The Pollution Battle: Coal Vs Oil

Coal, oil, and natural gas are fossil fuels that have been used for over a century to generate most of the energy required for transportation, businesses, and homes. Fossil fuels are non-renewable resources that are created when organic material is buried and exposed to pressure and heat. Coal is a carbon-heavy rock that is predominantly composed of carbon-carbon bonds, while oil and gas are hydrogen-rich and are formed from long chains of carbon and hydrogen. The carbon-intensity of each fuel determines how much CO2 it produces when burned, and coal has a much higher carbon content than oil or gas. As a result, burning coal releases more CO2, a significant greenhouse gas and driver of global warming, than oil or gas. In addition to CO2 emissions, burning coal also releases harmful pollutants such as sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, particulates, heavy metals, and volatile organic compounds, which have been linked to respiratory illnesses, lung disease, neurological problems, and cancer. However, it is important to note that oil and gas development also pose threats to waterways and groundwater through oil spills and leaks, and fracking has been associated with water and air pollution.

Coal mining techniques can change the landscape and harm wildlife

Coal mining techniques can have a significant impact on the landscape and wildlife. Surface mining, also known as strip mining, involves removing large amounts of soil and rock to access coal seams. This process can lead to deforestation, soil erosion, and the destruction of wildlife habitats. Mountaintop removal, a particularly controversial form of surface mining, has drastically altered the landscape of the Appalachian Mountains in West Virginia and Kentucky. This technique employs explosives to remove mountain tops, and the resulting rock and soil are dumped into nearby valleys, burying streams and disrupting aquatic ecosystems.

The conversion of forests into barren wastelands through surface mining forces wildlife to seek alternative habitats. Excessive logging and the removal of vegetation cover accelerate erosion, as loose topsoil is easily washed away by precipitation into nearby waterways. This not only degrades the quality of water but also leads to the loss of aquatic life. Additionally, the dust generated during coal mining and processing can impair photosynthesis in plants, further diminishing the availability of food and shelter for wildlife.

Acid mine drainage (AMD) is another significant environmental concern associated with coal mining. AMD occurs when water reacts with sulfur-bearing minerals in rocks, resulting in highly acidic water containing toxic heavy metals. This acidic water poses severe threats to aquatic wildlife and renders affected waterways unusable for drinking or recreational purposes. The release of coal ash, a toxic byproduct of coal-burning power plants, has also resulted in spills that devastate natural wildlife habitats and contaminate water sources.

Coal mining activities contribute to air pollution and climate change. The burning of coal releases harmful pollutants, including sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, mercury, carbon monoxide, and arsenic. These emissions contribute to smog, acid rain, and toxic air pollution, leading to respiratory and cardiovascular diseases in both wildlife and humans. Additionally, coal mining can release coalbed methane, a potent greenhouse gas that must be safely vented out of mines to prevent explosions.

While underground mines generally have a less noticeable impact on the landscape, they are not without their environmental challenges. Abandoned underground mines can experience the drainage of acidic water, similar to AMD, which further contaminates nearby water sources. Moreover, the ground above mine tunnels may collapse, altering the topography and creating physical barriers for wildlife movement and habitat connectivity.

Coal releases more CO2 than oil or gas

Coal, oil, and natural gas are fossil fuels that are used to generate energy. Fossil fuels are made of organic material that has decayed over millennia. However, burning coal releases more carbon dioxide (CO2) than burning oil or gas.

Coal is a solid, carbon-heavy rock that comes in four main varieties: lignite, sub-bituminous, bituminous, and anthracite. The carbon content of coal varies depending on the amount of heat and pressure it experiences during its formation. Younger "lignite" coal contains about 25% carbon, while anthracite coal can have up to 97% carbon. When coal is burned, chemical reactions release energy and toxic airborne pollutants, such as heavy metals, into the environment. These pollutants have been linked to asthma, cancer, heart and lung ailments, and neurological problems.

Oil and gas, on the other hand, are formed in the ocean from the remains of small plants and animals called plankton. This organic material mixes with other substances on the ocean floor and, under increased temperature and pressure, eventually becomes oil and gas. Unlike coal, oil and gas are hydrogen-rich and have lower carbon content. As a result, they produce less CO2 when burned.

The higher carbon content in coal makes it more carbon-intensive than oil or gas. According to Gregory Stephanopoulos, an MIT professor of chemical engineering, "coal has a lot more carbon in it" than oil or gas. This higher carbon intensity leads to increased CO2 emissions, making coal a significant contributor to climate change and global warming.

While oil and gas produce less CO2 than coal, they still contribute to climate warming. Additionally, natural gas, which is primarily composed of CH4, is a short-lived climate pollutant that has a more potent warming effect on the planet than CO2. Nevertheless, efforts to reduce CO2 emissions from coal burning are ongoing, including carbon capture and storage technologies.

Coal mining operations contaminate drinking water sources

Coal mining operations have been linked to the contamination of drinking water sources. While improvements have been made to mining practices in recent years, significant environmental risks remain. Water pollution from mine waste rock and tailings may need to be managed for decades, if not centuries, after a mine's closure. The negative impacts of coal mining on water quality can be seen in the following ways:

Acid Mine Drainage

Acid Rock Drainage (ARD) is a natural process that occurs when sulphur-bearing minerals in rocks are exposed to air and water, resulting in the formation of sulphuric acid. This process is similar to the human-induced process of Acid Mine Drainage (AMD), which is the most prevalent type of drainage associated with abandoned mines. AMD is the formation and movement of highly acidic water rich in heavy metals, which can contaminate nearby waterways and harm aquatic life.

Sedimentation and Water Disturbance

Poorly built roads during exploration, sedimentation, and the disturbance of water during mine construction can all impact water quality. Mountaintop removal and valley fill mining, for example, have altered the landscape of the Appalachian Mountains in West Virginia and Kentucky. Streams have been covered with rock and dirt, and the water draining from these filled valleys may contain pollutants that harm aquatic wildlife downstream.

Coal Ash Contamination

Coal ash, a grey powder-like substance left behind after coal is burned, contains toxic elements such as arsenic, lead, and mercury. It is often stored in unlined ponds or pits, and over time, these heavy metals can escape into nearby waterways, contaminating drinking water sources. Coal ash spills, such as the one that occurred in North Carolina's Dan River in 2014, further highlight the risks of coal ash storage and its potential impact on water sources.

Thermal Pollution

Coal plants that use a "once-through" system pump water from a source, heat it up, and then discharge it back, often at a higher temperature. This thermal pollution can decrease fertility and increase heart rates in fish, impacting the ecosystems within these water bodies.

Groundwater Contamination

The storage of coal ash and waste rock near power plants or in landfills can result in pollution that leaches into the ground and contaminates groundwater. This contaminated groundwater can then mix with surface water and soil, potentially harming humans, animals, and plants that come into contact with it.

Oil spills and leaks during extraction or transportation

Oil spills and leaks can occur during the extraction or transportation of oil. Oil spills can be classified in several ways, including natural leaks, daily human leaks, drilling blowouts, deliberate spills, transportation leaks, daily spills (small spills), tanker accidents (large spills), and unchecked leaks.

Extraction of oil can result in spills and leaks. Drilling blowouts, for instance, occur when oil gushes out of an exploration drill. One notable example is the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in 2010, which was the largest US oil spill. It resulted from a pipeline leak and an oil rig explosion, killing 11 people.

Transportation of oil also carries the risk of spills and leaks. Transportation leaks can occur during the movement of oil by pipes, ships, trucks, or trains to refineries. Large oil spills tend to happen when pipelines break or when oil tanker ships sink. For instance, the 1967 Torrey Canyon oil tanker spill and the 1991 Gulf War oil spill, which was the largest oil spill to date, were both caused by the destruction of oil tankers.

Oil spills can have detrimental effects on the environment, wildlife, and human activities. When oil spills into the ocean, it can harm sea creatures, such as birds and sea otters, by coating their bodies and impairing their movement or insulation. Oil toxicity can also lead to severe health issues, including heart damage, stunted growth, and immune system problems, and even result in death. Oil spills can ruin beaches, make seafood unsafe to eat, and have long-lasting negative impacts on ecosystems and economies.

Coal ash is often stored near power plants or placed in landfills

Burning coal and oil releases harmful pollutants into the atmosphere, causing profound environmental and public health impacts. Coal is a significant contributor to air pollution, global warming, and climate change.

Coal combustion for power production generates a waste product called coal ash, also known as coal combustion products (CCPs) or coal combustion residuals (CCRs). This ash includes fly ash, bottom ash, boiler slag, and flue-gas desulfurization materials. In the United States, coal ash is often stored near power plants or placed in landfills, with similar practices in other countries. Storing coal ash in landfills is typically the cheapest and easiest option, especially when a disposal site is located near a power plant. However, this practice has raised environmental concerns due to the risk of groundwater contamination.

Coal ash contains hazardous pollutants, including arsenic, boron, cobalt, chromium, lead, lithium, mercury, molybdenum, radium, selenium, and other heavy metals. These pollutants are associated with various adverse health effects, such as cancer, heart and thyroid disease, reproductive issues, and neurological damage. In 2024, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued a new rule requiring power plants to clean up their toxic coal ash and extending federal monitoring and cleanup requirements to previously excluded older coal ash landfills and ponds. This action was prompted by the discovery of toxic coal ash leaking into groundwater from dumps in 31 states and Puerto Rico.

The safe disposal of coal ash is regulated by the EPA, which has established guidelines for coal-fired power plants to store coal ash only in landfills and disposal sites that meet minimum structural standards. These sites are required to be monitored for leaks, and certain measures, such as lining the landfills, are implemented to prevent groundwater contamination. However, environmental groups have protested the EPA's classification of coal ash as a "non-hazardous" material, arguing for stricter definitions and more costly disposal rules.

While storage in landfills is prevalent, some countries have adopted alternative approaches to coal ash management. For example, the Netherlands recycles 100% of its coal ash, as landfill disposal is not permitted. In Germany, approximately 97% of the 10 million tonnes of coal ash produced annually is reused, with the remaining amount stored temporarily. Reusing coal ash offers environmental benefits, such as reducing greenhouse gas emissions and the need for landfill disposal, as well as economic advantages, including decreased disposal costs and increased revenue from the sale of coal ash.

Frequently asked questions