Tar Sands: A Toxic Legacy For Our Planet

Tar sands, also known as oil sands, are a mixture of sand, clay, water, and bitumen, a thick, molasses-like substance used to produce gasoline and other petroleum products. The extraction and refinement of tar sands are energy-intensive, costly, and environmentally destructive, resulting in toxic waste, air pollution, and water pollution. Tar sands extraction emits up to three times more global warming pollution than conventional crude oil production, and the water-intensive process consumes vast amounts of freshwater resources, polluting them with toxic substances. The impacts of tar sands extraction are felt disproportionately by Indigenous communities, who have experienced health issues, contaminated water sources, and cultural disruptions as a result. With the continued expansion of tar sands development, the pollution and environmental degradation it causes pose a significant threat to the planet's future livability.

Tar sands extraction emits more global warming pollution than conventional crude oil

Tar sands, also known as oil sands, are a mixture of sand, clay, water, and bitumen. Bitumen is a thick, molasses-like substance made of hydrocarbons, which is used to produce gasoline and other petroleum products. The largest deposits of tar sands are found in Alberta, Canada, where they cover an area larger than England.

Extracting bitumen from tar sands is a highly intensive process, requiring significant amounts of water and energy. This results in the emission of climate-polluting greenhouse gases, which contribute to global warming. According to the Congressional Research Service, tar sands oil emits 14 to 20% more planet-warming gases than conventional oil. Another source states that the amount of greenhouse gases emitted per barrel of tar sands oil can be up to 30% higher than conventional oil throughout its life cycle.

The production of tar sands oil has several environmental impacts. For every gallon of gasoline produced, about 5.9 gallons of freshwater are consumed, and the resulting wastewater is stored in massive toxic lakes that stain the landscape. These toxic storage ponds can cover over 30 square miles, making them some of the largest man-made structures on the planet. Additionally, the extraction and refining of tar sands oil produce hazardous by-products, such as petroleum coke, which further contribute to emissions.

The effects of tar sands extraction are particularly devastating for Indigenous communities living in the nearby areas. Traditional food sources are becoming scarce and polluted, and higher rates of cancer have been linked to tar sands chemicals. The air pollution caused by tar sands extraction includes a sharp smell like burned tires, which can cause a searing feeling in the lungs. Furthermore, the expansion of the tar sands industry has encroached on Indigenous lands, contaminating the environment and wildlife that these communities depend on.

The extraction process uses up massive amounts of water, depleting freshwater resources

Tar sands, also known as oil sands, are a mixture of sand, clay, water, and bitumen, a thick, molasses-like substance used to produce gasoline and other petroleum products. The extraction of bitumen from tar sands is a highly challenging and costly process, requiring significant amounts of energy and water. The water-intensive nature of tar sands extraction poses a significant environmental concern, particularly in terms of freshwater depletion and pollution.

The extraction and refinement of tar sands oil demand massive volumes of water, rivaling the daily water consumption of small cities. For every gallon of gasoline produced from tar sands, approximately 5.9 gallons of freshwater are consumed. This water usage is roughly three times higher than that of conventional oil extraction and refinement processes. The significant water requirements of tar sands operations contribute to the depletion of freshwater resources, placing strain on water availability for other essential purposes and ecosystems.

The issue is further exacerbated by the pollution caused by the wastewater generated during the extraction and refinement processes. This wastewater is often stored in vast toxic ponds, covering areas of up to 30 square miles. These ponds risk leaking and contaminating nearby water sources, including rivers and groundwater. The toxic substances present in the wastewater pose severe threats to human health and the environment, including elevated levels of mercury, lead, nickel, and other heavy metals.

The pollution from tar sands operations has had detrimental effects on nearby communities, particularly Indigenous Peoples who have lived in the region for generations. Traditional food sources, such as fish and wildlife, have become polluted and unsafe for consumption. Additionally, there are concerns about the increased rates of cancer and other health issues in these communities due to exposure to toxic substances and air pollution associated with tar sands development.

The depletion and pollution of freshwater resources by tar sands extraction have far-reaching consequences for the environment, ecosystems, and local communities. It not only affects water availability for human consumption and agricultural activities but also disrupts the natural habitats of various species and contributes to the overall biodiversity crisis. As a result, there are growing calls for a transition away from tar sands and towards cleaner energy sources to protect freshwater resources and mitigate the impacts of climate change.

The water used is polluted by toxic substances, creating giant ponds of toxic waste

Tar sands, also known as oil sands, are a mixture of sand, clay, water, and bitumen. Bitumen is a thick, molasses-like substance made of hydrocarbons, the same molecules found in liquid oil. It is used to produce gasoline and other petroleum products. The largest deposits of tar sands are found in Alberta, Canada, where they cover an area larger than England.

The process of extracting bitumen from tar sands and refining it into products like gasoline is significantly more costly and challenging than extracting and refining liquid oil. Common extraction methods include surface mining, where the extraction site is excavated, and "in-situ" mining, where steam is used to liquefy bitumen deep underground.

The amount of water used in the extraction, upgrading, and refining process for tar sands oil is considerable. For every gallon of gasoline produced, about 5.9 gallons of freshwater are consumed, roughly three times as much as used for conventional oil. This water is often polluted by toxic substances, creating giant ponds of toxic waste. These toxic storage ponds can cover over 30 square miles, making them some of the largest man-made structures on the planet.

The toxic substances found in the wastewater include salts, suspended solids, and dissolvable chemical compounds such as naphthenic acids, benzene, hydrocarbons, residual bitumen, and fine silts. These toxic ponds pose a significant risk to the environment and nearby communities, including Indigenous Peoples who have lived on these lands for generations. The contamination of water sources has led to concerns about the impact on human health and the environment, with reports of elevated levels of pollutants, including heavy metals, in downstream rivers and lakes.

The contamination of water supplies is just one aspect of the environmental and social impact of tar sands extraction. The overall volume of toxic waste, or tailings, has been growing for over 50 years, and there are concerns about leaks and the potential contamination of groundwater. The cleanup of these mines and tailings ponds will require an enormous investment, estimated at US$195 billion (C$260 billion) by the government.

Tar sands are linked to higher rates of cancer in Indigenous communities and dangerous air pollution

Tar sands, also known as oil sands, are a mixture of sand, clay, water, and bitumen. They are found in vast quantities in Alberta, Canada, and their extraction is an energy-intensive process that consumes large volumes of water. The process also releases air pollutants, and the resulting wastewater is stored in large toxic ponds, which can contaminate groundwater.

The tar sands in Alberta have encroached on Indigenous Peoples' traditional lands, threatening their way of life and the environment. The chemicals released during the extraction process have been linked to higher rates of cancer in these Indigenous communities. For instance, a 2014 study found elevated levels of toxic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the area, which are known to damage DNA and cause cancer. Another study from Fort Chipewyan, Alberta, revealed a 30% higher cancer rate than expected from 1995 to 2009. While a direct causal link to pollution from tar sands has been challenging to establish, researchers have found a correlation between cancer rates and proximity to the mines, as well as the consumption of traditional foods like fish that may be contaminated.

The air pollution caused by tar sands extraction is also a significant concern for these Indigenous communities. Studies have shown increased levels of hazardous air pollutants, including acid rain, which can have detrimental health effects. The air in these areas may have a sharp, burning smell, causing a searing sensation in the lungs. This air pollution contributes to respiratory issues and other health problems for those living nearby.

The impact of tar sands extraction extends beyond the local communities in Alberta. Globally, Indigenous Peoples and communities in the Global South are on the frontline of climate change impacts, experiencing rising sea levels and extreme weather events that endanger their homes and livelihoods.

Addressing the environmental and health consequences of tar sands extraction is crucial. While some companies have invested in technology to mitigate the tailings problem, the overall volume of toxic waste continues to grow. The cleanup of mines and tailings ponds will require significant investment, and the long-term effects of contamination on human health and the environment are still being understood.

The oil is thicker and more acidic than conventional crude, increasing the likelihood of leaks

Tar sands, also known as oil sands, are a mixture of sand, clay, water, and bitumen, a thick, molasses-like substance used to produce gasoline and other petroleum products. The extraction of bitumen from tar sands and its refinement into products like gasoline is a costly and challenging process. Tar sands extraction emits up to three times more global warming pollution than producing the same amount of conventional crude.

The oil derived from tar sands is thicker and more acidic than conventional crude oil. This increases the likelihood of leaks in pipelines transporting it. Tar sands pipelines have already experienced serious leaks and spills. For instance, the Keystone 1 pipeline, touted as the world's safest pipeline, had 12 spills in its first two years of operation, including a 21,000-gallon spill in North Dakota.

The increased risk of leaks associated with tar sands oil poses a significant threat to sensitive water resources. Lake Athabasca, located downstream from the oil sands mines, is one such example. Fish from this lake are now considered too polluted for human consumption due to the contamination from tar sands operations.

Additionally, the extraction and conversion of tar sands into usable fuel result in the creation of toxic waste and air and water pollution. The toxic waste is stored in massive ponds, which can cover over 30 square miles, becoming some of the largest man-made structures on the planet. These ponds have been known to leak, further contaminating the surrounding environment and impacting local communities and wildlife.

The impacts of tar sands pollution extend beyond the immediate vicinity of the extraction sites. In Alberta, Canada, where the largest deposits of tar sands are found, the effects of pollution have been observed in nearby Indigenous communities. Studies have found elevated levels of pollutants, including mercury, lead, and nickel, in the river downstream of oil sands developments and in Lake Athabasca. These pollutants have been linked to higher rates of cancer and other health issues in these communities.

Frequently asked questions