Indigenous Plight: Polluted Water, A Human Rights Issue

Indigenous communities in Canada, known as First Nations, have been facing a water crisis for generations. This is due to a multitude of factors, including a lack of binding water quality regulations, erratic and insufficient funding, faulty or sub-standard infrastructure, and degraded source waters. The water in these communities is often tainted by parasites, bacteria, and toxic heavy metals, which has led to a number of water-borne diseases and skin issues. The federal government has a responsibility to provide funding and oversee water management in these communities, but there is often a lack of urgency in solving the problem. As a result, Indigenous leaders have launched lawsuits against the government, demanding access to clean water and compensation for the impacts of water insecurity on their communities.

Inadequate government funding and support

The vast geography of Canada and the remote locations of many Indigenous communities make setting up water treatment infrastructure a logistical challenge. However, the government's failure to provide adequate funding has exacerbated this issue. For example, in Manitoba, plans for a water treatment plant in Shoal Lake 40 were scrapped in 2011 due to the federal government balking at the cost. As a result, the community has been under a water advisory since 1997.

The lack of funding has also contributed to a regulatory void and a lack of resources to support water management. This has led to a situation where Indigenous communities are disproportionately affected by drinking water advisories and are subjected to these advisories for longer periods than non-Indigenous communities. The federal government's focus on long-term advisories as a measure of water security has been criticized as faulty, as it does not capture the broader impacts of a lack of clean, safe running water on people's health and well-being.

The water crisis has had significant health consequences for Indigenous communities. The number of water-borne diseases in these communities is 26 times higher than the national average, and people living on reserves are 90 times more likely to have no access to running water. The lack of clean water also impacts traditional practices, such as hunting and fishing, as pollutants can make fish unsafe to eat.

The federal government has made some efforts to address the water crisis, such as earmarking $1.5 billion for water management in 2020. However, there is still a long way to go to ensure that Indigenous communities have access to clean, safe drinking water. The government's failure to adequately address this issue has led to lawsuits and criticism from Indigenous leaders and human rights organizations.

Poor infrastructure and water treatment

Indigenous communities in Canada have struggled with access to clean water for generations. This is due to a variety of factors, including poor infrastructure and water treatment.

Many Indigenous communities in Canada rely on outdated and deteriorating infrastructure, which leads to water insecurity. In some cases, the infrastructure is so old that it is considered crumbling. This aging infrastructure is unable to effectively treat, store, or distribute potable water. As a result, many communities are forced to rely on alternative sources of water, such as bottled water or community water stations.

The lack of proper water treatment infrastructure has led to water contamination in Indigenous communities. In some cases, the water is tainted by parasites and bacteria that occur naturally. In other cases, it is impacted by pollutants from industries and growing municipalities. For example, the community of Grassy Narrows struggles with a legacy of toxic heavy metals due to negligent industry.

Inadequate water treatment infrastructure also impacts the ability of Indigenous communities to maintain their traditional practices. For instance, hunters and trappers cannot stay out on the land for extended periods without access to safe drinking water. Additionally, pollutants can make fish harmful to eat, further disrupting cultural practices and food sources.

The Canadian government has made some efforts to address these issues. In 2016, the Trudeau government announced significant funding to address failing infrastructure in Indigenous communities, including water and wastewater systems. However, financial investment alone is not enough. Proper monitoring, maintenance, and regulation are also critical to ensuring safe water access.

While there have been some improvements, Indigenous communities in Canada continue to face challenges when it comes to water infrastructure and treatment. These issues have resulted in unsafe drinking water, health problems, and disruptions to cultural practices. It is essential that the government and relevant institutions work collaboratively to find long-lasting solutions and ensure that all communities have access to clean and safe water.

Lack of community control and consultation

The water crisis in Indigenous communities in Canada, also known as First Nations, is a complex issue with far-reaching consequences. One of the key factors contributing to this crisis is the lack of community control and consultation, which has resulted in polluted water sources and inadequate water treatment infrastructure.

Colonial-era laws have historically barred Indigenous communities from funding and managing their water treatment systems, with the federal government bearing responsibility for fixing any problems. This lack of autonomy has led to a disconnect between the needs of these communities and the actions taken by the government. As a result, First Nations communities have faced challenges in accessing safe and clean drinking water, with some being forced to boil their water for decades.

The federal government's audits over two decades have revealed a pattern of overpromising and underperforming on water and sanitation for reserves. This is evident in the case of the Shoal Lake 40 community, which had a boil-water advisory in place for 24 years since 1997. Additionally, the government has failed to address the issue of contaminated water sources, which has impacted the health and well-being of First Nations people. For example, the Neskantaga First Nation in northern Ontario has dealt with an oily sheen on their reservoir, leaving the community without access to running water and requiring evacuation.

The lack of community control and consultation also extends to the protection of water sources. First Nations leaders have consistently raised concerns about the lack of consultation regarding commercial activities that impact their traditional territories and water sources. Industries and growing municipalities have contributed to the deterioration of lakes, rivers, and streams, which are essential for the cultural and spiritual practices of these communities.

To address these issues, greater control and self-determination for First Nations communities over their water sources and treatment systems are necessary. This includes ensuring adequate funding, addressing regulatory voids, and providing the necessary resources for water management. By empowering these communities to take ownership of their water-related challenges, Canada can begin to reconcile and close the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities in terms of access to safe and clean water.

Industrial and municipal pollutants

Indigenous communities around the world, particularly in Canada and Australia, have been facing a water crisis for decades. In Canada, despite the country possessing the world's third-largest freshwater reserves, many Indigenous communities are not supplied with clean and safe drinking water. This is due to a variety of factors, including the marginalization of these communities, contamination of water sources, their remote locations, and the lack of proper maintenance of water systems.

One of the main reasons for the polluted water in Indigenous communities is industrial and municipal pollutants. These communities often have their waterways and lands polluted by effluence from major corporations and growing municipalities. For example, in Grassy Narrows, a chemical plant dumped approximately ten tons of toxic mercury into a river upstream from the community, resulting in over half a decade of unsafe water and ecological damage. Other toxic heavy metals, such as arsenic, lead, and uranium, have also been found in the drinking water of Indigenous communities, posing significant health risks.

In addition to chemical pollutants, Indigenous communities' water sources are also contaminated by microbial pathogens, including viruses, bacteria, and parasites. This has led to an increased incidence of gastrointestinal infections and other waterborne diseases in these communities. The lack of binding water quality regulations and insufficient funding for water treatment infrastructure further exacerbates the problem.

The remote locations of many Indigenous communities also contribute to the difficulty in accessing clean water. It is more costly to maintain water systems in these areas, and they often lack the necessary equipment or transportation to ensure the safety of their water sources. Additionally, colonial-era laws have barred Indigenous communities from funding and managing their water treatment systems, relying instead on the federal government, which has a history of overpromising and underperforming on this issue.

The water crisis in Indigenous communities has resulted in a range of health issues, including skin diseases, iodine deficiency, and potential links to higher rates of infant mortality, birth defects, developmental problems, and cancers. It has also impacted traditional practices, such as hunting and fishing, as pollutants can make fish unsafe to eat, and limited water access disrupts cultural events.

Overall, the polluted water in Indigenous communities is a complex issue rooted in historical injustices, systemic racism, and environmental negligence. It is a violation of human rights, as recognized by the United Nations, and requires urgent attention and sustainable solutions.

Water-related illnesses and health issues

Waterborne Diseases and Infections

The number of waterborne diseases in Indigenous communities is significantly higher than the national average. For instance, the gastrointestinal infection H. pylori has been detected in community members, and while it may not be directly caused by poor water quality, the lack of access to running water and inadequate housing can increase the risk of contracting such infections. Another example is MRSA, an antibiotic-resistant infection prevalent among Indigenous people due to overcrowding and insufficient running water.

Contaminated Water Sources

The water sources for Indigenous communities are often contaminated due to pollutants from industries and growing municipalities. This not only affects the drinking water but also impacts traditional practices like hunting and fishing, as pollutants can make fish unsafe for consumption. The contamination of water sources also disrupts the spiritual and cultural relationship that Indigenous communities have with water, as recognised by the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP).

Lack of Access to Clean Water

Indigenous communities often lack access to clean, safe drinking water, forcing them to rely on alternative sources. For example, some households use private wells or wastewater systems, which can be even more precarious than public water systems. In some cases, communities have to boil their drinking water, which can lead to mould and housing deterioration, causing overcrowding and further health risks.

Inadequate Infrastructure and Funding

The infrastructure in place to provide clean water is often faulty or sub-standard. This includes issues with water treatment plants and purification processes, which can sometimes result in unsafe water due to reactions between organic material and purification chemicals. Additionally, there is erratic and insufficient funding for the maintenance and operation of drinking water systems, with a deficit of up to $138 million per year identified by the Parliamentary Budget Officer.

Health Disparities and Data Gaps

The lack of clean water contributes to significant health disparities between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities. Indigenous people are subjected to drinking water advisories for longer periods and are more likely to lack access to running water. Furthermore, governments are not effectively tracking or studying water-related illnesses in these communities, leading to a lack of data and understanding of the full scope of the issue.

Frequently asked questions