Octane's Impact: Air Pollution And Its Sources

Octane is a gasoline additive that is required for the proper functioning of modern engines. The octane number of gasoline is an important parameter that determines the fuel quality. While octane is essential for the functioning of engines, the production and use of gasoline contribute to air pollution. The vapors given off when gasoline evaporates and the substances produced when it is burned (carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and unburned hydrocarbons) contribute to air pollution. Burning gasoline also produces carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas. The Clean Air Act, first passed in 1970, seeks to reduce air pollution in the United States by requiring engines and fuels to produce fewer emissions. This has led to the development of various regulations and technologies to reduce pollution from gasoline use, such as emissions-control devices, cleaner-burning engines, and the reduction of gasoline leaks. The use of octane additives has been a key focus of these efforts, with the goal of finding additives that boost octane without causing toxic emissions.

Octane additives and their health and environmental consequences

Octane additives have been a cornerstone of US environmental policy, with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulating compounds that endanger human health and aiming to reduce harmful tailpipe emissions from cars and trucks. Octane is a gasoline additive that is required for the proper functioning of modern engines.

Health and Environmental Consequences of Octane Additives

Octane sources have evolved over the years, with both renewable and petroleum-based options being utilised. Some of the most common octane sources and their consequences are detailed below:

• Lead: Lead was a preferred octane source due to its lower production cost. However, it was phased out in the US starting in the mid-1970s due to serious health impacts. Lead was linked to suspected lead poisoning deaths among refinery workers, and longer-term exposure was warned to potentially result in chronic degenerative diseases. Today, lead has been eliminated from gasoline in most parts of the world.
• Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether (MTBE): MTBE is a petroleum-based octane additive that was widely used in reformulated gasoline (RFG) due to its ease of transport and blending. While it helped reduce ozone precursors and other air toxics during combustion, concerns arose over its solubility in water, leading to water resource contamination in multiple states. As a result, MTBE usage has significantly declined.
• Benzene and Other Aromatics: Aromatics like benzene, toluene, and xylene are components of the BTEX complex, a high-octane petroleum refining product. While BTEX usage increased initially after the lead phase-out, concerns were raised about its potential threats to the environment and public health. EPA regulations have since reduced the volume of aromatics in conventional gasoline, but health professionals continue to question the safety of even these lower levels.
• Ethanol: Ethanol is a renewable biofuel that has gained prominence as an octane source. It has lower lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions than conventional gasoline and is an excellent octane provider. However, some have questioned the safety of ethanol blends, and it is currently blended with gasoline to produce E10, which contains 90% gasoline.
• Manganese Tricarbonyl: While manganese additives can increase the octane number, they come with health and environmental trade-offs. Manganese tricarbonyl is toxic and can lead to increased wear and carbon formation on spark plugs and in the combustion chamber.
• N-Methylaniline: N-Methylaniline is an effective octane booster, with a small amount capable of increasing the octane number significantly. However, it has been forbidden for use in certain fuels in several countries, including the US, due to potential negative consequences.

The evolution of octane sources and additives has been characterised by trade-offs between performance, efficiency, and environmental and health risks. Regulations have played a critical role in addressing these trade-offs, and the continuous emergence of new risks has led to the need for more dynamic regulation.

The role of octane in the evolution of fuel regulations

Octane is a crucial parameter in the evolution of fuel regulations, as it determines a fuel's ability to avoid 'knock', a condition where fuel combusts unevenly, causing potential damage to the engine. The history of octane additives in gasoline reflects technological advancements, evolving public health knowledge, and environmental awareness. Initially, toxic substances like lead were used to boost octane levels, but the health and environmental consequences led to a shift towards more sustainable alternatives.

The evolution of octane in fuel regulations has been influenced by three key factors: consumer preferences, technical capabilities, and regulatory legislation. The quest for an effective and cheap octane booster began in the early 20th century, with the discovery of tetraethyl lead (TEL) as a potent octane-boosting additive. However, as the adverse effects of lead became evident, regulators and the industry sought alternatives. This led to the emergence of other octane sources, both renewable and petroleum-based, such as methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) and ethanol, a biofuel.

The Clean Air Act (CAA), first passed in 1970, played a significant role in reducing air pollution from engines and fuels. The EPA, formed under this act, was given the authority to regulate compounds that endanger human health, leading to the phased reduction of lead content in gasoline. The 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments further tightened regulations by requiring cleaner-burning reformulated gasoline to reduce air pollution in metropolitan areas with high ground-level ozone pollution.

As the understanding of octane's impact on the environment grew, the EPA continued to update regulations. In 2007, the EPA addressed hazardous air pollutants from mobile sources, capping benzene content in gasoline at 0.62%, down from 1.3%. This update also encouraged the use of benign additives to replace toxic aromatics used to boost octane. The regulation of MTBE, a successful ozone precursor reducer, was phased out due to its negative impact on water resources.

Today, the primary sources of octane in the US gasoline supply are the BTEX complex, a petroleum refining product, and ethanol, which is blended with gasoline to produce E10. Ethanol not only boosts octane levels but also burns cleaner, reducing harmful emissions and offering a more sustainable alternative to traditional gasoline. As the world moves towards reducing fossil fuel reliance, ethanol is expected to play a more significant role in the gasoline supply, with automakers and policymakers exploring higher ethanol blends.

The impact of octane on carbon dioxide emissions

Octane is a gasoline additive that is required for the proper functioning of modern engines. It does not have an inherent energy value but is rather a measure of how well a gas resists premature detonation in an engine. The octane number of gasoline is one of the most important parameters that determine fuel quality.

Over the years, octane sources have taken many forms, both renewable and petroleum-based. Some of these include lead, methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE), benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene, xylene (BTEX), and ethanol (a biofuel). As adverse health and environmental consequences were discovered for lead and petroleum-based octane providers, they have been removed from the fuel supply or decreased.

Today, the two primary sources of octane used in the US gasoline supply are the BTEX complex, a petroleum refining product commonly referred to as gasoline aromatics, and ethanol. The Clean Air Act (CAAA) gives the EPA the authority to use benign additives to replace the toxic aromatics used to boost octane in gasoline.

While the octane rating of fuel does not seem to affect a car's per-mile carbon dioxide emissions, it does have an impact on emissions during the production phase. Premium gas is made by adding oxygenates or hydrocarbons that contain one or more oxygen atoms. This process consumes more energy than making regular gas, and thus, the production of premium gas results in higher carbon dioxide emissions.

In addition, the use of higher-octane gasoline in older vehicles can lead to increased carbon emissions. This is because fuel-injection engines are typically designed to handle a specific grade of gasoline, usually the least expensive 87-octane "regular" fuel. Using a higher-octane gasoline than what is recommended for the vehicle can result in inefficient combustion and increased carbon dioxide emissions.

To reduce carbon dioxide emissions, it is important to choose the right octane gasoline for your vehicle and to follow engine maintenance recommendations. Additionally, driving less, carpooling, and using mass transit can help reduce carbon pollution from vehicles.

The use of octane in aircraft engines and its contribution to air pollution

Octane is a gasoline additive that is required for the proper functioning of modern engines. It is particularly important for aviation engines, as it determines the performance and versatility of the aircraft. The higher the octane rating, the higher the activation energy, or the amount of applied energy required to initiate combustion.

The use of octane in aircraft engines has been a significant contributor to air pollution. Aviation gasoline, or avgas, is used in aircraft with spark-ignited internal combustion engines. These engines are commonly found in general aviation piston aircraft. The octane rating of avgas is extremely important, as it was found to be during World War II, when the performance of aircraft was directly linked to the octane rating of the fuel.

The most common grade of avgas is 100LL, which has an aviation lean rating of 100 octane and an aviation rich rating of 130 octane. The lean setting is used for cruising, while the rich setting is used for take-off and other full-power conditions. The higher octane rating allows for a wider range of operating conditions, which is essential for aircraft performance.

However, the use of leaded avgas has been a significant source of air pollution. Tetraethyl lead, a toxic additive, is used to increase the octane rating and prevent engine knocking. While the use of lead in motor gasoline has been reduced since the 1970s to allow for the use of catalytic converters and reduce pollution, avgas still contains lead. This is because many aircraft engines are designed to use leaded fuels, and an unleaded replacement fuel is still being developed and certified.

Efforts are being made to reduce or eliminate the use of lead in aviation gasoline. In 2008, the annual US usage of avgas was 186 million US gallons, and it has been declining consistently by approximately 7.5 million US gallons each year. As of 2024, the annual US usage of avgas was 180 million US gallons, with most of it containing lead. The development of unleaded replacement fuels and the conversion to diesel engines burning jet fuel are encouraging steps towards reducing the use of leaded avgas and its contribution to air pollution.

The trade-offs between reducing emissions and preserving engine performance

Octane is a gasoline additive that is necessary for the proper functioning of modern engines. The vapours and substances produced by burning gasoline contribute to air pollution. As a result, reducing air pollution has been a cornerstone of US environmental policy.

The Clean Air Act, first passed in 1970, requires engines and fuels to produce less air pollution. The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has taken several actions to reduce pollution from gasoline use, including requiring emissions-control devices and cleaner-burning engines.

To preserve engine performance, engine shops must take steps to prevent high-performance engines from losing their edge. This includes reducing bore and ring wear, as well as valve seal wear.

However, there are trade-offs between reducing emissions and preserving engine performance. For example, while electric vehicles produce zero emissions, combustion engine vehicles will continue to be on the roads for the foreseeable future. This means that automakers must also focus on improving the efficiency of combustion engines to reduce their environmental impact.

One way to improve efficiency and reduce emissions is to transition to cleaner-burning fuels, such as ethanol, which has a high octane rating and lower lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions than conventional gasoline. Another approach is to improve engine technology, such as through hybridisation and light-weighting, which can reduce fuel consumption and emissions.

Regulations have played a significant role in reducing air pollution. However, the evolution of regulations and technologies has also led to new risks and unintended consequences. As a result, it is important to consider the broader developments in the industry when addressing environmental issues.

Frequently asked questions