Students, Teachers, Or Staff: Who Pollutes School Air?

Air pollution in schools is a pressing issue that can have detrimental effects on the health and academic performance of children. Children are more susceptible to the harmful impacts of air pollution due to their developing bodies and higher breathing rates. Various factors contribute to air pollution in schools, including outdoor sources such as nearby busy roads and school commutes, as well as indoor sources like building materials, paints, and classroom equipment. The impact of air pollution in schools is further exacerbated by overcrowded classrooms, inadequate ventilation, and exposure to allergens. Addressing these issues is crucial to protect children's health and create a conducive learning environment.

School location: Schools near busy roads or highways are exposed to more air pollution

School location plays a significant role in children's exposure to air pollution, with schools near busy roads or highways posing higher health risks. In the United States, about one in every eleven public schools is situated within 500 feet of major roadways, highways, or truck routes, serving approximately 4.4 million students. This proximity to heavy traffic significantly increases children's vulnerability to air pollution.

Children are more susceptible to the adverse health effects of air pollution than adults due to their developing organs, immature immune systems, and higher breathing rates. Research has linked traffic-related air pollution to various health issues in children, including stunted lung development, exacerbated asthma symptoms, and an increased risk of cancer. The impact of air pollution on children's health has led to growing concerns about school siting and the need to consider cleaner environments for educational institutions.

Studies have found that children attending schools near busy roads or highways are exposed to significantly higher concentrations of vehicle-related pollutants. The pollution levels can be even higher inside school buses, especially on urban routes with higher traffic density. Additionally, the time spent commuting to and from school can contribute significantly to a child's overall exposure to air pollution, as elevated pollutant concentrations in roadway environments can have detrimental effects.

To address this issue, some districts have considered relocating schools to cleaner air quality environments, requiring school bus transportation. However, this approach may not always reduce children's exposure to air pollution, as the increased time spent on buses can negate the benefits of cleaner air at the school site. Strategies such as implementing clean bus technology and improving HVAC systems can help mitigate exposure during longer commutes to "clean" schools.

Furthermore, the impact of air pollution from nearby busy roads or highways can extend beyond the immediate vicinity of the school. Fine particles and pollutants from vehicles, especially diesel trucks, can spread to surrounding areas, affecting nearby communities and schools. This highlights the importance of comprehensive approaches to reducing air pollution and protecting children's health, such as the Clean School Bus National Idle Reduction Campaign and the EPA's efforts to replace old diesel school buses.

School commute: Children's exposure to vehicle pollutants is higher during bus commutes

Children are more susceptible to the health risks associated with air pollution than adults. This is due to several factors, including the fact that their organs are still developing, they breathe more frequently than adults, and they spend a significant amount of time outdoors. As a result, children's exposure to air pollution during their school commute, particularly when travelling by bus, has become a growing concern.

School commutes, especially those involving bus rides, can contribute significantly to a child's total exposure to air pollutants. Despite accounting for less than 10% of a child's day, bus commutes can lead to up to 33% of their daily exposure to certain air pollutants. This is because buses, especially older diesel models, release harmful pollutants such as black carbon, particle-bound PAHs, and other exhaust pollutants. Additionally, the high concentrations of pollutants already present on roadways, especially in urban areas with heavy traffic, further increase children's exposure during bus rides.

Several studies have been conducted to understand and address this issue. Researchers in California, for example, found that children travelling on school buses were exposed to significantly higher concentrations of vehicle-related pollutants than ambient air concentrations. On-board concentrations were notably higher on urban routes compared to rural or suburban routes, indicating the influence of surrounding traffic density. Another study in Detroit, Michigan, simulated children's exposure to air pollution across different school locations and commute modes. They found that busing children from a high-traffic neighbourhood to a school in a low-traffic area resulted in average daily exposures 2 to 3 times higher than children walking to a local school.

To mitigate these concerns, organizations like the California Air Resources Board (CARB) have sponsored studies and initiatives to reduce children's exposure to air pollutants during school bus commutes. These include the development and testing of high-efficiency cabin air filters, which have shown promising results in reducing particulate pollution, black carbon, and ultrafine particles (UFP). Additionally, programs such as the Clean School Bus National Idle Reduction Campaign aim to promote a cleaner and healthier environment by reducing bus idling near schools.

While these efforts are a step in the right direction, more comprehensive solutions are needed. This includes the implementation of EPA's air pollution guidelines, which some local school districts have found challenging due to time and cost constraints. Additionally, the selection of school sites that are distant from students' neighbourhoods and accessible only by motorized transport further complicates the issue. Therefore, a multifaceted approach involving improved bus technology, stricter emission regulations, and careful consideration of school locations is necessary to effectively reduce children's exposure to vehicle pollutants during their school commute.

Indoor air quality (IAQ): Poor IAQ, due to lack of ventilation and indoor pollutants, negatively impacts health and cognition

Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) is a critical consideration in maintaining the health and comfort of individuals within buildings, especially in schools where children spend a significant amount of time. Poor IAQ, resulting from inadequate ventilation and indoor pollutants, can negatively impact the health and cognitive abilities of students and staff.

Ventilation plays a crucial role in maintaining good IAQ. When there is insufficient ventilation, outdoor air exchange rates are low, leading to a buildup of pollutants. This can be due to the design of the building, with some constructed to minimize the infiltration of outdoor air through openings, joints, and cracks, as well as windows and doors. Mechanical ventilation devices can help address this issue, but they may not be present in all schools. In addition, high temperatures and humidity levels can further increase pollutant concentrations.

Indoor pollution sources, such as building materials, paints, cleaning products, furniture, and school-specific items like blackboards and laboratory chemicals, release gases and particles that contribute to poor IAQ. These pollutants can have immediate and long-term health effects. Irritation of the eyes, nose, and throat, headaches, dizziness, and fatigue are common immediate symptoms. Prolonged exposure can lead to more severe issues, including respiratory diseases, heart disease, cognitive deficits, and even cancer.

Children are particularly vulnerable to the health risks associated with poor IAQ due to their developing organs and natural defenses. They breathe more frequently than adults, taking in more pollutants, and their immature immune systems struggle to detoxify and process toxins effectively. Schools with poor IAQ can experience higher absenteeism due to exacerbated asthma symptoms and other health issues.

Improving IAQ in schools is essential to protect the health and well-being of students and staff. This can be achieved through increased ventilation, source control by using low-emission products, and implementing effective IAQ management programs. By addressing these issues, schools can create healthier learning environments and mitigate the negative impacts of poor IAQ on health and cognition.

Outdoor air quality: Outdoor pollutants from traffic and industry can infiltrate indoor spaces, affecting air quality

Outdoor air quality is a critical factor in the overall air quality of schools. Outdoor pollutants from traffic and industry can infiltrate indoor spaces, significantly impacting the health and well-being of students and staff.

Traffic-related air pollution is a significant concern for schools located near busy roads or highways. Vehicle emissions release a mix of hazardous substances, including ozone, nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), and carbon monoxide. These pollutants can infiltrate schools, especially those situated downwind from major roadways. Studies have shown that children travelling to school by bus are exposed to significantly higher concentrations of vehicle-related pollutants, with urban routes exhibiting higher pollution levels than rural or suburban routes.

Industrial pollution sources, such as power plants, refineries, and industrial boilers, also contribute to outdoor air pollution. The combustion of fossil fuels and industrial processes release harmful substances like nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides (SOx), and fine particulate matter (PM 2.5). PM 2.5 is of particular concern as it can be inhaled deeply into lung tissue, leading to serious health issues.

Agricultural practices, such as agricultural burning to clear crop remnants, contribute to poor outdoor air quality in rural areas. Smoke from these burns can contain pollutants that negatively impact children's respiratory health, triggering and exacerbating asthma symptoms.

Outdoor air pollution can infiltrate indoor spaces through ventilation systems, open windows, and doors. Indoor air quality (IAQ) is crucial in schools as children spend a significant amount of time indoors. Poor IAQ can lead to various health issues, including headaches, fatigue, respiratory problems, and increased asthma symptoms. It can also impact learning outcomes, with healthy ventilation and CO2 monitors shown to enhance productivity, focus, and overall health.

To mitigate the impact of outdoor pollutants, schools can implement strategies such as air quality monitoring programs, adopting the US EPA's Air Quality Index (AQI) flag system, and participating in campaigns like the Clean School Bus National Idle Reduction Campaign. Additionally, schools can prioritize IAQ management programs, such as the EPA's IAQ Tools for Schools, to improve indoor air quality and create healthier learning environments for students and staff.

Social and environmental factors: Low-income and minority students may face greater health risks and learning challenges due to air pollution

Children are more susceptible to the health risks associated with air pollution than adults. Their heightened susceptibility is due to several factors, including the ongoing development of their lungs and immune systems, higher breathing rates, and higher metabolism, which leads to greater absorption of pollutants. Therefore, it is crucial to address the social and environmental factors that contribute to low-income and minority students facing greater health risks and learning challenges due to air pollution.

Low-income communities are often disproportionately affected by air pollution. Research has shown that areas with lower-income groups in the United States have been exposed to higher average levels of fine particulate matter (PM2.5) compared to higher-income areas. This disparity has increased over time, indicating that income plays a significant role in exposure to air pollution. Lower-income communities may be located closer to pollution sources, increasing exposure to harmful pollutants. Additionally, low-income students may have limited access to healthcare, healthy food options, and quality education, further exacerbating the health risks associated with air pollution.

Minority students, particularly students of color, also face greater health risks due to air pollution. Studies have found that exposure to air pollution is higher for people of color, regardless of region or income level. This disparity is a result of systemic racism, with people of color being pushed towards areas with higher pollution levels due to housing policies and other factors. Additionally, minority communities may face higher levels of pollution from multiple sources, including traffic and industrial emissions. The stress and health impacts of discrimination can also make minority students more susceptible to the health effects of air pollution.

The location of schools plays a significant role in students' exposure to air pollution. Schools built near busy roads or highways are more likely to be exposed to traffic-related air pollution. During their commute to school, students, especially those traveling by bus, are exposed to significantly higher concentrations of vehicle-related pollutants. Additionally, indoor air quality in schools can be poor due to a lack of ventilation, the use of specific materials and chemicals, and overcrowding, which increases the concentration of pollutants. These factors can disproportionately affect low-income and minority students, who are more likely to reside in areas with higher levels of outdoor pollution and attend schools with inadequate resources to address indoor air quality issues.

To address these social and environmental factors, it is essential to implement strategies to reduce traffic-related pollution exposure near schools and improve indoor air quality. This can include adopting programs such as the Clean School Bus National Idle Reduction Campaign and utilizing tools like the U.S. EPA's Air Quality Index to notify communities about outdoor air quality. Additionally, schools can prioritize indoor air quality (IAQ) management programs and follow guides and certifications, such as the Hainaut Vigilance Sanitaire in Belgium, to ensure the use of low-emission products. By addressing these factors, we can work towards reducing the health risks and learning challenges faced by low-income and minority students due to air pollution.

Frequently asked questions