Trade's Pollution Trail: Global Impact

Trade has a significant impact on the environment, and there is a growing body of literature examining the effects of international trade on the environment. While trade can facilitate access to clean technologies and encourage innovation, it also contributes to air pollution through the transportation sector and the use of petroleum-based fuels. The increase in foreign commerce has led to a rise in ship emissions, which have been deemed the last unregulated source of traditional air pollutants. These emissions include traditional air pollutants such as sulfur oxides (SOx) and nitrogen oxides (NOx), as well as greenhouse gases. In addition, the production and export of certain goods can result in environmental damage, with some industries generating hazardous exports that cause significant environmental harm. Trade agreements have also been associated with increased emissions, particularly in the shipping sector. However, it is important to note that the relationship between trade and pollution is complex, and other factors such as income levels and democratic values can influence the environmental impact of trade.

Transportation and cargo ships

Marine transportation drives global trade, with over 10 billion tons of containers, solid and liquid bulk cargo transported across the world's seas annually. About 90% of the world's trade is transported by sea, with 35% of the value of world trade being transported by air. The shipping industry is economically important, but it contributes heavily to the oceans' oil pollution and air pollution.

The marine transportation of oil is particularly risky, with oil spills being a significant negative externality of the economy. Oil spills can be categorized as accidental or intentional. Accidental spills are the result of ship collisions, fires, or groundings. Intentional spills, on the other hand, are operational and are often due to the improper management of oily residues or ballast and bilge water. In addition to oil pollution, ships are responsible for more than 18% of nitrogen oxides pollution and 3% of greenhouse gas emissions. The growth in tonne-kilometers of sea shipments has averaged 4% yearly since the 1990s and has grown by a factor of 5 since the 1970s. This growth, coupled with the industry's reliance on petroleum-based fuels, has resulted in significant emissions of traditional air pollutants.

Plastic pollution in the shipping industry is also a significant issue, including cargo losses and the illegal dumping of plastic waste into the ocean. Containers are often lost due to extreme weather, operational errors, and inconsistent securing standards, leading to large quantities of debris in the marine environment. Some vessels also violate international regulations by discharging plastic waste directly into the sea. This plastic pollution can have detrimental effects on marine life, causing entanglement and ingestion risks that affect mobility, respiration, and feeding behaviors in marine species.

To address these issues, various measures are being implemented. The International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL) is the main international convention to prevent marine pollution by ships from operational or accidental causes. Additionally, the International Maritime Organization (IMO) uses various instruments to protect the marine environment from shipping activities. Amendments to Annex VI in 2022 require improvements in operational efficiency and the reporting of annual operational carbon intensity indicators (CII). The CII rating indicates the amount of GHG emissions produced to transport cargo for the distance traveled. Canada and the United States have also implemented initiatives to reduce air pollution, such as the North American ECA, which mandates the use of fuel with less than 0.1% sulphur content for ships operating in certain areas.

Environmental regulation

Trade has been shown to have both positive and negative impacts on the environment. On the one hand, trade can facilitate access to clean technologies and innovations, helping to push a pollution-free agenda. For example, multinational corporations tend to bring clean and state-of-the-art production techniques from higher-standard countries to host countries. Additionally, trade can provide incentives to reduce pollution by revealing the true cost of "dirty" products to society and encouraging the trade of cleaner products.

On the other hand, trade, especially international trade, can contribute to air pollution through the transportation sector, specifically cargo ships and the shipping sector. Furthermore, at low levels of income, growth can worsen pollution before eventually having a beneficial effect as countries become prosperous enough to afford cleaning up their environments.

To mitigate the negative environmental impacts of trade, environmental regulations have been put in place by various organizations and governments. These regulations aim to reduce pollution, promote sustainable growth, and encourage the use of clean technologies. Here are some examples of environmental regulations:

• The Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum has listed 54 environmental goods, categorized into renewable energy, environmental monitoring and assessment equipment, environmental production, and environmentally preferable products.
• The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has a list of 198 environmental goods, including categories from APEC as well as clean technology, pollution management, remediation and cleanup, and cleaner technologies.
• The Chinese government has strengthened environmental regulations to address environmental pollution and overcapacity issues, with mandatory and market-incentive approaches. However, the effectiveness of these regulations is still debated, with some studies showing an increase in pollution despite regulations.
• Studies by Tobey (1990) and Van Beers and Van Den Bergh (1997) investigated the impact of rigorous environmental regulations on the trade of "dirty" commodities. They found no evidence to support the "Pollution Haven Hypothesis," suggesting that environmental controls do not impact the location of dirty industries.

Technological innovation

Electric vehicles (EVs) are a significant innovation, reducing carbon emissions from traditional cars. The adoption of EVs, along with blockchain carbon trading and increased digitisation, can lead to less waste and a minimal reliance on fossil fuels.

Agricultural IoT technology is another innovation that can reduce environmental damage. By ensuring farmers use the correct amount of fertiliser and pesticides, unnecessary ecological damage and waste caused by land mismanagement can be prevented. IoT sensors can also monitor soil quality and support precision watering, reducing water waste.

Trade itself can encourage technological innovation, with multinational corporations bringing clean, state-of-the-art production techniques to host countries. This can lead to a cycle of innovation and environmental improvement.

Income and growth

International trade has expanded massively over the past half-century, with world trade growing more than 27 times larger since 1950. This expansion has been driven by technological change, which has reduced the cost of transportation and communications, and by the opening-up of trade regimes.

The impact of this expansion on the environment is complex. On the one hand, increased trade can lead to greater income and growth, which can stimulate a demand for better environmental quality. This is known as the "gains-from-trade hypothesis". For example, at higher levels of income per capita, growth can lead to environmental regulation and a reduction in pollution as countries can afford to clean up their environments. Trade can also lead to international pressures to increase environmental standards, and to beneficial technological and managerial innovations.

On the other hand, increased trade can also lead to increased production and economic activity, which can have a negative impact on the environment. This is known as the "scale" effect. Trade can also lead to the development of "pollution havens", where some countries specialise in dirtier production and export their products to other countries that specialise in cleaner production.

Overall, the relationship between trade and the environment is complex and multifaceted. While trade can lead to increased income and growth, which can stimulate a demand for better environmental quality, it can also lead to increased production and economic activity, which can have a negative impact on the environment.

Trade agreements

However, the relationship between trade and pollution is complex. While increased trade may initially worsen pollution, particularly in developing countries, it can also drive innovation and the adoption of cleaner technologies. Trade agreements can play a role in mitigating pollution by including environmental provisions that reduce "dirty" exports and promote "green" exports. These provisions can be used as targeted policy tools to encourage the use of cleaner production techniques and the development of green technologies.

For example, the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has been studied for its environmental impact, considering the effects of trade liberalization on scale, composition, and technique. The "scale" effect refers to the increased economic activity and energy use leading to higher greenhouse gas emissions. On the other hand, the "composition" effect describes how trade liberalization can change a country's production mix towards products where it has a comparative advantage, potentially impacting pollution levels.

Additionally, trade agreements can facilitate the transfer of clean technologies and production techniques from more developed countries to host countries. Multinational corporations often bring state-of-the-art, environmentally friendly practices to countries where such standards are not yet established. This transfer of knowledge and technology can help raise environmental standards and reduce pollution over time.

In conclusion, while trade agreements have been associated with increased pollution, particularly in the transportation sector, they also present opportunities for mitigating pollution through the inclusion of environmental provisions and the transfer of clean technologies. Well-designed trade policies that consider the environmental impact can play a crucial role in promoting sustainable development and reducing pollution on a global scale.

Frequently asked questions