Natural Gas: Clean Energy Or Polluting Fossil Fuel?

Natural gas is often touted as a clean energy source, but it is a fossil fuel that contributes to climate change and air and water pollution. Natural gas is composed mostly of methane, a potent greenhouse gas that leaks during the extraction, production, and transportation of natural gas. While burning natural gas emits less CO2 than other fossil fuels, it is still emitting CO2. Methane leaks from natural gas appliances such as stoves can expose people to harmful pollutants. The extraction process, fracking, uses a lot of water from local reservoirs and can contaminate groundwater. While natural gas is a `lesser evil` option compared to other fossil fuels, it is not a solution to the climate crisis.

Natural gas is a fossil fuel that contributes to climate change

Natural gas is often marketed as a clean energy source, but it is a fossil fuel that contributes to climate change. While it is cleaner-burning compared to other fossil fuels like coal and liquid petroleum, it still releases carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere when burned, increasing CO2 levels, trapping heat, and contributing to global warming and climate change. Natural gas is composed mostly of methane, which is a potent greenhouse gas that leaks into the atmosphere in large quantities during the extraction, production, and transportation of natural gas. Methane has a global warming potential more than 25 times that of carbon dioxide over a 20-year period. Leaked methane cancels out any reduction in CO2 emissions achieved by replacing coal with natural gas.

The burning of natural gas also releases other pollutants, including carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides (NOx), formaldehyde, and sulfur dioxide (SO2). These pollutants have negative impacts on human health, triggering asthma, coughing, wheezing, and difficulty breathing, and sometimes resulting in hospitalization. Additionally, the extraction and handling of natural gas can lead to water pollution, as large volumes of water are used in the fracking process, and wastewater from wells can contaminate groundwater.

The debate around natural gas centres on its role as a ""bridge fuel" between fossil fuels and renewable energy. While natural gas has been credited for the decline in America's climate-warming carbon dioxide emissions as it replaces coal-fired power plants, it is not a solution to the climate crisis. The climate benefits of natural gas are questionable due to the incidental releases or "leaks" of methane throughout its lifecycle. Recent studies suggest that methane leaks are likely undercounted or underestimated, and these leaks can make natural gas as bad for the climate as coal.

Furthermore, investing in natural gas infrastructure creates a financial incentive to continue using gas, potentially delaying the transition to carbon-free energy sources like wind and solar. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), we need to reach net-zero carbon emissions by mid-century to limit global warming to the goals set by the Paris Agreement in 2015. This target underscores the urgency to reduce methane emissions, improve natural gas systems, and accelerate the adoption of renewable energy sources.

Natural gas is a significant source of methane emissions

Natural gas is a fossil fuel composed mostly of methane, a potent greenhouse gas. While natural gas burns cleaner than other fossil fuels like coal and oil, emitting about half as much carbon dioxide (CO2), it still releases CO2 and other harmful substances. Importantly, natural gas production, processing, storage, transmission, distribution, and use contribute significantly to methane emissions.

Methane (CH4) is a powerful heat-trapping gas, with a global warming potential around 28 times greater than carbon dioxide over a 100-year period. While methane has a shorter lifespan, breaking down after about 12 years, its concentration in the atmosphere has more than doubled over the past 200 years due to human activities. The largest sources of methane emissions are agriculture, fossil fuels, and the decomposition of landfill waste. Natural gas systems are the second-largest source of methane emissions in the United States, with methane released during every stage of its supply chain.

The extraction of natural gas through fracking can release methane into the air and pollute water sources. Leaks and unintentional releases during the production and transportation of natural gas further contribute to methane emissions. Studies indicate that these leaks may be undercounted or underestimated, erasing the climate benefits of using natural gas over coal. For instance, the Environmental Protection Agency is believed to underestimate actual methane leakage by 50 to 100%.

Addressing methane emissions from natural gas is crucial in tackling climate change. While reducing methane leaks is challenging and costly, particularly in populated cities, it is technically possible and can have a significant impact on slowing global warming. Taking quick and decisive action on methane emissions from the oil and gas industry could avoid approximately 0.1 degrees Celsius of warming by the middle of the century.

Natural gas extraction uses a lot of water and can cause pollution

Natural gas is often touted as an environmentally friendly "bridge" fuel to a cleaner energy system. Compared to other fossil fuels, it emits less carbon dioxide (CO2) to produce the same amount of energy. However, the extraction and production of natural gas can have significant environmental and health impacts, including water usage and pollution.

Natural gas extraction, particularly hydraulic fracturing ("fracking"), requires large amounts of water. Fracking involves pumping liquids under high pressure into wells to fracture rock formations and release natural gas. This process can affect aquatic habitats and reduce water availability for other uses. Additionally, the disposal of "produced water" can impact groundwater resources. Produced water is the water that surfaces with the gas during extraction and is often pumped back into wells or injected into formations below usable groundwater resources.

The extraction and production of natural gas can also cause pollution in various forms. Well drilling activities produce air pollution and can disturb vegetation, soil, and water resources. The construction of well pads, pipelines, and access roads can cause erosion and sedimentation, leading to increased aquatic contamination and habitat fragmentation. Natural gas production can also generate large volumes of contaminated water, which requires proper handling and treatment to prevent land and water pollution.

Furthermore, the release of methane, the primary component of natural gas, during extraction, production, and transportation is a significant environmental concern. Methane is a potent greenhouse gas, and leaks or flares during these processes can reduce or eliminate the climate benefits of natural gas over other fossil fuels. Other air pollutants emitted during natural gas combustion include nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide (SO2), and small amounts of sulfur, mercury, and particulates. These pollutants can have adverse health effects on nearby communities, including respiratory symptoms, cardiovascular disease, and cancer.

While natural gas is often considered a "lesser evil" compared to other fossil fuels in terms of climate impact, its extraction and production processes can have significant environmental and health implications. The high water usage and potential for pollution underscore the importance of transitioning towards cleaner and more renewable energy sources.

Natural gas appliances expose people to harmful pollutants

Natural gas is a fossil fuel composed mostly of methane, a powerful heat-trapping gas that contributes to climate change. While it is cleaner-burning compared to other fossil fuels like coal and oil, natural gas is still a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions. The extraction, production, and transportation of natural gas release methane into the atmosphere, reducing or negating its climate benefits.

Natural gas appliances, such as stoves, furnaces, and water heaters, expose people to harmful pollutants, both during use and through leaks. The combustion of natural gas releases pollutants such as carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides (NOx), sulfur dioxide (SO2), benzene, formaldehyde, and particulate matter. These pollutants have been linked to various health issues, including accidental poisoning deaths, respiratory problems, cardiovascular issues, reproductive harm, and cancer.

Research has found that gas stoves routinely generate unsafe levels of indoor air pollution, exposing tens of millions of people to levels of air pollution that would be illegal outdoors. A 2014 study by scholars at LBL found that gas stoves exposed 12 million people in California to illegal levels of NO2, with 1.7 million experiencing unsafe levels of CO. Additionally, a 2009 study linked early-life exposure to air pollution from indoor gas appliances to potential negative impacts on neuropsychological development in children.

The problem is not limited to indoor air quality. Gas appliances also contribute to outdoor air pollution, particularly in California. A 2022 publication by SPUR, Sierra Club, and RMI found that residential and commercial gas appliances generate approximately four times as much NOx as the state's electric utilities and two-thirds as much as its light-duty passenger vehicles. This NOx pollution contributes to smog formation, which is associated with a range of health problems.

While proper installation and ventilation can reduce the risk of harmful pollution from natural gas appliances, the challenge of completely eliminating indoor air pollution from these sources remains. Policymakers and utilities have a role in educating consumers about the potential health risks and making alternative energy sources more accessible. Additionally, improving natural gas systems to reduce methane leaks can have a significant positive impact on climate change mitigation.

Natural gas is marketed as a clean energy source, but is it really?

Natural gas is often marketed as a clean energy source. Compared to coal and other fossil fuels, it emits about half as much carbon dioxide (CO2) to produce the same amount of energy. Burning natural gas also produces very little sulfur, mercury, or particulate matter. These reduced levels of pollution have led to natural gas being touted as an environmentally friendly "bridge" fuel to a cleaner energy system.

However, the reality is that natural gas is still a fossil fuel and a highly polluting one at that. While it may be cleaner than coal or liquid petroleum, it still emits a large amount of carbon into the atmosphere in the form of CO2 and methane. CO2 is released during the combustion process used to generate electricity. Methane, the primary component of natural gas, is a potent greenhouse gas, with a global warming potential more than 25 times that of carbon dioxide over a 20-year period. Methane is leaked in large quantities during the extraction and transport of natural gas. Studies show that global methane emissions have spiked dramatically since 2002, largely due to the boom in natural gas extraction in the US.

The biggest threat of natural gas extraction is the process of fracking, which uses a lot of water from local water reservoirs and can pollute streams. Fracking also releases methane into the air. Burning natural gas also emits carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides (NOx), and sulfur dioxide (SO2). It is dangerous if not transported or extracted responsibly and can end in an explosion if not shipped correctly.

While natural gas may be a "lesser evil" option compared to other fossil fuels, it is not a solution to the climate crisis. Investing in natural gas infrastructure creates a financial incentive to continue using gas, potentially delaying the adoption of carbon-free energy sources. The climate benefits of natural gas over other fossil fuels have also been called into question, with some studies suggesting that methane leaks may be undercounted or underestimated.

In conclusion, while natural gas may be cleaner than some other fossil fuels, it is still a polluting and non-renewable energy source that contributes to climate change.

Frequently asked questions