Liquid Hydrogen: Clean Energy Or Polluting Hazard?

Liquid hydrogen is being investigated as a potential zero-carbon fuel for aircraft, cars, vessels, and heavy machinery. It is also used as rocket fuel by NASA and the U.S. Air Force. Hydrogen is considered a clean fuel because it burns with oxygen to produce water vapour and warm air, with no carbon dioxide emissions. However, the process of producing hydrogen does release carbon dioxide, and hydrogen combustion can produce dangerously high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx), which contributes to air pollution. Therefore, while liquid hydrogen has the potential to reduce pollution, particularly in the transportation sector, further research and the development of pollution control technologies are needed to mitigate the environmental risks associated with its production and combustion.

Hydrogen combustion produces nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions

Hydrogen combustion is a clean source of energy that burns with oxygen to produce water vapour and no soot, nitrous oxide, or carbon dioxide. However, hydrogen combustion can produce nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions, which are hazardous air pollutants. NOx formation occurs when air, which contains nitrogen and oxygen, is exposed to very high temperatures (above 1500°C). Any type of high-temperature combustion, including that of diesel, gasoline, natural gas, and hydrogen, can produce NOx. Nitrogen oxide emissions include nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2).

Hydrogen burns at higher temperatures than natural gas, so the combustion of pure hydrogen may result in comparatively higher NOx emissions. However, hydrogen has a larger stable combustion temperature range, meaning a higher ratio of air to fuel can be used. The additional air dilutes the hydrogen, cooling the flame and resulting in lower-temperature combustion, thereby reducing the amount of NOx emissions produced.

There are also multiple mitigation strategies and technologies to prevent or reduce NOx emissions when hydrogen is used for combustion. For example, flue gas treatment approaches can convert harmful emissions into less harmful compounds, using processes similar to those in catalytic converters in gasoline- and diesel-powered vehicles.

While hydrogen combustion may produce NOx emissions, current research has shown that hydrogen combustion via turbines can achieve comparable performance and NOx emissions to those of today's turbines running on natural gas.

Hydrogen is a low-carbon energy source

The production and use of hydrogen as an energy source have several advantages. Hydrogen can be produced from diverse domestic resources, such as natural gas, coal, solar energy, wind, and biomass, with the potential for near-zero greenhouse gas emissions. Once produced, hydrogen can be used to generate electrical power in fuel cells, emitting only water vapour and warm air. This makes it a promising alternative to gasoline and diesel, which produce harmful emissions such as nitrogen oxides, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter.

Liquid hydrogen, in particular, has several benefits. It has a high energy density compared to other fuels, making it a compact and efficient energy source. Liquid hydrogen is also commonly used for transporting and storing hydrogen due to its reduced volume and improved efficiency compared to hydrogen gas. Additionally, liquid hydrogen is non-corrosive, non-toxic, and odourless, making it safe to handle and transport.

However, there are also challenges associated with liquid hydrogen. It requires cryogenic storage technology, such as specialised thermally insulated containers, which can be costly. Additionally, liquid hydrogen is highly flammable and has a high likelihood of ignition, posing safety risks. Furthermore, the novel applications of liquid hydrogen, such as in vehicles and aircraft, may face obstacles due to infrastructure limitations, safety concerns, and costs.

Overall, hydrogen, including liquid hydrogen, has the potential to be a low-carbon energy source with significant benefits for the transportation and energy sectors. However, it is essential to address the challenges and carefully consider the environmental impacts of hydrogen combustion to ensure its sustainable and safe utilisation.

Hydrogen is non-toxic but can cause asphyxiation

Hydrogen is often touted as the clean fuel of the future. It burns with oxygen to produce water vapour and no carbon dioxide, soot, or nitrous oxides. However, the production of hydrogen does release carbon dioxide, and hydrogen combustion can produce dangerously high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx).

While hydrogen is non-toxic, it can cause asphyxiation. Asphyxiation is a form of suffocation that occurs when the body is deprived of oxygen. In the case of hydrogen, asphyxiation can occur when hydrogen gas displaces oxygen in the air, creating an oxygen-deficient atmosphere. This can happen in enclosed spaces where hydrogen or liquid hydrogen is stored or transported.

Hydrogen is a very light gas, and it dissipates quickly into the atmosphere. However, in a confined space, it can accumulate and pose a serious asphyxiation hazard. For example, in 1981, shortly before the launch of the first Space Shuttle mission, five technicians lost consciousness and two of them died after they entered a compartment where nitrogen had been used to flush out oxygen as a fire precaution. Similar incidents have occurred in other industrial settings, as well as recreational settings, such as a pool party where liquid nitrogen was poured into the pool.

To prevent asphyxiation hazards, it is crucial to ensure proper ventilation and oxygen monitoring in areas where hydrogen is handled or stored. Safety protocols, such as requiring the use of air packs, can also help protect workers from accidental exposure to oxygen-deficient atmospheres.

In summary, while hydrogen itself is non-toxic, it is important to recognise that it can cause asphyxiation in certain conditions. Proper safety measures and ventilation are essential to mitigate this risk.

Hydrogen is used as a rocket fuel

Hydrogen is an attractive rocket fuel because it has the highest specific impulse of all liquid fuels, making it the most fuel-efficient propellant. Liquid hydrogen is also the most energetic and burns at temperatures of up to 3,038° Celsius (5,500° Fahrenheit). Its light molecular weight and energetic nature allow combusted hydrogen gas to be propelled through a rocket engine's nozzle at a greater velocity.

Liquid hydrogen is a powerful rocket fuel that has been used for many decades. It is particularly well-suited for upper-stage use, where specific impulse is at a premium and thrust-to-weight ratios are less relevant. The Centaur upper stage, the Delta IV rocket, the H-IIA rocket, most stages of the European Ariane 5, and the Space Launch System core and upper stages all use liquid oxygen and liquid hydrogen. The Saturn rockets used liquid hydrogen for their secondary stage engines, and the NASA space shuttles used it to power their three main rocket engines.

Liquid hydrogen is a cryogenic fuel, which means it must be cooled to extremely low temperatures (below -253° Celsius or -423° Fahrenheit) before it can be used as rocket fuel. While liquid hydrogen offers several advantages, it also has some drawbacks. For instance, hydrogen occupies about seven times more volume per kilogram than dense fuels such as kerosene, which means that the fuel tankage, plumbing, and pump must be larger, increasing the vehicle's dry mass and reducing performance. It is also relatively expensive to produce and store, and causes difficulties with design, manufacture, and operation of the vehicle.

Liquid hydrogen is a clean-burning fuel, resulting in no engine residue buildup and no carbon emissions. When hydrogen combines with oxygen to produce energy, the main byproduct is pure water vapour, unlike other fuels that release harmful gases and pollutants when burned. However, hydrogen combustion can produce dangerously high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx), which could partially negate the environmental benefits of burning hydrogen.

Hydrogen is a zero-carbon fuel for aircraft

Hydrogen is a zero-carbon fuel that has been used in industry for decades. It is being investigated as a zero-carbon fuel for aircraft. Hydrogen burns with oxygen to make water vapour, and only water vapour—no soot, no nitrous oxides, and no carbon dioxide with its potential greenhouse warming. However, hydrogen combustion can produce dangerously high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx).

Liquid hydrogen is a common liquid rocket fuel for rocketry applications and is used by NASA and the U.S. Air Force. It is also being explored as a fuel for cars, vessels, aircraft, and heavy machinery. Hydrogen has a lower volumetric energy density than gasoline, requiring larger tanks at higher pressure than other gaseous fuels. However, liquid hydrogen has increased energy density, space savings, and transport efficiency compared to hydrogen gas.

The production of hydrogen fuel does release carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, although about half as much as burning fossil fuels. Hydrogen-based fuel cells are more efficient than internal combustion engines, and research programs are underway to find ways to sequester carbon dioxide. Hydrogen fuel cells emit only water (H2O) and warm air.

While liquid hydrogen has been used safely in industry for decades, its novel applications will bring it closer to the public. Safety is paramount to prevent accidents, protect human lives, and maintain public trust in hydrogen as a safe alternative fuel. Hydrogen is highly flammable, and its leaks are difficult to detect because it is non-corrosive, non-toxic, and odourless.

Frequently asked questions