Diesel Cars: Polluting Our Planet, Harming Our Health

Diesel cars have been the subject of much negative publicity due to the amount of toxic emissions they produce. While diesel fuel contains more carbon than petrol, diesel cars have lower CO₂ emissions. However, diesel engines produce nitrogen oxides, including toxic nitrogen dioxide and nitrous oxide, which can cause respiratory problems. These emissions are regulated, but diesel engines can operate for 30 years, so millions of older, polluting engines are still in use. As a result, diesel cars cause more than four times the pollution of petrol cars. Some governments plan to discourage their use or ban them from urban areas.

Diesel cars produce four times the pollution of petrol cars

Diesel cars have recently been subject to negative publicity due to the amount of toxic emissions they produce. Some governments are planning to discourage their use or even ban them from urban areas. This is because diesel vehicles produce more than four times the pollution of petrol cars.

Diesel engines are "lean-burn", meaning they use less fuel and more air to achieve the same performance as a petrol engine. While diesel fuel contains more carbon (2.68kg CO₂/litre) than petrol (2.31kg CO₂/litre), overall CO₂ emissions from a diesel car tend to be lower. However, diesel engines produce nitrogen oxides (NOx) which include the toxic nitrogen dioxide (NO₂), greenhouse gas nitrous oxide (N₂O) and nitric oxide (NO), which reacts with oxygen to form NO₂. These emissions can be cleaned up in petrol cars using a three-way catalytic converter, resulting in around 30% less NOx emissions than a diesel car without after-treatment. Long-term exposure to nitric oxide can increase the risk of respiratory problems.

Particulate filters in car exhausts can reduce PM emissions from diesel engines by more than 90%, but they require good operating conditions and regular maintenance. In contrast, petrol emissions systems regulate themselves, needing less driver input. Diesel engines also take longer to warm up than petrol engines, so for shorter journeys, petrol is a better choice.

Overall, while diesel engines may have lower CO₂ emissions, they produce more toxic emissions that are harmful to human health. This has led to the current backlash against diesel cars, as governments and the public become more aware of the negative impacts of diesel vehicles.

Diesel engines produce harmful nitrogen oxides

Direct effects on human health include irritation to the eyes and respiratory tract, and an increased risk of respiratory problems and asthma. Long-term exposure to nitric oxide can also increase the risk of respiratory issues. These harmful effects are especially pronounced in children and the elderly, who may experience more emergency room visits, hospital admissions, and absences from school or work as a result.

Indirect effects include damage to agricultural crops, trees, and other vegetation, as well as ecosystems. Nitrogen dioxide, for example, is a major component of smog and combines with volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the presence of sunlight to produce ozone and other compounds that negatively affect the respiratory system.

While diesel engines produce lower carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions than petrol engines, they emit more toxic emissions that are immediately harmful to humans. Diesel engines also produce higher levels of NOx than petrol engines, which can be mitigated with a three-way catalytic converter. However, diesel engine manufacturers have had to resort to other technologies, such as particulate filters, which tend to clog during urban driving.

The negative health and environmental impacts of diesel emissions have led to negative publicity for diesel cars, with some governments even planning to discourage their use or ban them from urban areas.

Diesel engines are harder to maintain than petrol engines

Diesel cars have been found to cause more than four times the pollution of petrol cars. This is due to the toxic emissions they produce, which are harmful to humans and the environment. Governments are now taking steps to discourage the use of diesel cars, with some even planning to ban them from urban areas.

Diesel engines are fundamentally different from petrol engines in the way they ignite the fuel and air mixture. While petrol engines use spark plugs, diesel engines rely solely on compression to ignite the mixture. Diesel engines also have glow plugs to heat the cylinders during cold starts. To comply with emissions standards, diesel engines may use particulate filters, which tend to clog during urban driving. They may also require the addition of a urea mixture, such as AdBlue, which needs to be topped up regularly. In contrast, petrol emissions systems are largely self-regulating and require less input from the driver.

Diesel engines have a reputation for being harder to maintain than petrol engines. This is partly due to the additional components and fluids needed to manage emissions, such as diesel particulate filters and AdBlue. Diesel engines also attract a higher road tax in some places due to their higher pollution levels. However, diesel engines have some maintenance advantages. For example, they do not require spark plugs, which are present in petrol engines. Additionally, diesel engines have fewer moving parts, making them easier to access and repair. The larger size of diesel engines also makes identifying problems simpler, as unusual noises and increased exhaust smoke can be more easily detected.

While diesel engines have certain maintenance benefits, they generally require more frequent servicing due to the need for regular emissions-related top-ups and soot removal cycles. Diesel engines may also be more expensive to purchase initially, and they are more costly to refuel than petrol engines. These factors contribute to the perception that diesel engines are more challenging to maintain than their petrol counterparts.

In conclusion, diesel engines produce significantly more pollution than petrol engines, leading to negative health and environmental consequences. While diesel engines offer certain maintenance advantages, such as easier access to parts and fewer moving components, they also present challenges with emissions-related components and fluids. As a result, diesel engines are often viewed as more complex to maintain than petrol engines.

Diesel engines are worse for human health

Diesel engines are significantly worse for human health than petrol engines. Diesel vehicles produce over four times the pollution of petrol cars, with toxic emissions that are immediately harmful to humans. These emissions include nitrogen oxides (NOx), such as nitrogen dioxide (NO2), nitrous oxide (N2O), and nitric oxide (NO). Long-term exposure to nitric oxide can increase the risk of respiratory issues, and diesel exhaust can lead to asthma and respiratory illnesses, worsening existing heart and lung diseases, especially in children and the elderly.

While diesel fuel contains slightly more carbon per litre than petrol, diesel cars have lower overall CO2 emissions. This led to governments promoting diesel cars as a more environmentally friendly option in the past. However, this focus on reducing CO2 emissions caused governments to ignore the issue of toxic emissions, which has now been recognised as a more pressing issue.

Diesel engines also require additional technologies to reduce emissions, such as particulate filters, which can clog during urban driving, and the latest emission technology requires the regular addition of a urea mixture. In contrast, petrol emissions systems are self-regulating and require less driver input.

The negative health impacts of diesel emissions have led to plans to discourage the use of diesel vehicles or even ban them from urban areas. However, the transition to newer, cleaner diesel engines will take time, and human health will continue to be impacted during this period. It is important to reduce exposure to diesel exhaust and encourage the adoption of cleaner energy alternatives to protect human health and the environment.

Diesel engines are worse for the environment

Diesel engines are a major source of harmful pollutants, and their use significantly contributes to air pollution. Diesel fuel produces many harmful emissions when burned, including ground-level ozone, nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter. Ground-level ozone, for instance, damages crops, trees, and other vegetation. Long-term exposure to nitrogen oxide can increase the risk of respiratory problems, and these emissions are particularly harmful to children and the elderly.

While diesel engines have lower CO2 emissions than petrol engines, they produce more toxic emissions that are immediately harmful to humans. For example, diesel engines emit 30% more NOx than petrol engines without after-treatment. This has led to some governments planning to discourage their use or even ban them from urban areas.

Diesel engines have been subject to negative publicity due to their toxic emissions, with some owners feeling misled as they believed they were choosing a more environmentally friendly option. This negative perception is partly due to the focus on CO2 output, causing other toxic emissions to be overlooked. Diesel engines also require more driver input to maintain emissions standards, as they need technologies such as particulate filters, which can clog up in urban driving conditions.

Furthermore, the longevity of diesel engines means that older, more polluting models remain in use for many years, prolonging the damage to human health and the environment. While new diesel engines are cleaner, the transition to a fully cleaner fleet will take time, during which human health will continue to be impacted by diesel emissions. Therefore, diesel engines are worse for the environment, especially when compared to petrol engines, due to their higher toxic emissions and their adverse effects on human health and the natural world.

Frequently asked questions