San Diego's Air Pollution: Where's The Worst Of It?

San Diego's air quality is adversely affected by high levels of ozone and particle pollution, which can have severe health effects on residents. While the air quality is generally acceptable, sensitive groups may experience symptoms such as coughing, asthma attacks, and difficulty breathing. San Diego's air pollution is also impacted by emissions from nearby Los Angeles, which has the worst ozone levels in the nation. Within San Diego County, Alpine, Borrego Springs, and Warner Springs have been identified as areas with the highest levels of ozone pollution.

San Diego's ozone pollution

San Diego's air quality is suffering from frequent and prolonged periods of unhealthy ozone pollution. Ozone is a corrosive gas pollutant made up of three oxygen atoms. Due to its highly reactive nature, prolonged exposure can damage lung tissue, leading to early lung ageing and the worsening of chronic lung disease. Short-term effects can trigger asthma attacks, coughing, and difficulty breathing. These effects are more acute in sensitive groups, including children, the elderly, and individuals with pre-existing heart and lung conditions. On average, San Diego experiences 43.3 days of unhealthy ozone annually, far exceeding the federal target of 3.2 days. This severe non-attainment status has resulted in an "F" rating by the American Lung Association (ALA).

There is a concerning trend of worsening ozone in San Diego. Since 2015, the number of unhealthy ozone days has risen by 42%. The majority (42%) of the pollutants that contribute to ozone formation in San Diego County come from tailpipe emissions from motor vehicles. The city's population and emissions are primarily concentrated in the western part of the County, particularly in the inland areas near the Cuyamaca Mountains. According to a state study, Alpine, Borrego Springs, and Warner Springs have the highest levels of ozone pollution in San Diego County.

Fine particulate matter, or PM2.5, is another key contributor to San Diego's air pollution. PM2.5 is a term for a suspended mixture of tiny particles, including metals, soot, soil, dust, and salt. Breathing PM2.5 has been linked to adverse health effects such as heart and lung diseases, cancer, and premature mortality. The ALA has rated San Diego a "C" for 24-hour particle pollution. While the city meets annual attainment levels for PM2.5 over a year, it failed to do so in 2017 and 2018. Since 2018, PM2.5 pollution levels in San Diego have improved by 32%.

The air pollution levels in San Diego are also influenced by its geographical location. The city is part of the San Diego Air Basin (SDAB), a subtropical climate zone with hot, dry summers and mild, wet winters. Light winds and stagnant air, combined with little precipitation and many days over 70 degrees, create ideal conditions for the creation and accumulation of ozone pollution. San Diego's coastal location also gives way to marine inversions, where cooler ground-level air near the ocean becomes trapped by warmer, denser air above. Additionally, winds flowing down from the South Coast Air Basin and Los Angeles, which has the worst ozone levels in the nation, can significantly elevate San Diego's air pollution levels.

Particle pollution in San Diego County

Particle pollution, or PM2.5, is a key contributor to San Diego's air pollution. PM2.5 is a term for a mixture of tiny particles, including metals, soot, soil, dust, and salt. This form of pollution is known as "visibility-reducing particles" due to their contribution to regional smog.

San Diego's air quality has been rated a "C" for 24-hour particle pollution by the American Lung Association (ALA). This is due to the city's average of two annual unhealthy PM2.5 days. While the city meets annual attainment levels for PM2.5 over the year, it failed to do so in 2017 and 2018. Since 2018, PM2.5 pollution levels have improved by 32%, although this may be due to more ideal weather and environmental conditions.

The ALA's "State of the Air" grades are based on the number of days a county's air reaches unhealthful levels on the Air Quality Index. Each unhealthy air day is given a weighted score, with orange days weighted at 1, red days at 1.5, purple days at 2, and maroon days at 2.5. These scores are averaged to give a grade for the county. For year-round particle pollution, grading is based on the national standard for annual PM2.5 of 9 μg/m3. Counties with a design value at or below this standard are given a passing grade, while counties above 9.1 μg/m3 fail.

According to a state study, Alpine, Borrego Springs, and Warner Springs have the highest levels of ozone pollution in San Diego County. The city's population and emissions are concentrated in the western part of the county, particularly in the inland areas near the Cuyamaca Mountains. The majority (42%) of the pollutants that contribute to ozone formation in San Diego County come from tailpipe emissions from motor vehicles.

Sources of air pollution in San Diego

San Diego's air quality is generally acceptable for most individuals. However, the air pollution levels in the region are still a cause for concern, particularly for sensitive groups, including children, the elderly, and those with pre-existing heart and lung conditions. On days with high pollution levels, even healthy individuals may experience respiratory issues such as difficulty breathing and throat irritation.

One of the primary sources of air pollution in San Diego is ozone pollution. Ozone is a corrosive gas composed of three oxygen atoms, and it can have detrimental health effects. Prolonged exposure to ozone can cause damage to lung tissue, leading to early aging of the lungs and exacerbating chronic lung diseases. Short-term exposure can trigger asthma attacks, coughing, and breathing difficulties. San Diego experiences a significantly high number of days with unhealthy ozone levels, far exceeding the federal target of 3.2 unhealthy days per year. The city's ozone levels are influenced by winds carrying pollution from the South Coast Air Basin and Los Angeles, which has the worst ozone pollution in the nation.

Another key contributor to San Diego's air pollution is fine particulate matter, known as PM2.5. This term refers to a mixture of tiny particles with various chemical compositions, including metals, soot, soil, dust, and salt. Exposure to PM2.5 has been linked to serious health issues such as heart and lung diseases, cancer, and premature mortality. While San Diego has shown some improvement in reducing PM2.5 pollution levels since 2018, it still falls short of meeting the annual attainment levels consistently.

Additionally, tailpipe emissions from motor vehicles significantly contribute to ozone formation in San Diego County. The western part of the county, particularly the inland areas near the Cuyamaca Mountains, has higher population density and emissions concentrations. Specific locations in San Diego with higher levels of air pollution include Barrio Logan, just south of downtown, which has exceptionally high asthma rates. Other areas with high pollution levels include Alpine, Borrego Springs, and Warner Springs, which have the highest ozone pollution levels in the county.

Health effects of San Diego's air pollution

San Diego's air quality has been described as \"good\" with an Air Quality Index (AQI) of 39. However, this is an average, and there are still frequent and prolonged periods of unhealthy air pollution, particularly concerning ozone and particle pollution. Ozone is a corrosive gas pollutant composed of three oxygen atoms. It is highly reactive, and prolonged exposure can damage lung tissue, leading to the early ageing of the lungs and the worsening of chronic lung disease. Short-term effects can trigger asthma attacks, coughing, and difficulty breathing. These effects are more acute in sensitive groups, including children, the elderly, and individuals with pre-existing heart and lung conditions.

San Diego experiences high levels of ozone pollution, with numbers more than 13 times the national target. This has been linked to the county's exceedingly high asthma rates, particularly in Barrio Logan, just south of the downtown area. A transition to more fuel-efficient, lower-emission vehicles and improved public transportation could help reduce ozone levels.

Particle pollutants, such as PM2.5, are another key contributor to San Diego's air pollution. PM2.5 refers to a mixture of tiny particles, including metals, soot, soil, dust, and salt. Breathing PM2.5 has been linked to adverse health effects, including heart and lung diseases, cancer, and premature mortality. While San Diego has shown some improvement in PM2.5 levels since 2018, it still faces challenges in meeting annual attainment levels.

Overall, while San Diego's air quality is generally acceptable for most individuals, sensitive groups may experience adverse health effects with long-term exposure. The city has made some progress in reducing air pollution, but there is still room for improvement, especially in addressing ozone and particle pollution levels.

San Diego's air quality compared to other cities

San Diego's air quality is frequently affected by high levels of ozone pollution, which is a corrosive gas pollutant composed of three oxygen atoms. Ozone pollution in the city has been described as ""among the nation's worst", and the city has been rated 6th nationally for worst ozone pollution out of 229 metropolitan areas. This is due in part to its proximity to Los Angeles, which is located 120 miles northwest of San Diego and has been consistently ranked as having the worst ozone pollution in the nation. Los Angeles' ozone pollution is blown down by winds from the South Coast air basin, significantly elevating San Diego's air pollution levels. Additionally, San Diego's location on the coast contributes to pollution-accumulating weather events known as marine inversions, where cooler ground-level air near the ocean becomes trapped by warmer, denser air above, leading to the accumulation of ground-level emissions.

The American Lung Association (ALA) has given San Diego an "F" rating for its severe nonattainment status in terms of ozone pollution. The city experiences an average of 43.3 days of unhealthy ozone levels annually, far exceeding the 3.2-day federal target. This has led to concerning health effects on residents, particularly sensitive groups such as children, the elderly, and individuals with pre-existing heart and lung conditions. The short-term effects of ozone exposure include triggering asthma attacks, coughing, and difficulty breathing. Prolonged exposure can cause more severe issues, such as damage to lung tissue, early aging of the lungs, and the worsening of chronic lung disease.

In addition to ozone pollution, fine particulate matter (PM2.5) is another key contributor to San Diego's air pollution. PM2.5 refers to a mixture of tiny particles with various chemical compositions and sources, including metals, soot, soil, dust, and salt. Breathing air with high levels of PM2.5 has been linked to adverse health effects such as heart and lung diseases, cancer, and premature mortality. While San Diego has shown some improvement in reducing PM2.5 pollution levels since 2018, the city still struggles to meet annual attainment levels, achieving only a barely passing grade of "C" from the ALA for 24-hour particle pollution.

When compared to other cities, San Diego's air quality fares better than some areas in California, such as Visalia, Bakersfield, the Fresno-Madera-Hanford area, Sacramento, and Roseville. However, it is important to note that these comparisons are based on specific years and may not reflect consistent trends over time. Additionally, while San Diego's air quality may be acceptable for most individuals on certain days, there are still periods when even healthy individuals may experience negative health effects, such as difficulty breathing and throat irritation, due to high pollution levels. Therefore, it is crucial for residents to stay informed about real-time air quality data and take necessary precautions to protect their health.

Frequently asked questions