Do Cloth Masks Protect Us From Air Pollution?

Air pollution is a global concern, and with millions moving to cities, the issue of poor air quality is only worsening. Face masks are often used to protect against air pollution, but do cloth masks offer adequate protection? Cloth masks are widely used in developing countries due to their affordability and reusability, but their effectiveness is questionable. While they may provide some protection, studies suggest that their filtration efficacy is limited, particularly against smaller particles. The pore sizes in cloth masks are larger than the nano-sized particles in air pollution, rendering them inadequate for protection against harmful pollutants. However, some innovators have designed consumer cloth masks that meet N95 standards, but their accessibility and real-world effectiveness remain uncertain.

Do cloth masks protect against air pollution?

Cloth masks offer partial protection against air pollution

Cloth masks are widely used in developing nations and highly polluted countries to protect against air pollution. However, their effectiveness in filtering out harmful particles is limited, offering only partial protection.

The level of protection provided by cloth masks depends on various factors, including the materials used, the particle size of pollutants, and the fit of the mask. While cloth masks can act as a barrier against particulate and solid matter, their filtration efficacy is lower compared to specialised masks like N95 respirators.

The pores or openings in cloth masks typically range from 80 to 500 microns, which is significantly larger than the nano-sized particles found in air pollution, such as nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, and bacteria. As a result, cloth masks may not effectively filter out these smaller pollutants, providing reduced protection against harmful airborne particles.

Additionally, the loose-fitting nature of cloth masks can allow particles to enter through gaps around the cheeks and nose, further reducing their effectiveness. However, cloth masks can still offer some level of protection and are better than no protection at all. They can reduce exposure to some extent, especially when compared to having no barrier at all.

It is important to note that no mask provides 100% protection against air pollution, and the best strategy is to prioritise reducing air pollution and educating individuals about ways to minimise their exposure.

Cloth masks are ineffective against nano-particulates

Cloth masks are widely used for protection against air pollution, especially in developing nations. However, their effectiveness in filtering out nano-particulates is questionable. The pores or openings in cloth masks range from 80 to 500 microns, which is significantly larger than particulate matter (PM) in the nano-micro range, such as nitrogen dioxide (NO2), carbon monoxide (CO), and bacteria. Due to this size discrepancy, cloth masks are ineffective in protecting against nano-particulates, which can have serious health implications.

Laboratory studies have analyzed the effectiveness of cloth masks in protecting against hazardous levels of PM. The results indicate that cloth masks provide limited protection, with basic cloth masks removing as little as 15% of fine particles from inhaled air. The filtration efficiency of cloth masks varies depending on the fabric and the number of layers, with single-layer fabrics filtering 5-80% of particles and multiple layers increasing filtration efficiency to 95% for particles >300 nm. However, these efficiencies are still significantly lower than N95 respirators, which have a filtration efficiency of <0.9-1.9% for particles in the nano-micro range.

The issue of nano-particulates is of particular concern in heavily polluted cities, where millions of people are exposed to dangerous levels of air pollution daily. The World Health Organization reports that 98% of cities in low- and middle-income countries fail to meet air quality guidelines. In such environments, the ineffectiveness of cloth masks against nano-particulates becomes a critical issue, as it can lead to serious health consequences. Exposure to particulate matter causes nearly six million premature deaths annually, mainly from heart attacks, strokes, and lung disease.

While cloth masks offer some protection and are better than nothing, they should not be solely relied upon to protect against air pollution, especially regarding nano-particulates. Governments and authorities should focus on implementing measures to reduce air pollution and educate individuals about ways to minimize exposure, rather than solely relying on cloth masks as a solution.

Cloth masks are better than nothing

While cloth masks may not be the most effective protection against air pollution, they do offer some benefits and are certainly better than nothing. Cloth masks are widely used in developing nations and heavily polluted countries, where they are often the most affordable and accessible option.

One study found that cloth masks reduced exposure to airborne pollutants to some extent, but their performance was poor compared to other options on the market. Another study from 2016 showed that cloth masks blocked 15 to 30 percent of particles, which is better than no protection at all. However, it's important to note that the same study also found that surgical masks are more effective than cloth masks due to the engineering of the fabrics.

The level of protection offered by cloth masks depends on various factors, such as the quality and type of materials used, the fit, and the size of the particles in the air. Cloth masks have larger pore sizes, ranging from 80 to 500 microns, which means they are ineffective against smaller particles in the nano-micro range, such as nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, and bacteria. However, they can still provide some protection against larger particles like pollen, dust, or hair.

Innovators have designed better consumer cloth masks that meet N95 standards, but these may not be accessible to everyone due to affordability and availability. In conclusion, while cloth masks may not provide complete protection against air pollution, they can still offer some level of defence, especially in areas where more advanced masks are not readily available.

Cloth masks are a popular, affordable option

The pores or openings in cloth masks range from 80 to 500 microns, which is significantly larger than the particulate matter (PM) found in air pollution, which can be as small as nano-sized. As a result, cloth masks are unable to filter out many harmful pollutants, such as nitrogen dioxide (NO2), carbon monoxide (CO), bacteria, and viruses.

However, cloth masks can still provide some benefit, particularly in reducing exposure to larger particles. A 2016 study found that cloth masks blocked 15 to 30 percent of particles, which is better than no protection at all. Additionally, cloth masks are breathable, washable, and reusable, making them a convenient and cost-effective option for many people.

It is important to note that the filtration efficacy of cloth masks can vary depending on the materials used and the fit of the mask. Some cloth masks with exhaust valves have been found to perform better, removing 80-90 percent of synthetic particles and about 57 percent of diesel exhaust.

While cloth masks may be a popular and affordable option, it is crucial to recognize that they offer limited protection against air pollution. In highly polluted areas, alternative options, such as N95 respirators, may be more effective in protecting against harmful particulate matter and improving air quality.

Cloth masks are reusable and customisable

Cloth masks are a popular option for those seeking a reusable and customisable face-covering. They are often chosen for their breathability and comfort, but how effective are they in protecting against air pollution?

The protection offered by cloth masks varies depending on the materials used and the level of air pollution. Cloth masks with exhaust valves, for example, have been found to remove 80-90% of synthetic particles and about 57% of diesel exhaust. However, basic cloth masks may only remove as little as 15% of fine particles from the air that wearers inhale. The smaller the particles are, the harder they are to filter. Cloth masks are typically less effective than surgical masks or N95 respirators, which are designed to block out smaller particles.

The pore sizes in cloth masks range from 80 to 500 microns, which is much larger than particular matter (PM) in the nano-micro range, such as nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, and bacteria. As a result, cloth masks provide little to no protection against these tiny particles. However, cloth masks can still offer some benefit, particularly in reducing exposure to larger particles. In a 2016 study, it was found that cloth masks blocked 15 to 30% of particles, offering more protection than not wearing a mask at all.

While cloth masks may not provide complete protection against air pollution, they are still widely used, especially in developing nations and highly polluted areas. This is due to their affordability and accessibility, as well as their customisability and reusability. Cloth masks can be washed and reused, making them a cost-effective option for those who need to wear masks regularly. Additionally, cloth masks can be customised to fit the wearer's face better, reducing gaps through which particles can enter.

Frequently asked questions