for ethanol emissions

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is responsible for regulating hazardous air pollutants, also known as air toxics, from industrial facilities. This includes regulating ethanol production facilities' emissions under the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program.

The Clean Air Act (CAA) establishes a two-stage regulatory process for the EPA to address emissions of hazardous air pollutants from stationary sources. The EPA first identifies categories of sources emitting hazardous air pollutants. Then, for those sources, the EPA promulgates technology-based National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP). These standards must reflect the maximum degree of emission reductions achievable, considering cost, energy requirements, and non-air quality health and environmental impacts.

"Major sources" of hazardous air pollutants are defined as those emitting or with the potential to emit 10 tons per year (tpy) or more of a single hazardous air pollutant or 25 tpy or more of any combination of hazardous air pollutants. For major sources, the NESHAP must be in the form of maximum achievable control technology (MACT) standards.

The CAA also requires the EPA to determine whether the emission standards provide an ample margin of safety to protect public health. The EPA aims to provide maximum feasible protection against health risks from hazardous air pollutants by protecting as many people as possible to an individual lifetime risk level of approximately one in a million. The EPA also considers the incidence of cancer or other serious health effects in the exposed population as an important measure of health risk.

The EPA proposed amendments to the NESHAP for the manufacturing of nutritional yeast in 2016. These amendments addressed the results of residual risk and technology reviews and included revising the form of fermenter volatile organic compound (VOC) emission limits, changing testing and monitoring requirements, and updating reporting and record-keeping requirements.

Monitoring and controlling ethanol pollution

Ethanol is a renewable bioenergy source that can be used to combat global climate change and energy security. While it is a better alternative to fossil fuels, it is still crucial to monitor and control ethanol pollution to mitigate its environmental impact. Here are some detailed strategies for monitoring and controlling ethanol pollution:

Monitoring Ethanol Pollution

Thermal Mass Flow Meters: These meters can be employed to measure fuel gas, air flows, and waste gases in ethanol production. By optimising the air-fuel ratio, thermal mass flow meters can improve combustion efficiency and reduce pollution. They help assess process inefficiencies and ensure compliance with environmental standards.

Real-time Monitoring with Electronic Nose: An electronic nose can quantitatively analyse the content of specific components in gases, enabling the online detection of volatile substances like ethanol. This technology can be used to monitor ethanol concentration in real-time during the fermentation process, allowing for better control of the fermentation state, feeding time, and endpoint.

Viable Cell Sensor: Introducing a viable cell sensor into the ethanol fermentation process provides real-time data on the number of living cells. This information can be used to develop dynamic feeding strategies and optimise ethanol production.

Controlling Ethanol Pollution

Optimising Combustion Control: By accurately measuring gases with thermal flow meters, it is possible to optimise the combustion control of process heaters, such as distillation tanks. This improves energy management and reduces energy consumption in manufacturing environments.

Glucose Feeding Strategies: Developing controlled glucose feeding strategies based on real-time data from electronic noses and viable cell sensors can improve ethanol fermentation performance and yield.

Reducing Emissions: Mixing ethanol with gasoline or using bioethanol as a fuel can significantly reduce pollutant emissions and carbon dioxide emissions from vehicles. Implementing ethanol as a fuel source can help mitigate environmental pollution and global warming caused by excess fossil fuel use.

By employing these monitoring and controlling strategies, it is possible to optimise ethanol production processes, reduce pollution, and contribute to a more sustainable energy future.

Strategies to reduce ethanol emissions

Ethanol is a biofuel that has been proven to emit significantly fewer emissions than petroleum-based fuels. However, strategies to reduce ethanol emissions further are still being explored.

One strategy is to transition to renewable process heat and power sources such as wind, solar, renewable natural gas, or biomass. This can help to reduce the carbon intensity of ethanol production and lower overall emissions. Another strategy is to develop new productivity and conversion efficiency measures in biorefinery processes. This can include improving the energy efficiency of the processes and reducing the amount of energy required, which can lead to lower emissions.

Additionally, the adoption of carbon capture, utilization, and sequestration (CCUS) technologies can play a crucial role in reducing ethanol emissions. By capturing and sequestering the CO2 emissions produced during ethanol production, the carbon footprint of ethanol can be significantly reduced. This can be achieved through the use of renewable feedstocks, which have been shown to realize greater than 70% emissions reductions for a range of end-use fuels.

Furthermore, improvements in farming practices can also contribute to reducing ethanol emissions. This includes increasing corn yields per acre, decreasing fertilizer use, and implementing more carbon-efficient farming techniques. These practices can help to reduce the emissions associated with crop production, which is an important step in the ethanol supply chain.

It is also important to consider the vehicle type, engine calibration, and blend level when using ethanol as a vehicle fuel. While ethanol can offer emissions benefits, it can also result in evaporative emissions, especially in low-level ethanol blends. Adjusting the vapor pressure of these blends can help adhere to volatility standards, and the use of high-level blends, such as E85, can result in lower evaporative emissions. Overall, a comprehensive approach that considers the entire lifecycle of ethanol production and use is necessary to develop effective strategies for reducing ethanol emissions.

Frequently asked questions