Air Pollution Receptor Regions: Oakland's Unwanted Legacy

Oakland, California, is known for its poor air quality, with the city's air pollution levels consistently ranking among the worst in the United States. The city has struggled to meet federal air pollution attainment levels, particularly in terms of PM2.5 and ozone pollution. West Oakland and Downtown Oakland are exposed to some of the highest levels of air pollution in the Bay Area, with residents experiencing higher rates of health issues such as asthma, stroke, and heart disease. The high levels of air pollution in Oakland are attributed to various factors, including busy roadways, industrial facilities, and transportation emissions. The impact of air pollution on the health of Oakland residents has raised concerns about environmental justice, as low-income and minority communities bear a disproportionate burden of environmental impact.

West Oakland has some of the highest levels of air pollution in the Bay Area

A 2008 health risk assessment by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) found that West Oakland residents are exposed to air concentrations of diesel pollution that are almost three times higher than average background levels in the Bay Area. The assessment also attributed 71% of the air pollution risk to truck traffic. West Oakland's proximity to busy roadways and industrial sources contributes to its elevated pollution levels.

The impact of this pollution on the health of West Oakland residents is significant. According to the Alameda County Public Health Department, residents of West Oakland experience higher rates of asthma emergency room visits, stroke, and congestive heart failure compared to the rest of the county. The area also has some of the highest asthma and cardiovascular disease impacts in the region. Census data also shows that West Oakland has a high prevalence of poverty and a higher proportion of minority populations, which often results in a heavier health burden from pollution exposure due to lower housing quality and decreased access to clean environments.

The high levels of air pollution in West Oakland have not gone unnoticed, and the community has been an area of focus for studies conducted over the last decade. Efforts to understand and address the issue include the use of hyperlocal maps and mobile sensor technology to track and measure pollution levels, as well as the development of air quality monitoring data by the Community Steering Committee and the West Oakland Indicators Project.

Air pollution in Oakland is caused by mobile sources, industrial sources, and port operations

Oakland, California, is a receptor region for air pollution, with East Oakland bearing the brunt of the poor air quality. Air pollution in Oakland is caused by mobile sources, industrial sources, and port operations.

Mobile sources, such as motor vehicles, are a significant contributor to air pollution in Oakland. The I-880 (Nimitz Freeway), a major transportation route serving the Port of Oakland and Oakland International Airport, has significantly higher levels of air pollution due to the high volume of truck traffic it carries. On average, this stretch of highway sees 200,000 vehicle trips per day. The high levels of air pollution from these mobile sources have severe health impacts on the surrounding communities.

Industrial sources also play a role in Oakland's air pollution. East Oakland, in particular, has a mix of commercial and industrial facilities located close to residential areas and public spaces. The 2010 community-based participatory research study by Communities for a Better Environment found high levels of air pollution along the same roadway, exceeding state and federal standards. The industrial sector has contributed to the elevated levels of air pollution in the area, impacting the health of nearby residents.

Port operations at the Port of Oakland have also been identified as a source of air pollution. The port handles a significant volume of truck traffic, contributing to the poor air quality in the region. However, efforts are being made to improve the situation, with the Port of Oakland working with tenants to convert to zero-emissions trucks and equipment. As of December 20, 2019, there were 33 electric ship-to-shore cranes at all marine terminals.

The combination of mobile sources, industrial activities, and port operations has led to elevated levels of air pollution in Oakland, particularly in East Oakland. This has resulted in adverse health outcomes for the residents, including higher rates of heart disease, stroke, and lung cancer and asthma hospitalizations. The communities most impacted by this poor air quality are predominantly low-income and of color, exacerbating existing social and environmental inequalities.

Oakland's weather and geography can exacerbate air pollution

Oakland's air quality consistently ranks among the worst in the United States. The city's weather and geography can further exacerbate the city's challenges with high emissions. Marine inversions cause Oakland's polluted air to become trapped at ground level. These inversions occur when air cooled by the Pacific Ocean becomes trapped by warmer, denser air above, flowing inland from the hills. As a result, emissions accumulate, contributing to elevated air quality index levels in the Bay Area.

The West Oakland community has a high cumulative air pollution exposure burden. The community is impacted by mobile sources such as diesel trucks and buses, locomotives, the Port of Oakland operations, railyard operations, and adjacent interstates. A 2008 health risk assessment by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) found that West Oakland residents are exposed to air concentrations of diesel pollution that are almost three times higher than average background levels in the Bay Area.

East Oakland's freight corridor, busy roadways, and industrial sector have also contributed to elevated levels of air pollution. Residents experience some of the highest asthma hospitalization rates compared to the rest of the region. A 2018 study by EDF and Kaiser Permanente found that differences in air pollution within neighbourhoods or even city blocks can increase the risks of heart attack and death from heart disease in the elderly.

Oakland's air pollution is not limited to specific areas of the city, as even within individual city blocks, air pollution can vary significantly. Mobile emissions from motor vehicles, ships, planes, and trains comprise the largest source of air pollution in Oakland. In 2019, the city ranked 3rd nationally for the worst 24-hour PM2.5 out of 217 metropolitan areas and 5th for annual particle pollution. PM2.5 is widely regarded as the most harmful air pollutant to human health and has been linked to cardiovascular disease, respiratory illness, and premature mortality.

Oakland's air pollution disproportionately affects low-income communities and communities of color

Oakland, California, is a receptor region for air pollution, with West Oakland and Downtown Oakland exposed to some of the highest levels of air pollution in the Bay Area. This is due to a mix of sources, including freight, freeways, industry, and port operations. The I-880 corridor, a major transportation route, features significantly higher levels of air pollution, which is unsurprising given that it carries the greatest volume of truck traffic in the Bay Area and California.

A 2008 California Air Resources Board (CARB) health risk assessment found that West Oakland residents are exposed to air concentrations of diesel pollution that are almost three times higher than average background levels in the Bay Area, with 71% of air pollution risk attributable to truck traffic. This has led to West Oakland and Downtown Oakland communities experiencing a high health burden, with higher rates of asthma, stroke, and congestive heart failure compared to the rest of the county.

Furthermore, historically redlined communities like West Oakland, where racial and ethnic groups were restricted in where they could purchase homes, continue to face the legacy of this discrimination. On average, Black and Hispanic people in Oakland experience air pollutant concentrations up to 30% higher than average, while white people experience levels about 15% lower than average. This disparity has led to worse health outcomes for communities of color, with higher death rates from heart disease, stroke, and lung cancer, and a shorter life expectancy compared to more affluent residents in the northern area of the city.

To address these disparities, there have been calls for stricter regulations and the adoption of zero-emission trucks to reduce pollution levels and protect the health of communities disproportionately impacted by poor air quality.

Oakland's air quality consistently ranks among the worst in the United States

Oakland, California, has some of the worst air quality in the United States. In 2019, the city ranked 3rd nationally for the worst 24-hour PM2.5 levels out of 217 metropolitan areas and 5th for annual particle pollution. PM2.5, or fine particulate matter, is an air pollutant that is widely considered the most harmful to human health. It has been linked to cardiovascular disease, respiratory illness, and premature death.

Several factors contribute to Oakland's poor air quality. The city is home to major transportation routes, including the I-880 freeway, which serves the Port of Oakland and Oakland International Airport. The I-880 corridor carries a significant volume of truck traffic, with an average of 200,000 vehicle trips per day. The presence of large distribution centers, a cement plant, a power plant, metal facilities, and industrial and manufacturing operations also contribute to the high levels of air pollution in the city.

The impact of air pollution on the health of Oakland residents is significant. According to the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), asthma affects about 18% of Oakland's youth, which is roughly twice the national average. Studies have estimated that nearly a third of these cases are a result of poor air quality. Additionally, residents of West Oakland and Downtown Oakland have higher rates of asthma-related emergency room visits, stroke, and congestive heart failure compared to the rest of the county.

The disparity in health outcomes is also evident within Oakland itself. For example, residents of East Oakland have higher death rates from heart disease, stroke, and lung cancer than those in other parts of the city. Life expectancy in East Oakland is seven years shorter than that of more affluent residents in the northern area of Oakland. These health disparities are influenced by multiple factors, including exposure to high levels of air pollution from motor vehicles, refineries, and other sources.

Efforts are being made to address Oakland's air pollution and its impact on public health. The Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) has partnered with local organizations to create hyperlocal maps of air pollution levels using mobile sensor technology. These maps reveal significant variations in pollution levels within neighborhoods and even within individual city blocks. By understanding the extent and sources of air pollution in Oakland, stakeholders can develop effective strategies to reduce pollution levels and improve the health of the community.

Frequently asked questions