Biomass Energy: A Noisy Affair?

Biomass incinerators are a source of noise pollution, with residents near these plants experiencing unbearable noise levels that disturb their peace and sleep. The Gainesville Renewable Energy Center (GREC) in Florida, for example, has been described as sounding like a continuous roar of jet planes revving up for takeoff. Similarly, in Rothschild, Wisconsin, and Turkey Creek, residents have complained about the noise from biomass plants, with one resident wishing that officials experience the same frequency and level of noise pollution. These issues are not limited to the US, as researchers in Mississippi have found noise pollution levels in wood pellet communities to be 10-12 decibels higher than in background communities, which doubles the perceived loudness.

Biomass incinerators cause noise pollution

Biomass incinerators are becoming an increasingly common source of noise pollution for communities across the United States. Taxpayer-subsidized biomass plants are being built in close proximity to residential areas, causing significant disruption to the lives of those living nearby. The Gainesville Renewable Energy Center (GREC) in Florida is a prime example, with residents describing the noise as a "continuous roar" akin to "jet planes revving up for takeoff".

The noise from biomass incinerators can come from a variety of sources, including truck and fuel unloading operations, conveyor systems, dust collectors, deaerator vents, boilers, and water cooling towers. The World Health Organization has identified seven health hazards associated with noise pollution from industrial facilities, including hearing impairment, sleep disturbances, and disturbances in mental health.

In the Turkey Creek neighborhood adjacent to the Gainesville Renewable Energy Center, retirees are finding themselves unable to get a peaceful night's sleep due to the constant noise. This issue is not unique to Gainesville, with similar complaints arising from communities across the country where biomass plants have been constructed. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory's report on the McNeil Generating Station noted that siting the plant in a residential area had caused a number of problems and extra expenses.

The wood pellet industry, a specific subset of the biomass energy industry, has come under fire for its negative impact on communities in the South. In Mississippi, for example, researchers have found that noise levels in wood pellet-producing communities are significantly higher than in background communities, with a difference of 10-12 decibels, which doubles the perceived loudness. This issue is compounded by the fact that these plants are often sited near communities of color that are already overburdened by industrial pollution, perpetuating environmental injustice and racism in the region.

The noise pollution caused by biomass incinerators is not just a nuisance but a serious health hazard that disrupts the well-being of those exposed to it. It is essential for regulatory agencies to address this issue and for communities to stand up against the corporations behind these harmful facilities.

The impact of biomass noise pollution on communities of colour

The noise pollution generated by biomass plants can be relentless and unbearable for those living in close proximity. Residents near biomass facilities have described the noise as a "continuous roar," comparable to jet planes revving up for takeoff or the operations on an aircraft carrier. The World Health Organization has identified several health hazards associated with noise pollution from industrial facilities, including hearing impairment, sleep disturbances, mental health issues, and cardiovascular problems.

In addition to the direct health impacts, the constant noise also disrupts the quality of life for community members. For example, a resident near the Enviva plant in Greenwood, South Carolina, complained about the noise and dust, stating that it was challenging for their grandchildren to play outside. Retirees in the Turkey Creek neighbourhood adjacent to the Gainesville Renewable Energy Center have expressed frustration that they are unable to enjoy the peace and quiet they had hoped for in their golden years.

It is important to recognize that the issue of biomass noise pollution and its impact on communities of colour is not an isolated incident but a systemic problem. Local activists and community advocates have been raising concerns about the dangerous effects of these facilities for years. Despite this, biomass energy companies continue to pursue tax incentives meant for clean energy sources, even though they release more climate-warming carbon than burning coal. This highlights the need for stronger regulations and protective measures to minimize the negative consequences of biomass facilities on nearby communities, particularly those of colour, who have historically borne the brunt of environmental injustices.

The health impact of biomass noise pollution

Noise pollution from biomass incinerators has been a concern for residents living near these facilities, with complaints about the loud and constant noise disrupting their peace and sleep. The World Health Organization (WHO) has identified seven health hazards associated with noise pollution from industrial facilities like biomass incinerators, including:

• Hearing impairment
• Sleep disturbances
• Disturbances in mental health
• Cardiovascular disturbances
• Interference with spoken communication
• Impaired task performance
• Negative social behavior and annoyance reactions

The noise from biomass incinerators has been described as a “continuous roar," resembling jet planes revving up for takeoff or the sound of a distant blow torch with a whine. The impact of this noise pollution on nearby residents is significant, with people reporting sleepless nights and feeling like they are living in a nightmare. The constant noise has also raised concerns about potential negative effects on mental health and well-being.

The health hazards associated with noise pollution from biomass incinerators are not limited to humans. Research has shown that noise pollution can have detrimental effects on various taxonomic groups, including mammals, birds, and fishes. It can lead to reduced species richness and abundance, altered community compositions, and even impact non-auditory animals through substrate-borne vibrations.

The impact of biomass noise pollution on human health and the surrounding ecosystem is a serious issue that needs to be addressed. Mitigation strategies and regulations are crucial to ensure the well-being of both the residents and the biodiversity in the affected areas.

The economic impact of biomass noise pollution

Health Hazards

The World Health Organization (WHO) has identified seven health hazards associated with noise pollution from industrial facilities, including biomass incinerators. These hazards include hearing impairment, sleep disturbances, mental health issues, cardiovascular problems, interference with communication, impaired task performance, and negative social behaviour. The social and economic costs of these health issues can be significant, impacting individuals' ability to work and participate fully in society.

Property Values

The noise pollution from biomass incinerators has also led to concerns about property values in affected areas. Residents near biomass plants have reported their worries about the potential decrease in property values due to the noise. For example, realtor and Turkey Creek resident Marianna Kampa explained that the noise pollution would make it "impossible to sell a home" in the area, and it would "decimate our property values". This could have a significant economic impact on homeowners, reducing their wealth and potentially affecting their ability to secure loans or financing.

Community Costs

Alternative Investments

Additionally, the economic impact of biomass noise pollution should be considered in the context of alternative investments in clean energy solutions. Investing in biomass energy diverts funds from truly clean and renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind, and battery storage. By allocating resources to biomass, which has been shown to contribute to noise pollution and other environmental issues, there are opportunity costs associated with forgoing investments in more sustainable and economically viable alternatives.

Overall, the economic impact of biomass noise pollution is multifaceted and far-reaching. It affects individuals, communities, and society as a whole. Addressing this issue requires recognising the true costs of biomass energy and prioritising investments in cleaner and more sustainable energy solutions.

The impact of biomass noise pollution on the environment

Noise pollution from biomass incinerators and other sources has a significant impact on both human well-being and ecological environments. Prolonged exposure to high levels of noise can lead to hearing loss, sleep disturbances, cardiovascular issues, cognitive impairment, and increased stress levels in humans. It can also contribute to mental health problems, reduced quality of life, and annoyance. These effects can be particularly harmful to nearby communities, as experienced by residents near the Gainesville Renewable Energy Center and the McNeil Generating Station.

The ecological impacts of biomass noise pollution are also significant. Noise pollution can disrupt natural communication patterns among wildlife species, impair feeding habits, and alter migratory behaviours. It can displace sensitive species, reduce their ability to find resources, and lead to population declines. Entire ecosystems can be affected, with the disruption cascading through the food chain and impacting multiple trophic levels. Marine life, for example, is highly susceptible to noise pollution, with whales struggling to navigate through water and ending up stranded onshore due to sonar signals and boat noise.

Additionally, noise pollution can interfere with the tranquility sought by humans and wildlife alike. The Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE) emphasizes the importance of "hearing peace and quiet" for both humans and fauna. As urbanization and industrialization continue to increase noise levels, the pursuit of tranquility has gained attention, recognizing the detrimental effects of noise on physical and mental well-being.

To mitigate the impact of biomass noise pollution on the environment, several strategies can be employed. Environmental noise monitoring is crucial for understanding the extent of the problem and devising effective solutions. Public policies and regulations, such as those implemented in Europe, can help address noise pollution from an environmental protection perspective. Additionally, initiatives like the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) Ocean Noise Strategy Roadmap aim to reduce noise pollution in specific ecosystems. Community groups are also taking action, advocating for their right to peaceful environments and holding corporations accountable for their noise pollution contributions.

Frequently asked questions