Indian River Lagoon: Pollution's Devastating Impact

The Indian River Lagoon, a biodiverse estuary in Florida, is suffering from a range of environmental issues caused by pollution. The lagoon is home to thousands of species of plants and animals, but they are under threat due to high levels of nutrient pollution from sources such as fertiliser runoff, wastewater, and leaking septic tanks. This has resulted in toxic algae blooms, which block sunlight from reaching and killing seagrass, a vital part of the lagoon's ecosystem and the main source of food for manatees. The pollution has also led to harmful bacteria in the water, making it dangerous for human contact. There have been numerous reports of deaths of pelicans, manatees, fish, sea turtles, and dolphins in the area. Efforts are being made to address the pollution and restore the lagoon's health, but it remains a fragile ecosystem.

Septic tank sewage

The problem is exacerbated by the fact that many of these septic tanks are old, improperly installed, or failing. Heavy rains cause septic systems to fail, sending waste into ditches, canals, and tributaries that lead to the lagoon. While the exact number of failing tanks is unknown, it is estimated that up to 10% of Florida's 2.6 million septic tanks may be failing, which could mean that over 14,000 failing tanks are contributing to the pollution of the Indian River Lagoon.

The impact of septic tank sewage on the lagoon has been the subject of scientific debate, with some arguing that fertilizers and sewage spills are more significant sources of pollution. However, research by Dr. Brian Lapointe of Florida Atlantic University has found that sewage is "the major driver" of algal blooms in the lagoon. Lapointe's research has also linked septic tank sewage to the presence of toxic microalgae in the lagoon, which is believed to have contributed to the deaths of over 130 manatees in 2012.

The Save Our Indian River Lagoon (SOIRL) program is working to address the issue of septic pollution by funding the extension of sewer lines, removing septic systems, and providing financial assistance to homeowners to connect to sewer systems. In areas where connecting to a sewer system is not possible, SOIRL offers grants of up to $18,000 to upgrade conventional septic systems to advanced treatment systems that can remove at least 65% of nitrogen. Since 2018, new construction near the lagoon has been required to connect to a sewer system or install a nitrogen-reducing advanced septic system, and existing septic systems in the lagoon watershed must make these changes by 2030.

Fertilizer runoff

The Indian River Lagoon (IRL) has been facing an ecological crisis due to pollution. One of the main pollutants is fertilizer runoff, which has contributed to the high levels of nutrient pollution in the water.

Fertilizer use has been implicated as the primary source of pollution in the Indian River Lagoon for decades. It was believed that fertilizers were responsible for about 71% of the environmental issues in the lagoon, including harmful algal blooms, seagrass die-offs, and fish kills. As a result, fertilizer restrictions have been implemented in counties and municipalities along the 156-mile-long IRL to reduce nutrient inputs from urban and agricultural sources. These restrictions aim to achieve total maximum daily loads for the lagoon and improve water quality.

However, a recent study by the Florida Atlantic University's Harbor Branch Oceanographic Institute (FAU) has revealed that fertilizer use might not be the root cause of these issues. The study found that recent estimates for residential fertilizer contributions to the IRL are much lower than previously thought. The current nitrogen loading estimates represent a 21% contribution from residential fertilizers compared to 79% from septic systems.

Despite the fertilizer restrictions and blackout periods, water quality and harmful algal blooms have worsened in some areas of the lagoon, leading to unprecedented seagrass die-offs and the starvation of manatees. The FAU study suggests that the increasing concentrations of dissolved inorganic nitrogen and phosphorus observed in some segments of the lagoon, following the fertilizer bans, could be contributing to the worsening trend of algal blooms.

While the findings of the FAU study suggest that sewage, rather than fertilizer, is the main culprit of pollution in the IRL, it is important to note that fertilizer runoff still plays a significant role in the overall pollution of the lagoon. The high levels of nutrients, especially nitrogen, from fertilizer runoff can have devastating effects on the ecosystem, leading to algal blooms, lowered dissolved oxygen in the water, and the loss of marine life.

Nitrogen and phosphorus

Nitrogen is the most abundant element in the air we breathe, and both nitrogen and phosphorus support the growth of algae and aquatic plants. However, when there is too much nitrogen and phosphorus in the water, it can fuel the growth of harmful algal blooms. These blooms can decrease oxygen levels in the water, leading to fish kills and creating dead zones where aquatic life cannot survive. The Indian River Lagoon has experienced these issues, with excessive algae growth harming water quality, food resources, and habitats.

The sources of nitrogen and phosphorus pollution in the Indian River Lagoon are diverse. They include agricultural activities, such as the use of chemical fertilizers and animal manure, as well as residential contributions like lawn fertilization and septic systems. Stormwater runoff also plays a significant role, as it can wash nutrients from fertilized soils and carry them into waterways.

The impacts of nitrogen and phosphorus pollution in the Indian River Lagoon are far-reaching. It has led to a decline in seagrass health and oyster beds, which are essential for filtering and cleaning the water. The pollution has also had economic effects, with tourism losses and negative impacts on commercial fishing and property values in the region.

Addressing nitrogen and phosphorus pollution in the Indian River Lagoon requires a multi-faceted approach. Implementing fertilizer restrictions and improving wastewater treatment infrastructure are crucial steps. Additionally, reducing nutrient inputs from septic systems and managing stormwater runoff more effectively can help mitigate the issue.

Algal blooms

The excess nutrients cause an overgrowth of algae, which blocks sunlight from reaching seagrass and reduces dissolved oxygen in the water, leading to the death of fish and other marine organisms. The Indian River Lagoon is home to seven species of seagrass, which provide food, shelter, and oxygen for a variety of marine life. The loss of seagrass has had a devastating impact on the ecosystem, with fish populations declining and manatees starving due to the loss of their primary food source.

In addition to the environmental impacts, the algal blooms also pose a potential threat to human health. Studies have found that the blooms contain toxins that can be harmful to humans, and the presence of these toxins is not always associated with blooms of known toxin-producing organisms.

Efforts to reduce the algal blooms have been made, including projects to dredge muck, upgrade septic tanks, repair leaks in pipelines, and slow stormwater using techniques such as baffle boxes and permeable pavers. However, the restoration of the Indian River Lagoon is a long and challenging process, and it will require continued commitment and investment to achieve lasting results.

While there have been some setbacks, such as the impact of Hurricane Ian, which caused wastewater spills and stormwater outflows, there are also signs of progress. Natural resource managers working to reduce the influx of nutrients have reported that the lagoon's restoration is still attainable, and some seagrass has started to return in areas with improved water clarity.

Water quality

The Indian River Lagoon (IRL) is a 240-km-long estuary in east-central Florida, considered North America's most diverse estuary. It is a valuable asset to Florida's economy, and the health of its ecosystem is critical to its value.

The water quality of the Indian River Lagoon is facing a crisis due to pollution, with the biggest threat being harmful algae blooms. These blooms are caused by excess nitrogen and phosphorus in the water, which supports the growth of algae and aquatic plants. However, when too much nitrogen and phosphorus enter the environment, the water quality is significantly impacted. This is known as nutrient pollution and is often caused by human activities such as agriculture and the use of fertilizers and animal manure.

In the case of the Indian River Lagoon, nutrients enter the water through the canal system built for flood control, as well as through residential and commercial septic systems. The enlargement of the Lagoon's watershed has also increased drainage, altering the natural water flow and contributing to the nutrient loading in the water. The result is a decline in water quality, with algae blooms reducing oxygen levels, causing fish kills, and producing toxins harmful to humans and animals.

Another form of pollution affecting the Lagoon is stormwater runoff, which carries excess fertilizers, household chemicals, trash, heavy metals, and other pollutants into the water. This is particularly problematic in urban areas, where impermeable surfaces such as roads and parking lots prevent rainwater from soaking into the ground, leading to increased runoff into the Lagoon.

The decline in water quality has severe consequences for the diverse habitats in the Lagoon, including seagrass meadows, oyster beds, and mangrove habitats. It also affects the economy, degrading the commercial and recreational value of the Lagoon's water resources.

To address the water quality issues, resource managers must improve wastewater treatment infrastructure and reduce nutrient pollution. Monitoring water quality is essential to generate real-time data and inform management decisions to improve the health of the Indian River Lagoon.

Frequently asked questions