Geothermal Energy: Pollution Paradox Or Clean Power Source?

Geothermal energy is one of the cleanest forms of energy used for electricity generation today, but it can still cause pollution. The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted into useful energy. Geothermal power plants emit small amounts of harmful gases, including carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, and hydrogen sulfide, which can lead to acid rain. Additionally, the process of extracting and re-injecting large quantities of water into the ground can cause land subsidence and minor earthquakes. Open-loop systems, which expel waste steam and gases into the atmosphere, generally have greater environmental impacts than closed-loop systems.

Geothermal energy is one of the cleanest forms of energy

Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity. Unlike fossil fuel power plants, they emit 97% less sulfur compound, which causes acid rain, and about 99% less carbon dioxide. They also emit negligible amounts of particulate matter and nitrous oxides compared to other energy sources. However, geothermal plants do release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide, as well as other harmful gases such as hydrogen sulfide, ammonia, methane, and boron.

Hydrogen sulfide is the most concerning pollutant emitted by geothermal power plants. It can lead to acid rain, which has detrimental effects on forests, vegetation, wildlife, soils, and historic buildings or monuments. To mitigate this, geothermal power plants can install Hydrogen Sulfide Abatement Systems, which remove up to 99.9% of hydrogen sulfide released into the atmosphere. Additionally, most geothermal power plants inject used geothermal steam and water back into the earth to minimize their environmental impact.

Open-loop systems, which expel waste steam and gases into the atmosphere, generally have greater environmental impacts than closed-loop systems. In closed-loop systems, gases and fluids removed from the well are not exposed to the atmosphere and are usually injected back into the ground. Land subsidence, caused by the removal of water from geothermal reservoirs, is another issue addressed by most geothermal facilities. They reinject wastewater back into geothermal reservoirs to mitigate this risk.

Hydrogen sulfide is the most concerning pollutant from geothermal plants

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the Earth's surface. The most widely developed type of geothermal power plant is known as a hydrothermal plant, which is located near "hot spots" where molten rock close to the Earth's crust produces hot water. Another type of geothermal system is called "hot dry rock", which involves drilling into the Earth's surface to access geothermal resources.

While geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide. These emissions are significantly lower than those of similarly-sized fossil fuel power plants. However, the presence of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) in the air, water, soil, and vegetation is one of the main environmental concerns for geothermal fields. Hydrogen sulfide is a colourless water-soluble gas with a distinctive rotten egg smell. It is a natural byproduct of geothermal processes, but it can also be produced artificially through the refinement of crude petroleum, among other industrial processes.

Geothermal power plants emit high amounts of hydrogen sulfide due to its presence as a main constituent of the geothermal fluids used in the plants. The release of hydrogen sulfide can have negative impacts on both the environment and the human body. For example, it contributes to the formation of small acidic particulates that can be absorbed by the bloodstream and cause heart and lung disease. As a result, there is increasing interest in developing methods and technologies to reduce hydrogen sulfide emissions from geothermal plants.

One such technology is the AMIS (Abatement of Mercury and Hydrogen Sulfide) system, which can be combined with a PEM electrolyzer to produce hydrogen from the hydrogen sulfide. This approach not only reduces emissions but also provides an alternative energy source. Overall, while geothermal energy has a much lower environmental impact than fossil fuels, hydrogen sulfide emissions are a concern that requires further mitigation strategies.

Geothermal plants emit harmful gases like carbon dioxide, ammonia, and methane

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the Earth's surface. The most common type of geothermal power plant is the hydrothermal plant, which is located near "hot spots" where molten rock close to the Earth's crust produces hot water. Another type of geothermal system is the enhanced geothermal system (or hot dry rock geothermal), which involves drilling into the Earth's surface to reach deeper geothermal resources.

While geothermal energy has a much lower environmental impact than fossil fuels, it is not without its drawbacks. Geothermal plants emit small amounts of carbon dioxide, ammonia, and methane. These gases are natural, minor constituents of all geothermal reservoirs and would eventually vent into the atmosphere without geothermal power plants, although at much slower rates. The amount of gas emitted depends on the type of power plant and the technology used to convert the resource to electricity and for cooling. For example, dry steam and flash steam power plants emit mostly water vapour, while binary-cycle power plants emit almost no gases because they use a closed-loop system.

Geothermal power plants also emit very low amounts of sulfur dioxide, which is a contributor to acid rain. However, these emissions are approximately 30 times lower per megawatt-hour than those from coal plants. Some geothermal plants also produce small amounts of mercury, which must be mitigated with mercury filter technology. In addition, the treatment processes used to remove hydrogen sulfide from geothermal gases can produce a toxic sludge that contains heavy metals and must be disposed of as hazardous waste.

To minimise the environmental impact of geothermal energy, most plants inject the steam and water they use back into the earth. This practice helps to sustain geothermal resources and has been shown to significantly reduce carbon dioxide emissions.

Geothermal plants can cause land subsidence and minor earthquakes

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the Earth's surface. The most widely developed type of geothermal power plant is known as a hydrothermal plant, which is located near "hot spots" where molten rock close to the Earth's crust produces hot water.

While geothermal energy is considered a clean and sustainable energy source, geothermal plants can cause land subsidence and minor earthquakes. Land subsidence occurs when the land surface sinks, sometimes as a result of the removal of water from geothermal reservoirs. This can be prevented by re-injecting wastewater back into the reservoirs, which is a common practice among geothermal power plants.

The drilling of wells for geothermal plants can also impact the land. However, advanced directional or slant drilling technology has evolved to minimize this impact. This technology allows multiple wells to be drilled from a single location, reducing the amount of land needed for drilling pads, access roads, and geothermal fluid piping. Slimhole drilling, which uses smaller-diameter wells, can also be employed to minimize environmental impacts and reduce the amount of land needed for site preparation and road construction.

Geothermal plants have also been associated with increased seismic activity in certain cases. A study by Brodsky and co-author Lia Lajoie examined earthquake records for a region containing a geothermal power plant from 1981 to 2012. They found a correlation between periods of increased geothermal operations and higher rates of seismicity. Another example is the 2017 magnitude 5.4 earthquake in Pohang, South Korea, which was attributed to an experimental geothermal power plant by a government panel.

The risk of earthquakes associated with geothermal plants can be mitigated by careful siting, such as avoiding locations near major fault lines. Additionally, enhanced geothermal systems (hot dry rock) that pump water at high pressures to fracture underground reservoirs, similar to hydraulic fracturing, may increase the risk of minor earthquakes and should be carefully managed.

Geothermal plants require large amounts of water for cooling

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the earth's surface. The most widely developed type of geothermal power plant, known as hydrothermal plants, are located near geological "hot spots" where hot molten rock is close to the earth's crust and produces hot water. Other types of geothermal plants include dry steam power plants, flash steam power plants, and binary cycle power plants.

Water is used by geothermal plants for cooling and re-injection. All U.S. geothermal power facilities use wet-recirculating technology with cooling towers. Depending on the cooling technology used, geothermal plants can require between 1,700 and 4,000 gallons of water per megawatt-hour. However, most geothermal plants can use either geothermal fluid or freshwater for cooling. The use of geothermal fluids rather than freshwater reduces the plant's overall water impact. Plants based on organic Rankine cycle technology have very minimal water loss (<1%). On the other hand, plants based on a flash steam turbine can have much higher water losses due to evaporation to condense the water enough for reinjection (~20%).

Geothermal power plants emit 97% less acid rain-causing sulfur compounds and about 99% less carbon dioxide than fossil fuel power plants of similar size. However, some geothermal plants produce small amounts of mercury emissions, which must be mitigated using mercury filter technology. Additionally, scrubbers can be used to remove the hydrogen sulfide naturally found in geothermal reservoirs, but they produce a watery sludge composed of captured materials, including sulfur, vanadium, silica compounds, chlorides, arsenic, mercury, nickel, and other heavy metals. This toxic sludge must then be disposed of at hazardous waste sites.

Overall, while geothermal plants do require large amounts of water for cooling, the specific amount varies depending on the plant type and the temperature of the resource, and some plants have very minimal water loss.

Frequently asked questions