Revolution's Pollution: Communism's Dirty Secret

Despite the promise of environmental protection under socialist regimes, Communist countries have historically suffered from some of the worst pollution on Earth. The Soviet Union, Eastern Europe, and China have all experienced severe environmental degradation, with little regard for future consequences. This has been attributed to the central planning of Communist governments, which often results in the misallocation of resources and a focus on heavy industry and industrial production, leading to increased energy consumption and pollution. The environmental consequences of Communism have been so severe that they played a significant role in the fall of Communist governments, with the Chernobyl disaster being a notable example of the government's failure to address ecological concerns.

The Soviet Union's environmental laws had no perceivable benefit

Despite the existence of a vast body of environmental laws and regulations in the Soviet Union, these constraints had no perceivable benefit in addressing the country's pollution issues. This was due in part to the "tragedy of the commons," where communally or governmentally owned property is treated as a free resource, leading to inevitable overuse and depletion of natural resources.

One example of environmental degradation in the Soviet Union is the destruction of forest land in the Lake Baikal region. Thousands of acres of forests have been decimated, leading to erosion and dust storms. The once-lush landscape surrounding the lake has been replaced by shifting sands, threatening the lake's very existence as it faces the possibility of being swallowed by the nearby Gobi Desert.

The Soviet Union's pursuit of industrialization also had detrimental effects on the environment. In their quest for coal, the Communist government employed bulldozers on a massive scale, turning towns, farms, and woodlands into barren deserts and hollows. Open-pit mining, though cheaper than underground mining, has led to the devastation of vast areas in Czechoslovakia.

The consequences of industrialization extend beyond the loss of natural habitats. In Leipzig, East Germany, half of the children are treated annually for illnesses associated with air pollution. The waters of eastern Germany have not fared better, with 80% of surface waters unfit for fishing, recreational activities, or drinking. The chemical waste dumped into these waters has led to one out of three lakes being biologically dead.

While some regions, like Upper Silesia, have implemented reforms to combat pollution, the progress has been slow. Despite environmental safeguards and compulsory filters in factory stacks, the underlying issue of industrialization remains a persistent challenge.

In summary, while the Soviet Union had environmental laws in place, they failed to effectively curb pollution and prevent environmental degradation. The country's pursuit of industrialization, combined with the "tragedy of the commons," resulted in the overuse of natural resources and severe ecological consequences.

Communist countries suffer from the worst pollution on Earth

While pollution is not unique to capitalist nations, communist countries have been observed to suffer from the worst pollution on Earth. In the Soviet Union, for instance, there was a vast body of environmental law and regulation, but these constraints had no perceivable benefit. The Soviet Union, like all socialist countries, suffered from a massive "tragedy of the commons," a term used by biologist Garrett Hardin in his classic 1968 article. Where property is communally or governmentally owned and treated as a free resource, resources will inevitably be overused with little regard for future consequences.

In Russia, a huge chemical plant was built right beside a beloved tourist attraction: Yasnaya Polyana, Leo Tolstoy's country estate. Unmonitored fumes are poisoning Tolstoy's forests of oak and pine, and conservationists are powerless to do anything about it. With equal indifference, the Soviet pulp and paper industry has settled on the shores of Lake Baikal, defiling the world's purest waters. The level of the Caspian Sea has dropped 81 ft. since 1929, mainly due to dams and irrigation projects along the Volga and Ural rivers diverting incoming water.

In East Germany, only one-sixth of the country's rivers could provide drinking water. Air pollution in Prague was reported to be far above internationally accepted levels, and in the Slovak capital, Bratislava, some people use bottled mineral water to brush their teeth. In Poland, 41 animal species have reportedly become extinct in recent years, and health statistics are alarming. A recent study of the Katowice region found that 21% of children up to 4 years old are frequently sick, and 41% of children under 6 have serious health problems. Life expectancy for men is lower than it was 20 years ago.

In Czechoslovakia, open-pit mining has devastated the land. In Leipzig, half of the children are treated each year for illnesses associated with air pollution, and 80% of eastern Germany's surface waters are unsuitable for fishing, sports, or drinking. One out of three lakes has been declared biologically dead due to decades of untreated dumping of chemical waste.

While communist countries have implemented environmental control programs and made efforts to address pollution, the results have been slow. Sulphur-dioxide emissions from smokestacks remain a significant issue, and industrial development often takes priority over environmental concerns.

Communist regimes' runaway industrialization causes environmental issues

Communism and socialism are associated with some of the worst pollution on Earth. Communist countries, such as the former Soviet Union, China, and former Communist countries in Eastern and Central Europe, have suffered from severe environmental issues as a result of their runaway industrialization.

One of the key features of Marxism that contributes to this is the "labor theory of value," which treats nature solely as a provider of resources for human consumption. This, combined with the denial of individual responsibility, leads to a reckless disregard for the environmental consequences of industrialization. The socialist goal of "transforming the world" also encourages "gigantomania," a desire for grandiose technological feats. This results in a single-minded focus on industrialization and economic growth, with little regard for the environmental costs.

The pursuit of coal and other natural resources has led to the devastation of vast areas of land in Communist countries. In Czechoslovakia, for example, open-pit mining has turned towns, farms, and woodlands into "coarse brown deserts and gaping hollows." Similarly, in Poland, thousands of acres of forest around Lake Baikal have been destroyed, causing dust storms and the potential advancement of the Gobi Desert into Siberia. The construction of dams and irrigation projects has also caused the water level of the Caspian Sea to drop by 81 feet since 1929.

Air and water pollution are also significant issues in Communist countries. In East Germany, 40% of the population suffers from pollutants in the air, and 50% of the children in Leipzig are treated annually for illnesses associated with air pollution. Eighty percent of the surface waters in East Germany are unsuitable for fishing, sports, or drinking, and one-third of the lakes have been declared biologically dead due to chemical waste. In Poland's Upper Silesia region, circulatory disease levels are 15% higher, respiratory disease is 47% higher, and there has been a concerning increase in the number of children with developmental issues.

While some Communist countries have attempted to address these environmental issues, their efforts have often been too little, too late. For example, in 1965, the provincial government in Upper Silesia recognized the need to strengthen its environmental control program, and while some progress has been made, the region continues to face significant ecological challenges. Ultimately, the structural and ideological constraints of Communist regimes have hindered their ability to effectively address the environmental consequences of their runaway industrialization.

Environmental concerns played a role in bringing down Communist governments

While capitalist nations are often criticised for their environmental impact, socialist countries have historically suffered from worse pollution. The Soviet Union, for example, had a vast body of environmental law and regulation, but these constraints had no perceivable benefit. In reality, the socialist world suffers from some of the worst pollution on Earth.

In the 1970s, pollution in Communist countries was a growing concern. In Russia, a huge chemical plant was built beside Yasnaya Polyana, Leo Tolstoy's country estate. The unmonitored fumes are poisoning the forests of oak and pine. In Poland, 41 animal species have reportedly become extinct in recent years, and health statistics are alarming. In Upper Silesia, an industrial region, circulatory disease levels are 15% higher, and respiratory disease is 47% higher. In East Germany, nearly 40% of the population suffers from pollutants in the air, and half of the children in Leipzig are treated each year for illnesses associated with air pollution.

In the late 1980s, the Communist dream of a proletarian workers' revolt was fulfilled, but ironically, it was directed at the Communist governments themselves. This was due to a growing yearning for democracy and human rights, as well as a desire for higher standards of living. However, it was environmental concerns that crystallised the sentiment that these regimes could be overthrown. The Chernobyl disaster, for example, precipitated a crippling crisis in the USSR, discrediting the government and emboldening its critics.

Moderately large "green" movements played a role in the toppling of Communist governments, and the environmental crisis in one country would weaken Communist regimes in neighbouring countries, often with environmental groups leading the way.

Communist countries' fixation on heavy industry leads to more pollution

Communist countries have historically displayed a fixation on heavy industry, which has had detrimental effects on the environment and contributed to high levels of pollution. This focus on industrialization was driven by the belief that it was necessary for the country's economic and military development, as well as becoming an ideological necessity.

The Soviet Union, for example, had a massive "tragedy of the commons," where communally or governmentally owned resources were overused with little regard for the future. This led to severe environmental degradation, with examples such as the destruction of forests around Lake Baikal and the dropping water levels of the Caspian Sea due to damming and irrigation projects. Similarly, in Czechoslovakia, open-pit mining practices turned towns, farms, and woodlands into barren landscapes.

Communist countries' pursuit of industrialization often came at the cost of the environment and public health. In Poland, the heavily industrialized region of Upper Silesia experienced high levels of pollution, with health consequences such as increased circulatory and respiratory diseases, and developmental issues in children. East Germany faced similar issues, with polluted surface waters and poor air quality impacting the health of the population.

The fixation on heavy industry in Communist countries resulted in a chronic underproduction of consumer goods, leading to shortages and long lines at grocery stores. This indicated a misallocation of resources and a disregard for the well-being of the people.

While some efforts were made to address pollution, such as environmental reforms in Upper Silesia, the scale of the problem and the resistance from industrial managers made it a challenging task. The Communist regime's centralized decision-making and emphasis on industrialization often took precedence over environmental concerns, resulting in a legacy of pollution that continues to impact these regions today.

Frequently asked questions