Hydroelectricity's Water Pollution: Is Green Energy Really Clean?

Hydroelectricity is often considered a 'clean' energy source, but it can have a range of environmental impacts and contribute to water pollution. The process of generating electricity from water often involves the construction of large dams and reservoirs, which can alter natural water temperatures, water chemistry, river flow characteristics, and silt loads, affecting the biodiversity and ecology of the river. While hydropower generators do not directly emit air pollutants, the reservoirs can produce carbon dioxide and methane, and the flooding of land for reservoirs can destroy forests, wildlife habitats, and agricultural land. Additionally, the slower water flow and release of cold water from reservoirs can adversely affect aquatic life, and the formation of reservoirs can lead to oxygen stratification and increased algal growth, further impacting water quality.

Hydroelectric power plants can cause flooding, destroying forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic lands

Hydroelectric power plants can have a significant impact on the environment, and in certain cases, they can cause flooding, leading to the destruction of forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic areas.

The size of the reservoir created by a hydroelectric project depends on the size of the generators and the topography of the land. Projects in flat areas tend to require much more land than those in hilly areas or canyons, where deeper reservoirs can hold more water in a smaller space. The Balbina hydroelectric plant in Brazil, for instance, flooded 2,360 square kilometers, an area the size of Delaware, and only provides 250 MW of power. In contrast, a small 10 MW run-of-the-river plant in a hilly location can use as little as 2.5 acres.

The flooding of land for a hydroelectric reservoir can have extreme environmental consequences. It can destroy forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic areas. For instance, the construction of the Three Gorges Dam in China led to the relocation of entire communities. The creation of a reservoir can also obstruct fish migration and alter water temperatures, chemistry, flow characteristics, and silt loads. These changes can negatively affect native plants and animals in and around the river.

Additionally, the water in reservoirs is usually more stagnant than normal river water, leading to higher levels of sediments and nutrients, which promote the growth of algae and other aquatic weeds. These weeds can crowd out other plant and animal life and negatively impact water quality. The taste, colour, and odour of the water can also be affected by the presence of algae, making it unsuitable for human consumption. Furthermore, certain types of algae are poisonous and can pose risks to human health if ingested.

While hydropower is a renewable and clean energy source, the construction and operation of hydroelectric power plants can have environmental impacts. The manufacturing of concrete and steel for hydropower dams can produce emissions, particularly if fossil fuels are used as energy sources. However, over the long operating lifetime of a hydropower plant, these emissions are offset by the electricity generated without burning fossil fuels.

Water quality degradation: the water in reservoirs is stagnant, leading to higher levels of sediments and nutrients, and algae, which can harm aquatic life and impair water quality

Water quality degradation is a significant concern associated with hydroelectricity. While hydropower does not produce direct carbon emissions, it can negatively impact water quality in several ways. One of the primary concerns is the stagnation of water in reservoirs, which leads to various issues that can harm aquatic life and impair water quality.

Reservoirs created by hydroelectric projects can vary in size, depending on the generators' size and the topography of the land. The water in these reservoirs is typically more stagnant than normal river water, resulting in the formation of layers with varying oxygen levels. The deeper areas of the reservoir experience oxygen depletion, creating hypoxic zones. This stratification, or separation of water into stable layers, has important consequences for downstream river water quality.

The stagnation of reservoir water also leads to higher levels of sediments and nutrients. This environment fosters the growth of algae and other aquatic weeds, which can crowd out native plant and animal life. Some types of algae can produce toxins, negatively impacting human health if consumed. Additionally, increased algal concentrations can cause premature clogging of filters, decrease biodiversity, and increase the concentration of certain compounds through the anaerobic decomposition of algae.

The water in reservoirs is also typically colder and has lower dissolved oxygen levels than normal river water. When this water is released downstream, it can negatively impact the plants and animals in those ecosystems. To mitigate these issues, aerating turbines can be installed to increase dissolved oxygen levels, and multi-level water intakes can ensure that water is released from various reservoir depths, helping to maintain more natural temperature and oxygen levels.

Moreover, the continuous decline in water levels within reservoirs can further impact water quality. Lower water levels can decrease the self-purification capacity of the reservoir, leading to increased pollutant release from sediments. Changes in water levels can also affect the temperature, light, and other conditions, directly influencing the internal ecological environment of the reservoir.

Changes in water temperature: the release of cold water from the bottom of reservoirs can negatively impact aquatic life

Water temperature plays a crucial role in the quality of aquatic habitats and the life of organisms within them. The "abiotic master factor", as defined by JR Brett, water temperature affects nearly every other water quality parameter. It influences the metabolic rates and biological activity of aquatic organisms, including their respiration and digestive responses.

The release of cold water from the bottom of reservoirs, as a result of hydroelectricity, can negatively impact aquatic life. Water temperature is determined by factors such as the type of water body, depth, season, latitude, and surrounding environment. The temperature pattern can shift if the reservoir stratifies and the dam release is too high or too low, releasing unusually cool or unusually warm water into the stream. This can affect the migration, spawning, and hatching of local fish species.

Reservoir water is typically colder than normal river water and has a lower concentration of dissolved oxygen. When this cold water is released, it can negatively impact downstream plants and animals. The deep water of reservoirs is hypoxic, lacking in oxygen, and this water can be detrimental to aquatic life if released. The formation of a reservoir results in the formation of layers within the water, with higher oxygen concentrations at the top and lower concentrations at the bottom.

To mitigate these impacts, some measures can be taken. Aerating turbines can be installed to increase dissolved oxygen levels in the water released from the reservoir. Additionally, multi-level water intakes can be used to ensure that the released water comes from all levels of the reservoir, rather than just the bottom, thus improving the water temperature and oxygen levels.

Changes in water chemistry: hydroelectric dams can alter the chemical makeup of water, affecting the ecology and physical characteristics of rivers

While hydropower generators do not directly emit air pollutants, the construction and operation of hydroelectric dams can have a significant impact on the environment. The creation of a reservoir or the diversion of water to a run-of-river hydropower plant can obstruct the migration of fish to their upstream spawning areas, particularly in rivers where salmon must travel upstream to spawn, such as the Columbia River in Washington and Oregon. This can lead to the extinction or near-extinction of fish species and a significant loss of aquatic biodiversity.

Hydroelectric dams can also alter the natural water temperatures, chemistry, flow characteristics, and silt loads of rivers. The water in reservoirs is typically colder and has lower dissolved oxygen levels than normal river water due to oxygen stratification. When this water is released, it can negatively impact downstream plants and animals. Additionally, reservoirs tend to have higher levels of sediments and nutrients, leading to increased algal growth, which can crowd out other plant and animal life and negatively impact water taste, colour, and odour, making it unsuitable for human consumption.

The formation of a reservoir can also result in the flooding of land, destroying forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic areas. The physical impacts of a dam and reservoir can change the environment over a much larger area than the reservoir itself. The manufacturing of concrete and steel for hydropower dams can also produce emissions, particularly if fossil fuels are used as energy sources.

The cumulative impacts of multiple hydropower dams can be greater than the sum of their individual effects. Even a small single dam can entrain fish, block fish passage, and displace wildlife. A series of dams can severely impact an entire watershed and contribute to the degradation of water quality, affecting both human and aquatic life.

Greenhouse gas emissions: the construction and operation of hydroelectric facilities can produce greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide and methane

While hydropower is a low-carbon source of renewable energy, the construction and operation of hydroelectric facilities can produce greenhouse gas emissions. The creation of a reservoir can result in the flooding of organic material, which undergoes aerobic and anaerobic decomposition, leading to the formation and release of gases such as carbon dioxide and methane. This process is influenced by various factors, including the reservoir's depth, shape, sun exposure, and wind speed.

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's (IPCC) Fifth Assessment Report highlights that hydropower has lower median lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions than other energy sources, except for wind and nuclear power. The median value of lifecycle GHG emissions for hydropower is 23 gCO2-eq/kWh, according to the International Hydropower Association's analysis of almost 500 reservoirs.

However, some dams, particularly those in lowland areas, can produce high greenhouse gas emissions per unit of electricity generated. For instance, the collective emissions of existing Amazon hydropower reservoirs are estimated at 14 Tg CO2eq per year, and if all the proposed Amazon dams are built, emissions are projected to increase fivefold. This emphasizes the importance of strategic planning to ensure the sustainable development of hydropower.

The manufacturing process for the concrete and steel used in hydropower dams may also contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. If fossil fuels are used as energy sources during the production of these materials, the resulting emissions are indirectly associated with the electricity generated by hydropower facilities. Nevertheless, given the long operating lifetime of a hydropower plant (50 to 100 years), these emissions are typically offset by the benefits of emissions-free hydroelectricity over time.

Frequently asked questions