Maine's Air Quality: Pollution Levels And Concerns

Maine's air quality is a mixed bag. While the state ranks fifth in the US for levels of toxic chemical pollution, the American Lung Association's 2020 State of the Air report found that air quality in Maine had improved slightly across the state and in most counties. The report also noted a stark contrast between the Bangor metro area, which is one of the cleanest cities in the US, and the Portland-Lewiston-South Portland metro area, which ranks in the top 100 most polluted cities for ozone. Maine's air pollution comes from various sources, including the burning of fossil fuels, vehicles, industrial sources, and power plants.

Bangor has some of the cleanest air in the US

Maine's air quality is generally considered to be good, especially when compared to other states in the US. However, there are concerns about the impact of pollution on the state's air quality, particularly in the southern part of the state, where there has been a slight increase in ozone pollution. Maine's air quality is influenced by various factors, including industrial pollution, vehicle emissions, and long-distance transport. Preliminary research at Harvard indicates that exposure to polluted air can increase COVID-19 death rates and make individuals more susceptible to lung infections.

Bangor, a city in Maine, has been consistently recognized for having some of the cleanest air in the United States. The American Lung Association's 2023 report on air quality highlights Bangor as one of seven cities in the country with the cleanest air. This positive assessment of Bangor's air quality is a significant achievement and a testament to the city's efforts to maintain a healthy and sustainable environment for its residents.

The clean air in Bangor can be attributed to several factors. One of the main reasons is the city's relatively small size and lower population density when compared to other urban areas. Bangor does not experience the same level of traffic congestion and industrial activity as larger cities, which are significant contributors to air pollution. The city's geographical location and weather patterns may also play a role in dispersing pollutants and maintaining good air quality.

Additionally, Bangor and the state of Maine have taken proactive measures to improve and maintain their air quality. There has been a push for the increased use of electric vehicles and the adoption of cleaner energy sources. The Sierra Club, an environmental organization, has advocated for stronger national and state air quality standards, car fuel economy standards, and the development of public transportation options to reduce emissions further. These efforts have likely contributed to Bangor's reputation for having clean air.

While Bangor enjoys relatively clean air, it is important to note that air quality can vary within a state or region. Other areas in Maine, such as Portland and Cumberland County, have received lower grades for their ozone levels. Additionally, natural events like wildfires in Canada can impact Maine's air quality, as haze and smoke from these fires can reach the state, affecting the air that residents breathe. Overall, Bangor's clean air is a valuable asset, and continued efforts to maintain and improve air quality across Maine are essential for the health and well-being of its residents.

Maine's air pollution is largely due to emissions from other states

Maine's air quality is generally considered to be good, especially in rural areas. However, there are concerns about the impact of air pollution from other states, as well as local sources. The state's clean air is considered to be under threat from a variety of factors, including wildfires in Canada, emissions from upwind states, and the weakening of federal air quality standards.

Maine's air quality is largely dependent on federal protections, which have been weakening in recent years. The relaxation of regulations in upwind states can have a significant impact on Maine, as pollution drifts into the state from elsewhere. This is particularly true of ozone pollution, which is a concern for the state. The American Lung Association's 2023 report on Maine's air quality highlighted that while Bangor continues to have some of the cleanest air in the country, southern Maine showed an increase in ozone pollution.

Ozone pollution is caused by a combination of sunlight and polluted air. Ground-level ozone and particulate matter, especially PM2.5, are two of the most dangerous and widespread pollutants that Maine imports from other states. The state's position downwind of the Eastern Seaboard and the Midwest means that it is vulnerable to these pollutants, which can have serious health impacts. Preliminary research at Harvard indicates that long-term exposure to polluted air may increase COVID-19 death rates and facilitate the spread of the coronavirus.

In addition to the threats posed by air pollution from other states, Maine also faces local air quality challenges. The state's small cities, such as Portland, can still have a significant impact on air quality. For example, Portland and Cumberland County dropped from an 'A' grade to a 'C' grade in the latest report for ozone levels. Local sources of pollution, such as industrial emissions and vehicle emissions, contribute to this. The pandemic shutdown offered a glimpse of how much cleaner the air could be with reduced pollution emissions, as industries and vehicles were temporarily halted.

Overall, while Maine's air quality is generally good, it is under threat from a variety of factors, including pollution from other states and local sources. The state's clean air is dependent on strong federal protections and local measures to reduce emissions and improve air quality. Without these protections, the health of Mainers, especially those with breathing problems, is at risk.

Wildfires in Canada caused a haze over much of the Northeastern US

Maine has long been dubbed the "tailpipe of the nation", as it is downwind of the Eastern Seaboard and Midwest and is therefore susceptible to air pollution from other states. The state's air quality is largely dependent on federal protections, which have weakened over the past four years, posing a direct threat to those with breathing problems.

In June 2023, wildfires in Canada caused a haze over much of the Northeastern US, including Maine. Smoke from dozens of wildfires burning in several Canadian provinces, including Quebec, Nova Scotia, and Ontario, blanketed the region in a yellowish-grey haze, prompting air quality alerts. The smoke travelled as far south as North Carolina and as far west as Ohio, with central New York experiencing hazardous levels of airborne soot.

The air pollution resulted in warnings for vulnerable populations to stay inside, particularly those with respiratory concerns such as asthma. The smoke was so dense that people could smell it in the air, and it shrouded iconic landmarks such as the Statue of Liberty and the New York City skyline. The haze also had widespread impacts on daily life, with New York City's public school system cancelling all outdoor activities, and similar measures taken in Washington, D.C., and New Jersey.

The wildfires highlighted the growing concern over air quality and the potential health risks associated with long-term air pollution, especially in a region like Maine, which is heavily dependent on federal protections and is vulnerable to the effects of climate change.

Maine's air quality is generally fresh and clean

The American Lung Association's 2023 report on Maine's air quality offered mixed results. While the Bangor area was found to have some of the cleanest air in the country, southern Maine showed a slight increase in ozone pollution during 2022, and Portland and Cumberland County's ozone levels dropped from an 'A' grade to a 'C' grade. Maine's air quality is also impacted by pollution from other states, as it is downwind of much of the Eastern seaboard and the Midwest.

During the pandemic shutdowns, Maine experienced a pause in pollution emissions, with regional monitors showing decreases of between 15 and 29 percent for the pollutant nitrogen dioxide. This offered a glimpse of how much better air quality could be with a transition to renewable power. However, there are concerns that the weakening of federal air quality standards and vehicle tailpipe emission and fuel efficiency standards could negatively impact Maine's air quality and public health.

While Maine's air quality is generally good, there are still some towns with cleaner air than others. For example, Bar Harbor, a tourist town on Mount Desert Island, has an average air quality rating of 40.8, which is considered good but borders on moderate. This rating can cause issues for people with existing health problems, and the high number of visitors the town receives each year likely contributes to the air quality being poorer.

Bar Harbor has the worst air quality in Maine

While Maine's air quality is far from ideal, Bar Harbor has been identified as one of the worst areas in the state. The air quality in Bar Harbor is generally acceptable, but it can be problematic for sensitive groups, including those with asthma or lung disease. On certain days, the air quality in Bar Harbor can be considered unhealthy, and even those without respiratory issues may experience symptoms such as difficulty breathing and throat irritation after prolonged exposure.

The Air Quality Index (AQI) in Bar Harbor is derived from raw measurements obtained by Plume Labs and converted using standards and guidelines developed by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the World Health Organization (WHO). While the data is subject to change and may be influenced by equipment limitations, it provides valuable insights into the air quality in the region.

Bar Harbor's air pollution levels can be attributed to a combination of local and regional factors. The state's proximity to other states, such as the Eastern Seaboard and the Midwest, means that much of the pollution that contributes to ozone drifts into Maine from these regions. This is a significant concern, as ozone pollution, formed when sunlight combines with polluted air, can reach unhealthy levels during summer days.

In addition to the influx of pollution from other states, Maine is also facing the challenge of weakened federal air quality standards and vehicle tailpipe emission regulations. The increase in greenhouse gas emissions contributes to a vicious cycle of exacerbating climate change and further aggravating ozone pollution. The impact of these rollbacks on the air quality in Maine is expected to be enduring, with higher pollution levels posing direct threats to the health of residents, particularly those with breathing problems.

The situation in Bar Harbor underscores the urgency of addressing air pollution in Maine. While the state has benefited from federal protections for clean air, the recent rollbacks and the impact of the pandemic have created a perfect storm for worsening air quality. As Maine grapples with the health and environmental consequences, it is crucial to explore solutions such as increasing the use of electric vehicles and adopting stricter emission standards to safeguard the well-being of its residents and protect the environment.

Frequently asked questions