Ovens And Pollution: What's Cooking?

Ovens and stoves are a common source of indoor pollution, which can have serious health impacts. Gas stoves, in particular, have been found to emit pollutants that irritate airways and can cause or worsen respiratory illnesses. The combustion of gas releases chemicals such as nitrogen oxide, nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, and formaldehyde, which linger in the home for hours. These pollutants can lead to dizziness, fatigue, headaches, nausea, and more severe health issues, including an increased risk of cancer. While all stoves contribute to some extent, gas stoves are the biggest offenders, with electric stoves being a cleaner alternative. However, the decision to switch from gas to electric is often influenced by factors such as cost, convenience, and personal preferences, leading to a ongoing debate about how to address the health and environmental risks associated with gas stove usage.

Gas stoves emit nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide and formaldehyde

Gas stoves emit nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, and formaldehyde, which can cause serious health issues, especially for children. Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) is a toxic gas that can trigger breathing problems for people with asthma or chronic pulmonary disease, even in low concentrations. Long-term exposure to NO2 has been linked to thousands of deaths each year, with a possible estimate of 19,000, which is around 40% of the number of deaths attributed to secondhand smoke. In addition, NO2 exposure increases the chances of children developing respiratory illnesses by about 20%, according to a 1992 study.

Gas stoves are a significant source of indoor air pollution, with levels of nitrogen dioxide often exceeding safe thresholds set by health organizations. The pollution from gas stoves can spread beyond the kitchen, affecting the entire household. A study by Rob Jackson, a sustainability researcher at Stanford University, found that NO2 concentrations in bedrooms located farthest from the kitchen exceeded health benchmarks within an hour of gas stove use and remained elevated for hours.

Carbon monoxide (CO) is an invisible, odourless gas that can be life-threatening at high concentrations. While CO poisoning from gas stoves is typically associated with malfunctions, such as a constantly burning pilot light or poor ventilation, it poses a significant risk. Formaldehyde (CH2O or HCHO) is another harmful pollutant emitted by gas stoves, contributing to the adverse health impacts on residents, particularly those with respiratory conditions.

The impact of gas stove emissions extends beyond individual health concerns. Gas stoves are connected to a supply system that leaks methane, a potent greenhouse gas. The release of methane during drilling, fracking, processing, and transportation contributes to climate change. Efforts to address this issue include California's new standards, which will require improved ventilation for gas stoves starting in 2023, and the Biden administration's plan to incentivize the transition to electric appliances.

To mitigate the pollution caused by gas stoves, some cities and states have passed legislation to phase out gas stoves and appliances in new construction projects. Additionally, regulatory bodies are considering measures such as mandating the sale of gas stoves with fume hoods or better-fitted pipes to prevent leaks. While the gas utility industry has resisted these changes, the growing awareness of the health and environmental risks associated with gas stove emissions is driving a push toward electrification and improved ventilation solutions.

Gas appliances can leak methane

Gas appliances, such as stoves, water heaters, furnaces, and driers, can leak methane, a potent greenhouse gas. This can occur even when the appliances are turned off, with one study finding that up to 80% of methane emissions from stoves happen when the appliances are off due to loose couplings and fittings. The impact of gas stove leaks in the US is significant, with an estimated 40 million gas stoves in the country, contributing to indoor air pollution and climate change. The gas utility industry has been accused of downplaying the science on indoor air quality and investing in campaigns to promote the use of gas stoves.

The health risks associated with gas stove emissions are well-documented. Gas stoves emit pollutants, including nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and fine particulate matter (PM2.5), which can irritate airways and cause or exacerbate respiratory problems. Studies have shown that children are particularly vulnerable, with a higher risk of developing respiratory illnesses and asthma. The impact of NO2 exposure is not limited to the kitchen, as it can spread to other areas of the home, including bedrooms.

To address the issue of methane leaks and reduce indoor air pollution, some cities and states have passed legislation to phase out gas appliances in new construction and promote electric alternatives. California, for example, has set new standards for ventilation requirements for gas stoves and is working towards ending the sale of gas furnaces and water heaters by 2030.

While switching to electric appliances is the most effective solution, it may not be feasible for everyone, especially renters. In such cases, it is recommended to use a range hood or open windows while cooking to improve ventilation and reduce the concentration of pollutants. However, the effectiveness of range hoods can vary, and some may not adequately vent pollution outside.

The gas industry is also exploring cleaner alternatives, such as "renewable natural gas" from agriculture and hydrogen produced with renewable energy. Additionally, efforts are being made to replace older pipes that leak and improve emission reduction across their networks.

Cooking with gas can cause or worsen respiratory illnesses

Additionally, unburned natural gas leaks from stoves contain benzene, a known carcinogen. Cooking with gas has also been linked to more severe asthma symptoms in people with asthma, as well as an increased risk of chronic lung disease and increased mortality. Women who cook with gas have been found to have reduced lung function and increased airways obstruction compared to women who do not.

The impact of breathing NO2 indoors is similar to breathing it outdoors. The levels of NO2 in homes with gas stoves can remain elevated for hours, even in rooms far from the kitchen. Ventilation can help reduce the concentrations of NO2, but it may not always be effective. The only way to completely prevent gas stove emissions is to switch to electric appliances.

The gas utility industry has downplayed the science on gas stoves and indoor air quality, emphasizing the affordability of cooking with gas. However, environmental groups and regulatory bodies are pushing for more ventilation requirements and incentives to switch to electric appliances. Some cities have already passed legislation to phase out gas stoves and appliances in new construction.

Gas stoves are the greatest offenders when it comes to kitchen pollution

Gas stoves are a major source of indoor air pollution, emitting unsafe levels of nitrogen dioxide and other pollutants that can irritate airways and cause or worsen respiratory illnesses. Studies have found that gas stoves increase the risk of asthma in children and that exposure to nitrogen dioxide is linked to the development of respiratory illnesses in children. Gas stoves also emit fine particulate matter, known as PM2.5, which is a known irritant and can exacerbate respiratory problems.

In addition to nitrogen dioxide and particulate matter, gas stoves also release other toxic chemicals into homes, including benzene, a known carcinogen, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These pollutants can linger in the home for hours, even outside the kitchen, and can have both acute and long-term health effects. Long-term exposure to nitrogen dioxide has been linked to chronic lung disease and increased mortality.

The impact of breathing nitrogen dioxide indoors is no different from breathing it outdoors. A study by Josiah Kephart, an environmental epidemiologist, found that boiling a pot of water and baking muffins on a gas stove resulted in nitrogen dioxide levels that exceeded the World Health Organization's (WHO) hourly guideline by 50%. After half an hour, the levels were nearly twice the WHO guideline. This level of pollution can be harmful to those with lung conditions or children, as it can worsen their symptoms or disease.

While regulatory bodies have not banned the use of gas stoves outright, some cities in California and New York have passed legislation to phase out gas stoves and other gas appliances in new construction. To reduce the health risks associated with gas stoves, experts recommend improving ventilation by using range hoods that vent to the outside or opening windows while cooking. Some also suggest replacing gas stoves with electric stoves, which do not produce the same level of pollution.

Electric stoves are a less-polluting alternative to gas

The combustion of organic fuel (gas) in gas stoves releases these harmful pollutants into indoor air, which can have detrimental effects on health, especially for children. A 1992 meta-analysis found that nitrogen dioxide exposure from gas stoves increases the likelihood of children developing respiratory illnesses by about 20%. A 2013 study further linked gas stove exposure to a higher risk of asthma in children. Moreover, gas stoves can leak pollutants even when they are turned off, and the leakage can occur wherever there is a natural gas utility connection in the home.

On the other hand, electric stoves generate heat through an electric current passed through a coiled copper wire, creating a magnetic current that directly heats the cookware. This method of heating is more precise and powerful, allowing for faster boiling of water while maintaining constant and precise temperatures. Electric stoves also eliminate the risk of gas leaks and the associated health risks, as the combustion occurs off-site at a power plant or other energy source.

While the environmental impact of electric stoves depends on the energy source used to generate the electricity, they are still a preferred option for reducing indoor air pollution. Regulatory bodies are considering measures such as requiring gas stoves to be sold with fume hoods or better-fitted pipes to prevent leaks. However, some cities have already passed legislation to phase out gas stoves and appliances in new construction projects.

In summary, electric stoves offer a less-polluting alternative to gas stoves, improving indoor air quality and reducing health risks associated with gas combustion and leakage.

Frequently asked questions