Surgical Masks: Effective Air Pollution Protection?

Air pollution is a serious issue that can have adverse effects on human health. One way to protect yourself from air pollution is to wear a mask. While N95 masks are widely considered the most effective at filtering out airborne particles, surgical masks are a common alternative. Surgical masks are typically made from breathable, non-woven fabric, and are therefore more comfortable for long-term wear. However, they are less effective at filtering out small particles in the air. Experts say they are basic in terms of fighting pollution and almost useless against urban aerosols. Nevertheless, some studies have found that surgical masks can provide a good level of protection against particulate pollution, including particles as small as viruses.

Are surgical masks good for air pollution?

Surgical masks are good for basic protection against air pollution

While N95 masks are considered the most effective at reducing exposure to air pollution, surgical masks can also provide basic protection. Surgical masks are made of breathable, non-woven fabric, which provides comfort during long periods of usage. They are widely available and affordable, making them a good option when N95 masks are unavailable or unaffordable.

Surgical masks can provide some level of protection against PM2.5 and other less severe pollution if properly worn. It is important to ensure that the mask covers the nose and mouth entirely and that there are no gaps between the face and the mask. The metal strap at the top of the mask can be adjusted to form a seal around the nose for a secure fit.

While surgical masks may not be as effective as N95 masks in filtering out small particles in the air, they can still offer some protection. Studies have shown that surgical masks can reduce concentrations of ambient air particles, aerosols, and pathogens by up to 68%. Additionally, in a test conducted by researchers from Edinburgh University, a surgical mask blocked 80% of diesel exhaust particles, even those smaller than the coronavirus.

Surgical masks are also widely used during wildfire season or in areas with poor air quality due to smoke or pollution. They can provide a basic level of protection against smoke particles and other pollutants, helping to keep people from getting sick. However, it is important to note that surgical masks may not be effective against all types of air pollution, such as nitrogen dioxide, a major component of urban pollution.

Overall, while N95 masks may offer superior protection against air pollution, surgical masks can still provide a basic level of defence against particulate pollution and other harmful substances in the air. They are comfortable, easily accessible, and can significantly reduce exposure to pollutants, making them a reasonable option for those seeking protection from air pollution.

N95 masks are more effective at filtering air pollution

While surgical masks have been widely used during the COVID-19 pandemic, they are not ideal for fighting air pollution. Surgical masks are made of breathable non-woven fabric, which provides comfort during long periods of usage. However, they are basic in terms of fighting pollution. They cannot filter out small particles in the air and are ineffective against urban aerosols. The largest particles are blocked by the mask, but they are also filtered by your nose.

N95 masks, on the other hand, are highly effective at filtering air pollution. They are designed to filter at least 95% of airborne particles, including large respiratory droplets and smaller particles. N95 masks are widely used in healthcare settings and industries where workers are exposed to hazardous particulates. They are made of several layers of non-woven synthetic material and offer a close fit to ensure optimal protection. Industrial respirators such as N95s leave almost no gap, ensuring a tight fit against the face. They also use denser filtering material than surgical masks, providing better protection against germs and PM2.5 particulate pollution.

In areas with high levels of air pollution, wearing N95 masks can protect individuals from harmful particulates and improve overall health. They are especially beneficial in highly polluted cities, where they can save individuals from allergens, pollutants, dust, and other harmful gases. N95 masks are also available with exhaust valves, which enable easier exhalation without encountering resistance. However, these masks are not recommended for use in highly infectious areas.

It is important to note that the fitting of the N95 mask is crucial for its effectiveness. If not fitted properly, N95 masks may not seal well enough around the edges, reducing their filtration efficiency. Therefore, individuals should ensure they select a mask that fits well and is comfortable to wear, as this will increase the likelihood of consistent usage and, consequently, provide better protection.

Cloth masks are not recommended for protection against air pollution

Cloth masks are typically constructed from breathable materials like cotton and may feature supplementary filters made from materials such as polypropylene. The filtration efficacy of multilayered cloth masks is 50-70% for respiratory aerosol particles. However, the effectiveness of cloth masks depends on various factors such as fabric material, the number of layers, and the fit of the mask. A snug fit is crucial to ensuring that no gaps are present on the sides, and that the nose, mouth, and chin are covered.

The issue with cloth masks is that they may reduce exposure to air pollution but do not provide sufficient protection due to their small particulate size and lack of tight fit. Fine particles (PM2.5) pose the greatest health risk as they can get deep into the lungs and even into the bloodstream. Cloth masks do not filter out these fine particles effectively, and as such, health experts recommend the use of N95 masks, which can filter out up to 95% of airborne particles, including PM2.5 matter and other pollutants.

In addition to the N95 masks, other types of masks that offer better protection than cloth masks include N99 and N100 masks, which are also highly effective at filtering out pollutants, and activated carbon respirators, which are good at filtering dust particles, odours, and other gases. These alternatives may be more costly, but they offer superior protection against air pollution, especially in places with severe air quality issues.

Face masks are the first line of defence against air pollution

Surgical masks, in particular, are widely used and easily available. They are made of breathable non-woven fabric, which provides comfort during longer usage. They can also provide some level of protection against PM2.5 and other less severe pollution if properly worn. To ensure proper usage of the surgical mask, it is essential to follow the recommended steps: place the mask over your nose and mouth, ensuring that it covers both areas entirely. Utilize the metal strap present at the top of the mask to form a seal around your nose and verify that there are no gaps between your face and the mask.

However, surgical masks are not very effective in tackling urban aerosols. They will hardly block anything smaller than 1 micron, while most urban aerosols are just 10-50 nm in size. The smallest particles, which are considered much more dangerous because they can reach your lungs and even enter your bloodstream, are not blocked by the mask. The mask will also not help against nitrogen dioxide, the major component of urban pollution.

N95 masks are another popular option for protection against air pollution. They are made of multiple layers of non-woven synthetic material and are known to filter up to 95% of airborne particles. They are ideal for individuals seeking comfort during prolonged usage as they enable easier exhalation without encountering resistance. However, it is important to note that they are not recommended for use in highly infectious areas. N99 and N100 masks are also good options, known to be the best in filtering pollutants.

Air purifiers with HEPA filters are another way to protect against air pollution

While surgical masks are widely used and provide some protection against air pollution, they are not the most effective solution. Surgical masks are made of breathable, non-woven fabric, which provides comfort for extended wear. However, they are basic in terms of fighting pollution and cannot filter out small particles in the air. These masks are more suitable for blocking larger particles, but smaller particles can still enter through gaps between the mask and the face.

As an alternative, air purifiers with HEPA filters offer a more comprehensive solution to protect against air pollution. HEPA stands for High-Efficiency Particulate Air filter, and it is designed to remove at least 99.97% of dust, mold, pollen, bacteria, and airborne particles as small as 0.3 microns. This effectiveness is crucial, as particles in the 0.3-micron range are the most challenging to capture and can pose a significant health risk if they reach the lungs or bloodstream.

Air purifiers with HEPA filters are highly beneficial for individuals with allergies or respiratory issues. They can effectively capture particulate pollutants, providing relief from symptoms such as sneezing, sore throat, coughing, and difficulty breathing. Additionally, HEPA filters are often paired with carbon filters, which are highly porous and can absorb gas pollutants, odors, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs).

For example, the Austin Air HealthMate HM400 air purifier uses a HEPA filter and a 15-pound adsorbent filter composed of activated carbon and zeolites, a type of mineral. This combination effectively captures both particulate and gaseous pollutants, including formaldehyde.

Another feature to consider in air purifiers is UV-C sanitizer filters. While these ultraviolet filters cannot remove airborne particles on their own, they are highly effective at killing viruses, parasites, mold spores, and bacteria when combined with a HEPA filter. It is important to ensure that the UV lights have proper lamp coatings to prevent the potential emission of ozone.

In conclusion, while surgical masks offer some protection against air pollution, they have limitations in filtering out smaller particles. For a more comprehensive solution, air purifiers with HEPA filters are highly effective at capturing a wide range of pollutants, including small airborne particles and gaseous pollutants, making them an ideal way to protect against the harmful effects of air pollution.

Frequently asked questions