Global Diesel Pollution Standards: Who Leads?

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in the United States has been regulating emissions standards since 1963, with a focus on pollutants released by automobiles and other vehicles. Over time, these standards have become more stringent, targeting not only vehicles but also the fuels they use, such as diesel. While the EPA sets the standards, states must also implement their own regulations to comply with the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS). California, for example, has the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to enforce even stricter air quality standards than the EPA. Other countries, such as India, China, and Japan, have also implemented vehicle emissions standards, often derived from European requirements, to address air quality issues caused by growing vehicle fleets.

The US's Clean Air Act

The Clean Air Act (CAA) is a federal law in the United States that was passed in 1970 and later amended to prevent air pollution, protect the ozone layer, and promote public health. The Act gave the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) the authority to take effective measures to combat environmental pollution.

The Clean Air Act is the primary law governing the DOE's air pollution control activities and is the most influential air quality law in the US. It requires compliance throughout the country and has led to a 62% reduction in air pollution, resulting in healthier and longer lives for Americans. The Act has added an estimated 1.5 years to the life expectancy of the average American.

The EPA, established under the CAA, set the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to regulate six pollutants that pose a threat to public health: sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, particulate matter, carbon monoxide, ground-level ozone, and lead. All states, cities, and towns in the US must maintain pollutant levels below the NAAQS-mandated thresholds or face substantial fines and penalties. The NAAQS also formed the basis for the online air quality index (AQI), which informs the public about the air quality in their area.

To address mobile source pollution, the EPA has set standards for specific pollutants emitted by on-road vehicles and non-road engines and equipment, including carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter. The EPA also collaborates with fuel manufacturers to establish sulfur standards for on-road and non-road diesel fuel to reduce pollution from these sources.

Additionally, the California Air Resources Board (CARB), which enforces the country's most protective air quality regulations, can adopt and enforce its own emission standards under the CAA. CARB-approved active diesel particulate filters (DPFs) can remove up to 95% of diesel particulate matter, helping diesel engines achieve compliance without sacrificing performance.

California's Air Resources Board

The California Air Resources Board (CARB) is a department within the California Environmental Protection Agency, established in 1967 by then-governor Ronald Reagan. CARB is responsible for implementing California's policies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases and air pollutants. California is the only state permitted to issue its own emissions standards under the federal Clean Air Act.

CARB's stated goals include achieving and maintaining healthy air quality, protecting the public from toxic air contaminants, and providing innovative approaches to complying with air pollution rules and regulations. The organization has been instrumental in driving innovation in the global automotive industry, particularly through its Zero-Emission Vehicle (ZEV) mandate.

One of CARB's notable initiatives is the Low-Emission Vehicle (LEV) Program, first adopted in 1990 to address smog-forming pollutants from automobiles sold in California. This program was later amended to LEV II in 1999, covering vehicles from 2004 to 2014. CARB also enforces regulations for off-highway motor vehicles (OHVs), with a Green Sticker indicating a vehicle has passed emission requirements, and a Red Sticker restricting OHV use due to non-compliance.

Additionally, CARB's Commercial Harbor Craft regulation targets emissions from commercial vessels, particularly diesel-powered ones operating in California's harbors and ports. This regulation has led to vessel owners replacing their engines or sending their boats out of state. CARB also enforces indoor air quality standards, requiring all portable indoor air cleaning devices sold in California to be certified by meeting specific ozone emission concentration limits.

CARB plays a crucial role in California's fight against air pollution and climate change, promoting and protecting public health, welfare, and ecological resources. The organization's efforts have contributed to California's success in decoupling greenhouse gas emissions from economic growth, achieving emission reduction targets ahead of schedule.

Europe's Euro VI standards

The European Union has been implementing increasingly stringent vehicle emission standards since the early 1970s, with the first EU-wide standard, Euro 1, introduced in 1992. Euro VI is the latest iteration of these standards, which have progressively reduced the acceptable limits of exhaust emissions from new vehicles sold in the EU. The Euro VI standards are different from the previous Euro V standards in terms of the certification test cycle, making direct comparisons between the two challenging.

Euro VI standards are not limited to exhaust emissions but also include regulations for on-board computer diagnostics to improve driver safety. These standards are mandatory and must be met by all new vehicles sold in the EU. The legal framework for the Euro VI standards consists of a series of directives, each amending the 1970 Directive 70/220/EEC. The Euro VI standards were introduced in September 2014 for new type approvals and were rolled out for the majority of vehicle sales and registrations in September 2015.

Euro VI standards have had a significant impact on the automotive industry, with manufacturers developing new technologies to comply with the regulations. For example, exhaust after-treatment systems have emerged as a breakthrough technology, effectively reducing emissions and improving air quality. The Euro VI standards also highlight the importance of fleet renewal, encouraging the adoption of more environmentally friendly vehicles and technologies.

Overall, Europe's Euro VI standards are a crucial component of the region's efforts to improve air quality and reduce emissions from road vehicles. By setting stringent emission limits and promoting innovative technologies, these standards contribute to a more sustainable and environmentally conscious transportation sector in Europe.

India's Bharat stage emission standards

The initial BSI (BS1) standard was introduced in mid-1999, followed by BSII in mid-2000 and BSIII in 2005. BSIV was introduced in 2017, and the delay between BSIII and BSIV led to the fast-tracking of BSVI (skipping BSV). Each new regulation has stricter emission standards than its predecessor. For instance, the BSIV norms mandated that all new vehicles be equipped with catalytic converters and use unleaded petrol.

In 2016, the Indian government announced that the country would skip the BS-V norms and adopt BS-VI norms by 2020. The Petroleum Ministry of India, in consultation with public oil marketing companies, decided to implement BS-VI grade auto fuels in the National Capital Territory of Delhi from 1 April 2018, two years ahead of schedule, due to the heavy air pollution problem in the city. The Supreme Court also banned the sale and registration of motor vehicles conforming to the BS-IV emission standard across India from 1 April 2020.

The National Auto Fuel Policy, announced in 2003, created guidelines for auto fuels, the reduction of pollution from older vehicles, and research and development for air quality data and health administration. The policy set out a roadmap for the implementation of Bharat Stage norms until 2010 and introduced emission requirements for interstate buses with routes originating or terminating in Delhi or ten other cities. The Bharat Stage norms also apply to all new four-wheeled vehicles sold and registered in the respective regions.

Japan, Canada, Australia and Europe's 1970s standards

In the 1970s, Europe began implementing increasingly stringent vehicle emission standards for pollution from new land surface vehicles and ships in EU waters. These standards, defined in a series of EU directives, aimed to reduce emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx), total hydrocarbons (THC), non-methane hydrocarbons (NMHC), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter (PM) from cars, trucks, locomotives, tractors, and barges.

Japan's diesel air pollution standards have undergone significant changes over time. While the country introduced its first engine emissions standards for on-road light-duty vehicles and heavy-duty engines in the late 1980s, these standards remained relaxed during the 1990s. However, in 2003, Japan's Ministry of the Environment (MOE) finalized stringent emission standards for 2005, which, at that time, were the strictest diesel emission regulations globally for heavy-duty vehicles. These standards were further tightened in 2009 to a level between the US 2010 and Euro V requirements, and the 2016 limits were comparable to the US 2010 and Euro VI standards.

Canada has also implemented measures to address air pollution from diesel-powered machines, but the specific standards and regulations were not readily available from the given sources.

In Australia, each level of government, including Australian, state, territory, and local, plays a role in managing air pollution. The Australian federal government works with state and territory governments to set national objectives for air quality and emissions through National Environment Protection Measures (NEPMs). The Ministerial Forum on Vehicle Emissions, established in 2015, is considering adopting Euro 6/VI noxious emissions standards and revised fuel quality standards based on European benchmarks.

While specific comparisons between these countries' diesel air pollution standards are challenging to find, it appears that Japan introduced particularly stringent standards in 2003 and 2005, which, at those times, were the strictest globally. Europe has also consistently aimed to reduce emissions through progressive standards, and Australia is considering aligning more closely with European benchmarks.

Frequently asked questions