Gas Furnace Emissions: Indoor Air Quality Concerns?

Gas appliances are a source of indoor and outdoor air pollution, with studies showing that gas cooktops and ovens affect indoor air quality the most. Gas-powered furnaces, which are generally vented to the outdoors, also contribute to indoor air pollution, particularly when they are installed improperly, or if vents and chimneys get blocked. Gas furnaces have been found to emit dangerous levels of nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide, which have been linked to asthma, cancer, heart disease, and other health problems. Given the health risks associated with gas appliances, there has been a growing movement to switch to electric alternatives.

Gas furnaces emit harmful nitrogen oxides

Gas appliances, including furnaces, pollute indoor and outdoor air. Gas-powered appliances burn fossil fuels, which have been linked to increased death rates from COVID-19 and other health issues, especially in low-income communities.

Gas stoves and ovens are the gas appliances that contribute most to indoor air pollution, as they are not typically vented outdoors like water heaters and furnaces. However, gas furnaces are still a concern, as they are a major factor in elevated nitrogen dioxide concentrations. A study of Australian homes found that the presence of a gas-fired heating furnace resulted in higher mean peak-to-average nitrogen dioxide ratios.

Indoor air pollution from gas appliances is challenging to eliminate completely, and malfunctioning gas appliances or gas lines can further increase the risk of pollution. Gas appliances can also emit other harmful substances, such as carbon monoxide, benzene, formaldehyde, and particulate matter.

To mitigate the risks associated with gas furnaces and other gas appliances, it is recommended to use exhaust fans vented outdoors, ensure proper ventilation and appliance maintenance, and consider replacing gas appliances with electric alternatives.

Gas furnaces can cause carbon monoxide poisoning

A study by the Rocky Mountain Institute, in collaboration with Physicians for Social Responsibility, found that cooking on gas can increase emissions of nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide to levels that violate outdoor pollution standards. Gas cooktops and ovens affect indoor air quality the most, while outdoor air quality is most impacted by gas-fuelled furnaces and water heaters that vent combustion gases outside.

Carbon monoxide poisoning from gas furnaces is a serious issue. It can cause headaches, dizziness, vomiting, and nausea, and if the levels are high enough, it can even lead to death. Low or negative indoor air pressure can cause a backdraft of the gas furnace exhaust, resulting in combustion fumes being sucked back into the home. A cracked heat exchanger, clogged or damaged furnace flues, and a malfunctioning furnace can all lead to dangerous levels of carbon monoxide being distributed throughout the home.

Additionally, modern "tight" homes that are built to be energy-efficient and airtight can contribute to CO buildup. These homes restrict outside airflow, which inhibits CO from dissipating when a gas furnace is improperly installed or experiencing issues. It is recommended that residents with gas appliances, especially older ones, own multiple carbon monoxide detectors to protect themselves from potential poisoning.

Gas stoves are a bigger indoor pollution source

Gas stoves are a significant contributor to indoor air pollution. The combustion of natural gas releases hazardous pollutants, including nitrogen dioxide, benzene, formaldehyde, and particulate matter, which are known to cause or worsen respiratory illnesses such as asthma. Unlike other gas appliances like furnaces, dryers, and water heaters, stoves are not required to be vented outdoors, allowing these pollutants to accumulate inside homes.

Research has found that gas stoves can lead to kitchen concentrations of nitrogen oxides that exceed national and state outdoor air quality standards in over 90% of modelled scenarios. This is particularly concerning for vulnerable individuals, including the elderly, children, and those with pre-existing health conditions. Low-income households, which often have inadequate ventilation and older, poorly maintained appliances, are at an even greater risk of exposure to these harmful pollutants.

The health risks associated with gas stoves have sparked a movement towards electrification, with scientists, environmental groups, and even chefs advocating for the adoption of electric or induction stoves, which produce fewer indoor pollutants and are more energy-efficient. Electric alternatives have been shown to significantly improve indoor air quality and reduce the health risks associated with gas stove usage.

While gas furnaces can also contribute to indoor air pollution, the impact of gas stoves is more pronounced due to the lack of mandatory venting requirements and the direct release of pollutants into living spaces. The high usage rate of gas stoves, with nearly 70% of California homes using them for cooking, further exacerbates the problem. Therefore, addressing gas stove pollution is crucial in improving indoor air quality and protecting the health of those who reside in homes with gas appliances.

Poor ventilation exacerbates indoor air pollution

Gas appliances, including furnaces, have been found to pollute indoor air. Gas cooktops and ovens affect indoor air quality the most, while gas-fueled furnaces and water heaters impact outdoor air quality. Gas appliances release hazardous air pollutants, such as nitrogen dioxide, benzene, formaldehyde, and particulate matter, directly into homes. These pollutants are linked to asthma, cancer, heart disease, and other health issues.

In the context of gas appliances, incomplete combustion and poor ventilation can lead to the accumulation of dangerous contaminants, such as carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides. Gas cooktops, for example, should be used with fans that vent exhaust outside to prevent the buildup of harmful pollutants. Similarly, gas-fired heating appliances should be sealed and equipped with power-vented systems to remove products of incomplete combustion.

The impact of poor ventilation is particularly pronounced in smaller, overcrowded spaces, where air pollution can become more concentrated. Low-income communities, renters, and the elderly are especially vulnerable to the health consequences of inadequate ventilation and exposure to toxic air. They may have limited control over the type of appliances in their homes and are more likely to have older, unmaintained, or improperly ventilated appliances.

To mitigate the effects of poor ventilation, it is essential to ensure proper ventilation and appliance maintenance. Regular maintenance of ventilation systems, such as HVAC systems, can minimize the spread of pollutants throughout the home. Additionally, the use of fans, exhaust systems, and natural ventilation by opening windows can help remove moisture and improve indoor air quality.

Gas furnaces are linked to childhood asthma

Gas furnaces have been linked to a host of health issues, particularly in children. Gas appliances, including furnaces, have been found to pollute indoor air, and children are especially susceptible to the negative health effects of this air pollution.

Gas-burning stoves in kitchens are responsible for a significant proportion of childhood asthma cases. A study published in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health found that gas stoves cause around 12.7% of childhood asthma cases in the United States, a figure comparable to the childhood asthma risks associated with secondhand smoke exposure. This study adds to the growing body of research highlighting the potential dangers of gas stoves to public health and the environment.

Another study in Victoria, Australia, found a strong association between gas stove exposure and asthma diagnosis, with a relative risk of 2.23. Even after adjusting for nitrogen dioxide (NO2) concentration, the association between gas stove use and respiratory symptoms remained significant, suggesting that other pollutants or unmeasured factors related to gas stove use may be responsible for the health effects.

The combustion of gas indoors releases gases such as nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide, as well as particulate matter, which can trigger asthma and exacerbate existing respiratory conditions. Gas stoves, in particular, emit these pollutants directly into areas where residents spend a lot of time, and they are often not properly vented to the outdoors. In smaller households, air pollution can become more concentrated, further increasing the risk of exposure.

The link between gas furnaces and childhood asthma is a pressing issue, given that gas stoves are commonly used for cooking in many countries, including Australia and the United States. It is estimated that 38% of Australian homes and 35% of US households cook with gas stoves. The high prevalence of gas stove usage, coupled with the daily occurrence of cooking, increases the potential for children to be exposed to asthma-inducing pollutants.

To reduce the impact of gas furnaces and stoves on childhood asthma, several measures can be implemented. These include using range hoods that vent to the outdoors when cooking, ensuring proper ventilation during and after cooking by opening windows, and transitioning to highly efficient electric appliances, such as induction cooktops, when possible.

Frequently asked questions