Whitewood Creek: Pollution's Impact And The Way Forward

Whitewood Creek, located in the Black Hills of southwestern South Dakota, has historically been impacted by significant pollution from mining activities. For almost a century, from 1870 to 1977, the creek received direct releases of tailings from nearby gold mines, resulting in the discharge of approximately 100 million to 1 billion tons of hazardous substances and mining waste. This pollution had a devastating effect on the ecosystem, rendering the creek incapable of supporting plant or aquatic life. Despite the creek's resilience and the subsequent reappearance of some plant and animal species, the pollution has left a lasting impact on the environment, altering the geomorphology of Whitewood Creek and affecting the quality of the water that flows into the Belle Fourche and Cheyenne rivers.

Gold mine wastewater and ground rock pollution

For nearly 100 years, wastewater mixed with finely ground rock from area gold mines was directly discharged into Whitewood Creek. At least 100 million tons of gold-mill tailings and hazardous substances were discharged from the Homestake Mine alone. The result was a turbulent grey sludge that prevented the growth of plant or aquatic life.

The finely ground tailings produced by gold mining can cause heavy metal pollution when arsenic, cobalt, copper, cadmium, lead, silver, and zinc contained in excavated rock or exposed in an underground mine come into contact with water. This can occur when the water infiltrates sulphide-containing tailings piles and ponds, surface and underground workings, waste, and development rock, leading to the leaching of large volumes of metals into stream and river ecosystems.

Acid mine drainage (AMD) is another significant environmental concern caused by gold mine wastewater and ground rock pollution. AMD occurs when sulfides in rocks are exposed to air and water, producing sulfuric acid that leaches metals and other substances from the rocks, degrading water quality and harming aquatic life. This process can last for hundreds or even thousands of years as long as the source rock remains exposed to air and water.

The impact of gold mine wastewater and ground rock pollution can be long-lasting, requiring management for decades or even centuries after a mine's closure. The extent of these impacts depends on factors such as the sensitivity of the local terrain, the composition of the minerals being mined, the technology employed, and the company's environmental commitment and ability to comply with regulations.

Hazardous substances and tailings

Whitewood Creek, situated in the Black Hills of southwestern South Dakota, has a long history of contamination from mining activity. Gold exploration in the region, which began in the 1870s, led to the discharge of wastewater mixed with finely ground rock from gold mines directly into the creek. This resulted in the release of at least 100 million tons of hazardous substances and gold-mill tailings into the water body, according to estimates.

The Homestake Mine, in particular, contributed significantly to this issue. The tailings created a turbulent grey sludge that severely damaged the ecosystem of the creek. During this period of pollution, Whitewood Creek was unable to support any plant or aquatic life. The inorganic elements dissolved in the water through the disturbed rock strata had a detrimental impact on the habitat.

Tailings deposition altered the geomorphology of Whitewood Creek, with deposits reaching depths of up to 4.6 meters. These deposits have now stabilised due to vegetation. The groundwater movement through the tailings deposits in the Whitewood Creek valley continues to impact the creek. The contaminated groundwater enters the creek at various points along its downstream course, carrying toxic substances and contributing to the overall pollution of the water body.

The pollution in Whitewood Creek had significant environmental consequences. It is estimated that approximately 100 million to 1 billion tons of mining, milling, and ore processing wastes were released into Whitewood Creek and neighbouring water bodies. This pollution not only affected Whitewood Creek but also extended to the Belle Fourche River, the Cheyenne River, and eventually, Lake Oahe. The far-reaching impacts of the hazardous substances and tailings from mining activities highlight the severe ecological damage caused by this pollution.

Loss of aquatic life and plant species

Whitewood Creek, situated in the Black Hills of southwestern South Dakota, has a long history of contamination from mining activity. The creek received a century's worth of wastewater mixed with finely ground rock from nearby gold mines. This resulted in a turbulent grey sludge that was considered an unfortunate but necessary byproduct of supporting the local mining industry and economy.

The severe pollution had a devastating impact on the aquatic life and plant species that called Whitewood Creek home. For almost a hundred years, the creek was unable to support any plant or aquatic life due to the hazardous substances released into its waters. The contamination included approximately 100 million to 1 billion tons of mining, milling, and ore processing wastes, drastically altering the geomorphology of the creek.

The Homestake Mine alone discharged at least 100 million tons of gold-mill tailings and harmful substances into the creek. This led to the creek becoming uninhabitable for many species. The water quality severely deteriorated, and the delicate balance of the ecosystem was disrupted. The sludge and toxic substances likely smothered and poisoned aquatic plants and animals, causing a significant decline in their populations or even local extinction.

However, the story of Whitewood Creek also showcases the resilience of nature. In December 1977, environmental legislation and technological advancements led to the cessation of tailings disposal into the creek. This marked a turning point for the creek's ecosystem. Almost immediately, nature began to reclaim the creek. Moss, algae, and insect species slowly returned, indicating the start of the creek's recovery.

Today, Whitewood Creek is home to a diverse range of plant and aquatic life. Sixteen species of fish have been documented, including Brown and Brook Trout. The creek also supports a variety of bird, mammal, reptile, amphibian, invertebrate, and plant species. The rebound of plant and aquatic life in Whitewood Creek serves as a testament to nature's remarkable ability to heal and recover from even the most severe environmental degradation.

Impact on fish and other wildlife

Whitewood Creek in South Dakota was severely polluted for over a century, from the 1870s to 1977. During this time, the creek was contaminated with mine waste, sewage, and hazardous substances. This pollution had a devastating impact on the fish and other wildlife that called the creek home.

The creek, once a thriving habitat for aquatic life, was transformed into a "turbulent grey sludge". The water became so fouled by pollution that it could no longer support plant or aquatic life. This included the sixteen species of fish that had been documented in the creek, such as brown and brook trout, mountain suckers, and creek chubs. The pollution also affected the insect population, which is a vital food source for many fish species.

The impact of pollution extended beyond the creek's aquatic inhabitants. Bird, mammal, reptile, amphibian, and invertebrate species that relied on the creek for water and habitat were also affected. The pollution likely disrupted food chains and ecological relationships, leading to a decline in populations or even local extinctions.

However, the resilience of nature is evident in Whitewood Creek's recovery. After pollution ceased in 1977, the creek began to rebound. Almost immediately, moss, algae, and insect species started to reappear. Today, the creek is home to a healthy population of brown trout, and brook trout thrive in the headwaters of the creek. The improvement in water quality has positively impacted the overall habitat quality, benefiting the various bird, mammal, reptile, amphibian, and invertebrate species in the area.

While the creek has shown remarkable recovery, careful monitoring is still necessary. The presence of arsenic and other pollutants in the creek's history means that regular water sampling and ecological assessments are crucial to ensure the continued health of the ecosystem and the safety of humans and livestock in the area.

Environmental legislation and recovery

Environmental legislation and subsequent recovery efforts have played a pivotal role in mitigating the pollution that severely impacted Whitewood Creek in South Dakota for over a century. The creek, located in the Black Hills, suffered from the discharge of mine tailings, wastewater, and sewage, primarily from the Homestake Gold Mine in Lead. This pollution turned the creek into a turbulent grey sludge, devoid of any plant or aquatic life.

In the 1970s, Whitewood Creek was recognised as South Dakota's most notoriously polluted waterway. It was heavily contaminated with arsenic and other pollutants from approximately 100 million to 1 billion tons of mining waste. This pollution had devastating effects on the ecosystem, making the creek incapable of supporting any plant or aquatic life.

The turning point came with the implementation of environmental legislation and technological advancements. In December 1977, the Homestake Mine was compelled to cease the disposal of tailings into Whitewood Creek due to changing environmental regulations. This marked the beginning of the creek's recovery.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) listed an 18-mile stretch of Whitewood Creek as a Superfund site in the 1980s, making it a national priority for remediation. This led to significant changes and costly improvements in waste disposal systems by the Homestake Mining Company. They also initiated clean-up and remediation efforts, including soil removal and replacement in affected residential areas.

The EPA, in collaboration with the company, closely monitored the Superfund site to ensure the effectiveness of the remedial measures. By the early 1990s, the creek began to show signs of recovery. Regular water samples met water-pollution standards, and the EPA received encouraging feedback about the remedial plan. The site was removed from the national priority list in 1996, although it still requires perpetual monitoring.

Today, Whitewood Creek is a testament to the resilience of nature. Almost immediately after the cessation of pollution, moss, algae, and insect species began to reappear. The creek now supports a diverse range of plant, fish, bird, mammal, reptile, amphibian, and invertebrate species. The recovery of Whitewood Creek demonstrates the positive impact of environmental legislation and collaborative efforts between government agencies and private companies in restoring damaged ecosystems.

Frequently asked questions