Sinkholes: Understanding Their Pollution Problems And Environmental Impact

Sinkholes are dramatic natural phenomena that occur when underlying rock layers are eroded by water, causing the land surface to collapse into the void left behind. While they can be caused by natural processes, human activity can also contribute to their formation and present significant environmental challenges. One of the primary pollution problems associated with sinkholes is the contamination of groundwater and drinking water supplies. This happens when toxic chemicals, waste, and pollutants are introduced into the sinkholes, seeping into the underlying aquifers and water systems. The impact of human activity on the formation and pollution of sinkholes is a growing concern, particularly in urban areas with specific geological characteristics.

Characteristics and Values of Sinkhole-Caused Pollution

Karst aquifers are sensitive to groundwater contamination

Karst aquifers are highly productive groundwater resources, providing drinking water for about 40% of the US population and 25% of the world's population. They are characterised by a network of interconnected fissures, fractures, and conduits in a relatively low-permeability rock matrix. Most of the groundwater flow and storage occur in this network of openings and the matrix, respectively, making these aquifers highly heterogeneous and anisotropic.

The unique hydrogeology of karst aquifers renders them highly vulnerable to contamination. Their excessive permeability enhances their susceptibility to retaining and spreading contaminants. Karst aquifers are particularly susceptible to emerging contaminants (ECs) comprising various chemical groups, including pharmaceuticals, personal care products, flame retardants, perfluorinated and polyfluorinated compounds, nanoparticles, and microplastics. These ECs can infiltrate groundwater through indirect pathways from surface water or directly from sources like landfill leachate and septic systems.

Agricultural, industrial, and urban activities further contribute to the vulnerability of karst aquifers to contamination. In agricultural settings, fertilisers, herbicides, and pesticides applied to fields overlying carbonate rock can infiltrate the aquifer, contaminating springs and wells. Improperly sited municipal landfills near karst areas can also allow hazardous chemicals, such as hydrocarbons, heavy metals, and PCBs, to leak or run off into karst waters. Additionally, leaky septic systems and sewage lines can introduce disease-causing organisms and bacteria into the karst system.

The sensitivity of karst aquifers to groundwater contamination is a critical environmental issue. The impact of human activities on karst is most severe when polluted surface waters enter these aquifers, especially in populated areas. Expanding urbanisation, the misuse and improper disposal of hazardous chemicals, and the shortage of suitable repositories for toxic waste all contribute to the contamination of karst aquifers. Conservation practices, such as establishing natural buffer zones around sinkholes and removing trash from their vicinity, are essential for maintaining the quality and quantity of recharge water entering the aquifer.

Human activity increases the possibility of sinkholes

While most sinkholes are naturally occurring, human activity can increase the possibility of their formation. Sinkholes are formed when underlying rock layers are eroded or dissolved, creating voids that cannot support the weight of the surface layer, leading to collapse. This process can be exacerbated by various human activities that alter the natural balance and stability of the land.

One significant factor is the increased use of groundwater, which can cause the ground to subside and sink. This is particularly relevant in areas with soluble rocks like limestone, gypsum, salt, dolomite, which are susceptible to erosion by water. Over-extraction of groundwater through activities such as heavy pumping or fracking can accelerate the formation of sinkholes. Additionally, changes in water drainage patterns due to human activities can introduce water to areas unaccustomed to accommodating erosion, increasing the risk of sinkhole formation.

Urbanization and population growth also contribute to the increased likelihood of sinkholes. As the population expands and spreads, the chances of encountering a sinkhole rise. The increase in impermeable surfaces due to urbanization prevents rainwater from infiltrating directly into the ground, leading to concentrated infiltration in specific areas. This, combined with erosion-prone landscapes, can result in an elevated risk of sinkhole formation.

Human activities such as mining, construction, and the decay of buried materials can also play a role. Mining can remove supportive structures underground, leaving voids that increase the likelihood of sinkholes. Construction activities can involve the improper disposal of debris, creating cavities that can lead to collapse. Furthermore, the decay of buried materials, such as utility lines, can wash away and create voids that contribute to sinkhole formation.

Additionally, human-induced pollution can indirectly increase the possibility of sinkholes. Acid rain, resulting from industrial emissions and other sources of air pollution, can accelerate the erosion of rocks, particularly those that are easily dissolvable, such as limestone. The acidification of rainwater by sulphurous and nitrous acids further contributes to this process.

While the direct impact of human activities on sinkhole formation is complex and varies based on geographical factors, it is evident that human actions can increase the risk. Understanding and mitigating these impacts are crucial for minimizing the occurrence of sinkholes and their associated environmental and economic consequences.

Karstlands are prone to land subsidence and sinkholes

Karstlands, also known as karst topography, are landscapes formed from the dissolution of soluble carbonate rocks such as limestone and dolomite. Karst areas are characterised by distinctive landforms like springs, caves, and sinkholes, as well as unique hydrology that results in highly productive aquifers. Karst areas are particularly vulnerable to contamination due to their cavernous and highly permeable nature, which reduces the opportunity for contaminant filtration.

The sensitivity of karst aquifers to groundwater contamination is a significant environmental issue. Human activities, such as improper disposal of hazardous chemicals, agriculture, and expanding urbanization, can introduce pollutants into karst groundwater supplies. Sinkhole dumping, improper siding of municipal landfills, leaky septic systems, and sewage lines are all ways in which humans contribute to the contamination of karstic groundwater.

Additionally, the improper management of storm drainage and the pumping of groundwater can increase the risk of sinkhole formation in urban areas. Karst formations are also susceptible to erosion, which can be accelerated by acidification of rainwater due to atmospheric pollution from the burning of fossil fuels. While the timescale of this process is debated, it is clear that human activities can play a role in the creation and exacerbation of sinkholes in karstlands.

To mitigate the risks associated with land subsidence and sinkholes in karstlands, conservation practices such as establishing natural buffer zones around sinkholes and proper management of drainage systems are recommended. Subsidence detection and mapping by organizations like the USGS are also crucial for understanding and managing the risks associated with land subsidence and sinkhole formation in these vulnerable areas.

Sinkholes can cause polluted wells and drinking water

Sinkholes are a significant environmental concern, particularly when it comes to groundwater contamination and the resulting impact on drinking water sources. Karstlands, characterised by sinkholes, caves, and solution valleys, are highly sensitive to pollution. The infiltration of polluted surface water into karst aquifers is a pressing issue in populated areas across the United States.

One of the primary ways sinkholes contribute to water pollution is by acting as direct conduits between the surface and groundwater. When sinkholes form, they create pathways for contaminants to reach water supplies. This includes pollutants from human activities such as industrial waste, agricultural runoff, and improper waste disposal. Fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides applied to fields can enter aquifers through diffuse infiltration, contaminating springs and wells. Improperly managed municipal landfills near karst landscapes can also allow hazardous chemicals, including hydrocarbons and heavy metals, to leak into the groundwater.

Additionally, sinkholes themselves have been used as dumping sites for trash, rusty metals, and pesticide containers in the past. This practice has led to highly polluted wells until it was recognised and largely discontinued. Even today, the restoration of polluted sinkholes requires significant effort and time to flush out remaining contaminants. The sensitivity of karst aquifers to pollution is further exacerbated by expanding urbanisation, the misuse of hazardous chemicals, and the lack of suitable repositories for toxic waste.

The impact of sinkholes on drinking water quality can be severe. For example, in 2016, a giant sinkhole at a fertilizer plant in Florida leaked polluted water containing low-level radiation into the state's primary drinking water aquifer. This incident raised concerns among residents and environmental advocates about the potential health risks associated with contaminated drinking water sources. While the company conducted tests and provided alternative water sources, the event highlighted the vulnerability of drinking water supplies in the vicinity of sinkholes.

To mitigate the pollution problem caused by sinkholes, conservation practices such as establishing natural buffer zones around sinkholes are recommended. Additionally, factors like fractures in the bedrock, drainage area size, and proximity to contamination sources should be considered when determining the necessary level of protection for a particular sinkhole.

Fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides can contaminate aquifers

Fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides are essential for plant growth and pest control. However, their improper use and disposal can lead to the contamination of aquifers and other water sources.

Fertilizers, when applied in excess, can cause nutrient enrichment in water bodies, leading to eutrophication. This process results in algae blooms that deplete the oxygen levels in the water, creating "dead zones" where aquatic life cannot survive. Additionally, fertilizers can increase the levels of nitrates in water, which are harmful to both humans and animals.

Herbicides and pesticides are designed to be toxic to target species, such as insects, weeds, and fungi. However, their toxicity can also pose risks to non-target organisms, including humans, if they enter water sources. These chemicals can contaminate aquifers through various pathways, including surface runoff, seepage from contaminated surface water, accidental spills and leaks, and improper disposal.

The time lag between the application of herbicides and pesticides and their arrival at a well can vary depending on aquifer permeability and depth. This delay makes it challenging to detect and address contamination promptly. Furthermore, wastewater treatment plants are often unable to remove all pesticide residues, leading to their release into waterways.

The impact of herbicides and pesticides on human health can be significant. For example, organophosphates and carbamates can affect the nervous system, while others may irritate the skin or eyes. Some pesticides are even suspected of being carcinogenic. The World Health Organization (WHO) emphasizes that the toxicity of a pesticide depends on its function and other factors, with insecticides generally being more toxic to humans.

To mitigate the contamination of aquifers by fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides, it is crucial to follow best management practices (BMPs). These practices include reducing runoff and soil erosion, increasing soil organic matter content, and properly storing and disposing of these chemicals. Additionally, it is important to follow label directions when using any pesticide product to minimize its environmental impact.

Frequently asked questions