Air Purifiers: One Size Doesn't Fit All

Air purifiers are a great way to improve indoor air quality and remove pollutants from the air. However, not all air purifiers are created equal, and different types of air purifiers are more effective at targeting specific pollutants. For example, High Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) filters are effective at removing fine particles like dust, pollen, and smoke, while carbon filters are better at absorbing volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Other factors such as the size of the room and the specific needs of the user also play a role in determining the best air purifier for a particular space. This article will explore the different types of air purifiers available and how they can be used to address specific pollutants and improve indoor air quality.

HEPA filters are effective at removing ultra-fine particles, such as dust, dander, pollen, and mould

HEPA stands for High-Efficiency Particulate Air. HEPA filters are mechanical air filters that work by forcing air through a fine mesh that traps harmful particles. They are considered the safest type of air purifier for home use.

HEPA filters are effective at removing dust, dander, pollen, and mould. They can remove at least 99.97% of dust, pollen, and any airborne particles with a size of 0.3 microns. Particles that are larger or smaller are trapped with even higher efficiency. They are also effective at removing mould spores, which can affect the quality of indoor air.

HEPA filters are commonly used to help with allergies and asthma. They can be found in most air purifiers and are recommended for use in bedrooms, as they do not emit ozone but do remove particulate matter from the air. The EPA has reported statistically significant improvements in respiratory health and allergy or asthma symptoms in research reviews.

HEPA filters can be used as part of a plan to remove irritating particles from the home. They are also available in vacuum cleaners, which can help to reduce the amount of dirt and dust mites that are thrown back into the room during vacuuming.

Electronic air purifiers can produce ozone gas and other pollutants that may be hazardous to health

Air purifiers are a great way to improve indoor air quality and reduce health issues caused by air pollution, such as stroke, heart disease, COPD, and lung cancer. However, it is important to choose the right type of air purifier as some can be hazardous to health.

Electronic air purifiers, including ionizers, electrostatic precipitators, hydroxyl generators, and UV light, use electric voltage to convert oxygen molecules and other species into charged ionic components. While these purifiers can be effective in removing certain contaminants, they can also produce ozone gas and other pollutants that may be harmful to health. Ozone is a lung irritant and can cause free-radical formation in biological systems, damaging tissues.

Ozone-generating air cleaners use ozone to chemically alter the compounds of pollutants, but this mechanism can also lead to harmful health effects. If the ozone concentration is high enough to effectively clean the air, it poses an inhalation hazard for occupants in the room. Additionally, ozone can react with existing chemicals in the air to create harmful by-products, such as formaldehyde and ultrafine particles. These by-products can be toxic and further contribute to indoor air pollution.

Health professionals have refuted the claims that ozone generators are safe and effective for indoor air purification. The California Air Resources Board (CARB) strongly advises against using ozone generators in spaces occupied by people or animals, and other governmental agencies support this recommendation. While ozone can be effective in water purification, its chemistry in air is different and can have adverse effects on indoor plants, as well as damage certain materials.

To ensure the safe use of air purifiers, it is recommended to choose filtered air purifiers or those with High-Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) filters, which do not emit ozone. Additionally, proper ventilation and source control are important strategies to mitigate indoor air pollution. Increasing ventilation by opening windows and maintaining HVAC systems can dilute and exhaust pollutants. Source control involves eliminating or controlling the sources of pollution, such as regular cleaning to prevent dust accumulation.

Air purifiers can help reduce allergic symptoms and lessen triggers of asthma symptoms

Air purifiers can be an effective strategy to improve indoor air quality. They can help reduce allergic symptoms and lessen triggers of asthma symptoms.

Air purifiers work by filtering and trapping pollutants from the air inside your home. They can also sanitise the air that comes through them. There are different types of air purifiers, each with its own mechanism for cleaning the air. Filtered air purifiers capture airborne pollutants and trap them in one or more filters. Electrostatic air purifiers create charged particles to trap particles in a filter. UV light air purifiers use UV light to target certain contaminants, such as viruses and bacteria.

When it comes to allergies and asthma, air purifiers can be beneficial. For allergies, air purifiers can reduce the allergen load in your indoor air. This includes common allergens such as dust, pet dander, pollen, and mould spores. For example, HEPA filters can remove up to 99.97% of dust, pollen, and airborne particles as small as 0.3 microns, effectively helping to eliminate pet dander. Additionally, carbon filters can passively absorb volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from the air.

For asthma, air purifiers can lessen triggers by reducing contaminants like dust, smoke, and pollen. Portable HEPA air purifiers, in particular, have been shown to benefit asthma symptoms. A 2016 review found that they could reduce particles in the air by 25-50% and decrease asthma symptoms and attacks. However, it's important to note that air purifiers may not be effective against gaseous pollutants or the gas pollutants in tobacco smoke.

While air purifiers can be helpful, it's essential to choose the right type and ensure proper maintenance. The EPA recommends using air purifiers with high-efficiency filters, such as HEPA filters. Additionally, regular cleaning and upkeep are necessary to maintain the effectiveness of air purifiers. It's also worth noting that a combination of strategies, such as regular cleaning, eliminating mould and pests, and increasing ventilation, may be more effective in managing asthma and allergy symptoms.

Air purifiers are not very effective at removing volatile gases or vapours

Air purifiers are indeed effective at removing certain pollutants from the air, but their effectiveness varies depending on the type of pollutant and the specific air purifier used. While some air purifiers can help reduce volatile organic compounds (VOCs), others may not be equipped to handle these gaseous pollutants effectively.

VOCs are a group of chemicals primarily composed of carbon that can easily evaporate into the air at room temperature. They can be human-made, such as those used in pharmaceuticals, paints, and refrigerants, or naturally occurring, like pleasant plant-based smells. Unfortunately, seemingly "clean" indoor air can have VOC levels that are significantly higher than outdoor air. As a result, exposure to these toxic compounds can lead to adverse health effects, including headaches, throat irritation, and even kidney and liver damage.

To effectively remove VOCs, carbon filters or PECO (Photo Electrochemical Oxidation) air purifiers are recommended. Carbon filters, such as activated charcoal, use adsorption to attract pollutants to stick to the outside of the tiny carbon particles. This process ensures that the pollutants are not released back into the air due to filter saturation or changes in temperature and humidity. On the other hand, PECO technology, as seen in the Molekule air purifier, destroys VOCs passing through the filter rather than merely collecting them. This technology has been independently verified by the University of Minnesota Particle Calibration Laboratory.

However, not all air purifiers are created equal when it comes to VOC removal. HEPA filters, for example, are popular and effective at removing particulate matter but are unable to clear gases and chemicals from the air. Similarly, electrostatic air purifiers can capture particulates like solid particles and liquid droplets using an electrically charged screen but are ineffective against gaseous molecules like VOCs. Ozone generators, another type of air purifier, actively release ozone (a form of oxygen with an extra atom attached) to alter pollutant compounds. However, ozone itself is harmful to human health, and while it can kill biological cells, it is not effective at removing VOCs from the air.

In summary, while air purifiers can be beneficial for improving indoor air quality, not all of them are equally effective at removing volatile gases or vapours, specifically VOCs. To address this specific concern, it is essential to select air purifiers with carbon filters or PECO technology, which have been specifically designed to remove gaseous pollutants.

Air purifiers work best in conjunction with other pollutant-reducing measures, such as proper ventilation

Air purifiers are designed to improve indoor air quality by removing airborne pollutants and allergens. While they can be effective, their performance in real-life settings is often less impressive than in laboratory tests. This is due to the turbulence they create, which can stir up dust and other particles that then accumulate again.

To ensure the best performance from an air purifier, it should be used in conjunction with other measures to reduce pollutants. For example, proper ventilation is key to maintaining good indoor air quality. Opening windows and maintaining HVAC systems can help to dilute and exhaust pollutants.

It is also important to address the source of indoor air pollution. Regular cleaning can prevent dust accumulation, for example. Choosing the right type of air purifier is another important consideration. Portable air purifiers can be a good supplement to ventilation, but they are the least effective way to clean the air. Electronic air cleaners, such as ionizers, and ozone-generators are not recommended due to health and safety concerns. Ozone is a lung irritant and can be hazardous at high concentrations.

Filtered air purifiers are considered the safest type for home use. HEPA filters are particularly effective at removing ultra-fine particles, such as dust, dander, pollen, and mold. They can also reduce gaseous pollutants, though studies on their effectiveness are limited and inconsistent. To address volatile organic compounds (VOCs), carbon filters can be used to absorb them, and the Austin Air HealthMate HM400 is recommended.

Air purifiers can be beneficial for those with allergies, asthma, and other respiratory conditions. They can reduce allergic symptoms and triggers for asthma attacks, such as dust, smoke, and pollen. However, it is important to note that the benefits may be small and may not be solely due to the use of air purifiers.

Frequently asked questions