Pennsylvania's Air Pollution Problem: Is It The Worst?

Pennsylvania, the fifth most populous state in the US, is home to over 12.8 million people and a significant industrial presence. The state has a large agricultural sector and is involved in steel production, paints and other household materials, and food products. With so many different industrial activities and a large population, Pennsylvania's air quality is affected by a wide range of sources, pushing it to the top of the list of the most polluted states in America. In 2023, Central Pennsylvania was named the 8th most polluted area in the US, with York, Lebanon, Lancaster, Harrisburg, and Carlisle as polluted hotspots.

Canadian wildfires cause poor air quality in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania has been facing severe air pollution, with Central Pennsylvania being named the 8th most polluted area in the United States, according to a 2023 report. The primary cause of this poor air quality has been the ongoing Canadian wildfires, which have led to multiple Code Red air quality alerts being issued across the state.

The smoke from the Canadian wildfires has blanketed Pennsylvania, degrading air quality not just in the state but across other states in the northeast as well. The Delaware Valley, in particular, has witnessed the worst of this haze, with air quality alerts remaining in effect even as the smoke began to clear. The state Department of Environmental Protection noted that while conditions were expected to improve, Code Red conditions persisted in most of Pennsylvania.

The Code Red alert indicates that air pollution concentrations are unhealthy for the general population, and outdoor activities are advised to be avoided. The Air Quality Index (AQI) rates air pollution on a scale of 0 to 500, with lower numbers indicating cleaner air. The AQI is also colour-coded, with green representing healthy air quality, yellow being acceptable, orange affecting sensitive groups, and red indicating potential health effects for everyone. During the Canadian wildfires, some places in Pennsylvania reached even more dangerous purple and maroon levels.

The wildfires have brought into sharp focus the existing air quality health concerns in Pennsylvania. Experts believe that the current conditions could be a preview of the consequences of severe air pollution levels. Rob Altenburg, the senior director for Energy and Climate with PennFuture, highlighted the contribution of various industries, transportation, and a large population to air pollution in Central Pennsylvania. He emphasized the need for policies and collective will to address this issue.

As the world continues to grapple with the impacts of climate change, including more frequent and intense wildfires, it is crucial for residents to stay informed about air quality conditions and take necessary precautions to safeguard their health.

Pennsylvania's industrial activities and transport contribute to air pollution

Pennsylvania is one of the largest sources of greenhouse gases in the US, including carbon dioxide and methane, most of which come from the burning of fossil fuels. The state is home to various industrial activities, such as steel production, and has a significant presence in sectors such as paints, household materials, and food products. It also has a sizeable agricultural industry. With over 12.8 million residents, there is a significant anthropogenic movement and a large number of vehicles on the roads, all of which contribute to air pollution.

Industrial facilities, power plants, and mines are the biggest sources of climate pollution in Pennsylvania. In 2020, industrial facilities were responsible for 76.9 million metric tons of greenhouse gases, accounting for 31% of the state's total emissions. Just 12 industrial facilities, power plants, and mines, known as Pennsylvania's "Dirty Dozen", contribute to nearly one-fifth of the state's total climate pollution. The Pittsburgh area, home to more than half of these "Dirty Dozen" facilities, ranks 14th worst in the country for year-round emissions of particulate pollution.

Southwestern Pennsylvania, including the Pittsburgh region, accounted for 44% of greenhouse gas emissions reported by large polluters in 2021. This region had the largest share of any Pennsylvania region and is home to the greatest number of facilities reporting their emissions to the EPA. Industrial facilities, including power plants, often utilise their own fossil fuels, such as coal, which can lead to large-scale pollution when combusted for energy. During colder months, increased energy consumption for heating can lead to greater coal consumption and, consequently, more pollution.

Vehicle emissions and exhaust fumes from Pennsylvania's large population of cars, motorbikes, buses, and trucks also contribute significantly to air pollution. These vehicles release chemical compounds and hazardous particulate matter that can irritate the respiratory tract and lung tissue and have carcinogenic effects on those exposed, particularly those living near industrial areas or busy roads. The transportation industry, including the trucking industry, is a significant contributor to air pollution in Central Pennsylvania, which has been named one of the worst areas in the country for air pollution.

Air pollution in Central Pennsylvania is among the worst in the US

The state's air quality has been impacted by several factors, including emissions and exhaust fumes from vehicles, a large population of over 12.8 million people, and its proximity to other states and Canada. The state's industrial activities, such as steel production, transportation, and agriculture, also contribute to the elevated levels of pollution.

In June 2023, Pennsylvania was affected by smoke from Canadian wildfires, which degraded air quality across the state. The state Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) declared a Code Red Air Quality Action Day, and the air quality index in Lebanon and York counties reached 457, one of the highest levels on the scale of 0 to 500. The hazardous air pollution led to advisories for people to avoid outdoor activities and stay indoors, particularly for those sensitive to air pollution.

Experts attribute the poor air quality in central Pennsylvania to various factors that also make the region attractive to businesses, such as the trucking and transportation industries and a large population. Rob Altenburg, senior director for Energy and Climate with PennFuture, stated that there is a need for policies and action to address the pollution issue. Dr. Rizzo advised residents to stay informed about air quality conditions and take safety precautions when necessary, such as minimizing time spent outdoors during periods of poor air quality.

Pennsylvania's air quality is rated as 'moderate' to ''poor'

Pennsylvania's air quality has been rated as moderate to poor, with the state being named one of the worst areas in the country for air pollution. The central region of the state, including the cities of York, Lebanon, Lancaster, Harrisburg, and Carlisle, has been identified as a polluted hotspot. The air quality in these areas has been described as "dangerous" and "some of the worst ever", with the Air Quality Index (AQI) reaching levels that can impact the health of even those without sensitivities.

The primary contributors to Pennsylvania's poor air quality are emissions and exhaust fumes from vehicles, as well as industrial activities. With a population of over 12.8 million people, there are a significant number of cars, motorbikes, and industrial operations contributing to the state's air pollution. Additionally, the state's proximity to other highly populated states and the province of Ontario, Canada, further exacerbates the issue.

The impact of poor air quality on the health of Pennsylvanians has become an increasing concern. During periods of high pollution, individuals are advised to minimize their time outdoors, and those who are sensitive to air pollution are recommended to stay indoors. The state has also seen cancellations of outdoor activities, field trips, and sporting events due to the hazardous air conditions.

While Pennsylvania faces challenges in improving its air quality, there is recognition that policies and collective efforts can make a difference. Experts emphasize the importance of staying aware of current air quality conditions and adhering to safety precautions. With the right measures in place, there is optimism that Pennsylvania can reduce its air pollution levels and improve the living conditions for its citizens.

Nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide are prominent pollutants in Pennsylvania

Nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide are prominent air pollutants in Pennsylvania. The state's air quality has been a growing concern, with Central Pennsylvania named the 8th most polluted area in the United States in 2023. The region, including cities like York, Harrisburg, and Lancaster, has faced challenges due to factors contributing to air pollution, such as the trucking and transportation industries.

Nitrogen dioxide (NO2), a reddish-brown gas, is a highly toxic pollutant formed through the oxidation of nitric oxide (NO). It is emitted primarily from the combustion of fuels in stationary sources, such as industrial processes, and transportation sources, including motor vehicles. NO2 can cause an odorous, brown haze, irritate the eyes and nose, reduce visibility, and contribute to acidic rain. It also plays a key role in nitrogen loading in forests and ecosystems and has been linked to adverse health effects, particularly for those with respiratory diseases.

Sulfur dioxide (SO2) is another significant pollutant in Pennsylvania. While sulfur dioxide itself is not mentioned specifically in the context of Pennsylvania, it is classified as a prominent air pollutant by the World Health Organization (WHO), which is a global authority on health matters. Sulfur dioxide is typically emitted directly into the atmosphere during industrial processes, forming primary sulfates. It can also be formed in the atmosphere from other sulfur-containing compounds through photochemical processes, resulting in secondary sulfates. High sulfate levels have been correlated with increased absences from work and school due to illness. Additionally, sulfates contribute to reduced visibility and the formation of acid rain.

The presence of these pollutants, particularly nitrogen dioxide, in Pennsylvania's air has led to concerns about respiratory health and overall air quality. Efforts to improve air quality and reduce emissions of these pollutants are ongoing, with experts advocating for policy changes and increased awareness of current air quality conditions to ensure the well-being of Pennsylvania's residents.

Frequently asked questions