Sugarcane States: Polluting Our Environment?

Sugarcane production has had a significant impact on the environment, with some arguing it has had as great an impact as any other agricultural commodity. The industry's traditional farming methods contribute to soil degradation, water pollution, and high emissions, with certain sugarcane states being major culprits. Brazil, for instance, has seen its Atlantic Forest reduced to just 7% of its original size due to sugarcane farming. São Paulo, in particular, has experienced biodiversity loss and polluted waterways as a result of sugarcane production. Other regions, such as the Mekong Delta and the Amazon Forest, have also been negatively affected by the industry.

Deforestation and habitat loss

Sugarcane production has had a significant impact on the environment, with historic plantings leading to biodiversity loss and water pollution. Sugarcane is a water-intensive crop that remains in the soil all year round, impacting environmentally sensitive regions like the Mekong Delta and the Atlantic Forest.

Sugarcane farming has fuelled deforestation in some of the world's most threatened ecosystems. In Brazil, the Atlantic Forest, which once covered a vast area, has been reduced to just 7% of its original size due to sugarcane production. Between 2002 and 2012, 16.3 thousand square kilometres of forest was lost to sugarcane plantations in frontier counties, constituting 12.2% of deforestation in Brazil during that period. This resulted in an estimated 189.4 million Mg of carbon emissions.

The expansion of sugarcane plantations has also indirectly contributed to deforestation in the Amazon. Recent trends in decoupling soybean and sugarcane expansion from deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon have raised hopes for balancing environmental protection with crop production. However, the adverse effects of sugarcane expansion on forests can be mitigated through biofuel price adjustments to compensate for environmental costs, particularly carbon stock loss.

Indonesia is also facing a similar challenge, with the government planning to convert over 1 million hectares of tropical forest into sugarcane plantations in the name of national food security. This expansion will undermine Indonesia's goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and significantly alter the global environmental impact of sugarcane.

To address these issues, organisations like the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) have established initiatives such as Bonsucro (formerly known as the Better Sugar Cane Initiative) to reduce the environmental impact of sugarcane production. Bonsucro establishes global standards to certify sustainable production, with companies like The Coca-Cola Company committing to purchasing certified sugarcane.

Water pollution

Sugarcane is a water-intensive crop that remains in the soil all year long. As one of the world's thirstiest crops, it has a significant impact on many environmentally sensitive regions, such as the Mekong Delta and the Atlantic Forest. The historic and widespread planting of sugarcane has led to a significant impact on biodiversity and water pollution.

Sugarcane production often pollutes freshwater ecosystems with silt and fertilizers washed from farms, as well as plant matter and chemical sludge from mills. The large-scale processing of sugar crops releases pollutants into the water system, including heavy metals, toxic elements, and organic matter. Sugar mills produce wastewater, emissions, and solid waste that impact the environment. The massive quantities of plant matter and sludge washed from mills decompose in freshwater bodies, absorbing all the available oxygen and leading to massive fish kills.

In addition to the large volumes of wastewater, the sugar industry also generates solid waste and emissions that can further pollute water sources. The mill house wastewater is polluted mainly with oil and grease, while the wastewater from the process house contains high levels of organic matter. The presence of different pollutants in the effluent also poses a challenge for conventional treatment methods, and the inadequate treatment and disposal of effluents from sugarcane industries have resulted in extensive soil and water pollution.

Water quality concerns have prompted a reduction in sugarcane production in certain areas, with production intensified and expanded onto sandy soils. However, due to the ease of leaching in sandy soils, production can only be maintained over time with increasing applications of fertilizer, which can further contribute to water pollution.

There are efforts to reduce the environmental impact of sugarcane production, such as the Better Sugar Cane Initiative (BSI), now known as Bonsucro, which establishes global standards to certify sustainable production. Various treatment technologies have also been developed for sugarcane wastewater, including anaerobic digestion, enzymatic pretreatment, and fermentation. These initiatives and technologies aim to mitigate the water pollution associated with sugarcane production and promote more sustainable practices in the industry.

Soil degradation

Soil erosion is one of the critical land degradation processes in sugarcane farming. The intensive land use associated with sugarcane cultivation leads to compacted soils, reduced organic matter, and lower cation exchange capacity. Soil compaction and structural breakdown during harvesting and cultivation operations contribute to this degradation. The burning of crop residues further depletes organic matter, and the excessive use of nitrogen fertilizers causes soil acidification. These factors collectively undermine the environmental sustainability of sugarcane farming.

In regions like the Herbert Valley in North Queensland, sugarcane yields have been declining over the years due to soil degradation. Soil management practices play a crucial role in mitigating these issues. By implementing strategies to increase soil organic matter, reduce physical damage during harvesting, and improve fertilizing practices, it is possible to enhance soil health and reduce the environmental impact of sugarcane cultivation.

The impacts of sugarcane production on soil degradation extend beyond local ecosystems. Sugarcane farming has fueled deforestation in some of the world's most threatened ecosystems, such as Brazil's Atlantic Forest, which has been reduced to a fraction of its original size. The expansion of sugarcane cultivation to meet global demands threatens biodiversity in regions like the Mekong Delta. The intensive water requirements of sugarcane also impact environmentally sensitive regions.

To address these challenges, initiatives like the Better Sugar Cane Initiative (BSI), now known as Bonsucro, have been established. Bonsucro is a rigorous certification program that sets global standards for sustainable sugarcane production, aiming to reduce the social and environmental impacts of the industry. By encouraging better land-use practices and promoting sustainable production, these initiatives strive to balance the limitations and weaknesses of sugarcane cultivation with its potential benefits.

Climate change

Sugarcane is an important industrial crop used for sugar and bioenergy worldwide. It is the world's most widely produced cash crop, accounting for approximately 80% of global sugar production. Sugarcane is heavily reliant on specific temperature ranges and regular rainfall to grow. It thrives in temperatures ranging from 27°C to 32°C, with growth and sugar concentration peaking in these conditions. Additionally, it requires substantial rainfall, needing 1500 to 2500 litres of water to produce 1 kg of sugarcane.

Additionally, climate change has indirect effects on sugarcane production through changes in pest pressures, availability of pollination services, and other ecosystem services that influence agricultural productivity. The frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, such as droughts or floods, are also expected to increase due to climate change, further impacting sugarcane yields.

To mitigate the impact of climate change on sugarcane production, researchers have suggested developing and adopting new sugarcane varieties. Genetically modified sugarcane varieties have been shown to positively impact crop production. For example, in Brazil, genetically modified sugarcane varieties provided by RIDESA represented more than 60% of Brazilian sugarcane fields in 2020. However, some researchers argue that the expansion of sugarcane production through the occupation of natural areas via deforestation contributes to environmental and social issues, highlighting the complex nature of mitigating climate change while balancing food production needs.

Overall, climate change poses significant challenges to sugarcane production, and the development and implementation of effective adaptation and mitigation strategies are crucial to ensure the sustainability of this important global crop.

Loss of biodiversity

Sugarcane production has had a significant impact on biodiversity. The wholesale conversion of habitat on tropical islands and in coastal areas has led to considerable environmental damage, particularly the loss of biodiversity. Globally, 26 million hectares of land are used for sugarcane plantations, with Brazil being the top producer and exporter.

Brazil's Atlantic Forest, one of the most biodiverse regions on the planet, has been reduced to just 7% of its original size due to sugarcane farming. This has resulted in deforestation and the loss of critical habitats for numerous species. Similarly, the Amazon Forest, once a significant carbon sink, is now a carbon source due to deforestation caused by sugarcane production.

In São Paulo, the expansion of sugarcane production has resulted in biodiversity loss through forest fragmentation and polluted waterways. It has disrupted local ecosystems, leading to a surge in small rodent and capybara populations, which can be potential carriers of diseases transmissible to humans.

Sugarcane production often pollutes freshwater ecosystems with silt, fertilizers, plant matter, and chemical sludge from mills. These contaminants flow into the sea, damaging coral ecosystems such as the Great Barrier Reef and the Mesoamerican Reef. The industry's water-intensive nature impacts environmentally sensitive regions like the Mekong Delta and the Atlantic Forest.

Initiatives like Bonsucro, previously known as the Better Sugar Cane Initiative, aim to address these issues by establishing global standards for sustainable sugarcane production. Bonsucro seeks to reduce the environmental impact of sugarcane farming through innovative funding programmes, regenerative agriculture, and emissions reduction projects.

Frequently asked questions