Hydropower's Water Pollution Paradox: Clean Energy, Dirty Water?

Hydropower is a widely used form of renewable energy, but it is not without its environmental impacts. One of the major concerns associated with developing hydroelectric facilities is water quality degradation, which is a form of water pollution. The use of water to produce electricity can pollute the water directly or as a by-product of creating a reservoir or redirecting water systems. Hydropower dams can alter the temperature and chemical makeup of the water, affecting the biological integrity of river ecosystems and causing harm to native plants and animals. Additionally, the creation of reservoirs can result in the flooding of land, destroying forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and archaeological sites. While hydropower is considered a clean energy source due to its lack of direct carbon emissions, recent studies have shown that it can still contribute to climate change through the release of greenhouse gases and methane during the construction and operation of facilities.

Hydropower dams can alter the temperature and chemical makeup of water

Hydropower is a renewable source of energy that uses the kinetic energy of flowing water to generate electricity. While hydropower does not produce direct carbon emissions, it can still negatively impact the environment and cause water pollution. Hydropower dams can alter the temperature and chemical makeup of water, which can have detrimental effects on the surrounding ecosystem.

The creation of a reservoir, which is a body of water created by a dam, can result in the formation of layers within the water with varying oxygen levels. The top layers of the reservoir, which are oxygen-rich, are warmer due to their proximity to the sun, while the bottom layers become progressively colder and hypoxic. This phenomenon, known as thermal pollution or oxygen stratification, can alter the temperature of the water downstream when it is drawn into the turbine through a penstock located at the bottom of the reservoir.

The presence of algae in the water can also negatively impact its taste, colour, and odour, making it unsuitable for human consumption. Certain types of algae are poisonous and can pose risks to human health. In addition, increased algal concentrations can decrease biodiversity, reduce dissolved oxygen levels, and increase the concentrations of harmful substances such as hydrogen sulfide, iron, manganese, and ammonia through the anaerobic decomposition of algae.

Furthermore, the flooding of land to create a reservoir can introduce mercury into the water. When elemental mercury found in the rock and soil interacts with bacteria released from the decomposition of submerged plant material, water-soluble forms of mercury are formed. These mercury compounds can accumulate within the water system and biomagnify within the food chain, posing health risks to people who consume fish from these waters.

The construction and operation of hydropower dams can also affect the natural water temperatures and chemistry of rivers. According to a study that analysed the impact of 100 existing dams, it was predicted that around 73% of dams would cool downstream waters in the summertime, while most dams would warm rivers in the winter. These temperature changes can have significant effects on native fish populations, altering their metabolic rates, reproduction, and growth.

The creation of reservoirs can result in the loss of important natural areas

The creation of reservoirs can have a significant environmental impact, and one of the most notable consequences is the loss of important natural areas. When land is flooded to create a reservoir, it becomes unsuitable for many of its previous uses, including farming, wildlife habitats, and human recreation. This can result in the displacement of both people and wildlife.

Reservoirs are often created by building a dam across a valley or using natural or man-made depressions. This process can obstruct the natural flow of water and alter the water chemistry, temperature, and silt loads. These changes can have far-reaching effects on the surrounding ecosystem, impacting native plants and animals. For example, the altered water flow can disrupt fish migration and affect the reproductive and growth rates of aquatic organisms.

The formation of a reservoir also results in the creation of layers within the water, with higher oxygen concentrations at the top and lower concentrations at the bottom. These areas of low oxygen, known as hypoxic areas, can negatively impact aquatic life and decrease biodiversity. Additionally, the slower-moving water in reservoirs can lead to increased algal growth, further degrading water quality and posing risks to human health if consumed.

The flooding of land for reservoirs can also have specific consequences for the natural biogeochemical cycle of mercury. Studies have shown that the production of toxic methylmercury can increase significantly following the creation of a reservoir. This increase in methylmercury can bioaccumulate in predatory fish, potentially posing health risks to humans who consume them.

In conclusion, while reservoirs may serve important purposes for human society, their creation can result in the loss of valuable natural areas and have significant ecological impacts. These impacts should be carefully considered and mitigated to ensure the sustainable use of water resources for both human and environmental needs.

Water quality degradation is a major concern, affecting plant and animal life

Water quality degradation is a major concern in the development of hydroelectric facilities, with a wide range of plant and animal life being affected. Hydropower does not directly emit air pollutants, but dams, reservoirs, and the operation of hydroelectric generators can have a significant environmental impact.

One of the primary ways in which hydropower affects water quality is by altering the temperature and chemical composition of the water. The creation of a reservoir, which is more stagnant than a flowing river, results in the formation of layers with varying oxygen levels. The top layers are oxygen-rich, while the deeper layers experience oxygen depletion, leading to the formation of hypoxic areas. This oxygen stratification, along with changes in water temperature, can have detrimental effects on aquatic life, impacting metabolic rates, reproduction, and growth.

The flooding of land to form reservoirs can also have severe environmental consequences. It can destroy forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic areas. The submerged plant material and soil can release mercury into the water, which then accumulates and biomagnifies within the food chain, posing health risks to humans who consume fish from these waters. Additionally, stagnant reservoir water can promote the growth of algae and aquatic weeds, which can crowd out native plant and animal species and negatively impact water taste, colour, and odour, making it unsuitable for human consumption.

Furthermore, the construction and operation of hydropower facilities can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. The manufacturing of concrete and steel for dams may involve the use of fossil fuels, and the decomposition of vegetation underwater can release carbon dioxide and methane. While hydropower plants have long operating lifetimes that can offset these emissions over time, recent research suggests that emissions during the operation of a facility can be significant, especially in the near term.

The cumulative impacts of multiple hydropower dams can be greater than the sum of their individual effects. Even a small dam can disrupt fish migration and wildlife habitats, and a series of dams can severely impact an entire watershed. Therefore, it is crucial to consider the siting, design, and operation of renewable power sources like hydropower to ensure they protect local ecosystems while providing clean energy.

Hydropower facilities can produce carbon dioxide and methane

Hydropower is widely regarded as a low-carbon source of renewable energy and a reliable alternative to electricity generation by fossil fuels. However, hydropower facilities can produce carbon dioxide and methane, which are greenhouse gases (GHG).

When a reservoir is created and filled with water, the submerged organic matter, such as vegetation, decomposes and breaks down, releasing carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane. These gases can reach the atmosphere through diffusion, ebullition (bubbles), transmission via vegetation, and degassing when water passes through a pump house or turbine.

The extent of GHG emissions from a reservoir is influenced by several factors, including the amount of shallow littoral area. More littoral area results in more methane production and, consequently, higher GHG emissions. Additionally, the operating level of the reservoir can be adjusted to reduce shallow littoral areas and, subsequently, the amount of GHG emissions.

The long residence time of the reservoir allows for the accumulation of these gases, particularly methane, which has a stronger immediate effect on atmospheric warming and climate change. Methane can last in the atmosphere for about a decade, while carbon dioxide can persist for thousands of years, gradually building up over time.

It is important to accurately estimate the GHG emissions from hydropower facilities to ensure a stronger and cleaner electric grid. While hydropower has a lower carbon footprint than fossil fuels, it is crucial to acknowledge and address the carbon dioxide and methane emissions associated with its generation to make informed decisions about the transition to a clean energy future.

The construction of hydropower plants may require fossil fuels, producing emissions

Hydropower is one of the main sources of renewable energy worldwide, and countries are increasingly adopting it to reduce their reliance on fossil fuels. However, the construction of hydropower plants may require fossil fuels, producing emissions.

The construction of hydropower dams requires concrete and steel, the manufacturing of which may be associated with emissions. If fossil fuels are used as energy sources during the manufacturing process, the resulting emissions from the equipment could be associated with the electricity generated by the hydropower facilities. Nevertheless, given the long operating lifetime of a hydropower plant (50 to 100 years), these emissions are offset by the emissions-free hydroelectricity generated over time.

The creation of a reservoir, which is a common feature of hydropower plants, can also impact the environment. The flooding of land for a reservoir can make it unsuitable for farming, wildlife habitats, or human recreation. The formation of a reservoir can result in the accumulation of thermal energy in the top layers, closest to the sun, while the deeper layers become progressively colder. This thermal stratification can alter the temperature of water downstream when it is drawn into the turbine, affecting aquatic life.

In addition, reservoirs can influence the chemical composition of water. The long residence time of water in reservoirs allows for the accumulation and biomagnification of mercury within the food chain, which can pose health risks to humans who consume fish from these water bodies. Furthermore, increased algal concentrations in reservoirs can negatively impact water quality and biodiversity, as well as cause premature clogging of filters due to increased organic content.

While hydropower plants may contribute emissions during their construction, it is important to note that all energy sources, even renewables, produce carbon emissions at some point in their lifecycle. Hydropower, with its long lifespan, offers a more favourable emissions profile compared to fossil fuel alternatives.

Frequently asked questions