Harmonic Mean: Water Pollution's Unseen Culprit

Water pollution is a critical global issue, with unsafe water causing more deaths annually than war and other forms of violence combined. The problem is exacerbated by water's unique ability to dissolve more substances than any other liquid, making it highly vulnerable to contamination. While there are various sources of water pollution, including agricultural, industrial, and municipal waste, another concerning contributor is harmonic distortion in water treatment facilities. This distortion, caused by non-linear loads, leads to inefficiencies and potential equipment failures, resulting in increased costs and, in some cases, the release of untreated or partially treated wastewater into nearby water bodies, further exacerbating water pollution.

Harmonic distortion can cause equipment failure and increased repair costs

Harmonic distortion is a deviation of an electrical waveform from its fundamental frequency due to additional frequencies introduced by non-linear loads. It can cause equipment failure and increased repair costs in several ways.

Firstly, harmonic distortion can lead to equipment overheating. This is because harmonics increase the rms current, resulting in increased operating temperatures for many devices. This additional heating can cause transformers, capacitors, motors, or generators to fail prematurely.

Secondly, harmonic distortion can cause incorrect meter readings, which can lead to incorrect control decisions and subsequent equipment failure. It can also cause protective devices to trip unnecessarily, resulting in disrupted operations and increased maintenance costs.

Thirdly, harmonic distortion can reduce the lifespan of electrical components. This is due to the increased temperatures and additional stress placed on the equipment, causing premature aging and failure.

Furthermore, harmonic distortion can interfere with the operation of sensitive electronic equipment, leading to malfunctions or unexpected shutdowns. This is particularly problematic in highly automated environments with small maintenance staffs, such as water treatment plants, where operational problems caused by harmonic distortion can have major consequences.

To mitigate harmonic distortion, several solutions can be implemented, including:

• Line reactors: These limit current spikes and filter harmonics before they enter the system, reducing voltage distortion.
• Isolation transformers: These provide electrical separation, preventing the spread of harmonics and protecting sensitive equipment.
• Harmonic filters: Passive or active filters can be added to the system to suppress harmonic frequencies and protect equipment.
• Power factor correction: By maintaining a balanced power factor and stable voltage supply, harmonic disturbances can be reduced.
• Regular maintenance and system monitoring: This helps detect harmonic distortions early and prevent equipment failures and downtime.

High levels of harmonic distortion can stress the electrical network within a water treatment facility

High levels of harmonic distortion can have detrimental effects on the electrical network within a water treatment facility. The term "harmonics" refers to distortions in the periodic voltage or current waveform, resulting from the difference between the waveform required by power electronic loads and the sinusoidal voltage supplied by the utility. This non-linear current draw leads to an irregular waveform and harmonic distortion.

The impact of harmonic distortion on a water treatment facility can be significant. Firstly, it can cause problems for sensitive electronic equipment within the facility, leading to potential disruptions or shutdowns of critical processes. This, in turn, can result in reduced productivity, increased maintenance and repair costs, and, most importantly, the potential release of partially treated or untreated wastewater into nearby water bodies, thus contributing to water pollution.

Harmonic distortion can also lead to energy losses within the electrical network. The non-linear loads create harmonics, which are multiples of the base frequency, causing deviations from the pure sine wave in both current and voltage. This results in "electronic pollution," where energy is lost within the network instead of being utilized by the equipment. The higher the level of harmonic distortion, as measured by the Total Harmonic Distortion on Current (THDi), the greater the energy losses. For example, a THDi of 40% results in 16% greater losses compared to a network without harmonics.

To address these issues, water treatment facilities employ various techniques and equipment for harmonic mitigation. One common approach is to oversize power components or cables to handle overheating caused by harmonic distortion. However, this method can be costly and impact project sustainability. A more effective solution is to install devices that actively reduce or eliminate harmonic frequencies, such as Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) or Ultra-Low Harmonic (ULH) drives. These drives not only improve energy efficiency but also help maintain the stability and productivity of water treatment operations.

Additionally, proper installation techniques and the use of harmonic mitigation equipment, such as active filters, can play a crucial role in eliminating problems before they occur. By considering harmonic mitigation during the design stage of a project, facilities can find cost-effective solutions that improve overall power quality and reliability, ultimately reducing the risk of water pollution due to disruptions in water treatment processes.

Harmonic distortion can cause voltage drop and overheating of power factor correction capacitors

Power factor correction capacitors are used to improve the power factor of electrical systems and influence the frequency response of a system. However, the presence of these capacitors in a facility can also increase the potential for harmonic problems.

Harmonic distortion on power systems can be described as noise that distorts the sinusoidal wave shape. Harmonics are caused by non-linear loads (e.g. ASDs, compact fluorescent lighting, induction furnaces) connected to the power system. These loads draw non-sinusoidal currents, which react with the system impedance to produce voltage distortion.

One of the possible consequences of harmonic distortion is voltage drop. Voltage distortion increases with the voltage drop, which is influenced by the distance from the transformer and the impedance of the line. The presence of harmonics affects all phenomena related to frequency increase, resulting in a decrease in capacitive reactance and an increase in current in the capacitors. This can lead to capacitor damage or resonance, causing further issues.

Another consequence of harmonic distortion is the overheating of power factor correction capacitors. When capacitor banks are installed in a harmonic-rich environment, they create a low impedance path, attracting a large portion of the harmonic current. This elevated current can cause the capacitors to overheat, leading to degradation of the dielectric material and eventual failure.

To address these issues, it is important to carefully analyse the electrical system before installing power factor correction capacitors. This includes considering the nature of the installed equipment and following technical guidelines, such as IEEE STD 1531 2003, to ensure proper design, control, and protection of harmonic filters. Additionally, methods to mitigate harmonic distortion include altering capacitor size, moving or adjusting the non-linear load, or adding reactors to configure the capacitors as harmonic filters.

Harmonic distortion can cause power failures and power quality issues in the distribution grid

Harmonic distortion is an inconsistency in the electrical supply, causing problems in the distribution network. It occurs when the waveform of the alternating current on the grid is subject to volatility and gets distorted. The primary cause of harmonic distortion is the presence of non-linear loads, which draw current in a non-sinusoidal manner, causing the current waveform to be distorted.

Non-linear loads include power electronic devices such as rectifiers, inverters, adjustable speed drives, and electronic equipment like computers, fluorescent lights, and LED lamps. The switching operations in these devices generate harmonics, which can then propagate through the power system. Other examples of non-linear loads are motors, variable frequency drives (VFD), DC power supplies, uninterruptible power supplies, and many other solid-state devices.

Harmonic distortion can lead to several issues, including additional losses and heating in electrical machines, misoperation of protective devices, and malfunctions in sensitive electronic equipment. Voltage harmonics, for instance, can cause problems in magnetic devices, such as transformers, as well as relaying devices and meters in substations and at service locations. The more distorted the voltage sine wave (the higher the THD), the more power is wasted in the form of heat in the motor, decreasing energy efficiency and shortening the motor's lifetime.

Harmonic distortions can also cause wire overheating, power loss, and excessive heating in neutral conductors, transformers, and motors, leading to premature equipment failure. In extreme cases, harmonic distortion can even lead to the catastrophic failure of grid-connected equipment.

As the electrical grid evolves to include more renewable energy sources and modernized grid components, it faces new challenges in maintaining power quality. Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) has become a critical metric for evaluating power quality, as excessive THD reduces the efficiency and lifespan of electrical equipment, leading to increased costs and reliability issues for consumers and utility companies.

Harmonic distortion can be mitigated by installing Active Harmonic Filters

Harmonic distortion can cause significant issues in water treatment facilities, including increased costs, reduced productivity, equipment damage, and even the spilling of untreated wastewater into nearby waterways. To mitigate these issues, Active Harmonic Filters (AHFs) can be installed. AHFs are a type of harmonic correction unit (HCU) that helps to manage power system distortions. They are installed in parallel with the electrical distribution system, allowing them to interact directly with the power flow.

AHFs work similarly to noise-cancellation systems in audio technology. They detect harmonic distortions that deviate from the ideal sinusoidal waveform and generate a counteracting waveform of equal magnitude but opposite in phase. This counteracting waveform is then injected back into the power system to negate the effect of the distortion. By doing so, AHFs can improve the power factor, reduce voltage fluctuations, and extend the operating life of equipment.

One example of AHFs in action can be seen in the case of a food processing unit in Coimbatore, India. The customer wanted to reduce the Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) to less than 8% and achieved this by installing an active harmonic filter of 200A at the PCC. Another example is the use of ULH drives, which mitigate harmonics and improve energy efficiency, resulting in lower electricity bills and increased stability in water operations.

In addition to AHFs, other techniques to mitigate harmonic distortion include oversizing power components or cables to handle overheating and using passive harmonic filters, which consist of a series circuit of reactors and capacitors to shunt the harmonic currents. However, oversizing equipment can be costly and impact sustainability, while passive filters may not be sufficient for all applications. As such, a combination of active and passive filters may be used in some facilities to address harmonic distortion on both the power and non-power sides of the system.

Frequently asked questions