Fracking's Air Pollution: How Much Is Too Much?

Fracking, or high-volume hydraulic fracturing, has been associated with multiple environmental damages, including air pollution. The process involves extracting natural gas and oil from rock formations, which results in the release of various airborne contaminants and pollutants. These emissions have been linked to detrimental health effects, including respiratory and cardiovascular issues, and in some cases, an increased risk of cancer. The specific pollutants released during fracking include particulate matter, volatile organic compounds, benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, sulfur dioxide, and methane, among others. While regulations and technological advancements have helped reduce emissions, the continued growth of the fracking industry and potential deregulation of methane emissions may exacerbate air pollution concerns.

Flaring and gas burning emit sulfur dioxide, which can cause respiratory illness and heart conditions

Flaring, or burning gas, is a common practice in fracking when gas is either a safety hazard or uneconomical to collect and sell. Flaring emits a host of air pollutants, including carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, and sulfur dioxide (SO2).

Sulfur dioxide is a gaseous compound that is harmful to both human health and the environment. When emitted, it reacts with other chemicals in the atmosphere to form particulate pollution, such as fine sulfate particles, that can be suspended in the air as dust or soil. These particles can cause respiratory issues and heart conditions, damage lungs, and even lead to premature death. They also contribute to the formation of acid rain, which can harm sensitive ecosystems.

The burning of fossil fuels by power plants and industrial facilities is the largest source of sulfur dioxide emissions. However, fracking activities, such as flaring, also contribute to these emissions. During fracking, natural gas may be flared due to high concentrations of hydrogen sulfide, a toxic gas. While flaring is considered safer than releasing natural gas into the air, it still contributes to air pollution, particularly in areas with a high density of fracking sites.

The health impacts of fracking have been a cause for concern, with some studies indicating that continuous exposure to sulfur dioxide can increase ozone absorption and enhance responses to allergen challenges in asthmatics. However, the complex interactions of multiple substances during fracking make it challenging to fully assess the health impacts.

Fracking releases methane, a greenhouse gas that contributes to global warming

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, involves injecting liquids at high pressure into the earth to fracture rock formations and release oil and natural gas. This process releases methane, a greenhouse gas that contributes to global warming.

Methane is a fossil fuel and a major greenhouse gas. It is obtained through fracking, which fractures shale formations to extract the fossil fuels within. Methane may be released from pipelines, vented into the air, or burned in a process known as flaring. No matter how it is released, methane emissions are harmful to human health and the environment.

Flaring, for example, often releases sulfur dioxide, ammonia, or volatile organic compounds (VOCs) into the atmosphere. Some of these compounds, such as benzene, are known carcinogens. Toluene, another compound released during flaring, is a neurotoxin that can cause miscarriages and birth defects. A study of the Eagle Ford Shale region found that pregnant women living near areas with frequent flaring had a 50% higher chance of giving birth prematurely.

The release of methane through fracking has significant climate implications. Methane traps 30 to 90 times more heat in the atmosphere than carbon dioxide and persists for decades. According to Cornell research, the spike in atmospheric methane levels from 2008 to 2014 was due to global human-induced methane emissions. Robert Howarth, a researcher involved in the study, emphasized the potential for reducing methane emissions to quickly slow down global warming, stating:

> "If we can stop pouring methane into the atmosphere, it will dissipate... It's the low-hanging fruit to slow global warming."

In addition to the direct release of methane, fracking also contributes to air pollution through the increased truck traffic and related emissions associated with unconventional production. The large operations at conventional well sites have been replaced by numerous well pads, each requiring the transportation of water, chemicals, and equipment, as well as the removal of wastewater. This has resulted in a resurgence of hydrocarbon emissions, affecting the abundance of toxic benzene and ozone in the atmosphere.

Fracking increases hydrocarbon emissions, which affect abundances of toxic benzene and ozone

Fracking involves blasting huge volumes of water mixed with toxic chemicals and sand deep into the earth to fracture rock formations and release oil and natural gas. This extreme form of energy production endangers our health and wildlands. A fracking boom can transform an area almost overnight, creating massive new environmental and social problems.

The fracking boom has led to a new source of hydrocarbons in the atmosphere, affecting abundances of toxic benzene and ozone. Benzene is a known carcinogen and was routinely measured at over 1 part per billion in urban areas in the 1970s and 1980s. Urban ambient benzene concentrations have dropped by 5-10% per year over the last 20 to 30 years, and annual average benzene levels are now below 1.5 parts per billion at over 90% of locations monitoring benzene regularly. However, few such monitoring stations are in or near shale areas, and the risks for people living in these areas are elevated by their proximity to well pads. Health research has revealed connections between exposure to well density or proximity to oil and gas wells and minor health effects such as sinusitis, migraines, and fatigue, as well as hospitalization rates and certain birth defects.

The increase in hydrocarbon emissions due to fracking has also contributed to the resurgence of benzene as an air toxic in the US. While ozone is widely monitored, benzene is not, despite being a known carcinogen. Studies from Colorado and Texas show that elevated levels of benzene in shale areas are correlated with other hydrocarbon gases emitted.

In addition to the direct release of hydrocarbons, fracking also contributes to methane emissions, a potent greenhouse gas. Methane is leaked or deliberately flared at various stages of fossil fuel production and transport, and fracked shale gas is a significant source of methane emissions. While methane doesn't persist as long as CO2 in the atmosphere, it is much more potent while it is present, trapping heat at roughly 84 times the rate of CO2.

Fracking operations generate particulate matter and stir up dust, increasing ground-level ozone and smog

Fracking is a combination of techniques, including hydraulic fracturing, that allows operators to draw hydrocarbons from rock formations that were once too difficult to tap. This process involves blasting huge volumes of water mixed with toxic chemicals and sand deep into the earth to fracture rock formations and release oil and natural gas. The fracking boom has led to a new source of hydrocarbons in the atmosphere, affecting the abundance of toxic benzene and ozone.

In addition to the particulate matter and dust stirred up by fracking operations, the process of flaring, or burning off excess gas, emits a host of air pollutants, including sulfur dioxide. Sulfur dioxide can react with other chemicals to form particulate pollution, further contributing to the increase in ground-level ozone and smog.

The release of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, during fracking operations, also contributes to air pollution. Methane is the primary component of natural gas, and its release can occur during venting operations or leaks. High rates of methane leakage from natural gas fields can negate any climate benefits of using natural gas as an alternative to coal.

The increase in hydrocarbon emissions from fracking has led to a resurgence of benzene, an air toxic that was previously thought to be under control in the United States. Benzene is a known carcinogen and is routinely measured above 1 part per billion in urban areas. While regulations and technological innovations have reduced hydrocarbon emissions over the last 30 years, the decentralized nature of fracking well pads makes it challenging to regulate and monitor emissions effectively.

Fracking leaks and incomplete combustion of fuels release pollutants into the air

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, is a process used to extract natural gas and oil from deep rock formations. This is done by forcing water, sand, and a mix of chemicals into horizontally drilled wells, causing the rock to crack and release natural gas or oil. This process has been linked to air pollution in several ways.

One way is through leaks and incomplete combustion of fuels. The production, distribution, and use of hydrocarbons can result in emissions of pollutants into the air, either through intentional or unintentional releases or during incomplete fuel combustion. While regulations and technological advancements have significantly reduced these emissions over the last three decades, the fracking process still contributes to air pollution. Each well pad requires the transportation of water, chemicals, and equipment, as well as the removal of wastewater, leading to increased truck traffic and related emissions.

Fracking has been associated with increased levels of toxic benzene and ozone, even in regions that were not previously significantly impacted by air pollution. Benzene is a known carcinogen and has been monitored and regulated due to its health risks. While urban benzene concentrations have decreased over the years, the emergence of fracking has led to a resurgence of this toxic substance in the atmosphere.

In addition to benzene, fracking releases large amounts of methane, a potent greenhouse gas. Shale gas wells produced by fracking may have methane leakage rates as high as 7.9 percent, making natural gas obtained through this process more harmful to the climate than coal. Methane emissions have been a primary focus of research, and measurements suggest that current estimates may significantly underestimate actual emissions.

The release of hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) near development sites, including fracking operations, has been linked to various adverse health outcomes, such as increased leukemia risk in children and low birth weight. These health impacts are not limited to local communities near fracking sites but also affect older adults in the surrounding areas. The production phase of fracking has been identified as the most critical period for emitting high concentrations and diverse mixtures of air pollutants.

Frequently asked questions