Shipwrecks' Pollution Legacy: Ocean Impact And Solutions

Sunken vessels and shipwrecks have a profound impact on marine ecosystems, influencing their structure, chemistry, and biology for decades. While some shipwrecks are intentionally placed underwater to create new habitats for marine life, others pose significant environmental risks. There are an estimated 3 million sunken and abandoned vessels in the ocean, with over 8,500 of these identified as potentially polluting wrecks. These wrecks often contain harmful chemicals, oil, heavy metals, and even unexploded munitions, which can leak and damage marine life, ecosystems, and human communities. Climate change is also accelerating the degradation of shipwrecks, particularly those made of iron and steel, as oceans become more acidic. As a result, governments are urged to develop international standards and proactive plans to address the complex issue of pollution from shipwrecks.

Sunken vessels can influence the structure, chemistry and biology of marine ecosystems

Sunken vessels can have a profound impact on marine ecosystems, influencing their structure, chemistry, and biology. This impact can persist for decades after the sinking event, leaving a lasting imprint on the ocean environment.

Firstly, in terms of structure, shipwrecks can alter the physical layout of the seafloor. When large vessels sink, they can scrape and damage a significant area of the ocean habitat, affecting over 10,000 square feet of seafloor. This disruption to the seafloor can have cascading effects on the marine organisms that rely on these habitats.

Secondly, the chemistry of marine ecosystems can be significantly altered by sunken vessels. Shipwrecks often contain fuel, oil, and other toxic chemicals, which can leak and contaminate the surrounding water. For example, a study of the area around the Sea Diamond shipwreck found elevated concentrations of heavy metals like lead and cadmium, exceeding safe levels set by the Environmental Protection Agency. These toxic substances can be taken up by microorganisms and transferred up the food chain, impacting the health of fish and crustaceans.

Additionally, the introduction of new chemical elements can create novel opportunities for certain marine microbes. For instance, shipwrecks can provide a bountiful source of iron, attracting iron-oxidizing bacteria that thrive on steel surfaces. This complex interplay between the chemistry of the seawater and the biology of marine organisms underscores the dynamic nature of marine ecosystems.

Moreover, the presence of sunken vessels can create what are known as "artificial reefs." Intentionally placed shipwrecks can serve as new habitats for marine life, attracting fish and other organisms. While this practice is sometimes criticized as greenwashing, it highlights the potential for shipwrecks to reshape marine ecosystems by providing novel structures for colonization.

In conclusion, sunken vessels exert a profound influence on the structure, chemistry, and biology of marine ecosystems. From altering the seafloor topography to introducing new chemical elements and creating artificial habitats, the impact of shipwrecks can be long-lasting and far-reaching. As the oceans continue to hide thousands of wrecks, managing and understanding their impact is crucial for preserving the delicate balance of marine life.

The impact of shipwrecks on marine life and human health

Shipwrecks have a significant impact on marine life and human health, and the consequences can be long-lasting. Firstly, shipwrecks often contain toxic materials, such as fuel, oil, heavy metals, and chemicals, which can leak into the surrounding environment. These pollutants can be extremely harmful to marine organisms, including plants, animals, and microorganisms. For example, a study of the area around the Sea Diamond shipwreck found elevated levels of lead and cadmium that exceeded safe thresholds. This contamination can spread through the food chain, affecting fish and crustaceans.

Additionally, shipwrecks can physically damage sensitive marine habitats. When ships crash into coral reefs or scrape the seafloor, they can destroy over 10,000 square feet of ocean habitat, which can have a detrimental effect on marine life and ecosystems. The loss of these habitats can also impact human communities, particularly those whose livelihoods depend on marine resources.

Furthermore, the degradation of shipwrecks can be accelerated by climate change. As oceans warm, species compositions change, and if these include marine boring organisms that eat or bore holes through wood, shipwrecks may degrade faster. Ocean acidification, caused by the increased absorption of carbon dioxide, can also lead to faster metal degradation. This means that pollutants from shipwrecks may be released more rapidly, posing an ongoing threat to the environment and human health.

However, it is important to note that not all shipwrecks are detrimental to marine life. Some can actually serve as artificial reefs, providing new habitats for marine organisms. These artificial reefs can help mitigate the loss of natural reef ecosystems, and some ships are intentionally sunk for this purpose. Nonetheless, the overall impact of shipwrecks on marine life and human health is largely negative, and the lack of data and international cooperation on managing pollution from wrecks means that proactive action is often lacking.

To address these issues, there have been calls for the creation of an international standard to guide responses to shipwreck pollution and the development of national plans to support affected communities and restore ecosystems. Systematic assessments of wrecks, including their location, cargo, and pollution potential, are also necessary to identify and mitigate environmental threats effectively.

The role of governments and international cooperation in mitigating pollution from shipwrecks

Sunken shipwrecks pose a significant threat to marine environments, with over 8,500 shipwrecks at risk of leaking approximately 6 billion gallons of oil. This issue is exacerbated by the lack of data and effective international cooperation, resulting in delayed responses that fail to prevent harm to marine ecosystems, coastal communities, and economies. Therefore, it is crucial for governments and international organizations to collaborate and take proactive measures to mitigate pollution from shipwrecks.

Governments play a pivotal role in addressing pollution from shipwrecks. Firstly, they should incorporate wrecks into their marine spatial and contingency planning. National plans should include measures to stop the spread of pollution, such as removing pollutants from wrecks and responding swiftly to leaks. Additionally, governments should provide financial support to communities impacted by pollution and prioritize the restoration of damaged ecosystems.

International cooperation is essential to effectively address the global issue of shipwreck pollution. The International Maritime Organization (IMO), as the UN body that regulates global shipping, plays a crucial role in facilitating collaboration and implementing measures for safer and more sustainable shipping practices. IMO works with its member states to develop and enforce legislation that promotes cleaner and safer shipping. For instance, IMO's London Convention and Protocol regime contribute to climate change mitigation by regulating carbon capture and providing guidance on assessing proposals for marine geoengineering.

Additionally, the UN has taken steps towards addressing shipwreck pollution through initiatives such as the UN Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development framework and the Lisbon Declaration. The former emphasizes the goal of achieving "a clean ocean where sources of pollution are identified and reduced or removed" by 2030. The Lisbon Declaration, agreed upon by UN countries in May 2022, highlights the importance of science-based actions, international cooperation, and partnerships in overcoming challenges related to marine pollution, including pollution from shipwrecks.

Furthermore, the Institute of International Law (IDI) adopted a resolution in 2015 titled "The Legal Regime of Wrecks of Warships and Other State-Owned Ships in International Law." This resolution provides a legal framework for addressing wrecks, considering their cultural heritage status and the fact that warships are also gravesites. It emphasizes the need for cooperation among states to protect and preserve wrecks, remove those that pose a hazard, and ensure they do not cause pollution.

To summarize, mitigating pollution from shipwrecks requires a multifaceted approach involving both governments and international cooperation. While governments should take proactive measures through national planning and community support, international collaboration facilitated by organizations like IMO and UN helps establish standards, regulations, and frameworks to address this global issue effectively.

Climate change and its effects on the degradation of shipwrecks

Climate change is causing an increase in severe weather events, ocean warming, and ocean acidification, which are accelerating the degradation of shipwrecks. As shipwrecks degrade, there is a risk of fuel and other pollutants being released into the marine environment, posing serious environmental and economic threats.

The Impact of Climate Change on Shipwreck Degradation

The warming of the oceans is causing species to migrate, and if these are marine boring organisms that eat or bore holes through wood, shipwrecks may degrade faster. Ocean acidification, which occurs when the ocean absorbs more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, can also cause metal to degrade at a faster rate. As the pH of the ocean decreases, metal shipwrecks may be particularly vulnerable to corrosion.

Environmental and Economic Threats

The release of fuel and other pollutants from degrading shipwrecks poses a significant threat to the environment. Oil spills, for example, can damage animals' habitats, pollute water, and be extremely difficult to clean up. In addition to oil, shipwrecks may also contain heavy metals, chemical pollutants, and unexploded munitions. These pollutants can have severe environmental consequences if released into the marine environment. For instance, a study of the area around the Sea Diamond shipwreck found concentrations of lead and cadmium that exceeded safe thresholds set by the Environmental Protection Agency.

The economic impacts of shipwreck degradation can also be substantial. The cost of addressing an oil spill can be very high, and if not addressed promptly, it can harm coastal economies and communities' health and livelihoods.

Mitigation Strategies

To protect wrecks from climate change, one expert suggests that they need to be buried in sand. However, this may not be a feasible solution for all shipwrecks, and the lack of data and international cooperation on wreck management means that proactive action to prevent leaks is often not taken. There have been calls for the creation of an international standard to guide action and prioritize resources, as well as for governments to develop national plans that include financial support for communities impacted by marine pollution.

The benefits of creating artificial reefs from shipwrecks

While shipwrecks often damage the marine environment, some are intentionally placed underwater to create new habitats. Research suggests that "artificial reefs" can be created by shipwrecks under the right conditions. Here are some benefits of creating artificial reefs from shipwrecks:

Providing habitats for marine life

Shipwrecks can create new places for fish and other marine life to live, helping to mitigate the loss of reef ecosystems. Artificial reefs are often used as a tool by marine conservationists to restore coral reefs and provide a stable growing area for corals. They can also provide habitats for the fishes and invertebrates that play a role in keeping the ecosystem healthy and functioning.

Economic benefits

Artificial reefs can provide local economic benefits by attracting fish to a known location. They are popular attractions for commercial and recreational fishermen, divers, and snorkelers. However, it is important to note that artificial reefs can also attract illegal dumping and poaching, as seen in the Florida Keys.

Controlling erosion and protecting coastal areas

Artificial reefs can be used to control erosion and protect coastal areas from the impacts of waves and currents. They can also block ship passage and the use of trawling nets, which can damage marine habitats.

Enhancing scuba diving and surfing experiences

Artificial reefs can enhance scuba diving and surfing experiences by providing interesting and challenging underwater environments. Thousands of popular wreck diving sites throughout the world are shipwrecks sunk as artificial reefs, deliberately placed to attract divers.

However, it is important to note that artificial reefs can also have negative impacts. They can unbalance the natural ecosystem and attract invasive species that disrupt local ecosystems. Additionally, some scientists criticize the use of artificial reefs as a form of greenwashing, arguing that it addresses the symptoms rather than the root problems facing coral reefs.

Frequently asked questions