Plastic Pollution's Impact On China And India

India and China are two of the most populous countries in the world, with India recently surpassing China for the top spot. Both countries have also been ranked among the highest plastic polluters globally, with India taking the lead in recent years. China's plastic pollution crisis is driven by its consumption of at least one-fifth of the world's plastics and its position as the single largest producer and exporter of single-use and virgin plastics. On the other hand, India's plastic waste crisis is fuelled by rapid urbanisation, population growth, and economic development, with per capita plastic consumption expected to rise with increasing industrialisation and consumerism. While China has made strides in waste management and reduced its plastic pollution, India faces challenges in effectively managing and reducing its plastic waste, with open burning and informal waste sectors exacerbating pollution and health issues.

India's plastic waste crisis: uncollected waste and uncontrolled burning

India has emerged as one of the world's largest plastic polluters, with uncollected waste and uncontrolled burning being leading causes of its plastic waste crisis. India's per capita plastic consumption has grown to approximately 11 kg per year, and this number is expected to rise with increasing industrialization and consumerism.

The country's waste management services have struggled to keep pace with the increasing amount of waste generated by its large and growing population. India's official waste collection rate is cited as 95%, but studies reveal that this number is closer to 81% in practice. This discrepancy reflects inefficiencies within the collection and disposal systems, resulting in uncollected waste. It is estimated that 60% of India's plastic waste is handled by an unregulated sector, and without formal recognition or support, much of this waste remains unaccounted for.

The open burning of plastic waste is a significant issue in India, contributing to air pollution and releasing harmful chemicals such as dioxins, furans, and PCBs. These toxic chemicals have been linked to severe health issues, including respiratory diseases, cancer, and reproductive problems. People whose waste is not collected often resort to burning it, but this practice can lead to substantial human health damage, including neurodevelopmental, reproductive, and birth defects.

India's dumpsites, or uncontrolled land disposal sites, outnumber sanitary landfills by 10 to 1. Approximately 30% of India's plastic waste is dumped in uncontrolled landfills, where it can leach chemicals into the soil and water bodies. India's plastic waste crisis has been exacerbated by the prevalence of single-use plastics, which account for 43% of the country's total plastic waste due to weak enforcement of regulatory bans and the lack of affordable alternatives.

India's per capita plastic consumption is increasing

India has been deemed the world's largest plastic polluter, emitting 9.3 million metric tonnes of plastic waste per year, which accounts for one-fifth of the world's plastic waste. India's per capita plastic consumption has increased to approximately 11 kg per year, and this number is expected to rise further due to increasing industrialization and consumerism.

Several factors contribute to India's growing plastic waste crisis. Firstly, India's large and increasing population is becoming more affluent, leading to increased waste generation. The country has struggled to keep up with providing adequate waste management services, particularly in rural areas and urban slums, where open burning of waste is prevalent. This lack of proper disposal systems results in higher levels of mismanaged plastic entering the environment. India's waste management infrastructure has not kept pace with the growing volume of plastic waste, with only a small proportion of waste being handled by the formal sector.

Rapid urbanization, population growth, and economic development have also fueled the increase in plastic waste. In urban areas, the demand for single-use plastics and packaging materials has risen drastically. Despite regulatory bans, 43% of India's total plastic waste still consists of single-use plastics due to weak enforcement and the lack of affordable alternatives.

The divide between the Global North and Global South also plays a role in India's plastic crisis. High-income countries generate more waste per capita but have efficient waste management systems in place. In contrast, India, as a country in the Global South, has limited infrastructure and often relies on open dumping or burning of waste.

India's plastic waste crisis has severe environmental and health impacts. The open burning of plastic waste contributes to air pollution and releases harmful pollutants, affecting local communities' health and exacerbating climate change. India's plastic pollution also extends to water bodies, with uncontrolled landfills allowing chemicals to leach into soil and water.

China's regulatory response to plastic pollution

China has an international reputation as one of the largest contributors to plastic pollution in the world's oceans. However, research analysing China's regulatory approach to plastic pollution has been limited and fragmented, with little known about the trends and trajectories dominating the country's plastic policy landscape. Despite this, China has made significant strides in addressing plastic pollution in recent years, with a notable increase in the attention paid to the issue in the regulatory realm since 2016.

From 2000 to the first half of 2021, the total number of Chinese plastic-pertinent policies increased from 4 to 231. During this period, China's approach to governing plastics became more complex and comprehensive, targeting different types of plastics and various life-cycle stages of the plastic value chain. The deployment of regulatory instruments has also become more diversified, with a current focus on prohibitive bans and information campaigns. While economic incentives have only recently gained popularity, most government agencies have published policies relevant to the regulation of plastic pollution control and prevention.

China's plastic pollution legislation in 2020 was a pivotal moment in the country's efforts to tackle plastic issues. Under Article 69 of the amended "Law of the People's Republic of China on the Prevention and Control of Environmental Pollution by Solid Wastes", the production, sale, and use of non-degradable plastic bags and other disposable plastic products were prohibited or restricted. The 2020 amendment to the Solid Waste Law also provided a legal framework for controlling plastic pollution, specifying waste management and control measures for agricultural films, packaging materials, and disposable plastic products.

While China has made significant progress in its regulatory response to plastic pollution, questions remain about the effectiveness of these policies in preventing and controlling the issue. Future research will focus on examining the policy effectiveness and exploring variable factors influencing enforcement and compliance. China's legislative efforts to control and prevent plastic pollution are important steps towards environmental protection, and the country continues to work towards solving the severe environmental and ecological problems caused by plastic pollution.

China's plastic waste management and global impact

China has long been regarded as one of the world's largest contributors to plastic pollution, particularly in the oceans. However, in the last 15 years, China has made significant efforts to improve its waste management systems and address plastic pollution.

In 2016, China began to focus more intently on plastic pollution in its regulatory policies, with a particular emphasis on prohibitive bans and information campaigns. Notably, in 2017, China implemented a ban on the import of 24 types of solid waste, including plastic waste, which had a significant impact on global plastic waste trade flows. This ban prompted other countries to re-evaluate their plastic waste treatment systems and reduced the global trade of plastic waste.

China is currently the world's largest producer and consumer of plastics, with an annual production of 80.1 million tons of plastic in 2021. The country's large and growing population, combined with increasing industrialization and consumerism, contribute to its high levels of plastic waste. China's plastic pollution situation is further exacerbated by its position as the biggest greenhouse gas emitter, largely due to coal production.

Despite the international perception of China as a major plastic polluter, the country has demonstrated a commitment to addressing this issue. China's recent policies indicate a shift towards a circular economy, with increased regulatory focus and fiscal investment in solid waste management and infrastructure. The country has also taken steps to reduce plastic production, consumption, and waste treatment, aligning with its ambition for carbon neutrality.

China's efforts to combat plastic pollution have had both domestic and global impacts. While the full consequences of these policies are yet to be fully analyzed, they have prompted other countries to reduce, reuse, and manage their plastic waste more effectively. China's actions have also highlighted the need for a stronger global focus on plastic cleanup and waste management, particularly in the context of environmental sustainability and the potential for irreversible environmental damage.

Population growth and economic development in India and China

India has emerged as one of the world's largest plastic polluters, with around one-fifth of global plastic emissions, or 9.3 million metric tonnes per year. This can be attributed to its large and growing population, increasing affluence, and rapid urbanization, industrialization, and economic development, all of which have resulted in more waste being generated. India's per capita plastic consumption is approximately 11 kg per year, and this figure is expected to rise with increasing consumerism.

China, which was previously considered the world's top plastic polluter, has improved its waste management substantially and is now ranked fourth. China's strong economic growth, averaging almost 10% GDP growth annually since 1978, has lifted over 800 million people out of poverty and improved access to health and education services. However, this growth has led to environmental imbalances, with China now accounting for nearly a third of annual global carbon dioxide emissions and 30% of the world's greenhouse gas emissions.

China's population has reached its peak and is projected to remain above 1.39 billion until 2035, after which it will gradually decline due to a combination of fewer women of reproductive age, declining fertility rates, and societal trends towards delayed marriage and increased individuality. This shrinking workforce will likely result in slower economic growth, and structural reforms are needed to address these imbalances and transition to more environmentally sustainable growth.

India's population, on the other hand, is still growing, and with insufficient waste management services, the country struggles to keep up with the increasing waste generation. About 60% of India's plastic waste is handled by an unregulated sector, and without formal recognition, much of this waste remains unaccounted for, leading to plastic pollution.

Both India and China's high rankings in plastic pollution are largely due to their large populations. However, India's lack of comprehensive waste management services and China's previous lack of environmental sustainability in their economic growth have contributed significantly to their plastic pollution problems.

Frequently asked questions