The Environmental Impact Of Tape And Velcro: Which Is Worse?

Tape and velcro are both commonly used materials, with tape being used in construction and households, and velcro being used in clothing, shoes, and other items. However, the question arises: do these materials contribute to pollution? Tape, for example, is typically made with a plastic carrier, although some tapes are biodegradable and environmentally friendly. Velcro, on the other hand, is made from plastic materials derived from petroleum, which can harm the environment during extraction and processing. Both materials face challenges when exposed to external factors like UV light, temperature fluctuations, and water, which can affect their performance and durability. With the growing concern for the environment, it is essential to consider the impact of these widely used materials and explore more sustainable alternatives.

Tape vs Velcro: Environmental Impact

Velcro is made from non-biodegradable plastic materials derived from petroleum

Velcro is a widely used product, employed in a variety of applications, from clothing and personal accessories to manufacturing and the automotive industry. However, its environmental impact has come under scrutiny due to its non-biodegradable composition.

Velcro is primarily made from nylon, a synthetic material that is a type of plastic. Nylon is produced through a chemical process, using petroleum or crude oil as its base product. This process involves refining crude oil, which is inherently harmful to the environment. The drilling and extraction of crude oil can lead to habitat destruction and pollution, and the refinement process consumes significant energy while emitting pollutants such as NOx and CO2.

As a synthetic plastic, nylon, and by extension, Velcro, is not biodegradable. It can take hundreds or even thousands of years for nylon to completely biodegrade. Even if it did break down, the chemicals and additives used in Velcro's production could be hazardous to the environment. The non-biodegradability of Velcro contributes to pollution, particularly plastic pollution in water bodies, affecting aquatic life and potentially spreading to land, impacting livestock and other animals.

The Velcro company has recognized the environmental concerns associated with their product and has implemented initiatives to improve sustainability. The Velcro Brand Eco Collection, for example, features products made from recycled materials, reducing the reliance on non-renewable resources. Additionally, they have removed solvents from the manufacturing process, implemented recycled water cooling systems, and diverted waste from landfills.

While these efforts are commendable, the inherent challenges associated with the non-biodegradability of Velcro remain. The recycling of Velcro is also difficult due to the energy and cost-intensive nature of breaking down and repurposing the material. As a result, most worn-out Velcro ends up in landfills, further contributing to environmental issues.

Drilling, extracting, and refining the petroleum used in Velcro harms the environment

Velcro is derived from petroleum, which is extracted from crude oil. The process of drilling, extracting, and refining petroleum harms the environment in several ways. Firstly, drilling for oil often involves clearing large areas of vegetation and can destroy natural habitats and ecosystems. This disruption can have detrimental effects on wildlife, impacting their communication, breeding, and nesting patterns. The infrastructure built for oil and gas extraction, such as roads, facilities, and drilling sites, can leave long-lasting scars on the land, with the damage often being irreversible.

Additionally, oil drilling and extraction processes can lead to pollution through the release of hazardous waste into the air and water. The drilling fluids, or "mud," used for lubrication can leak and contaminate the surrounding environment. Oil spills, which are common, have devastating consequences for local wildlife and ecosystems, as the toxic chemicals can be inhaled, ingested, or come into direct contact with animals. The burning of fossil fuels further contributes to air pollution, leading to respiratory and cardiovascular diseases.

The extraction and refining of petroleum for Velcro also contribute to energy consumption. The process of refining crude oil into petroleum products requires significant energy input, and the non-renewable nature of petroleum makes it unsustainable in the long term. The energy-intensive nature of the process contributes to the environmental footprint of Velcro.

Furthermore, the sites used for fossil fuel extraction are often located in semi-arid climates, hindering the possibility of natural recovery. Even with human intervention and resource investment, the recovery process can take centuries. The impact of oil and gas development on these lands can degrade the experience for visitors and local communities, affecting millions of people living near these sites.

Tape adhesives are affected by temperature and can melt or freeze

Temperature plays a pivotal role in the application, storage, and performance of adhesive tapes. Tapes should ideally be stored in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight, within a temperature range of 10°C (50°F) to 25°C (77°F). Extreme temperatures can negatively impact the performance of adhesive tapes.

Adhesive tapes are affected by temperature variations. Extreme cold can make the adhesive brittle, while high temperatures can cause it to soften or even melt. This can significantly reduce the tape's effectiveness. The ability of adhesives to ""wet out" or fully contact and adhere to a surface is hindered by cold temperatures, which can prevent proper bonding. On the other hand, high temperatures can cause the adhesive to melt and flow easily, potentially leading to a mess and a slowdown of processes.

The chemical makeup of adhesives changes with increasing temperatures, causing certain components to break down, and the adhesive to crystallize and become unstable. This decreased elasticity may result in the cracking or shattering of the adhesive, rendering the bond useless. Extreme heat can also decrease the solidity, stiffness, or "toughness" of the adhesive, causing substrates to slide apart.

Hot melt adhesives, in particular, are thermoplastic polymers that generally become pliable at warm temperatures and solidify when cooled, forming a lasting bond. Small variations in temperature, even as little as 5 degrees, can have significant long-term consequences on the durability of adhesives. Therefore, it is important for users to consider the operating temperature when choosing an adhesive tape to ensure it is suitable for the intended environment.

Tape is not biodegradable but some eco-friendly alternatives exist

Tape, specifically Sellotape or sticky tape, is not an eco-friendly choice for sealing as it contains polypropylene (plastic) and cannot be recycled. However, there are several eco-friendly alternatives available on the market.

One alternative is paper-based tape, which is made from kraft paper and contains natural rubber. This type of tape is renewable but may vary in its biodegradability and recyclability. It is a good option for sealing lightweight packages and cartons, making it a sustainable choice for some businesses. Another option is water-activated tape, also known as gummed or brown paper tape. This type of tape consists of a starch-based adhesive over a paper backing, and its adhesive becomes sticky only when wet. This makes it a more eco-friendly choice compared to standard plastic-containing tape, as it does not need to be covered in wax, which is not compostable.

Some specific brands that offer eco-friendly tape include Peace With The Wild, which provides a compostable and vegan-friendly tape that is recyclable and comes with no packaging. The tesapack® paper ecoLogo® is made from a blend of recycled cardboard, recycled fibres, and bio-based materials, with an adhesive coating free from solvents and other toxic chemicals. Noissue Custom packing tape uses paper that is Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI)-certified and acid-free, made from 100% recycled material. Maxpack’s brown paper tape is also biodegradable and 100% recyclable.

While tape is not biodegradable, these eco-friendly alternatives offer more sustainable options for consumers and businesses alike, helping to reduce their environmental footprint.

Velcro can be reused but is not biodegradable or easily recycled

Velcro is a useful material for clothes and accessories. It is also used in manufacturing and the automotive industry. The product was invented in the 1950s as a solution for removing cockleburs from clothing. It works as a hook-and-loop system, with one part of the fastener hooking itself onto the other to attach two pieces of fabric together.

While Velcro is undoubtedly a revolutionary material, it is neither eco-friendly nor sustainable. This is because it is made from plastic materials such as nylon, polyester, polypropylene, polyamide, and polyvinyl chloride (PVC). These materials are derived from petroleum and are extracted and processed using methods that harm the environment. For instance, to obtain crude oil, one must drill the earth, which can pollute the environment and destroy natural habitats.

The Velcro company has instituted some sustainability practices to make things better. They have been trying to manufacture Velcro in a way that is as eco-friendly as possible, recycling as much as possible. For example, their Eco Collection products are made from 40% recycled materials. They have also partnered with other companies to find a way to make Velcro and its components more recyclable. However, it is not easy for individuals to recycle Velcro at home because local recycling programs don't accept it. This is because it takes a lot of energy and money to completely break down this material and create new products.

Although it is not easy to recycle Velcro, it can be reused. If the Velcro is attached to clothing or another textile and is still in good condition, you can always donate the clothing to an organization that will provide it for others who can use it.

Frequently asked questions