The Dark Side Of Batteries: Pollution And Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of batteries is a growing concern as the global demand for them increases. Batteries are used in a variety of applications, from electric vehicles (EVs) to consumer electronic products, and their production, transportation, distribution, and disposal all have potential effects on the environment. The manufacturing of batteries, especially the mining of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, can result in toxic fumes, water pollution, and ecosystem contamination. Lead-acid and lithium-ion batteries, in particular, have been associated with environmental and health hazards, including memory loss, cardiovascular damage, and negative pregnancy outcomes. Improper disposal of batteries can lead to the release of toxic substances into groundwater and the environment, and the recycling of batteries is also a challenge, with lithium-ion batteries recycled at a rate below 5%. The energy source used to power batteries also contributes to their carbon footprint, with rechargeable batteries generally having a lower impact than disposable ones. As the demand for batteries continues to rise, addressing their environmental and health impacts becomes increasingly crucial.

How much pollution do batteries cause?

Mining and manufacturing batteries causes pollution

The mining and manufacturing of batteries have been associated with pollution and other negative environmental impacts. The process of mining the materials required for batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, can result in the release of toxic fumes and the depletion of water resources. For instance, in 2016, protests occurred in Tibet due to a lithium mine's unethical practice of polluting the local ecosystem through toxic chemical leaks. Similarly, lithium production was halted in China's Yichun city due to concerns over water quality. The production of lithium is extremely water-intensive, requiring approximately 2 million tonnes of water per tonne of lithium. This has led to heavy water depletion in regions like the South American Lithium triangle, comprising Chile, Argentina, and Bolivia.

The mining of nickel and cobalt has also resulted in environmental degradation, with satellite analysis revealing lifeless land and contaminated coastlines near nickel and cobalt mines in Cuba. The Philippines was compelled to shut down 23 mines due to the environmental impact of these mining operations. Furthermore, the disposal of batteries contributes to the pollution caused by mining and manufacturing. Consumers dispose of billions of batteries annually, many of which contain toxic or corrosive materials such as cadmium, mercury, lead, and lithium. Improper disposal of these batteries in landfill sites can result in the release of toxic substances into the environment, threatening both human health and ecosystems.

The manufacturing of batteries also contributes to pollution, particularly in countries that rely on coal-fired power plants. The production of electric vehicle (EV) batteries has been associated with the release of climate-warming gases, with some studies indicating that the manufacturing stage of an EV releases significantly more carbon dioxide than a gas or diesel-engined car. For example, researchers found that battery production for electric cars could generate up to 74% more carbon dioxide than efficient conventional cars if the batteries are produced in fossil fuel-powered factories. The weight of lithium-ion batteries, which are prevalent in EVs, further exacerbates the issue as the metals required are mined in only a few countries, often using environmentally detrimental methods.

The pollution caused by mining and manufacturing batteries is not limited to the production stage but extends to the disposal and recycling of batteries. While lead-acid batteries are recyclable, the recycling rate for lithium-ion batteries is below 5%. Improper recycling methods can lead to contamination and adverse health effects. For instance, a World Health Organization (WHO) report highlighted cases in Senegal, the Dominican Republic, and Vietnam, where lead-acid battery recycling resulted in negative health consequences, including the potential death of children. Thus, the mining and manufacturing of batteries have direct and indirect impacts on pollution and the environment, underscoring the need for sustainable practices and regulatory policies to mitigate these effects.

Battery disposal and recycling

Disposing of batteries improperly can have a detrimental impact on the environment. Batteries contain reactive chemicals and metals that generate electrical energy, and these can cause pollution if they are not disposed of correctly.

There are two main types of batteries: single-use and rechargeable. Single-use batteries, such as AA, AAA, 9-volt, and D cells, are found in alarm clocks, remotes, flashlights, and smoke detectors. When they are dead, they must be replaced. Rechargeable batteries can be used over and over and are found in smartphones, digital cameras, and cordless power tools.

When it comes to disposing of single-use batteries, it is best to recycle them if possible, although putting them in the trash is allowed in many places. Many local districts host collection events for residents to drop off batteries, and some battery manufacturers and recycling facilities have mail-in programs. Rechargeable batteries can also be recycled and should be disposed of properly to ensure that the metals and chemicals don't end up in streams and landfills.

Car batteries contain lead and acid, so they cannot be put in the trash or taken to the dump, and they are not accepted at most battery recycling collection sites. Many auto retailers will accept old car batteries and dispose of them properly, and some cities or counties may offer car battery collection sites.

The recycling of lithium-ion batteries is also becoming an increasingly important issue. Lithium-ion batteries are found in many products worldwide, and the extraction of lithium requires a lot of water, leading to water depletion and pollution. While lead-acid batteries are 99% recyclable, lithium-ion batteries are recycled at a very low rate, but this may be due to the fact that lithium-ion batteries do not need to be replaced as often as other types of batteries.

Pollution in developing countries

The transition to electric vehicles (EVs) is driving an increase in the demand for batteries, which is having a significant environmental impact on developing countries. While most consumers of EVs live in industrialised nations, the majority of the raw materials used in batteries are concentrated in a few developing countries. This includes lithium, with more than half of the world's lithium resources found in the Andean regions of Argentina, Bolivia, and Chile.

The mining of these materials has a high environmental cost, with toxic fumes released during the mining process and the water-intensive nature of the activity. Lithium mining requires huge amounts of groundwater, with some estimates showing that almost 2 million litres of water are needed to produce one ton of lithium. In Chile's Salar de Atacama, lithium mining consumed 65% of the region's water, causing groundwater depletion, soil contamination, and other forms of environmental degradation, forcing local communities to abandon their ancestral settlements.

In addition to the environmental impact of mining, the disposal of batteries at the end of their life cycle is also a growing problem. Batteries are often disposed of as e-waste in landfills, which can result in hazardous compounds leaching into the soil and causing fires. While recycling is being pursued by governments, it is expensive and challenging due to the lack of standardisation in battery design and the difficulty of dismantling them.

The quality of life in developing countries has improved due to the availability of a broad range of energy sources. However, for a sustainable future, these countries need to adopt renewable energy sources and energy storage technologies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and combat climate change. Grid-connected battery storage has the potential to transform power systems in developing countries, but careful assessment of the specific benefits and economic analysis is necessary.

Overall, the production and disposal of batteries are contributing to pollution and environmental degradation in developing countries, with local communities bearing the brunt of the negative impacts.

Environmental impact of electric vehicles

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally considered to be better for the environment than traditional gas-powered cars. Gasoline vehicles are responsible for significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with passenger vehicles accounting for 41% of all global CO2 emissions in the transportation sector. In contrast, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions and are more energy-efficient, with 87-91% of the energy from the battery being used to propel the vehicle.

However, the environmental impact of EVs is not entirely positive. The production of EV batteries, for example, can have a significant environmental footprint. The manufacturing process requires mining for raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can be energy-intensive and release toxic fumes and waste into the surrounding ecosystem. Additionally, the production and use of batteries contribute to carbon emissions, with the amount varying based on the local power source, such as coal or natural gas versus renewable sources like wind or solar.

Another issue to consider is the recycling of EV batteries. While lead-acid batteries are 99% recyclable, lithium-ion batteries are recycled at a much lower rate. This low recycling rate contributes to a growing worldwide e-waste problem. However, it is important to note that recycling lithium-ion batteries is challenging due to their chemical composition, and landfilling them can contaminate a large area.

Despite these concerns, EVs are still generally regarded as a more environmentally friendly option than traditional gas-powered cars. They produce fewer total emissions over their lifetime, and the development of new technologies and recycling methods is expected to further reduce their environmental impact in the future.

Health impact of lead batteries

Lead batteries have been identified as a growing global public health challenge. The health impact of lead batteries is significant, with lead poisoning affecting both adults and children. Exposure to lead can cause memory loss and damage the cardiovascular system. In pregnant women, it can cause miscarriages and premature deliveries. According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, there is no safe level of lead in a child's blood. Lead exposure at low levels can affect the developing brain, resulting in IQ deficits, lower school performance, and behaviour problems. Adults exposed to lead experience higher blood pressure, a risk factor for cardiovascular diseases, including stroke and myocardial infarction. Lead is responsible for approximately 674,000 deaths annually, primarily due to the chronic effects of high blood pressure.

The health impact of lead batteries is not limited to direct exposure to lead. The manufacturing and recycling of lead batteries can result in environmental contamination, which can indirectly affect human health. Regulatory actions and consumer demand in one country can influence lead exposures in other parts of the world, as the industry may shift to distant communities in other countries. Smelters, lead battery manufacturers, and recycling plants emit airborne lead particulates, contributing to soil and dust contamination in surrounding areas.

The unsafe recycling of lead batteries, particularly in unregulated operations, poses a lethal threat to human health. Children are especially vulnerable to lead poisoning, which can cause irreversible neurological damage. In Senegal, for example, at least 18 children died in just three months from encephalopathy due to toxic lead pollution from a battery recycling plant. Similarly, in Vietnam, a study found high levels of lead in the blood of children living near households specialised in recycling lead batteries, with a quarter of the children having levels nine times the US safety limit.

The growing demand for lead batteries, particularly in the automobile industry, has led to the rapid development of the lead-acid battery industry, especially in China, which has the world's largest LAB industry. This rapid growth has resulted in mass lead poisonings and continuous exposure to lead pollution, affecting both adults and children. China's LAB industry accounts for over 30% of global LAB output and uses over 67% of the country's total lead production.

The health impact of lead batteries has led to increasing scrutiny and calls for regulatory action to protect public health. In 2016, the United Nations Environmental Assembly adopted a resolution addressing the growing public health threat from lead battery recycling, highlighting the lack of adequate infrastructure to handle the increasing number of waste lead-acid batteries. It is imperative to develop global strategies to reduce lead emissions, implement take-back programs for used lead batteries, and improve the safety of lead battery manufacturing and recycling processes.

Frequently asked questions