Italy's Pollution Laws: Are They Effective?

Italy has a range of environmental laws and regulations in place to tackle pollution. The country's environmental policy is based on principles of sustainable development, prevention, precaution, and the polluter pays. The Ministry of Environment and Energy Security (MASE) plays an important role in environmental protection, alongside regional and local authorities. Italy has national targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions and specific laws to control air and water pollution, as well as waste management. For example, permits and licenses are required for operations that qualify as air polluters, and waste disposal is regulated according to the IPPC authorization or other regimes. Italy also has a national remediation programme for polluted areas, and it is one of the few countries to fund this through state funds rather than public-private partnerships.

Air pollution

Italy has several laws and regulations in place to combat air pollution. The country's environmental policy is based on principles of sustainable development, prevention, precaution, and the "polluter pays". These principles are codified in Legislative Decree no. 152/2006, which applies to public and private figures as well as lawmakers. The Ministry of Environment and Energy Security (MASE) plays an important role in environmental policy, and technical organisations such as the Institute for Environmental Protection and Research (ISPRA) provide technical surveys and assessments.

In terms of specific air pollution control legislation, Italy has the following measures in place:

• Legislative Decree, 4 March 2014, No. 46, which implements Directive 2010/75/EC on industrial emissions to prevent and mitigate pollution.
• Legislative Decree, 13 August 2010, No. 155 (the Framework Regulation on Air Pollution Control), as amended by Legislative Decree 2012, No. 250. This decree aims to establish and define environmental air quality standards to protect human health. It also identifies the authorities responsible for carrying out air quality assessments and drafting Restoration Plans in areas where limit values have been exceeded.
• Law, 12 December 2019, No. 141, converting Decree-Law, 14 October 2019, No. 111 (the Climate Decree), which develops a national strategic policy for improving air quality.

Despite these laws and regulations, Italy has been criticised for not doing enough to combat air pollution. In 2020, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that Italy had "systematically and persistently" breached EU rules on air pollution. The court found that Italy had failed to fulfil its obligations under a 2008 EU directive and had not taken appropriate measures to ensure that periods of exceedance of daily and annual limit values for PM10 were kept as short as possible.

To address these issues, northern cities like Milan and Turin introduced traffic restrictions in 2017 to improve air quality. Additionally, Italy has developed the Air Pollution Abatement (APA) system, which controls air quality in industrial sites, workplaces, urban spaces, commercial and residential areas. This system integrates intelligent environmental sensor monitoring systems, WiFi, IoT, AI solutions, and provides cloud-based real-time data.

Water pollution

Italy has a range of environmental protection laws and regulations in place to tackle water pollution. The country's environmental policy is based on the principles of sustainable development, prevention, precaution, and the "polluter pays" principle. The Italian Ministry of the Environment, or the authorities in the province or region where the business operates, issue the Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) authorisations, which are valid for 10-12 years. Sole Environmental Licenses are valid for 15 years and can be transferred without restrictions.

The Environmental Code, which includes provisions for water pollution, serves as the foundation for Italian environmental law. According to Articles 133 and 134 of the Environmental Code, administrative offences related to protecting water against pollution are outlined, while Article 137 details criminal offences. Additionally, any activity that involves a discharge requires a permit, as stated in Article 124, Paragraph 2, of the Environmental Code.

Italy imposes strict regulations for the disposal of wastewater. Urban wastewater, for instance, must be treated before discharge to prevent environmental pollution. The authorisation to discharge wastewater is issued by the province where the company or factory is located, and subsoil discharges are prohibited. Companies that do not comply with the regulatory regime for water pollution can face criminal and administrative sanctions, including imprisonment for discharging certain dangerous substances.

The country also has national targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, with factories, power plants, and other installations required to adhere to legal limits as per EU Directives. Italy is one of the few countries with a national remediation programme developed by the Ministry for Sites of National Interest, funded by state allocations. This programme has facilitated a transition from a purely tabular criterion to a mixed criterion for identifying contaminated sites.

Waste management

Italy's waste management strategies are designed to comply with stringent EU standards, focusing on waste reduction, sustainability, and circular economy principles. The country has implemented several waste disposal laws that regulate the treatment, recovery, and disposal of waste to protect the environment and public health. These laws include strict regulations on landfilling, particularly for hazardous waste, to prevent contamination of soil and water resources.

The Ronchi Decree is a pivotal piece of Italian legislation that regulates waste management. It establishes the foundations for waste collection, disposal, and recycling, in line with EU directives. Italy's waste management framework includes decrees and regulations that provide guidelines for waste management practices, standards for the collection, treatment, and disposal of various waste types, and measures to minimise waste production and promote the use of recycled materials.

Extended producer responsibility systems are also in place, identifying the producer's responsibilities in the organisation of recovery and recycling waste collection. These systems cover waste management costs and are regulated by specific legislation for each waste stream. Examples include regulations for packaging and packaging waste, end-of-life tyres, and waste electrical and electronic equipment.

The success of Italy's waste management policies relies on local implementation and public engagement, which can vary between regions. As a result, waste disposal laws and regulations can differ significantly across Italian regions, and knowledge of local waste disposal laws is essential for responsible waste management. Regions and Autonomous Provinces are responsible for authorising waste management, treatment, and disposal activities, with entities carrying out such activities required to obtain permits.

Illegal dumping, or the unauthorised disposal of waste in non-designated areas, poses serious risks to the environment and public health. Penalties for illegal dumping and non-compliance with waste management regulations are in place to ensure adherence to sustainable practices. These penalties include imprisonment and fines, with the severity varying depending on the presence of dangerous waste and the extent of unauthorised management.

Environmental restoration

Italy has a range of environmental protection laws and regulations in place, including those pertaining to air and water quality, industrial emissions, and waste management. The country's environmental policy is based on the principles of sustainable development, prevention, precaution, and the "polluter pays" principle. The "polluter pays" principle, enshrined in Legislative Decree no. 152/2006, holds that those responsible for environmental harm should bear the cost of remediation. This decree also establishes rules for the management and disposal of waste, including packaging, electronic waste, and end-of-life vehicles.

In Italy, environmental restoration and remediation measures for polluted areas are overseen by regional authorities, except for sites of national interest, which fall under the purview of the Ministry for Sites of National Interest. The Ministry of Environment and Energy Security (MASE) and the Institute for Environmental Protection and Research (ISPRA) also play crucial roles in environmental protection and restoration. ISPRA provides technical support to MASE and coordinates regional and provincial environmental agencies.

The Italian government has implemented several decrees to address specific environmental concerns. For example, the Climate Decree of 2019 establishes a national strategic policy for improving air quality. Additionally, the Legislative Decree of 2014 on industrial emissions aims to prevent and mitigate pollution, while the Framework Regulation on air pollution control seeks to establish environmental air quality standards to protect human health. These decrees outline the responsibilities of various authorities in conducting air quality assessments and drafting restoration plans for areas that exceed limit values.

Additionally, Italy has taken steps to address coastal environmental damage caused by oil spills, hazardous waste releases, and vessel groundings. The Office of Response and Restoration (OR&R) plays a crucial role in evaluating and restoring affected coastal and estuarine habitats, partnering with other organizations to create the Damage Assessment, Remediation, and Restoration Program (DARRP) to protect and restore marine natural resources.

Polluter pays principle

Italy's environmental policy is based on the "polluter pays" principle, which is codified in Legislative Decree no. 152/2006. This principle requires polluters to bear the environmental and social costs of their actions, including the costs of pollution prevention and remediation. It aims to ensure that the polluter, rather than society, pays for any damage caused to the natural environment.

The "polluter pays" principle is applied in Italy through specific schemes, such as extended producer responsibility (EPR) schemes, which are designed to shift the responsibility of waste disposal from the government and taxpayers to the entities producing the waste. These schemes are currently being reformed to adapt to Directive (EU) 851/2018. Non-compliance with obligations under the EPR schemes may result in sanctions.

The "polluter pays" principle also underpins environmental policies such as ecotaxes, which are intended to deter and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Italy has implemented various regulations to improve air and water quality, prevent and mitigate industrial emissions, and establish environmental air quality standards to protect human health. These regulations include the Climate Decree, the Legislative Decree on industrial emissions, and the Framework Regulation on air pollution control.

The Ministry of Environment and Energy Security (MASE) plays an important role in administering and enforcing environmental laws in Italy. Technical organizations, such as the Institute for Environmental Protection and Research (ISPRA), also provide support to MASE and coordinate regional and provincial environment agencies.

Overall, the "polluter pays" principle is a fundamental aspect of Italy's environmental policy and is applied through various legislative measures and regulations to ensure that polluters are held responsible for the environmental and social impacts of their actions.

Frequently asked questions