Groundwater Vs Surface Water: Which Cleanses Pollutants Better?

Groundwater and surface water are both susceptible to pollutants, which can include gasoline, oil, road salts, chemicals, and natural contaminants like arsenic and radon. Groundwater pollution occurs when these pollutants are released into the ground and make their way into aquifers, which can result in hazards to public health. Surface water pollution, on the other hand, is often caused by spills, improperly treated wastewater, erosion, or runoff from rain storms. While both types of water sources can be contaminated, the question arises: does one type of water remove pollutants faster than the other? This is an important consideration, especially when examining the effectiveness of remediation techniques and the potential risks to human health and the environment.

Characteristics of Groundwater and Surface Water in Relation to Pollutant Removal

Groundwater contamination from human activity

Groundwater contamination refers to the addition of undesirable substances to groundwater caused by human activities. Over 50% of the US population depends on groundwater for drinking, and it is also a crucial source of water for irrigation. Groundwater is susceptible to pollutants, and when contaminated, it becomes unsafe and unfit for human use. Materials from the land's surface can move through the soil and end up in groundwater supplies.

One significant source of groundwater contamination is urban pollution, which includes leaking underground fuel tanks, often from neighbourhood gas stations. Prior to the 1970s, military bases and industrial facilities also dumped fuels, solvents, and other liquid wastes into pits, where the pollutants leached into the groundwater. Today, toxic substances from mining sites, used motor oil, and road salts used in winter to melt ice on roads can all seep into groundwater supplies.

Agricultural practices are another source of groundwater contamination. The use of pesticides and fertilizers can lead to nitrate contamination, which has been reported in regions worldwide. Arsenic, a toxic semi-metallic element used in wood preservatives and agricultural chemicals, can also contaminate groundwater, posing severe health risks to humans. Improperly managed septic systems can leak bacteria, viruses, and household chemicals into the groundwater, causing serious health issues such as hepatitis and dysentery.

Additionally, landfills can contribute to groundwater contamination if they lack a protective bottom layer or if it is cracked. Contaminants from landfills, such as car battery acid, paint, and household cleaners, can seep into groundwater supplies. Climate change is another factor that poses a significant threat to groundwater quality, and the increasing numbers of contaminant classes detected in groundwater is a growing concern for human populations and the environment.

Natural groundwater contaminants

Groundwater often appears clean and clear, as the ground naturally filters out particulate matter. However, natural and human-induced chemicals can contaminate groundwater. Natural groundwater contaminants include:

• Arsenic: A semi-metallic element used in wood preservatives, agricultural chemicals, herbicides, and pesticides. Arsenic is toxic to humans, and the ingestion of as little as 100 milligrams can result in severe poisoning. Arsenic occurs naturally in some soils and can be found in groundwater at low concentrations.
• Fluoride: Fluoride is a growing concern as deeper groundwater sources are being used. More than 200 million people are at risk of drinking water with elevated concentrations of fluoride. Fluoride is especially released from acidic volcanic rocks and dispersed volcanic ash when water hardness is low. High levels of fluoride in groundwater are a serious issue in several regions, including the Argentinean Pampas, Chile, Mexico, India, Pakistan, the East African Rift, and some volcanic islands.
• Nitrate: Nitrate is a common groundwater contaminant, leaching into the soil and water supply from various sources. While it occurs naturally in the soil, nitrate dissipates when the soil is extensively farmed. Irrigation water containing fertilizers, septic systems, wastewater treatment plants, dairies, and natural conditions can all contribute to nitrate contamination in groundwater.
• Other natural elements: In addition to arsenic and fluoride, other natural elements that can contaminate groundwater include radon and boron, and trace metals such as lead, cadmium, and chromium. These elements can enter the environment through natural processes like weathering or human activities such as mining and industrial operations.

These natural contaminants can have significant impacts on the safety and usability of groundwater, highlighting the importance of effective groundwater management practices to prevent and mitigate contamination.

Surface water pollution

One of the primary sources of surface water pollution is human waste, especially in developing countries. Poor sanitation infrastructure and inadequate waste treatment systems contribute to this issue. Additionally, industrial activities play a significant role in polluting surface water. Byproducts from industrial processes can leak into rivers and drainage systems, introducing various contaminants. These include heavy metals, solvents, toxic sludge, and other chemical pollutants. Furthermore, agricultural practices contribute to surface water pollution through fertilizer seepage from farmland. When excess fertilizers are used, they can find their way into nearby water bodies, causing nutrient pollution and leading to harmful algal blooms.

Urban stormwater runoff is another major contributor to surface water pollution. During rainfall, stormwater can pick up various contaminants from impermeable surfaces, such as roads, parking lots, and rooftops. These contaminants include road salts, oil, grease, chemicals, and debris, which are then washed into nearby waterways. Flooding can exacerbate this issue, as it spreads contaminated water across a larger area, including regions that are not typically exposed to water.

The consequences of surface water pollution are far-reaching. It can lead to the contamination of drinking water sources, causing major illnesses in humans. Additionally, it can result in toxic products remaining in fish due to exposure to pathogens, making them unsafe for consumption. The presence of certain pollutants, such as antibiotics, can also contribute to the development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, further endangering human health.

Addressing surface water pollution requires a multifaceted approach. It is crucial to implement effective waste treatment systems and improve sanitation infrastructure, especially in developing regions. Strict regulations and monitoring of industrial waste discharges are also necessary to prevent the release of harmful byproducts into water bodies. Additionally, promoting sustainable agricultural practices can help reduce fertilizer runoff and nutrient pollution. Public education and awareness about the impacts of surface water pollution can empower individuals to make environmentally conscious choices and support initiatives that protect and restore water quality.

Groundwater treatment techniques

Groundwater treatment is a complex process that requires careful consideration of various factors such as site conditions, contaminant types, concentrations, budget, and timeframe. While there is no one-size-fits-all approach, several treatment techniques are commonly used to address groundwater contamination.

Biological Treatment Methods

Bioaugmentation, for example, involves the use of cultured microorganisms that are added to the subsurface to expedite the biodegradation of contaminants like chlorinated VOCs. This approach can take one to five years to demonstrate results and has proven to be cost-effective. Certain types of permeable reactive barriers also utilize biological organisms to remediate groundwater.

Chemical Treatment Techniques

Chemical treatment techniques include ozone and oxygen gas injection, chemical precipitation, membrane separation, ion exchange, carbon absorption, aqueous chemical oxidation, and surfactant-enhanced recovery. In Situ Chemical Oxidation (ISCO) is a versatile chemical treatment method where chemical oxidants are injected or mixed with groundwater to destroy contaminants upon contact. Oxidants can include air, oxygen, ozone, hydrogen peroxide, permanganate, and persulfate.

Physical Treatment Techniques

Physical treatment techniques include pump and treat, air sparging, and dual-phase extraction. Pump and treat is a widely used technology where groundwater is pumped to the surface and coupled with biological or chemical treatments to remove impurities. Air sparging involves blowing air directly into the groundwater, allowing rising bubbles to carry contaminants into the unsaturated zone (soil). Dual-phase vacuum extraction (DPVE) or multi-phase extraction uses a high-vacuum system to remove both contaminated groundwater and soil vapour.

Nanomaterials and Nanoparticles

Nanomaterials and nanoparticles are also being utilized to address groundwater contamination. Carbon Nanotubes (CNTs), for instance, have attracted attention for their high surface area, thermal and chemical stability, and optical and electronic properties. CNTs have been used in water monitoring, pesticide and heavy metal detection, water purification, and desalination.

Other Considerations

When designing a groundwater and leachate treatment system, flexibility is crucial to accommodate changing field conditions. Additionally, economic evaluations play a significant role in selecting a groundwater remediation technique, as rapid cleanups may not always be cost-effective, especially when utilizing expensive equipment for short periods.

Health risks of contaminated groundwater

Groundwater is a crucial source of drinking water for millions of people worldwide, including in the United States, where over 50% of the population depends on it. However, it is susceptible to pollutants and contamination from human-induced chemicals and natural sources, which pose significant health risks.

One of the primary health risks associated with contaminated groundwater is the ingestion of toxic substances. Groundwater can become contaminated with various chemicals, including gasoline, oil, road salts, pesticides, fertilizers, and toxic waste from landfills and industrial activities. These contaminants can have severe health effects, with even small amounts leading to poisoning. For example, arsenic, a common contaminant found in groundwater, is highly toxic to humans, and ingestion of just 100 milligrams can result in severe poisoning.

Another health risk is the presence of biological organisms and pathogens in the water. Improperly managed septic systems can leak bacteria, viruses, and other harmful microorganisms into groundwater sources, leading to potential infections and waterborne diseases. Additionally, natural elements like radon, boron, and arsenic, which can be toxic to humans and plants, may also leach into the groundwater from certain types of soil and rock formations.

Groundwater contamination can also occur due to atmospheric contaminants and pollutants from surface water, which are transferred into groundwater supplies as part of the hydrologic cycle. This includes contaminants from the atmosphere, such as emissions from industrial facilities and power plants, as well as pollutants from bodies of surface water, such as lakes and rivers.

The health risks associated with consuming contaminated groundwater are serious and can have both immediate and long-term effects. While treatment methods can help remove certain contaminants, ensuring safe and reliable access to clean groundwater remains a critical challenge, particularly in areas with limited resources or inadequate infrastructure for water treatment.

Frequently asked questions