Nuclear Power: Pollution Or Promise?

Nuclear power is a highly debated topic when it comes to its environmental impact. Nuclear power plants produce no direct greenhouse gas emissions during operation, and over their lifetimes, they produce similar carbon dioxide emissions per unit of electricity as wind power and a third of solar power. This makes nuclear power a viable alternative to fossil fuels, which emit far more carbon dioxide and are responsible for millions of deaths each year due to air pollution. However, nuclear power plants do produce radioactive waste, which must be carefully handled, transported, stored, and disposed of to prevent harm to human health and the environment. Uranium mining, which is necessary for nuclear fuel, also exposes workers to severe health risks and can destroy ecosystems, leaving polluted land and water. While nuclear power has the potential to reduce carbon emissions, it also carries the risk of catastrophic accidents and long-term waste management challenges.

Nuclear power plants emit radioactive waste

Nuclear power plants do emit radioactive waste, and this is a major environmental concern. Radioactive waste is hazardous because it contains or emits radioactive particles, which, if not properly managed, can be a risk to human health and the environment. Radioactive waste can remain dangerous to human health for thousands of years.

Radioactive wastes are classified as low-level or high-level waste. Low-level waste includes contaminated tools, protective clothing, wiping cloths, and other disposable items that become contaminated with small amounts of radioactive dust or particles at nuclear fuel processing facilities and nuclear power plants. High-level waste includes irradiated or spent nuclear reactor fuel, which is no longer useful for producing electricity. Spent reactor fuel assemblies are highly radioactive and must be stored in specially designed pools of water, which cools the fuel and acts as a radiation shield. The radioactivity of nuclear waste decreases over time through a process called radioactive decay.

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) regulates the operation of nuclear power plants and the handling, transportation, storage, and disposal of radioactive wastes. Radioactive wastes are subject to special regulations that aim to protect human health and the environment. Most high-level waste is currently stored at the site where the waste was generated. However, the United States does not currently have a permanent disposal facility for high-level nuclear waste.

Nuclear power plants do not burn fossil fuels and so do not directly emit carbon dioxide during operation. However, nuclear power is not emission-free. The processes for mining and refining uranium ore and making reactor fuel require large amounts of energy, and if fossil fuels are used in these processes, then emissions can be associated with the electricity that nuclear power plants generate. Additionally, nuclear power plants still produce other environmentally damaging wastes and can pollute water, killing many billions of fish and other aquatic life every year.

Uranium mining causes lung cancer in miners

Nuclear power is a highly debated topic, with various environmental impacts, both positive and negative. While nuclear power plants do not burn fossil fuels and thus do not directly emit carbon dioxide, the processes involved in the nuclear fuel cycle, such as mining, milling, and transportation, do contribute to carbon dioxide emissions. Additionally, nuclear power plants produce radioactive waste, which is classified as low-level or high-level waste, and can pose a catastrophic risk if containment fails.

One of the significant concerns regarding nuclear power and its environmental impact is the issue of uranium mining. Uranium mining has been linked to severe health risks, particularly the development of lung cancer in miners. Underground uranium mining exposes workers to radon and its decay products, which are known respiratory carcinogens. Studies have shown a correlation between uranium mining and increased lung cancer risk, with cases reported among miners in the United States, Germany, and France.

In the United States, most uranium mining occurred in the Four Corners region of the Southwest, including Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, and Utah, as well as on Native American lands. Even though the industry collapsed in the late 1980s, former miners continue to face an elevated risk of developing lung cancer. For example, a case study describes a 72-year-old Navajo male who worked as an underground uranium miner for 17 years and was diagnosed with lung cancer 22 years after leaving the industry, despite being a lifelong non-smoker.

Similarly, extensive uranium mining operations took place in the former German Democratic Republic from 1946 to 1990. A cohort study of former male employees of the Wismut Company during this period revealed a radon-related lung cancer risk, with an excess relative risk (ERR) per working level month (WLM) of 0.21%. The risk was highest 15-24 years after exposure and in the youngest age group (<55 years).

To address the health risks associated with uranium mining, the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act (RECA) was passed by the U.S. Congress in 1990. This legislation provides partial restitution to individuals harmed by radiation exposure resulting from underground uranium mining and above-ground nuclear tests.

Nuclear energy is water-intensive

Nuclear energy is a water-intensive process. Nuclear power plants require large volumes of water in various stages of the power generation process. The water is used for cooling and steam generation, which then spins a turbine to generate electricity. This is a closed-loop system, with water pumped through the reactor core, then condensed back into water in a condenser, before being pumped back into the reactor.

Nuclear power plants use water in two distinct roles. Firstly, the fuel in the reactor vessel is immersed in water, which slows down the neutrons released in fission, making them more likely to cause another fission. Secondly, the water carries away the heat generated by fission, turning to steam and spinning the turbine. This steam is then condensed back into water and pumped back into the reactor.

Nuclear power plants use different water sources for cooling, including the sea, rivers, lakes, and cooling towers. The water used in the cooling process becomes contaminated with radionuclides, and this water is then pumped back into the environment. While this water is not considered tainted, it is warmer, and this can have an impact on the surrounding ecosystem.

Nuclear power plants are responsible for the deaths of many billions of fish and other aquatic life each year, and climate change-driven water scarcity could jeopardize the functioning of nuclear power plants. However, nuclear power plants have advanced water recycling systems, and some newer reactor designs, such as gas-graphite reactors, use smaller volumes of water.

Nuclear power plants produce no greenhouse gas emissions during operation

Nuclear energy has low greenhouse gas emissions over its lifecycle, with nuclear power plants producing about the same amount of carbon dioxide-equivalent emissions per unit of electricity as wind, and one-third of the emissions per unit of electricity compared with solar. Nuclear energy produces about 10 grams of carbon dioxide per kilowatt-hour, compared to about 500 for fossil gas and 1000 for coal. This makes nuclear energy a significant contributor to reducing emissions, with the use of nuclear energy today avoiding emissions roughly equivalent to removing one-third of all cars from the world's roads.

However, it is important to note that the nuclear fuel cycle, including mining, milling, transport, fuel fabrication, enrichment, reactor construction, decommissioning, and waste management, uses fossil fuels and emits some carbon dioxide and conventional pollutants. Uranium mining, for example, can expose workers to severe health risks, including lung cancer, and open-pit mining can destroy ecosystems, leaving toxic, radioactive remnants and polluted land and water. In addition, nuclear power plants require enriched uranium for fuel, which can be achieved through in situ leaching, a process that permanently contaminates groundwater.

While nuclear power plants do not emit greenhouse gases during operation, the extraction and transformation of raw materials, construction, and other processes in the whole life cycle can result in indirect GHG emissions. Nuclear power is also water-intensive, consuming large volumes of water in various stages of the process. Climate change, driving heat waves and droughts, can increase competition for water resources, potentially affecting the functioning of nuclear power plants.

Nuclear power plants require physical security

Nuclear power plants do not burn fossil fuels and so do not directly emit carbon dioxide. Nuclear energy has helped reduce environmental costs by decreasing CO2 emissions resulting from energy consumption. However, nuclear power plants still produce environmentally damaging waste. Radioactive waste is subject to special regulations that govern its handling, transportation, storage, and disposal to protect human health and the environment. Uranium mining, which is necessary for nuclear power, exposes workers to severe health risks, including lung cancer, and can also destroy ecosystems, leaving toxic, radioactive remnants and polluted land and water.

Frequently asked questions