Air Pollution Vs Smoking: Who's The Deadlier Killer?

Air pollution and smoking are two of the most pressing public health issues of our time. While they share many similarities, they are not equally dangerous. A 2019 study published in the medical journal JAMA found that long-term exposure to air pollution can lead to similar changes in the lungs as those caused by smoking. However, the negative health effects of tobacco smoke appear to be much larger than those of air pollution. Additionally, air pollution is not as addictive or aggressively marketed as tobacco products, and efforts to improve air quality have gained significant public support. Nevertheless, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that air pollution and smoking cause a similar number of deaths annually, with each claiming around 7 million lives.

Air pollution and smoking both cause emphysema

Air pollution and smoking are both harmful to human health. While tobacco smoke is a well-known cause of emphysema, air pollution can also lead to the development of this debilitating lung condition. Emphysema is a chronic lung disease that falls under the umbrella term Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) and is characterised by shortness of breath. It damages the alveoli or air sacs in the lungs, making it hard for oxygen to reach the bloodstream and causing breathing difficulties.

Smoking is the primary cause of emphysema, with up to 75% of people with the condition being smokers or former smokers. Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, many of which are toxic and carcinogenic. These chemicals include 1,3-butadiene, acrolein, acetaldehyde, cyanide, arsenic, cresols, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, benzene, hydrogen cyanide, nitrous oxides, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). However, air pollution also contains many of these same harmful chemicals, especially in busy cities.

Ground-level ozone, the main component of smog, is of particular concern. Smog forms when pollution from sources such as vehicle exhaust and smokestacks reacts with UV light and bakes in the sunlight. Hot and sunny days, therefore, tend to have higher levels of ozone. A study published in JAMA found that long-term exposure to slightly elevated levels of ground-level ozone can lead to changes in the lungs similar to those seen in smokers. The researchers estimated that an increase of about three parts per billion of ground-level ozone was equivalent to smoking a pack of cigarettes a day for 29 years.

While the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that tobacco-related deaths and deaths caused by air pollution are each around 7 million per year, the distribution of these deaths differs. Tobacco smoke is responsible for about half a million deaths in the United States annually, while air pollution causes approximately 60,000. This discrepancy is likely due to the fact that air pollution levels in the US are generally too low to cause as many health issues as cigarette smoke. However, in cities with high levels of air pollution, such as Los Angeles, long-term exposure to air pollution may be as harmful to the lungs as smoking.

Air pollution kills more people annually than tobacco

Air pollution is a broad term that describes anything that can decrease air quality, both indoors and outdoors. It includes sources such as vehicle exhaust, wildfires, and tobacco smoke. While tobacco smoke contains many of the same chemicals as air pollution, it also contains additional toxic chemicals that lead to added potential health effects.

Tobacco smoke is a product of combustion and contains gaseous chemicals, liquid aerosols, and particulate matter (including PM2.5). Hundreds of the chemicals in cigarette smoke are toxic, and over 70 can cause cancer. Some of the most harmful components of tobacco smoke include 1,3-butadiene, a known carcinogen and the most significant cancer risk in cigarette smoke; acrolein and acetaldehyde, which have the greatest potential to irritate the respiratory tract; and cyanide, arsenic, and cresols, which have the most significant potential to harm cardiovascular health.

Air pollution has been labelled the "new smoking", with news articles claiming that living in a big city is equivalent to smoking every day. In 2018, WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus highlighted this comparison, stating that "the world has turned the corner on tobacco. Now it must do the same for the 'new tobacco' – the toxic air that billions breathe every day". However, the suggestion that air pollution is as bad as smoking has been deemed inaccurate and potentially dangerous to public health.

While it is difficult to estimate the total worldwide health burden of air pollution, many scholars agree that between 5 to 9 million people die from air pollution each year. In comparison, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that around 7 million people die from tobacco-related causes annually. These numbers suggest that air pollution kills more people annually than tobacco. However, it is important to note that air pollution and tobacco use are not distributed equally worldwide. For example, in the United States, tobacco smoke is responsible for about half a million deaths each year, while air pollution is responsible for approximately 60,000 deaths. This discrepancy is likely due to the generally lower levels of air pollution in the US compared to other countries.

Outdoor air quality rarely gets bad enough to mimic smoking

While air pollution and tobacco smoke share many similarities, they are not equally dangerous. Outdoor air quality rarely deteriorates to the extent that it mimics the effects of smoking. For instance, in the United States, tobacco smoke is responsible for approximately 500,000 deaths annually, whereas air pollution accounts for about 60,000 deaths. This discrepancy is likely due to the relatively lower levels of air pollution in the US, which do not cause as many health issues as cigarette smoke.

Air pollution is a broad term encompassing various sources, including vehicle exhaust, wildfires, and tobacco smoke. It refers to any factor that diminishes air quality, either indoors or outdoors. While tobacco smoke contains numerous chemicals also found in air pollution, it also introduces additional pollutants that amplify its adverse health effects. The Clean Air Act has established a set of air quality standards, known as the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS), to enhance public understanding and reduce exposure to outdoor air pollution.

Tobacco smoke is a complex mixture of over 7,000 chemical compounds, many of which are carcinogenic and detrimental to cardiovascular health. Some of the most harmful substances in tobacco smoke include 1,3-butadiene, acrolein, acetaldehyde, cyanide, arsenic, cresols, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, benzene, hydrogen cyanide, nitrous oxides, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). These toxic chemicals contribute to the extensive health risks associated with tobacco smoke.

In contrast, air pollution primarily consists of ground-level ozone, fine particulate matter, nitrogen oxide, and black carbon. Ground-level ozone, or smog, forms when pollution from sources such as car exhaust and smokestacks interacts with UV light and bakes in the sunlight. While air pollution has been labelled the "new smoking," this comparison is inaccurate and potentially detrimental to public health. The tobacco industry may benefit from this comparison as it minimizes the perception of harm associated with their products.

Furthermore, air pollution is not as addictive as smoking, and it is not aggressively marketed by a notorious industry. Measures to enhance air quality tend to receive widespread public support, as individuals are not addicted to toxic air in the same way they may be dependent on nicotine. However, it is important to recognize that both air pollution and tobacco smoke pose significant risks to human health, and efforts to mitigate their impacts are crucial.

Air pollution and tobacco smoke share many of the same chemicals

Air pollution and tobacco smoke do indeed share many of the same chemicals. Tobacco smoke is made up of a complex mixture of over 7,000 chemical compounds, many of which are also found in other sources of air pollution. These include gaseous chemicals, liquid aerosols, and particulate matter (including PM2.5).

Tobacco smoke and air pollution also share similar carcinogens, such as PAHs, heterocyclic compounds, N-nitrosamines, aromatic amines, aldehydes, phenolic compounds, volatile hydrocarbons, and metals. These harmful chemicals are known to cause cancer and other serious health issues. For example, a study published in JAMA found that long-term exposure to elevated levels of air pollution, specifically ground-level ozone, can lead to accelerated lung damage, even in non-smokers. The changes observed in the lungs of those exposed to air pollution were similar to those seen in smokers.

Additionally, air pollution and tobacco smoke can have comparable effects on lung health. While tobacco smoke is the number one risk factor for lung cancer, accounting for over 85% of lung cancer deaths, air pollution also contributes significantly to lung cancer cases and deaths worldwide. The fine particles found in both tobacco smoke and air pollution, particularly PM2.5, have been linked to an increased risk of lung cancer.

It is important to note that the health impacts of air pollution and smoking are not exactly the same. Smoking tends to cause more disability and premature deaths than air pollution, and the medical problems associated with smoking often arise at a younger age. However, this does not diminish the severity of air pollution as a major public health issue, particularly in developing countries.

In summary, while air pollution and tobacco smoke share many of the same chemicals and health effects, they also have distinct differences. Understanding these similarities and differences is crucial for addressing the public health challenges posed by both tobacco smoke and air pollution.

Air pollution is not addictive like smoking

Air pollution has been labelled the "new smoking". Some articles have gone as far as to claim that living in a big city is the same as smoking every day. However, air pollution is not addictive like smoking.

While air pollution and tobacco smoke share many of the same chemicals, tobacco smoke contains additional pollutants that lead to added potential health effects. Cigarette smoke is made up of over 7,000 chemical compounds, and hundreds of these chemicals are toxic and over 70 can cause cancer. Some of the most harmful components of tobacco smoke include 1,3-butadiene, a known carcinogen and the most significant cancer risk in cigarette smoke; acrolein and acetaldehyde, which have the greatest potential to irritate the respiratory tract; and cyanide, arsenic, and cresols, which have the most significant potential to harm cardiovascular health.

The tobacco industry would likely welcome the comparison between air pollution and smoking, as it creates the perception that using their products is "only as bad as breathing polluted air". However, unlike the tobacco industry, no industry deliberately produces toxic and addictive air as a commodity. The success of the tobacco industry depends on generating as many nicotine-dependent customers as possible.

Additionally, measures to improve air quality have tremendous public support, in part because people are not addicted to toxic air in the same way that smokers are dependent on nicotine. While it is difficult to estimate the worldwide health burden of air pollution, many scholars agree that between 5 to 9 million people die from air pollution each year. In contrast, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that around 7 million people die from tobacco-related causes annually.

In conclusion, while air pollution and smoking can both have detrimental effects on health, air pollution is not addictive like smoking.

Frequently asked questions