Cruise Ships: Polluting The Oceans And Earth?

Cruise ships are a popular choice for vacations, with the industry being the fastest-growing in tourism. However, there are concerns about their environmental impact and contribution to pollution. Cruise ships have been found to emit large amounts of pollutants, such as sulfur oxides, nitrogen oxides, and carbon emissions, leading to air pollution and acid rain. They also generate billions of gallons of waste, including sewage, oily wastewater, and garbage, which is often dumped into the ocean, contaminating water bodies and destroying marine ecosystems such as coral reefs. The industry's growth has led to larger ships, exacerbating the problem. While some cruise lines have implemented initiatives to reduce their environmental impact, critics argue that these efforts are insufficient and that true sustainable measures are needed.

Cruise ships emit large amounts of harmful sulphur and nitrogen oxides

In 2022, Europe's cruise ships emitted as much sulphur oxide as 1 billion cars. Cruise liners run by Carnival Corporation emitted nearly ten times more sulphur oxide air pollution around European coasts than all of Europe's cars. Sulphur oxide emissions from ships have been linked to higher rates of cancer and other forms of respiratory diseases.

Nitrogen oxide emissions from cruise ships also impact the environment and human well-being. Cruise ships accounted for 15% of the nitrogen oxide particles emitted by Europe's passenger vehicles. In Marseille, France, where 57 cruise ships docked in 2017, their nitrogen oxide emissions were nearly equivalent to those produced by a quarter of the city's 340,000 passenger cars.

To reduce emissions, cruise operators have been urged to switch to cleaner fuel alternatives with lower sulphur content. However, few have heeded these calls, as safer fuels like liquefied natural gas are more expensive. As a result, operators have favoured using scrubbers, which are considered "emission cheat" systems. While scrubbers can help clean" smokestacks from dirty fuel and reduce air pollution, they convert air pollution into water pollution by discharging toxic byproducts directly into the sea.

Cruise ships produce and dump large amounts of sewage and other waste into the ocean

Cruise ships produce an estimated food waste of around 30%. They often dispose of this waste by liquifying it and calling it "fish food". However, the food served on a cruise ship is not part of a fish's natural diet and often contains pesticides, chemicals, antibiotics, and hormones. This waste is then consumed by fish and other marine wildlife, leading to bioaccumulation, where the contaminants accumulate in the organism's body and cannot be expelled.

In addition to food waste, cruise ships also produce a significant amount of human waste and wastewater. This waste is often referred to as black water or greywater and includes water from flushing toilets, showers, sinks, laundry machines, and other non-toilet drains. While there are regulations in place that specify where and how this waste can be discharged, with sewage typically needing to be treated before release, cruise ships in the past have not always complied with these regulations.

The sewage from cruise ships not only contains human waste but also chemicals, pharmaceuticals, bacteria, viruses, heavy metals, and hazardous waste. Cruise ships often lack the necessary sewage treatment facilities to adequately filter out these toxins, leading to increased pollution and oxygen depletion in the waters. The release of sewage can also contribute to the growth of algae blooms, which can suffocate coral reefs, manatees, shellfish, and fish.

Overall, the dumping of sewage and other waste by cruise ships has a significant negative impact on the ocean and marine life, and while regulations and treatment technologies have improved, more stringent enforcement and industry-wide changes are needed to address this issue effectively.

Cruise ships contribute to carbon emissions, with a large carbon footprint per passenger

Cruise ships are major contributors to carbon emissions, with a large carbon footprint per passenger. A medium-sized cruise ship emits greenhouse gases equivalent to 12,000 cars, with a five-night, 1,200-mile cruise resulting in about 1,100 lbs of CO2 emissions. Cruise ships emit large amounts of sulfur oxides (SOx), contributing to air pollution and acid rain. In 2022, Europe's 218 cruise ships emitted as much SOx as one billion cars. These emissions are particularly harmful around ports and exceed pre-pandemic levels.

The cruise industry is also a major producer of waste, with a large cruise ship generating over a ton of rubbish per day and billions of gallons of waste pumped into the oceans. Cruise ships generate large volumes of oily bilge water, sewage sludge, garbage, and hazardous wastes. They also produce blackwater, or sewage wastewater, which is released into the oceans, containing bacteria, viruses, and parasites. This waste disrupts marine ecosystems, impacting the food, migration patterns, and overall health of marine wildlife.

In addition to carbon emissions and waste generation, cruise ships are notorious for water, noise, and air pollution. They release nitrogen oxides (NOx) into the atmosphere, affecting the environment and human well-being. Cruise ships in Europe impacted cities like Marseille, with NOx emissions equivalent to about 15% of the NOx emitted by Europe's passenger cars. The use of scrubbers to reduce air pollution has led to increased water pollution as toxic byproducts are discharged into the sea.

The environmental impact of the cruise industry has attracted the attention of groups like Friends of the Earth, which produces an annual Cruise Ship Report Card evaluating cruise lines on environmental and health impacts. Despite the industry's promises to introduce zero-emission vessels and fuels by 2030 and achieve net-zero carbon cruising by 2050, environmental groups doubt their ability to reach these goals.

Cruise ships pollute the air, causing serious health issues and global warming

Cruise ships are a major source of air pollution, which has been linked to serious health issues and global warming. According to an undercover report by CNN, the air quality on cruise ships is so poor that it could harm the health of passengers, staff, and port communities. The report found that the concentration of particulate matter on the decks of certain cruise ships was comparable to that of heavily polluted cities like Beijing and Santiago. These particles can lead to respiratory and cardiovascular issues, with health experts warning of the dangers of poor air quality.

Cruise ships emit high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx) and sulfur oxide (SOx) emissions, which contribute to air pollution and acid rain. In Europe, cruise ships emitted more than four times more sulfur oxides than all the continent's cars combined. These emissions are particularly harmful around ports and can impact the health of nearby residents. For example, in Marseille, France, the shipping industry is responsible for 10% of the city's air pollution, and cruise ships docking in the harbor have led to increased pollution and health issues for locals.

The impact of cruise ship air pollution is not limited to Europe. A single cruise ship can emit as much pollution as 700 trucks and as much particulate matter as a million cars. In addition, the cruise industry's growth has led to larger ships, exacerbating the problem. A medium-sized cruise ship can emit greenhouse gases equivalent to 12,000 cars. The largest and most efficient cruise ships emit around 250 grams of CO2 per passenger per kilometre, and a five-night, 1,200-mile cruise can result in about 1,100 lbs of CO2 emissions.

The pollution caused by cruise ships is not just limited to air quality. These ships also generate large amounts of sewage and wastewater, which is often dumped directly into the ocean without treatment. Heavy metals and other toxic chemicals released by cruise ships can also contaminate the water and harm marine life. As a result, coastal communities and wildlife are affected, and fragile marine ecosystems are destroyed.

To address these issues, port cities are considering banning or restricting cruise ships. Environmental groups and governments have also implemented emissions tests and issued fines to offending cruise lines. However, the cruise industry has been criticized for failing to meet air quality safety standards and for using "emission cheat" systems that discharge pollutants into the ocean. While there are alternatives to traditional cruising that offer lower carbon footprints and less pollution, the cruise industry's unsustainable practices continue to have a detrimental impact on the environment and public health.

Cruise ships contaminate coral reefs and destroy valuable marine life

Cruise ships have been deemed a serious threat to coral reefs and the marine life that depends on them. Coral reefs are an enticing marine habitat, constituting a rich ecological integrity and biodiversity, sheltering one-fourth of all marine species worldwide. They provide shelter for marine organisms, protect coastlines from erosion and storms, and are a source of nutrients and nitrogen for marine food chains.

However, cruise ships have been found to contaminate coral reefs and destroy valuable marine life in several ways. Firstly, cruise ships generate and dump large amounts of sewage and wastewater, also known as blackwater and greywater, respectively, into the ocean. While some of this waste is treated before dumping, much of it is discharged directly into the ocean without any treatment. This waste can contain bacteria, viruses, and parasites that are harmful to marine life. For instance, chemicals in the treatment process can harm the reproductive systems of marine animals. When dumped into the ocean, this waste decreases oxygen levels and increases acidity, leading to algae blooms that further threaten coral reefs.

Secondly, cruise ships produce and release large volumes of oily bilge water, sewage sludge, garbage, and hazardous wastes. These pollutants can directly poison marine life and contribute to global warming. In addition, the physical presence of cruise ships can also damage coral reefs. For example, anchoring and grounding of cruise ships have been documented to endanger marine species and damage coral reefs, with one incident involving a cruise ship destroying 3150 square meters of coral reef in a single day. Furthermore, noise pollution generated by cruise ships can impact the sonar of animals that rely on it, such as whales and orcas.

The environmental impact of cruise ships on coral reefs and marine life is significant and has been recognized by organizations such as Friends of the Earth, which has ranked and assessed the environmental and human health impacts of major cruise lines. While some regulations, such as Annex IV of MARPOL, prohibit the unloading of sewage wastes within a certain distance from land, the lack of advanced sewage treatment systems on many modern cruise ships remains a concern. The rapidly expanding size and number of cruise ships have triggered a pollution crisis, and new laws and standards are urgently needed to protect coral reefs and marine life from the destructive impacts of the cruise industry.

Frequently asked questions