Italian Lakes: Polluted Or Pristine?

Italy's lakes are renowned for their beauty, attracting tourists from all over the world. However, a growing concern surrounding the pollution of these lakes has emerged in recent years. The environmental organization Legambiente has investigated the water quality of Italian lakes, revealing alarming results. The report highlights issues such as trash, microplastics, and untreated sewage, with an average of 2.5 items of trash found per square meter of beach. Additionally, Italy's Lugano and Maggiore lakes were ranked as the most polluted in an international survey of 38 lakes. Climate change, pollution from tourism, and the Clooney Effect are also contributing to the deteriorating health of Italy's lakes.

Lake Maggiore and Lake Lugano are the most polluted

Italy is home to many beautiful lakes, which are popular tourist attractions. However, a significant number of Italian lakes are polluted, with Lake Maggiore and Lake Lugano being the most polluted.

Lake Maggiore, situated in northern Italy, has been described as "hideously polluted". The lake has been the subject of several studies investigating the contamination of its surface and drinking waters. The studies have targeted various pollutants, including herbicides, pharmaceuticals, steroid estrogens, and bactericides found in personal care products. The presence of these pollutants in Lake Maggiore's waters poses potential risks to both human health and the ecosystem.

In addition to chemical pollution, Lake Maggiore also faces issues with bacterial pollution. Samples from the lake have shown high levels of bacterial contamination, including Escherichia Coli, which can be harmful to humans. The upper part of Lake Maggiore, above the mouth of the river Toce, is reported to be cleaner than the lower part, likely due to the influence of sewage plants.

Lake Lugano, located on the border between southern Switzerland and northern Italy, has also been identified as one of the most polluted lakes in Italy. Swimming in Lake Lugano was officially forbidden in the 1960s and 1970s due to pollution concerns. While sewage treatment plants have since been introduced, the lake continues to struggle with high levels of pollution. The Italian environmental group Legambiente found Lake Lugano to be the most polluted of all the northern Italian lakes in their 2007 study.

Lake Lugano's pollution is characterized by high levels of phosphorus, which is a consequence of insufficient sewage treatment and a lack of oxygen in the lake. This has resulted in a state of high eutrophication, which can lead to harmful algal blooms and oxygen depletion, further endangering the lake's ecosystem.

Both Lake Maggiore and Lake Lugano face significant challenges when it comes to pollution. While there have been efforts to improve the situation, such as the introduction of sewage treatment plants, more comprehensive and effective measures may be required to address the extent of pollution in these lakes.

Pollution sources: trash, microplastics, untreated sewage

The environmental state of Italy's lakes has been a cause for concern in recent years. A report by the Legambiente environmentalist association found that the country's lakes are polluted with trash, microplastics, and untreated sewage. This was the group's first national report on freshwater basins, and it highlighted some alarming issues with water quality in popular tourist destinations.

The report was based on scientific findings from 20 shore areas across Italy's great lakes. These included the famous Lake Como, Lake Garda, Lake Iseo, Lake Maggiore, and Lake Trasimeno. The scientists on board the Goletta dei Laghi vessel discovered an average of 2.5 items of trash per square meter of beach, with 75.5% of this waste being plastic. This indicates a significant presence of litter and human-made debris in these natural environments.

Untreated sewage is another major issue impacting the lakes. The Legambiente group found that 55% of water samples from 17 Italian lakes, including the great lakes, had excessive levels of bacteria resulting from untreated sewage. This pollution has severe ecological consequences and poses risks to human health, especially for swimmers and other recreational users.

The presence of microplastics in the water is also a growing concern. Microplastics are tiny plastic particles that do not degrade and can accumulate in the environment, entering the food chain and potentially impacting the health of aquatic life and ecosystems. This form of pollution is often a result of the breakdown of larger plastic items, such as those found in the trash polluting the lakes.

Lake Garda and Lake Como are also at risk

Italy's lakes are polluted by trash, microplastics, and untreated sewage, according to a report by the Legambiente environmentalist association. The report was based on findings by scientists who collected and analysed samples from 20 shore areas in Italy's most popular lakes, including Lake Como and Lake Garda. These lakes are at risk due to several factors.

Lake Garda, Italy's largest lake, is under attack from various sources, according to the annual dossier by the heritage association Italia Nostra. Pollution, aggravated by a booming tourism industry, is the most immediate cause of concern. The situation has deteriorated to the extent that local authorities have prohibited swimming in several parts of the lake. In addition, climate change is contributing to falling water levels as a result of rising temperatures, further upsetting the lake's delicate ecosystem.

Lake Como, located near the Swiss border, is also facing environmental threats. The "Clooney Effect", as dubbed by the association, refers to the increased interest in local properties and subsequent construction projects since George Clooney bought a lakeside villa. This rapid development is damaging the lake's ecosystem and the surrounding natural environment.

The density of plastic waste in lakes can be higher than that of the largest oceanic garbage patches, and even lakes located in pristine areas can contain significant debris. An international study found that Italy's Lugano and Maggiore lakes were the most polluted out of 38 lakes surveyed. However, the ban on motorboats in these lakes has resulted in impressive improvements, with all three lakes now reaping the benefits of 20 years of 'detox'.

Climate change, drought, and tourism are contributing factors

The National Research Institute (CNR) has also expressed concerns about some of Italy's lakes, particularly the impact of tourism on Lake Garda, which receives around ten million visitors a year. The so-called ""Clooney Effect"" has also been blamed for the damage to Lake Como's ecosystem and natural environment. Since George Clooney bought a villa in the area, there has been increased interest and construction, which has negatively impacted the lake.

The environmental organization Legambiente has also investigated the water quality of Italy's lakes and found them to be in poor health. Their report, based on findings from 20 shore areas in Italy's great lakes, revealed an average of 2.5 items of trash per square meter of beach, with 75.5% being plastic. Legambiente also found that 55% of water samples from 17 Italian lakes had excessive levels of bacteria from untreated sewage. The group's vessel, Goletta Verde, has been monitoring Italy's sea coasts and lakes for 30 years, and their findings are concerning.

In addition to the above, an international survey of 38 lakes found that Italy's Lugano and Maggiore were the most polluted. More than 90% of the fragments retrieved from Lake Bolsena were fibres or fragments that originated from the degradation of larger plastic objects. This highlights the significant presence of plastic debris even in lakes located in pristine areas. The ban on swimming in several parts of Lake Garda due to pollution is a testament to the severity of the issue.

The Clooney Effect: celebrity association impacts lake health

Italy's lakes are renowned for their beauty, attracting tourists from all over the world. However, in recent years, they have faced a growing threat from pollution, with plastic waste, untreated sewage, and climate change posing significant risks to their delicate ecosystems.

Lake Garda, Italy's largest lake, and Lake Como, made famous by its celebrity residents, have been particularly affected. The annual dossier by the heritage association Italia Nostra has warned of the serious cause for alarm, blaming pollution and the "Clooney Effect" for the deteriorating health of these lakes.

The "Clooney Effect" refers to the impact of Hollywood celebrity George Clooney, who purchased a lakeside villa on Lake Como several years ago. The resulting influx of tourists and new construction projects has damaged the natural environment and ecosystem of the lake. This has been exacerbated by the booming tourism industry, which has increased the concentration of pollutants in the water and aggravated the problem of untreated sewage.

The environmental organization Legambiente has also raised concerns about the water quality of Italy's lakes. Their investigations revealed an average of 2.5 items of trash per square meter of beach, with 75.5% of it being plastic. They also found that 55% of water samples from 17 Italian lakes had excessive levels of bacteria from untreated sewage. These issues have been further compounded by climate change, which has contributed to falling water levels and disrupted the lakes' delicate ecosystems.

While Lake Como and Lake Garda have faced significant challenges, other Italian lakes have also been impacted by pollution. Lugano and Maggiore were found to be the most polluted in an international survey of 38 lakes, and Lake Bolsena in central Italy has been affected by abandoned tires and plastic debris. However, there is some hope for improvement, as the ban on motorboats in Maggiore, Como, and Lugano has led to positive results, with these lakes now enjoying the benefits of 20 years of 'detox'.

Frequently asked questions