Carbonaria Moths: Pollution's Unlikely Residents

The carbonaria moth, also known as the peppered moth, is a species of moth that has been studied extensively for its evolution and adaptation to polluted environments. Carbonaria moths are the dark-coloured variant of the peppered moth, which experienced a rapid increase in population during the Industrial Revolution due to the high levels of pollution in the atmosphere. The carbonaria variant of the peppered moth is particularly prevalent in polluted areas as the dark pigmentation provides them with effective camouflage against predators.

Carbonaria moths are more common in polluted areas

The carbonaria form of the peppered moth (Biston betularia) is more common in polluted areas. This phenomenon is an example of directional colour change in the moth population as a consequence of air pollution during the Industrial Revolution.

Before the Industrial Revolution, the light peppered moth (typica) was common, while the dark-coloured or melanic form (carbonaria) was very rare. The light moths blended in with the light-coloured trees, which were covered in light speckled lichens. However, pollution from coal-burning factories and plants during the Industrial Revolution led to the demise of the lichens and deposited a layer of black soot on the once light-coloured trees. The tree bark was now exposed and dark.

The dark-coloured carbonaria form of the peppered moth became more common in these polluted areas as they could better camouflage themselves against the darkened tree trunks. The light-coloured moths, on the other hand, became easier targets for birds as they stood out against the darkened trees. This led to a higher survival rate for the dark-coloured moths, which then passed their dark-coloured genes onto their offspring.

Over time, the frequency of the dark-coloured carbonaria form increased drastically in polluted industrial cities like Manchester, England. By 1895, it had reached a reported frequency of 98% in Manchester. Bernard Kettlewell's experiments between 1953 and 1956 confirmed that light-coloured moths were more easily detected by birds in polluted environments, while the dark-coloured moths benefited from their camouflage.

However, as pollution levels decreased in response to clean air legislation, the light-coloured form of the peppered moth once again became predominant. The decline in pollution was accompanied by a decline in the frequency of the carbonaria allele, and the light-coloured typica variety saw a resurgence. This further reinforced the understanding of the carbonaria moth form being more common in polluted areas.

Dark pigmentation is a result of industrial melanism

Dark pigmentation, or melanism, is a congenital excess of melanin in an organism. When artificial impacts on natural selection cause a species' colour to change, it is known as industrial melanism.

Industrial melanism is widespread in the Lepidoptera (butterflies and moths), involving over 70 species. The most studied example is the evolution of the peppered moth, Biston betularia, which has two forms: typica, a pale lighter colour that is peppered with black speckles, and carbonaria, a much darker colour that is peppered with light speckles.

Before the Industrial Revolution, the light peppered moth was common, while the dark form was very rare. The light moths blended in with the light-coloured trees. However, the Industrial Revolution changed the colour of the trees. Coal burning released large amounts of smoke and smog into the surrounding environment, leaving a layer of black soot on the once light-coloured trees. The pollution also killed the light-speckled lichens that grew on the tree trunks, leaving the tree bark exposed and dark. As the trees darkened with soot, the light-coloured moths were easier to see by predators, and the rare dark-coloured moths blended in better on the darker trees. This made the dark-coloured moths have a higher survival rate, and they passed their dark-coloured genes onto their offspring. Over time, the dark-coloured moths became the more common of the two colour forms.

As pollution decreased in response to clean air legislation, the light-coloured form of the peppered moth once again predominated. The rapid decline of melanism that has accompanied the reduction of pollution makes natural selection for camouflage "the only credible explanation". Other explanations for the observed correlation with industrial pollution have been proposed, including strengthening the immune system in a polluted environment, absorbing heat more rapidly when sunlight is reduced by air pollution, and the ability to excrete trace elements through skin shedding.

Carbonaria moths use camouflage to avoid predation

The carbonaria morph of the peppered moth is a darker colour, peppered with light speckles. This is in contrast to the typical peppered moth, which is lighter and speckled with black. The carbonaria form benefits from extra camouflage, allowing it to hide from predators.

The carbonaria form of the peppered moth is a classic example of Darwinian evolution and natural selection. During the Industrial Revolution, pollution from coal burning released large amounts of smoke and smog, leaving a layer of black soot on the once light-coloured trees. The pollution also killed the light-coloured lichens that grew on the tree trunks, exposing the now dark tree bark.

As the trees changed colour, so too did the peppered moth. The light-coloured moths that had once blended in with the trees now stood out against the darkened bark. They were, therefore, eaten by birds more frequently. The rarer dark-coloured moths, on the other hand, were better camouflaged against the polluted trees. They had a higher survival rate, allowing them to pass on their dark-coloured genes to their offspring. Over time, the dark-coloured carbonaria form became the more common of the two colour morphs.

Since the 1950s, conditions have started to reverse. The introduction of the Clean Air Act, along with technological advancements and cleaner-burning fuels, has decreased pollution in the areas where peppered moths live. The lichen has started to grow back, and the soot no longer settles on the tree bark. As a result, the light-coloured typica form has become more common, as it is better camouflaged against the cleaner environment.

The peppered moth is a model of parallel evolution, with the British form (carbonaria) and the American form (swettaria) being indistinguishable in appearance. The evolution of the peppered moth is an example of directional colour change in response to air pollution. The increase in dark-coloured moths during the Industrial Revolution and the subsequent decline in frequency as pollution decreased are evidence of the role of camouflage in the species' survival.

Experiments prove dark moths are better camouflaged in polluted areas

The carbonaria variant of the peppered moth is dark, a change influenced by environmental factors during the Industrial Revolution. The typical variant is light-coloured. The carbonaria variant is also referred to as the "melanic form".

During the Industrial Revolution, there was a rise in the new dark melanic form of the peppered moth, coinciding with a decline in the pale form. This was due to the increased industrialisation and domestic coal fires that caused air pollution, killing off lichens and blackening tree trunks and walls. The pale form of the moth became more obvious to predators, while the melanic form was better camouflaged and more likely to survive and reproduce.

Bernard Kettlewell was the first to investigate the evolutionary mechanism behind peppered moth adaptation, between 1953 and 1956. He found that a light-coloured body was an effective camouflage in a clean environment, such as in rural Dorset, while the dark colour was beneficial in a polluted environment like industrial Birmingham. He used a technique known as mark-release-recapture, releasing hundreds of light and dark moths into woodland and attempting to recapture them two days later using light traps. In polluted woodland, a greater proportion of dark moths were recaptured compared to light moths, and vice versa in unpolluted woodland.

Kettlewell's hypothesis was proven correct, and his work supported the theory that British Peppered Moths had evolved by natural selection. In polluted areas, the dark form had outcompeted the light form because it was better camouflaged from predators. This was further supported by Brakefield's detailed experiments on the visual selection of predators and habitat selection of male and female peppered moths. The outcome of these interactions with predators was that close to the source of pollution, the carbonaria allele had an advantage.

The decline of carbonaria moths is linked to cleaner air

The carbonaria moth, also known as the peppered moth, has been a subject of interest for scientists studying evolution and natural selection. The moth's colouration changed from light to dark during the Industrial Revolution due to increased pollution, and this process has reversed since the introduction of clean air laws in the 1950s and 1960s. The decline in pollution has led to a decline in the frequency of the carbonaria morph of the moth.

The carbonaria moth is a dark-coloured or melanic form of the peppered moth (var. carbonaria). It was first recorded in 1811 and then again in Manchester, an industrial city in England, in 1848. At this time, the frequency of the variety was found to have increased drastically, coinciding with the industrialisation of the European economy. The pollution from coal-burning factories and plants killed the light-speckled lichens that grew on tree trunks, leaving the bark exposed and darkened with soot.

The light-coloured or typical form of the peppered moth was well-camouflaged against the light-coloured trees and lichens, but as the trees darkened due to pollution, they became easier to spot by birds, their primary predators. The dark-coloured carbonaria moth, on the other hand, blended in better with the darkened trees, giving them a higher survival rate. This is an example of industrial melanism, where the genetic darkening of a species occurs in response to pollutants.

However, with the introduction of clean air laws and improved environmental standards, pollution levels started to decrease in the areas where the peppered moth lives. As a result, the light-coloured form of the moth, which was once predominant, began to regain dominance. The decline in pollution has been accompanied by a decline in the frequency of the carbonaria morph, as measured by scientific studies conducted by Kettlewell in 1956, Bruce Grant in 1996, and L.M. Cook in 2003. This decline in the carbonaria moth population is linked to cleaner air and provides further evidence for natural selection and evolutionary theory.

Frequently asked questions