Air Quality Alert: Indoor Vs. Outdoor Pollution — Which Is Worse?

It is easy to assume that outdoor air quality is worse than the air quality inside. However, research suggests that indoor air pollution may be as much or more of a problem as outdoor air pollution. According to the EPA, the levels of indoor air pollutants are often 2 to 5 times higher than outdoor levels, and in some cases, these levels can exceed 100 times that of outdoor levels of the same pollutants. Spending more time indoors, especially for children and older adults, means that the impact of indoor air pollution could be greater than outdoor air pollution.

Indoor air pollution is harder to regulate than outdoor air pollution

While outdoor air pollution is often more visible, indoor air pollution can be worse for your health. Research indicates that people spend approximately 90% of their time indoors, so the risks to health may be greater due to exposure to indoor air pollution. According to the EPA, levels of indoor air pollutants are often 2 to 5 times higher than outdoor levels, and in some cases, these levels can exceed 100 times that of outdoor levels of the same pollutants.

The sources of indoor air pollution are varied and include combustion sources such as building materials and furnishings, household cleaning and maintenance products, central heating and cooling systems, outdoor sources such as radon, pesticides, and outdoor air pollution, and even personal care products such as perfumes and hairsprays. The effects of indoor air pollution on health are also significant, with poor air quality contributing to or causing infections, allergies, chronic lung diseases, lung cancer, and even other forms of cancer.

Despite the seriousness of the issue, indoor air pollution is harder to regulate than outdoor air pollution. While the federal government in the United States has measures in place to regulate outdoor air pollution, there is little government oversight regarding indoor air pollution. This is partly because indoor air pollution is often an invisible issue, and also because it occurs in private spaces where government regulation is more challenging. While individual states have the power to regulate indoor air pollution, they cannot regulate all areas, such as private residences.

The challenges of regulating indoor air pollution lie in the fact that it occurs in private spaces, such as homes, where government intervention is more restricted. Additionally, indoor air pollution is often invisible, with sources such as mould, tobacco smoke, and building materials releasing gases or particles that are not easily detected. As a result, indoor air pollution has often been ignored in public health promotion, and there is a lack of awareness about the potential health risks associated with it.

Outdoor air pollution can enter homes through walls, doors, and windows

In addition to infiltration, outdoor air can also enter homes through natural ventilation, such as opened windows and doors, and mechanical ventilation devices, such as outdoor-vented fans and air handling systems. These ventilation systems are designed to remove indoor air and distribute filtered and conditioned outdoor air throughout the house.

While outdoor air pollution can enter homes through these various means, it is important to note that indoor air quality can often be worse than outdoor air quality. Scientific evidence suggests that the air within homes can be more polluted than the outdoor air in industrialized cities. This is due to various indoor pollution sources, such as building materials, furnishings, household products, and activities like smoking, cooking, and cleaning. These sources can release gases and particles into the air, leading to indoor air quality problems. Inadequate ventilation can further exacerbate the issue by not bringing in enough outdoor air to dilute emissions and carry indoor pollutants out of the home.

The health risks associated with indoor air pollution are significant, especially for vulnerable groups such as children, the elderly, and individuals with respiratory or cardiovascular diseases. Exposure to indoor air pollutants can lead to various health issues, including respiratory and cardiovascular problems, and in some cases, premature death. Therefore, it is crucial to take steps to improve indoor air quality, such as ensuring adequate ventilation, changing air filters regularly, and avoiding indoor smoking.

Indoor air pollution is often more harmful than outdoor air pollution

It is a common misconception that outdoor air is more polluted than indoor air. However, scientific evidence suggests that the air within homes and other buildings can be more polluted than the outdoor air in industrial cities. This is because indoor air pollution sources release gases and particles into the air, causing indoor air quality problems. Inadequate ventilation can increase indoor pollutant levels by not bringing in enough outdoor air to dilute emissions from indoor sources and by failing to carry indoor air pollutants out of the home. High temperature and humidity levels can also increase the concentration of some pollutants.

There are many sources of indoor air pollution in any home. These include combustion sources such as tobacco, wood, and coal-heating and cooking appliances, and fireplaces, which can release harmful combustion byproducts such as carbon monoxide directly into the indoor environment. Cleaning supplies, paints, insecticides, and other commonly used products introduce many different chemicals, including volatile organic compounds (VOCs), directly into the indoor air. Building materials are also potential sources, whether through degrading materials (e.g. asbestos fibers released from building insulation) or from new materials (e.g. chemical off-gassing from pressed wood products). Other substances in indoor air are of natural origin, such as radon, mould, and pet dander.

Outdoor air pollutants can enter buildings through open doors, windows, ventilation systems, and cracks in structures. For example, harmful smoke from chimneys can re-enter homes and pollute the indoor air. Some pollutants come indoors through building foundations. Radon, for instance, can enter buildings through cracks or gaps in structures. In areas with contaminated groundwater or soils, volatile chemicals can enter buildings through the same process. When people enter buildings, they can inadvertently bring in soils and dust from the outdoors, along with pollutants that adhere to those particles.

The air exchange rate with the outdoors is an important factor in determining indoor air pollutant concentrations. The air exchange rate is affected by the design, construction, and operating parameters of buildings and is a function of infiltration, natural ventilation, and mechanical ventilation. Outdoor climate and weather conditions, combined with occupant behaviour, can also affect indoor air quality. For example, occupant cleaning activity can influence indoor air quality, as seen in the case of two neighbouring homes in the UK, where a VOC differed by over 1,000 times due to differences in occupant cleaning activity.

Overall, indoor air pollution is often more harmful than outdoor air pollution due to the variety of sources of indoor air pollution and the lack of dilution and ventilation in indoor environments. The majority of people spend significantly longer periods indoors, making indoor air quality a critical determinant of their health and well-being.

Indoor air pollution is caused by cooking, cleaning, and building materials

Research has shown that the air inside homes and buildings can be more polluted than the outdoor air in industrialized cities. People spend approximately 90% of their time indoors, so the health risks from indoor air pollution are significant. Indoor air pollution is caused by a variety of sources, including cooking, cleaning, and building materials.

Cooking is a major contributor to indoor air pollution, especially when using combustion stoves such as gas stoves that release harmful particles. The World Health Organization (WHO) warns that one-third of the world's population uses cooking methods that may be detrimental to their health. Gas stoves that are not properly ventilated are a significant source of particulate matter, which can cause respiratory issues and even lead to chronic lung disease. Frying and deep-frying release high levels of harmful pollutants due to the high temperatures involved. To mitigate this, it is recommended to cook on the back burner, which is better ventilated, and to use exhaust fans or open windows to improve ventilation.

Cleaning products also contribute to indoor air pollution. Household cleaning and maintenance products, as well as personal care products, release gases and particles that can accumulate indoors due to inadequate ventilation. These chemicals can have negative health effects, especially for those already suffering from respiratory or cardiovascular issues.

Building materials and furnishings can be another source of indoor air pollution. Deteriorated asbestos-containing insulation, damp carpets, and pressed wood products can release particles and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) into the indoor air. Additionally, central heating and cooling systems can circulate these pollutants throughout the building.

To reduce the impact of indoor air pollution, it is crucial to improve ventilation by bringing in outdoor air and removing indoor pollutants. Installing carbon monoxide detectors and indoor air quality monitoring devices can help identify issues and protect the health of occupants. Overall, addressing indoor air pollution caused by cooking, cleaning, and building materials requires a combination of improved ventilation, strategic cooking practices, and the selection of appropriate building materials and finishes.

Outdoor air pollution affects indoor air quality, especially in urban areas

Outdoor air pollution is a major environmental health problem, affecting individuals in low-, middle-, and high-income countries. It is caused by a variety of sources, including industry, transport, waste management, urban planning, and agriculture. While outdoor air pollution is a significant issue, it is important to recognize that it can also impact indoor air quality, especially in urban areas.

In urban areas, outdoor air pollutants can enter buildings through open doors, windows, ventilation systems, and even cracks in structures. This includes harmful smoke from chimneys, which can re-enter homes and pollute the indoor air. Additionally, volatile chemicals in contaminated groundwater or soils can enter buildings through cracks or when occupants use water for activities like showering or cooking. People can also inadvertently bring outdoor pollutants into their homes on their shoes and clothing.

The impact of outdoor air pollution on indoor air quality is particularly notable in urban areas due to the high population density and proximity to sources of pollution. High-rise buildings, narrow streets, and limited green spaces can contribute to the concentration of pollutants in the air. Furthermore, the design and construction of buildings in urban areas can influence the infiltration of outdoor air pollutants. For example, energy-efficient buildings with insufficient mechanical ventilation may have reduced air exchange, leading to the accumulation of pollutants.

To mitigate the impact of outdoor air pollution on indoor air quality in urban areas, it is crucial to implement effective policies and practices. This includes reducing industrial emissions, improving waste management practices, promoting clean modes of transportation, and prioritizing rapid urban transit, walking, and cycling networks. Additionally, improving the energy efficiency of buildings and incorporating green spaces in urban planning can help reduce outdoor air pollution and create more sustainable and healthy living environments for residents.

While outdoor air pollution is a significant concern, it is important to address the combined effects of ambient and indoor air pollution. Individuals can take steps to improve indoor air quality by ensuring adequate ventilation, using air purifiers, and reducing the use of pollutants, such as tobacco smoke, cleaning supplies, and pesticides. By addressing both outdoor and indoor air pollution, we can create healthier and more sustainable environments, especially in urban areas.

Frequently asked questions