Cruise Ships: A Polluting Paradise

Cruise ships have long been associated with luxury and the opportunity to visit multiple destinations in a short period of time. However, their environmental impact has become an increasingly concerning issue. From air pollution to ocean dumping, the cruise industry has been under scrutiny for its unsustainable practices. While the industry claims to be adopting more sustainable measures, critics argue that more needs to be done to address the global impact of cruise ships on the environment. In addition to environmental concerns, cruise ships have also faced scrutiny for their sanitation practices, with the CDC conducting random inspections to prevent the spread of illnesses.

Cruise ships emit more CO2 than flying commercial

Cruise ships are known for their significant environmental impact, particularly concerning the pollution they generate. While the cruise industry claims to be working towards sustainability, critics argue that more urgent action is needed to address the global impact of cruise ships on the ocean and air.

One of the main concerns regarding cruise ship pollution is their high level of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. According to the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), even the most efficient cruise ships emit more CO2 per passenger kilometre (CO2/pax-km) than a passenger jet. Specifically, the ICCT found that the largest and most efficient cruise ships emit about 250 grams of CO2 per passenger kilometre, while the industry average for aircraft ranges from approximately 10 to 130 grams of CO2 per passenger kilometre, with longer flights tending to have lower carbon intensity.

Comparing a standard seven-day cruise to a short-haul return flight, the cruise is estimated to have a carbon footprint of 875 kilograms of CO2 per passenger, while the flight would emit 241 kilograms of CO2 per passenger. This means that cruising is approximately three to four times more carbon-intensive than flying to the same destination. Furthermore, cruising emits more CO2 per passenger kilometre than flying, and this disparity increases for longer cruises.

Cruise ships also emit other pollutants, such as methane, black carbon, nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and particulate matter. In addition, cruise ships often use scrubbers to clean their exhausts, which results in the discharge of acidic wastewater containing heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), suspended particulate matter, and nitrates into the ocean, causing harm to marine life.

While the cruise industry is taking some steps towards sustainability, such as adopting cleaner fuels and advanced wastewater treatment systems, the environmental impact of cruise ships remains a significant concern. The high level of CO2 emissions from cruise ships, which is often higher than that of commercial flights, contributes to their negative impact on the environment.

Cruise ships pollute the ocean with sewage, food waste, and fuel waste

Cruise ships have a significant environmental impact, and their effect on the ocean is particularly harmful. The pollution they generate is a cause for concern, and it is not limited to air pollution alone.

Cruise ships pollute the ocean in several ways, including the dumping of sewage, food waste, and fuel waste. Sewage sludge, also known as blackwater, is released into the ocean, containing bacteria, viruses, parasites, and chemicals. This wastewater is not adequately treated by cruise ships, leading to toxic substances ending up in the habitats of marine life. The sewage sludge contains human waste mixed with chemicals, pharmaceuticals, and heavy metals, which are harmful to marine ecosystems.

Food waste is another major contributor to ocean pollution. Approximately 30% of food on cruise ships is disposed of as "fish food," which includes liquified human food mixed with water. This waste often contains pesticides, chemicals, and growth hormones that are not natural for aquatic wildlife and can lead to the creation of ''dead zones'' in the ocean. These dead zones are areas with low oxygen levels due to rampant algae growth, which can be toxic to fish, turtles, birds, and dolphins.

Additionally, cruise ships generate large volumes of fuel waste, including oily bilge water and hazardous wastes. The ships' diesel generators emit greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, sulfur oxides, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and global warming.

The impact of cruise ship pollution on marine life is significant. The toxic substances in sewage sludge can lead to reproductive issues, illnesses, and population decline among coastal animals, including otters, dolphins, and whales. The accumulation of contaminants in animals at the bottom of the food chain can also affect predators and other wildlife higher up.

Overall, the pollution generated by cruise ships, including sewage, food waste, and fuel waste, has severe consequences for ocean health and the ecosystems that depend on it. While some cruise lines are making efforts to manage their waste and minimize their environmental impact, stronger laws and regulations are needed to address this pressing issue effectively.

Cruise ships emit harmful air pollutants and greenhouse gases

Cruise ships have long been criticised for their environmental impact, particularly concerning air pollution and the emission of harmful air pollutants and greenhouse gases.

A medium-sized cruise ship can emit as much particulate matter as one million cars. Cruise ships emit large amounts of sulfur oxides (SOx), contributing to air pollution and acid rain. In 2022, Europe's 218 cruise ships emitted as much SOx as one billion cars. Cruise liners run by Carnival Corporation emitted nearly ten times more SOx air pollution around European coasts than all of Europe's cars combined. The fuel used by cruise ships emits about 2,000 times more sulfur oxides than normal diesel fuel. Cruise ships also emit nitrogen oxides (NOx), which, along with SOx and fine particles (PM2.5), cause premature death by various means such as lung cancer, throat cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), cardiovascular diseases, and morbidity such as childhood asthma.

Cruise ships also emit carbon dioxide (CO2), phosphorus (P4), soot, heavy metals, and other particulates into the atmosphere. A typical cruise ship emits roughly 421.43 kg of CO2 daily, eight times more than one individual staying on land. A five-night, 1,200-mile cruise results in about 1,100 lbs of CO2 emissions. A ship sailing from Seattle to Alaska during the six-month cruise season emitted 1.1 million tons of CO2 to 559,414 passengers. Larger ships make up the vast majority of black carbon emissions, and while cruise ships make up only 1% of the global fleet, they account for 6% of black carbon emissions.

The cruise industry is the fastest-growing in tourism, and environmental groups have raised concerns about the industry's greenhouse gas emissions. The industry has promised to make zero-emission vessels and fuels widespread by 2030 and to achieve a goal of 'net-zero carbon' cruising by 2050. However, critics remain unconvinced, arguing that much more needs to be done to tackle cruisers' global impact on the air.

Cruise ships have a negative impact on air quality in ports

Cruise ships have a significant negative impact on air quality in ports and the environment. They are known for their large environmental impact, particularly concerning the amount of pollution they generate. For years, campaigners have highlighted the unsustainable practices of the cruise industry, including the dumping of sewage, food waste, and wastewater, as well as the emission of air pollutants and greenhouse gases.

A photo of a large cruise ship sparked outrage due to the massive amount of pollution it was releasing. The image showed huge plumes of smoke being released from the ship's funnels as it docked in Lyttelton, near Christchurch, New Zealand. This prompted concerns about the lack of regulation and enforcement of port rules prohibiting excessive funnel smoke.

Cruise ships produce high levels of carbon emissions, with a single trip averaging 700-1000 pounds of carbon emissions per day, significantly more than flying, driving, or a traditional land vacation. They are also major contributors to black carbon emissions, accounting for 6% of global black carbon emissions despite making up only 1% of the global fleet. The use of cheaper, dirtier fuels and scrubber systems to clean exhaust further exacerbates the problem, as the resulting polluted wastewater is often discharged into the ocean, causing harm to marine life.

The impact of cruise ships on air quality has led cities like Amsterdam, Venice, Monterey Bay, and Bar Harbor to implement regulations banning or limiting the presence of large cruise ships. These measures aim to mitigate the negative environmental and air quality impacts associated with cruise ship operations.

While the cruise industry claims to be working towards sustainability, critics argue that more urgent and comprehensive action is needed to address the industry's global impact on the ocean and air. The adoption of advanced wastewater treatment systems, cleaner fuels, and other sustainability measures is a step in the right direction, but the continued use of highly polluting fuels and practices underscores the need for stricter regulations and faster implementation of environmentally friendly alternatives.

Cruise ships are linked to disease outbreaks, such as Legionnaires' disease

Cruise ships have long been associated with disease outbreaks, particularly Legionnaires' disease. Legionnaires' disease is a serious form of pneumonia caused by Legionella bacteria. In November 2022, the CDC reported 12 cases of Legionnaires' disease among travellers on two cruise ships, with eight cases on ship A and four on ship B. The likely source of exposure was attributed to private balcony hot tubs, which provided favourable conditions for Legionella growth due to inadequate maintenance and operation.

Legionnaires' disease outbreaks on cruise ships have also been linked to contaminated whirlpool spas and water supply systems. In one instance, a 67-year-old male cigarette smoker with heart disease contracted Legionnaires' disease during a cruise in September 1995 and passed away 9 days after disembarking. Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 was isolated from both the patient's sputum and the ship's water supply.

Another instance of Legionnaires' disease was reported on the Norwegian Prima ship of the Norwegian Cruise Line. While the source of exposure was not confirmed, the cruise line worked closely with the CDC to investigate and implement elevated sanitation procedures to ensure a safe onboard environment.

The issue of Legionnaires' disease on cruise ships has prompted responses from organizations such as the FDA, which issued a warning to American Cruise Lines after finding evidence of legionella bacteria in the potable water systems of their vessels. American Cruise Lines promptly responded by implementing new water management policies and equipment, claiming to have had no further cases since 2021.

The occurrence of Legionnaires' disease on cruise ships highlights the importance of proper water management and sanitation procedures to prevent the growth and transmission of Legionella bacteria. By adapting maintenance and operation protocols, cruise ship operators can minimize the risk of Legionnaires' disease outbreaks and protect the health and safety of their passengers and crew.

Frequently asked questions