Desalination Plants: Environmental Impact And Pollution

As access to clean freshwater becomes increasingly scarce, countries are turning to desalination plants to meet their water needs. However, this solution comes at a cost. Desalination plants produce large amounts of salty wastewater or brine, which is often pumped back into the ocean, leading to concerns about its environmental impact. This has sparked debates about the pollution caused by desalination plants and the need to balance water security with ecological preservation.

The environmental impact of brine discharge

Desalination is the process of separating dissolved salts from an aqueous solution to obtain freshwater. While it is an effective and reliable process for obtaining freshwater, there are concerns about its possible adverse environmental impacts. A major issue with the desalination process is the waste called 'brine' or 'reject', which has a high salinity along with chemical residuals and is discharged into the marine environment.

Secondly, brine discharge can reduce oxygen levels in seawater, profoundly impacting seabed creatures like shellfish and crabs, leading to observable ecological effects throughout the food chain. Additionally, the dense brine can sink to the sea bottom and spread over the seabed, impairing the activities of benthic organisms, including bacteria, seagrasses, polychaetes, and corals, and altering nutrient fluxes from the sediment to the water column.

Moreover, the high total alkalinity of brine discharge increases the levels of calcium carbonate, calcium sulphate, and other elements in seawater, which can have ecological implications. Brine discharge can also change the pH range of marine environments, although this impact is considered negligible compared to other effects.

Furthermore, brine discharge may contain residues of cleaning chemicals, reaction by-products, and heavy metals from equipment corrosion, adding to the chemical pollution in the marine environment. While some plants treat the chemicals and dilute the brine before discharge, the release of these substances can still have ecological consequences.

In conclusion, while desalination provides freshwater for over 300 million people worldwide, the environmental impact of brine discharge is a significant concern. The discharge of brine waste increases salinity, introduces harmful chemicals, reduces oxygen levels, spreads over the seabed, alters seawater composition, and contributes to chemical pollution. Mitigation strategies are available but may be costly, highlighting the urgent need to develop affordable and sustainable solutions to minimize the environmental footprint of desalination plants.

The effect of brine on marine life

Desalination plants are becoming increasingly common as a solution to water shortages. However, they produce large volumes of hypersaline brine waste, which is often pumped into the ocean. This can have a detrimental effect on marine life.

Brine waste from desalination plants is estimated to be around 1.5 times more than the world's desalination capacity, equating to 142 million cubic metres per day. This waste is often pumped into the ocean, raising salinity levels to dangerous levels. Brine is about twice as salty as seawater, and when it is discharged into the ocean, it can carry harmful chemicals, such as copper, chlorine, lead, zinc, arsenic, and naphthalene. These toxic chemicals can have a detrimental effect on marine life, with potential impacts observable throughout the food chain.

The discharge of brine can also affect the temperature of the ocean, which can influence the production rate and lifespan of marine species. For example, an increase in temperature can lead to a higher growth rate of plankton but can also be fatal to other species. Additionally, the complex mixing and stratification patterns of brine due to changes in density and hydrodynamic properties can result in brine intrusion disasters, directly impacting both ecosystems and human life.

The impact of brine on marine life can be mitigated to some extent. Newer desalination plants are often fitted with high-pressure diffusers that discharge brine at high velocity, increasing the mixing and dilution of brine with ocean water. Additionally, multiport submerged diffusers are considered an effective solution to protect marine life by providing high dilution capabilities. However, these methods may not be suitable for environmentally sensitive areas.

The negative effects of brine on marine life highlight the importance of exploring alternative water sources, such as wastewater reuse and conservation, as well as improving water supply systems to reduce leaks.

The energy requirements of desalination

Desalination is a process that can provide an unlimited supply of freshwater. However, the process has high energy requirements, which pose a significant challenge. The energy requirements for desalination are theoretically estimated at around 0.86 kWh of energy for every cubic metre of saltwater (34,500 ppm), or 3 kJ kg-1. In practice, current desalination plants consume between 5 and 26 times this amount, depending on the specific process used. As a result, it is crucial to enhance the energy efficiency of desalination processes through technological advancements and economies of scale.

The energy demands of desalination processes are predominantly met by burning fossil fuels, which are not only limited in supply but also contribute to air pollution and climate change. With the world's energy landscape in the 20th century being largely shaped by oil, the transition to sustainable energy sources is imperative. However, this transition is influenced by various factors, including the relative cost of renewable energy sources and the pace at which the world can adopt sustainable technologies.

The high energy consumption of desalination processes is a concern, and efforts are being made to improve energy efficiency. One approach is to utilise renewable energy sources, such as solar energy, to reduce the environmental impact of the desalination process. Additionally, certain strategies can be employed to minimise the adverse effects of brine discharge on the environment. For instance, plants can be strategically located in areas with strong currents, facilitating better dispersion of brine.

While brine waste from desalination plants can have detrimental effects on marine ecosystems, there are potential economic opportunities in "mining" it. With advanced technology, valuable metals and salts can be extracted from the brine for industrial and agricultural applications. This approach could be particularly beneficial for countries with large brine production and low efficiencies, such as Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Kuwait, and Qatar.

In conclusion, the energy requirements of desalination are substantial, and the current reliance on fossil fuels is environmentally unsustainable. To address these challenges, it is essential to prioritise investments in renewable energy sources and sustainable technologies. Additionally, the environmental impact of brine waste can be mitigated through strategic plant locations and the exploration of economic opportunities presented by brine mining. By implementing these measures, it is possible to balance the need for freshwater with the preservation of marine ecosystems and the reduction of pollution.

The economic impact of brine waste

Desalination plants produce an excess of highly salty wastewater, or brine, which is pumped into the ocean and has been shown to harm marine ecosystems. This is a problem that is likely to worsen as more countries build desalination plants to combat the effects of climate change and population growth on fresh water supplies.

The disposal of brine waste is costly, and the environmental damage caused by brine waste can also have economic repercussions. Technologies exist to reduce brine waste prior to disposal, or to mine pollutants out of the waste for commercial use, but these are generally cost-prohibitive. In addition, the environmental damage caused by brine waste can have economic consequences for industries such as fishing and tourism. For example, brine can cut levels of oxygen in seawater near desalination plants, having "profound impacts" on marine life and "ecological effects observable throughout the food chain".

However, brine waste also presents economic opportunities. Salt and metals contained in brine, including magnesium, gypsum, sodium chloride, calcium, potassium, chlorine, bromine and lithium, can be extracted for commercial uses. This process, known as brine valorisation, can recover valuable resources such as water, minerals, salts, metals, and energy. While this technology is currently expensive, improvements could make it more economically viable in the future.

In conclusion, while the economic and environmental costs of brine waste are significant, there is potential to mitigate these costs and even turn brine waste into an economic opportunity through advancements in brine valorisation technology.

Strategies to minimise damage

Desalination plants are an integral component of human society, offering benefits that were unthinkable before their creation. They are particularly important in regions facing acute water scarcity. However, they also have a negative impact on the environment.

• Improve waste brine management: Brine is a byproduct of the desalination process and contains elevated levels of salt and chemicals. It can harm marine life and disrupt the delicate balance of marine ecosystems. Proper brine disposal management is crucial to minimise environmental impact. One approach is to situate plants in areas with strong currents to help disperse the brine. However, this is not always possible, as seen in the case of the Arabian Gulf, where the lack of strong currents has led to a 25% increase in salinity.
• Reduce brine waste: Technologies exist to reduce brine waste before disposal, such as reverse osmosis, which has a lower heat impact than thermal technologies. However, these technologies are often cost-prohibitive.
• Mine pollutants for commercial use: With bolstered technology, valuable metals and salts can be extracted from brine and sold for industrial and agricultural uses. This approach can help turn an environmental problem into an economic opportunity.
• Explore alternative water sources: In many arid areas, reusing wastewater and sourcing freshwater from streams, rivers, lakes, and underground aquifers can be more environmentally and economically viable options than desalination.
• Improve conservation and reduce leaks: Water conservation measures and reducing leaks in water supply systems can help reduce the need for desalination.
• Hybrid renewable-powered desalination: Hybrid renewable-powered desalination and reusing brine for irrigation-tolerant plants are promising solutions that are currently being explored.
• Improve brine dispersal technologies: Enhancing dilution through improved brine dispersal technologies can help reduce the immediate harm caused by direct exposure to highly salty wastewater.

Frequently asked questions