Hydropower's Air Pollution: A Clean Energy Conundrum

Hydropower has long been considered a clean and renewable energy source, with the potential to provide a significant amount of electricity worldwide. However, there is a growing body of research that suggests that hydropower can actually contribute to air pollution and have negative impacts on the climate. The construction and operation of hydroelectric power plants, particularly the creation of reservoirs, can result in the emission of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide and methane. While hydropower is still a low-carbon source of energy compared to fossil fuels, the true extent of its carbon footprint and air pollution potential warrants further investigation and careful consideration in future hydropower projects.

Hydropower has a low carbon footprint compared to fossil fuels

Hydropower is a low-carbon source of renewable energy and a reliable and cost-effective alternative to electricity generation by fossil fuels. Independent research suggests that the use of hydropower instead of fossil fuels for electricity generation has helped to avoid more than 100 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide in the past 50 years alone. This is roughly equivalent to the total annual carbon footprint of the United States for 20 years.

The IPCC states that hydropower has a median greenhouse gas (GHG) emission intensity of 24 gCO₂-eq/kWh, which is significantly lower than the median figure for gas at 490 gCO₂-eq/kWh. The International Hydropower Association's analysis of almost 500 reservoirs worldwide using the G-res Tool confirms this low carbon footprint, with a median value of 23 gCO2-eq/kWh.

However, it is important to note that hydropower facilities can still produce greenhouse gas emissions. When a reservoir is created and filled with water, submerged organic matter such as vegetation decomposes and breaks down, releasing carbon dioxide and methane. These gases can reach the atmosphere through diffusion, ebullition, transmission via vegetation, and degassing when water passes through a pump house or turbine. The temperature of the reservoir water can also play a role in the production of methane emissions, with higher temperatures leading to increased emissions.

Despite these considerations, hydropower still has a lower carbon footprint compared to fossil fuels. If hydropower were replaced with coal for electricity generation, the International Hydropower Association estimates that more than 4 billion metric tonnes of additional greenhouse gases would be emitted annually, and global emissions from fossil fuels and industry would be at least 10% higher. Therefore, while not completely carbon-free, hydropower remains a cleaner and more environmentally friendly option compared to fossil fuels.

However, hydropower reservoirs produce carbon dioxide and methane

Hydropower is often considered a "clean" energy source and a low-carbon alternative to fossil fuels. However, the reservoirs used in hydropower generation produce carbon dioxide and methane, which are greenhouse gases that contribute to atmospheric warming and climate change.

When a hydropower reservoir is created and filled with water, vegetation and other organic matter become submerged and begin to decompose underwater, releasing carbon dioxide and methane. These gases can reach the atmosphere through diffusion, ebullition (bubbles), transmission via vegetation, and degassing when water passes through a pump house or turbine. Methane is particularly potent as a greenhouse gas, with over 80 times the warming power of carbon dioxide in the first 20 years after its release.

The amount of carbon dioxide and methane emitted by a hydropower reservoir can vary depending on several factors. The size and depth of the reservoir, the temperature of the water, the rate of sedimentation, and the amount of organic matter present can all influence the level of greenhouse gas emissions. For example, reservoirs with a larger shallow littoral area tend to produce more methane. Additionally, the ratio of electricity generated to the size of the reservoir can impact emissions, with facilities that produce a relatively small amount of electricity from a large reservoir likely to have disproportionately high emissions.

While hydropower reservoirs do release greenhouse gases, it is important to note that they also play a role in carbon sequestration. On average, human-made reservoirs are six times more effective at carbon burial than natural lakes, and in temperate climates, they can bury more carbon than they emit. However, the conditions that promote carbon burial can also favor methane production. As a result, the balance between carbon storage and emissions is delicate and dependent on various factors.

In summary, while hydropower is generally considered a low-carbon energy source, the reservoirs used in its generation can produce significant amounts of carbon dioxide and methane. These emissions can vary widely depending on the specific characteristics of the reservoir and the surrounding conditions. Accurate estimation and consideration of these emissions are crucial in understanding the full climate impact of hydropower and ensuring that it contributes to a cleaner energy future.

The ratio of electricity generated to water used affects greenhouse gas emissions

Hydropower is a source of renewable energy that is considered a low-carbon alternative to electricity generation from fossil fuels. However, the ratio of electricity generated to water used can impact its greenhouse gas emissions.

The use of hydropower instead of fossil fuels for electricity generation has helped to avoid over 100 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions in the past five decades. The International Hydropower Association (IHA) estimates that replacing hydropower with coal for electricity generation would result in more than 4 billion metric tonnes of additional annual greenhouse gas emissions.

While hydropower has a lower carbon footprint than fossil fuels, it is not entirely carbon-neutral. The reservoirs used for hydropower generation produce carbon dioxide and methane, a potent greenhouse gas with 80 times the warming power of CO2 in the first two decades after its release. The decomposition of vegetation submerged in reservoir water releases these gases.

The ratio of electricity generated to water used, or "power density," is a critical factor in the overall greenhouse gas emissions from hydropower facilities. A facility drawing from a large reservoir but producing a relatively small amount of electricity may result in disproportionate greenhouse gas emissions. Additionally, the temperature of the reservoir water can influence methane emissions, with warmer water potentially increasing emissions.

The construction and operation of hydroelectric power plants also contribute to global warming emissions. These emissions vary depending on the size of the reservoir and the characteristics of the flooded land. Furthermore, downstream water levels and ecosystems can be affected by the release of water from reservoirs, requiring measures to mitigate negative impacts on aquatic life.

Water quality degradation is a major concern, with oxygen stratification and thermal pollution

Hydropower is a low-carbon source of renewable energy that has helped avoid more than 100 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide in the past 50 years. However, it is not without its environmental impacts, and water quality degradation is a significant concern.

Water quality degradation in hydropower refers to the negative effects on the water that flows through hydroelectric dams and reservoirs. This type of water pollution can be defined as the addition of any substance or energy that harms living resources, poses hazards to human health, hinders aquatic activities, or impairs water quality. One of the main concerns is oxygen stratification.

Oxygen stratification occurs when the dissolved oxygen content in the water decreases with depth. The top layers of the reservoir, closest to the sun, are oxygen-rich, while the deeper layers experience oxygen depletion. These deeper layers, known as hypoxic areas, can have detrimental effects on aquatic life. The formation of a reservoir, which is much more still than a river, results in the creation of these distinct oxygen layers.

Another major concern is thermal pollution, which is closely related to oxygen stratification. Thermal pollution refers to the change in water temperature caused by the accumulation of thermal energy in the top layers of the reservoir. This warmer water is then drawn into the turbine through a penstock located at the bottom of the reservoir, altering the temperature downstream. Even minor temperature changes can impact the metabolic rates, reproduction, and growth of animals. For example, trout eggs may not hatch if the water temperature is too warm.

In addition to the direct effects on aquatic life, thermal pollution can also have indirect consequences. Increased water temperatures can enhance the accumulation of pollutants and change the oxygen demand in the water. Furthermore, the creation of reservoirs can lead to the entry of mercury into the water. This occurs when elemental mercury in the rock and soil of the reservoir interacts with bacteria released from the decomposition of submerged plant material, forming harmful water-soluble mercury compounds.

While thermal pollution is often neglected because it does not directly affect human health, it can have both positive and negative effects on wildlife populations and aquatic habitats. For instance, it can extend fishing seasons and cause a rebound in some wildlife populations. However, drastic temperature changes can result in direct casualties in marine populations.

Hydropower can obstruct fish migration and harm other wildlife

Hydropower is a low-carbon source of renewable energy and a reliable and cost-effective alternative to electricity generation by fossil fuels. However, hydropower plants are not entirely free of environmental impact. Dams, reservoirs, and the operation of hydroelectric generators can affect the environment.

One of the significant ways in which hydropower can harm wildlife is by obstructing fish migration. Many migratory fish species, such as salmon, shad, river herring, and American eel, need access to both ocean and freshwater habitats to complete their life cycles. They swim up rivers and streams to reproduce in their spawning grounds. When hydropower dams block their migration routes, these populations decline.

Dams can also change natural water temperatures, water chemistry, river flow characteristics, and silt loads. These changes can have negative effects on native plants and animals in and around the river. For example, reservoirs may cover important natural areas, agricultural land, or archaeological sites.

In addition to obstructing fish migration, hydropower turbines can also kill and injure fish that pass through them. The U.S. Department of Energy has sponsored research and development of turbines that could reduce fish deaths, but even the best existing turbines still result in fish kills of 2% to 10%.

To mitigate the impact on fish migration, various solutions have been proposed, such as the construction of fish ladders and elevators that help fish move around or over dams to reach their spawning grounds upstream. Organizations like NOAA Fisheries work to improve fish passage at non-federal hydropower dams and support the sustainability of economically important commercial and recreational fisheries.

Frequently asked questions