Solar Energy: Clean Power, But What's The Catch?

Solar energy is a fast-growing energy source that is vital to the effort to reduce fossil fuel use. It is also a clean energy source that does not produce emissions contributing to climate change or air pollution. However, there are environmental concerns associated with solar energy production, including land use and habitat loss, water use, and the use of hazardous materials in manufacturing. As the solar market grows, so will the volume of end-of-life panels, which may contain hazardous materials and metals such as lead and cadmium. While solar energy has many advantages, it is important to consider its potential environmental impacts and how these can be mitigated.

Solar panels can contain hazardous materials

Solar panels are made with photovoltaic (PV) cells of silicon semiconductors that absorb sunlight and create an electric current. While in use, solar panels safely generate electricity without creating any air emissions. However, solar panels can contain hazardous materials, and as the solar PV market grows, so will the volume of end-of-life panels.

The two most common types of solar panels are crystalline-silicon and thin-film solar panels. Crystalline-silicon solar panels, which represent over 95% of solar panels sold today, contain small amounts of valuable metals such as silver and copper. Thin-film solar cells, on the other hand, contain thin layers of semiconductor material, such as cadmium telluride (CdTe) or copper indium gallium diselenide (CIGS), layered on a supporting material such as glass, plastic, or metal.

Hazardous waste testing on solar panels has indicated that different varieties of solar panels have different metals present in the semiconductor and solder. Some of these metals, like lead and cadmium, are harmful to human health and the environment at high levels. If these metals are present in high enough quantities, solar panel waste could be classified as hazardous waste. In such cases, regulations under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) must be followed to ensure the panels are safely recycled or disposed of.

The disposal of solar panels has emerged as a significant concern, with many panels ending up in landfills. The Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) has warned against disposing of solar panels in regular landfills, as the release of toxic materials into the soil can have detrimental effects. California is currently working on diverting solar panels from landfills, implementing new regulations to address the issue of solar waste.

While recycling efforts for solar panels are increasing, the process can be expensive, and the proper disposal of hazardous materials remains a challenge. Some countries, such as China, have been criticized for releasing toxic chemicals into the environment instead of disposing of them safely due to the high costs associated with proper disposal. However, companies like the French startup ROSI Solar are developing innovative processes to extract valuable materials from used panels, contributing to the growing trend of solar panel recycling.

Land use and habitat loss

Solar energy is a fast-growing energy source that is vital to the effort to reduce fossil fuel use. However, it is not without its environmental impacts, including land use and habitat loss.

Land use for solar energy is currently negligible compared to other human land uses. However, as the world transitions to renewable energy sources, solar energy will require more land. At 25-80% penetration in the electricity mix of the EU, India, Japan, and South Korea by 2050, solar energy may occupy 0.5-5% of total land. This increased land use will likely cause a net release of carbon, ranging from 0 to 50 gCO2/kWh, depending on various factors such as the region, scale of expansion, solar technology efficiency, and land management practices.

The competition for land between solar energy and other land uses, such as forests and agriculture, has led to land-use conflicts. Solar farms have been built in forested regions, resulting in deforestation. Remote sensing analysis showed that 9.14% of solar farms exhibit land-use conflicts with forests, accounting for 4.9% of the total solar farm area. Deforestation may increase the local solar capacity factor (CF), but it still remains lower than over open land (cropland or grassland). Additionally, the effect of increased CF following deforestation may take about 36 years to emerge, potentially exceeding the service lifetime of a solar farm (25-30 years).

To minimize land-use conflicts and habitat loss, siting policies should avoid adverse land impacts and limit land competition. This can be done by excluding high-yield cropland, maximizing the use of urban areas and degraded arable land, or by seeding solar land with herbs and managing these lands as common pastures. Additionally, the design and management of solar parks are crucial for the carbon cycle. For example, higher-placed modules can allow more sunlight to reach the vegetation below, and careful consideration of how to manage the land below the solar infrastructure can impact the local carbon cycle.

Water usage

Solar energy is widely regarded as a sustainable and environmentally friendly alternative to traditional energy sources. Notably, solar panels do not produce emissions when generating electricity, which significantly reduces air pollution and promotes a healthier environment.

However, the water usage associated with solar energy systems is a more complex issue. While solar panels themselves do not require water to generate power, the overall solar energy system may require water for cooling and cleaning purposes. This is particularly true for solar power plants, which can use significant amounts of water for cooling, especially in arid regions where water resources are already limited. In such cases, solar plants can place a strain on local or regional water resources and even consume more water per unit of electricity produced than conventional fossil fuel plants.

The cleaning of solar collectors, concentrators, receivers, and panels also necessitates water usage. While photovoltaic power plants are highly water-efficient, using only a fraction of the water consumed by fossil fuel plants for daily operations, the chemicals used in the cleaning process can be a cause for concern. These chemicals, if not properly managed, can contaminate groundwater sources.

Furthermore, the production of solar panels involves water usage during the manufacturing of certain components, such as photovoltaic units. The chemicals employed in this process are caustic and toxic, posing a risk of soil and groundwater contamination in the event of spills.

To summarize, while solar energy systems themselves do not directly consume water during electricity generation, the broader context of water usage in the cooling, cleaning, and manufacturing processes associated with solar energy infrastructure warrants consideration. The potential impact on water resources and the risk of groundwater contamination underscore the importance of responsible water management and the development of safe disposal mechanisms in the solar energy industry.

Manufacturing emissions

Solar panels produce around 50g of CO2 during manufacturing. This is significantly lower than the amount of CO2 produced by other energy sources, such as natural gas, coal, and petroleum. However, it is important to note that the manufacturing process for solar panels can vary between different countries and panel types, which can impact the emissions produced. For example, China, which is responsible for half of the world's photovoltaic panel production, produces double the emissions per panel compared to Western countries.

The manufacturing process for solar panels involves extracting raw materials, manufacturing equipment, and constructing the manufacturing plants. The production of silicon, a key component in solar panels, is particularly energy-intensive, contributing about 6.0 kg of CO2 per kg of silicon metal produced. Other metals used in solar panels, such as copper, silver, indium, and tellurium, also require mining, which produces carbon emissions.

The carbon footprint of manufacturing solar panels accounts for roughly two-thirds of the life-cycle emissions of solar energy. However, it is important to note that the operational emissions of solar panels are minimal, especially for rooftop solar systems. Once installed, solar panels quickly offset the carbon emissions associated with their manufacturing, typically within 2-3 years. This is because solar panels produce clean, renewable energy, and their long lifespans of 25 years or more allow them to generate far more energy than was required to produce them.

While solar panels have a lower carbon footprint than many other energy sources, there are still opportunities to reduce their manufacturing emissions. This can be achieved by transitioning to renewable energy sources for powering the manufacturing process, recycling materials, and improving the efficiency and longevity of solar panels. Researchers are also exploring ways to upcycle waste created during solar panel manufacturing, such as "silicon powder", to reduce the need for extracting raw materials and associated emissions.

End-of-life disposal

Solar panels have a lifespan of 25-30 years. When they reach the end of their lives, they must be managed and disposed of safely. In the US, there are no nationwide regulations for solar panel disposal, with a few exceptions, such as the solar panel recycling law in the State of Washington. However, federal solid and hazardous waste regulations (i.e. the RCRA requirements) apply to solar panels when they are discarded. If solar panels are considered hazardous waste, regulations under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) must be followed to ensure proper recycling or disposal.

The hazardous chemicals used for manufacturing photovoltaic (PV) cells and panels must be carefully handled to avoid releasing them into the environment. Some solar panels contain heavy metals, and these types of cells and panels may require special handling at the end of their useful life. Some solar panels are considered hazardous waste, even within the same model and manufacturer. Homeowners with solar panels on their houses should contact their state/local recycling agencies for more information on disposal/recycling.

There are already some recycling programs for solar panels, and the recycled materials can be used to manufacture new panels. The International Renewable Energy Agency estimates that by 2023, the cumulative value of recoverable raw materials from dead solar panels will be equivalent to the cost of raw materials needed to produce about 60 million new solar panels.

However, there is still a lack of awareness about proper solar panel disposal, and some used solar panels end up in landfills. As the solar photovoltaic (PV) market grows, the volume of end-of-life panels will also increase. By 2030, the United States is expected to have up to one million total tons of solar panel waste, and by 2050, it is projected to have the second-largest number of end-of-life panels in the world, with up to an estimated 10 million total tons of panels.

Frequently asked questions